Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
28.09.2026
Item No.19
Ct. No. 10
BR
WPA 25932 of 2026
Papia Dey
-vsIndian Oil Corporation Ltd. and
Ors.
Mr. Debabrata Saha Roy, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. PIngal Bhattacharyaya
…. For the petitioner
Mr. Sunit Bhunia
… for the UOI
Mr. A.K.NAG,
Ms. Rishita Sarkar
… for the IOCL
Mr. Debashis Saha,
Mr. Avirup Roy Sanyal,
Mr. Hyotishman Sarkar,
Ms. S.Pal
… for the SBI
Mr. Pramit Bag,
Mr. A. K. Mishra,
Mr. Ritesh Kumar Ganguly,
Mr. Rahul Agarwala,
Ms. Utsa Poddar,
Ms. Anjali Singh
… for the respondent no. 12
1.
The Writ Petition has been filed by the petitioner
challenging,
inter
alia,
the
action
of
the
Banking
authorities in freezing the Joint Current Bank Account
being No. 43754381056 with the State Bank of India,
Bethuadahari Branch without verifying and scrutinizing
the veracity of the documents submitted by the time of
opening the said Bank Account.
2.
The Learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner
submits that a Partnership Deed was executed on 12th
July 2024 between the petitioner and the respondent No.
12 in the name and style of H. N. Memorial Dey KSK, an
unregistered Partnership firm, having a share in Profit and
Loss
to
the
extent
of
90%
and
10%
respectively.
Thereafter, the partners made an application for renewal of
the Retail Selling License by submitting the reconstitution
of the Partnership Deed. The same was subsequently
executed with the private respondent IOCL on 28.05.2025
by
entering
into
the
terms
and
conditions
of
the
Dealership Agreement dated 10.09.2025 in the name of
the Partnership firm.
3.
The petitioner draws the attention of this Court
that a complaint dated 28.08.2026 was lodged by the
private respondent before the local Police Station, thereby
registering an FIR on the ground that the petitioner has
been operating the Bank Account individually by forging
the signature of the Private Respondent.
4.
The petitioner submits that the complaint lodged
by the private respondent is mischievous and has been
filed only to stall the smooth running of the Retail Outlet
Dealership, alleging siphoning of money from the Bank
Account maintained with the State Bank of India,
Bethuadahari Branch and also for forging the signature of
the private respondent for withdrawal of the money from
the said account. On the basis of such complaint, the
banking authorities of State Bank of India have frozen the
Bank Account without prior information to the petitioner
as a result of which the entire running of the Outlet
Dealership has been hampered and the day to day
business transaction have come to a stand still. Such
action of the banking authorities in freezing the bank
account is in violation of the principles of natural justice
and is detrimental to the interest of the public at large.
5.
The petitioner submits that such complaint lodged
against the petitioner is harassive and violates Article 14,
19(1G) and 21 of the constitution of India. Despite
purchasing the entire plot of land from the private
respondent
for
constructing
the
petrol
pump,
the
petitioner’s interest in the business is at stake by not
permitting the petitioner to operate the Joint Bank
Account for running the retail outlet business. It is not in
dispute that the plot ofland on which the petrol pump has
been constructed stands in the name of the petitioner
which is evident from the Deed of Conveyance annexed to
the Writ Petition at page 54 and 55 of the Writ Petition.
6.
It is further submitted that upon execution of the
Dealership Agreement, the petitioner and the private
respondents being partners, opened a Joint Current Bank
Account in state Bank of India, Bethuadahari Branch for
operating the retail outlet dealership, being joint bank
current account No. 43754381056. The petitioner submits
that the business was running uninterruptedly. To its
utter surprise, the petitioner found in the 1st week of
January 2026 the said bank account has been frozen and
has
been
made
inoperational
as
instruction of the Private respondent.
per
the
standing
7.
The Learned Counsel appearing for the private
respondent raises an objection and submits that the Writ
Petition is not maintainable and is defective as one of the
partners has approached this Court in individual capacity
while the cause of action, if any, survives for the
Partnership firm which is not impleaded as a party. It is
also submitted that the Partnership deed contains an
Arbitration Clause. When disputed questions of fact and
documents requiring evidentiary scrutiny as to veracity are
involved, the writ court ought not to exercise jurisdiction
under Article 226.
8.
It is submitted that on the ground of opening a
Joint Current Account No. 43754381056 with State Bank
of India, Rajapur Petrol Pump which was to be operated
jointly as per the Partnership deed and on allegation of
withdrawal of money by forging signature, a complaint has
been lodged and an FIR has been registered.
9.
It is further submitted that the Partnership deed
annexed to the Writ Petition is not the original deed and is
different from the deed that was submitted before the IOCL
at the time of grant of the Retail Outlet Dealership.
10.
It is further submitted that as per the Partnership
deed there is an arbitration clause. Without invoking such
clause, the petitioner has approached by invoking Article
226 of the Constitution of India which is not maintainable
in the eye of law since it is a settled proposition of law that
Writ Court has very limited scope to entertain a matter
where
factual
disputes
are
involved
along
with
documentary evidentiary value which requires scrutiny
and examination of the veracity of the documents relied
upon for adjudication.
11.
It is further submitted that the Partnership Deed
which has been annexed to the Writ Petition is not the
original Partnership deed and it is a manufactured /
forged document and the original Partnership deed was
never submitted for effective adjudication before the IOCL
at the time of change of status of the retail outlet from Sole
Proprietorship to Joint Partnership Account and thus the
same cannot be taken as a part of the record for
adjudication.
12.
The Learned Counsel appearing for the IOCL
submits that the Partnership Deed furnished by the Writ
Petitioner was submitted for approval of the Retail Outlet
Dealership and the same has been duly scrutinized by the
concerned authorities.
13.
The Learned Counsel appearing for the respondent
IOCL submits that the partnership deed annexed to the
writ petition is the deed which was submitted for approval
of the license of the Retail Outlet Dealership. On the basis
of such document, approval for the reconstitution has
been granted in favour of the partnership firm.
14.
The Learned Counsel appearing for the Banking
authorities produces a bunch of documents which are
taken on record to demonstrate that the Bank Account
which stood in the name of Current Joint Account has
been frozen on the basis of a letter dated 24.08.2026
issued by the private respondent and the FIR registered
against the petitioner being Nakashipara P.S. Case No.
881 of 2026 dated 28.08.2026
15.
After hearing the rival contentions of the parties
this Court finds that the petitioner has been able to make
out a prima facie case warranting interference at this
stage. This Court has taken judicial notice of all the
relevant documents annexed to the Writ Petition including
the documents relied upon by the banking authorities.
16.
Upon perusal of the said documents this Court is
of the considered view that the issue of alleged forgery and
withdrawal is a subject matter of separate criminal
proceeding which shall be decided on merits independently
and the same cannot be a ground to freeze the operation of
the Joint Current Account meant for running the retail
outlet dealership which is required to be run in public
interest.
17.
This Court has considered the objection as to the
maintainability. Prima facie, the dispute relates to freezing
of
the
Joint
Current
Account
No.
43754381056
maintained with State Bank of India for operation of the
IOCL Retail Outlet at Rajapur which directly affects the
petitioner’s right to operate the account as a Joint Account
holder. The presence of an arbitration clause or disputed
questions as to Partnership deed cannot oust the writ
jurisdiction
when
arbitrary
action
of
the
banking
authorities in making the account in operational is under
challenge. Hence, the objection as to maintainability is
overruled at this stage.
18.
This Court has perused the documents produced
by the Banking authorities. Prima facie it appears that the
Current Joint Account maintained with State Bank of
India for Rajapur Petrol pump was made inoperational /
frozen solely at the behest of the private respondent on the
basis of his letter dated 24.08.2026 and subsequent FIR
dated 28.08.2026 without issuing any prior notice to the
Writ Petitioner, who is a Joint Account Holder and without
following the due procedure laid down for freezing a
Current Account. Such unilateral action by the Bank, at
the instance of one Joint Account holder against the other,
is not sustainable in law. Particularly when the account is
required for running the IOCL Retail Outlet Dealership in
for the public interest at large.
19.
This Court is also takes note with regard to the
conduct of the private respondent which is highly
condemnable
and
that
serious,
stringent
action
is
warranted against him for misleading this Court by
projecting a Partnership deed, as the original deed, while
alleging the Partnership deed annexed to the Writ Petition
to be forged. As submitted by the IOCL authorities the
Partnership deed furnished for reconstitution of the
partnership for execution of the Dealership Agreement and
the Partnership deed annexed to the Writ petition
submitted for dealership as one and the same. This court
has taken serious note of the conduct of the private
respondent No. 10 to hoodwink this Court by way of
misrepresentation.
20.
The Learned Counsel appearing for the private
respondent
sought
to
make
such
an
extraneous
submissions which, in the opinion of this court, is not
warranted to be gone at this stage. From the documents
on record this Court is satisfied that the prayer made in
the Writ Petition deserves to be allowed so that the retail
Outlet Dealership can run smoothly in the interest of the
public at large.
21.
The respondent No. 11 is directed to forthwith
change the mode of operation of the Joint Current Bank
Account No. 43754381056 and make the Current Account
to be operational in such a manner that it can be operated
jointly by both the partners by running the Retail Outlet
Dealership, within a period of 72 hours from the date of
communication of this Order.
22.
However, it is made clear that such operation shall
continue as per the earlier mode of operation of funds as
mentioned in the application for maintaining the Bank
Account. This Court does not express any opinion with
regard to criminal proceedings initiated against the
petitioner. There shall be no bar to operate the Bank
Account for running the business and the proceeding shall
continue independently on its own merits.
23.
This Court has taken the most serious view of the
conduct of the private respondent. The said respondent
has
not
only
attempted
to
mislead
this
Court
by
suppressing the material facts and projecting a fabricated
Partnership deed as genuine but also tried to hoodwink
the Banking authorities and IOCL authorities for unlawful
gain. Such conduct amounts to a clear abuse of the
process
of
the
Court
and
interference
with
the
administration of justice. The act of forging the signatures
of the petitioner for operating the Joint Current Account
No. 43754381056 of State Bank of India, Rajapur Branch
and thereafter filing a false Deed before this Court is
highly condemnable, dishonest and perverse. This Court,
therefore deprecate such misdemennour in the strongest
term and hold that the private respondent is liable to be
saddled an exemplary cost for his contumacious conduct.
The
conduct
of
private
respondent
is
deliberately
misleading this Court by producing a false and fabricated
Partnership deed is nothing short of forgery and fraud
played upon the Court. Such unscrupulous attempt to
subvert the course of justice coupled with the allegation of
forging the signature of the petitioner for siphoning of
funds from the Joint current Account shocks the concern
of the Court. This Court cannot countenance such
dishonest litigant who has abused the process of law.
Accordingly, this Court imposes an exemplary cost of Rs.
50,000/- upon Private respondent to be deposited with the
West Bengal State Legal Services Authority within a week
from the date of communication of this order and an
affidavit of compliance annexing proof of payment shall be
filed before the Learned Registrar General.
24.
With the above observations and directions the
Writ Petition is disposed of.
(Smita Das De, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review