The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
32. The Ld. District Judge, thus, rightly concluded that by accepting and encashing the cheque, he was left with no ground to subsequently question the grounds of termination. Therefore, the Suit of the Plaintiff denying him reinstatement and compensation as claimed, has rightly been dismissed while granting him salary @ Rs.35,000/- along with 6% interest for the month of June, 2009, during which he had worked, since the Letter of Termination was served upon him later on 07.07.2009.
33. There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed along with pending Application(s), if any.
34. The Appeal is accordingly Dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 08th January, 2026
Pronounced on: 13th March, 2026
RFA 976/2025 & CM APPL. 21122-24/2024
+
PANKAJ VAID
S/o Sh. H.K. Vaid,
R/o 488, Jheel Khuranja
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Ayush Negi, Advocate
versus
1.
ICICI BANK LIMITED
ICICI Bank Tower,
Bandra Kurla Complex,
Mumbai-400051
Through its managing director
2.
THE ASSISTANT GENERAL MANAGER,
Human Resource Management Group,
ICICI Bank Limited,
ICICI Bank Towed, Bandra Kurla Complex,
Mumbai
Through:
.....Respondents
Dr. M. Y. Khan, Advocate
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
CM APPL. 21123/2024:
1.
An Application under Section 5 of Limitation Act, has been filed
seeking condonation of delay of 168 days, in filing the present Appeal.
2.
For the reasons stated in the Application, delay is condoned.
RFA 976/2025
KUMAR BHATT
18:26:51
3.
The Application stands disposed of.
CM APPL. 21124/2024:
4.
Application under Section 5 of Limitation Act has been filed seeking
condonation of delay of 40 days, in re-filing the present Appeal.
5.
For the reasons stated in the Application, delay is condoned.
6.
The Application stands disposed of.
RFA 976/2025, CM APPL. 21122/2024:
7.
Regular First Appeal under Order XLI read with Section 96 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as „CPC‟) has been
filed by the Appellant/Plaintiff against the Judgment and Decree dated
20.05.2023, whereby the Suit of the Plaintiff has been partially decreed for
Rs.35,000/- along with interest @ 6% per annum from 07.07.2009 until
realization as salary for the month of June, 2009, while his other reliefs for
damages and reinstatement, were dismissed.
8.
The Appellant/Plaintiff filed a Civil Suit CS (OS) No. 1644/2011for
recovery of damages in the sum of Rs.50,00,000/- for loss of his salary visà-vis future employment and Rs.20,00,000/- for mental suffering on account
of arbitrary termination of his job.
9.
Briefly stated, the Plaintiff/Appellant having the qualification of B.E.
(Electronics), was given a Letter of Appointment dated 29.10.2007 by the
Respondent/Defendant Bank as Manager (I), in the office of Respondent
Bank at Videocon Tower in Credit Card Collection Division.
10.
The Appellant was assigned the job to supervise the collection
Agencies deputed by the Defendant Bank, in respect of collection of dues
relating to credit cards. In June, 2008, he was moved to Vintage Team (360
days delinquency).
RFA 976/2025
KUMAR BHATT
18:26:51
11.
On 07.05.2009, he was promoted to the post of Area Manager, in
recognition of his hard work with the Bank, reflecting that he was getting
promotions on account of his sincerity, honesty and hard work.
12.
However, merely after one month of getting promotion, the Plaintiff
noticed that he has not received the salary for the month of June, 2009 in his
bank account. He made queries from the Regional Debt Manager and other
senior officials vis-à-vis non-payment of his salary in June, 2009 but did not
get any satisfactory reply.
13.
Shockingly, he received a Termination Letter on 07.07.2009
indicating that his services stand terminated w.e.f. 05.06.2009, in terms of
Letter of Appointment dated 29.10.2007. The Plaintiff claimed that as per
the Letter of Appointment dated 29.10.2007, his services could be
terminated only in the following conditions:“a. Any breach of the conditions mentioned in this letter on
the part of the Plaintiff;
b. On furnishing any incorrect information by him;
c. On suppression of any material information by him.”
14.
The Plaintiff asserted that the Termination Letter dated 05.06.2009,
did not assign any reason for termination of his services, which reflects that
the Bank has acted arbitrarily, unethically and in a high-ended and unfair
manner. The Plaintiff claimed that he had been performing his work/service
for the entire month of June, 2009 and his Termination Letter though dated
05.06.2009, had been communicated to him only on 07.07.2009. The
Termination Letter dated 05.06.2009, is therefore, termed as illegal and
arbitrary.
15.
The Appellant served a Legal Notice dated 22.06.2010 on the
Defendant Bank, for recalling the termination and to pay compensation of
RFA 976/2025
KUMAR BHATT
18:26:51
Rs.20,00,000/-. However, the bank failed to respond to it.
16.
The Plaintiff claimed that he suffered mental injury, because of the
illegal act of the Defendant Bank. He, asserted that if for technical reasons,
he cannot be reinstated in his job, he in the alternative, may be compensated
for the losses, which he would face because of losing his salary, for his
entire life.
17.
Additionally, the Appellant stated that he has suffered a job stigma on
his future prospects of employment and is likely face great difficulty in
getting another employment, on account of termination of his service by the
Defendant Bank.
18.
The Plaintiff, thus filed the Suit for setting aside the Termination
Order dated 05.06.2009, as being arbitrary and claimed compensation in the
sum of Rs.50,00,000/- for loss of his salary in terms of future employment in
coming years and Rs.20,00,000/- for mental suffering on account of
arbitrary termination of his job.
19.
The Defendant/Respondent in its Written Statement, asserted that
the Plaintiff was terminated in terms of the Appointment Letter dated
29.10.2007, which provided that:
“…after confirmation, your services would be terminated at
any time by giving 90 days’ Notice or on payment of an
amount equivalent to 90 days’ gross salary in lieu of the Notice
period.”
20.
The Plaintiff was accordingly, given a cheque of Rs.99,634/-
equivalent to 90 days gross salary at the time of termination from his
employment, which was duly encashed by him. Now, it is out of greed that
he is claiming the relief of reinstatement and compensation.
21.
All the averments made in the Plaint were denied. It is, therefore,
RFA 976/2025
KUMAR BHATT
18:26:51
submitted that the Suit was liable to be rejected.
22.
The Plaintiff in the Replication, reaffirmed his assertions, as made in
the Plaint.
23.
The Issues were framed on the pleadings on 30.05.2012, as under:“1. Whether in terms of appointment letter dated 29.10.2007, it
was obligatory upon the Employer / Bank to assign reason
before terminating the services of the plaintiff?
2. Whether the respondent bank has acted in a highly arbitrary
manner, by terminating the services of plaintiff, who was a
confirmed employee and was working to the full satisfaction of
his employer?
3. Whether the respondent bank has acted in an unjust and
unfair manner, while terminating the services of plaintiff w.e.f
05.06.2009 and communicating the same to the plaintiff on
07.07.2009 and taking full work from him during all the period
despite his termination from the services on 05.06.2009?
4. Whether the termination order dated 05.06.2009 has been
passed in highly arbitrary manner without assigning any reason
and the defendant bank has acted in a high handed and unfair
manner with the plaintiff?
5. Whether the termination order dated 05.06.2009 is illegal and
liable to be set aside?
6. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to received compensation
from the defendant bank for the mental agony, humiliation and
financial losses suffered by him on account of highly arbitrary,
unjust and unfair act of defendant bank by illegal terminating
his services?”
24.
The Plaintiff examined himself as PW1 in support of his assertions.
25.
The Defendant/Respondent, though Affidavit of DW1 Meghana Rao,
Chief Manager, (HR) was filed, but no witness was examined by the
Defendant Bank.
26.
The Ld. District Judge on appreciation of the evidence, concluded
that the termination of the Plaintiff was in terms of the Appointment Letter
dated 29.10.2007 and he was given 03 months’ salary in lieu of the Notice
RFA 976/2025
KUMAR BHATT
18:26:51
period; the termination was held to be valid. However, it was concluded
that the Termination Letter was communicated to the Plaintiff on
07.07.2009, while he had continued to work with the Bank for the month of
June, 2009. Consequently, salary of one month, i.e. Rs.35,000/- along with
interest @ 6% p.a. was granted, from 07.07.2009 till the date of realization.
27.
Aggrieved by the denial of relief of Reinstatement, Compensation and
Damages, the Plaintiff has filed the present Appeal.
28.
The grounds of challenge are that the learned Trial Court on one
hand, observed that the Termination Letter did not disclose any ground for
termination of service of the Appellant, but on the other hand, held the
termination to be in terms of the Appointment Letter. Further, the learned
Trial Court came to the conclusion that once the cheque given in lieu of
Notice period, was encashed by the Appellant, which was the mode of
termination of the service provided in the Appointment Letter, he cannot
challenge his termination. It has been ignored that there has been no reason
given for the termination of the Appellant/Plaintiff, which was mandatory as
per the Appointment Letter.
29.
It
is
prayed
that
the
impugned
judgment
denying
the
Appellant/Plaintiff relief of reinstatement/damages for mental injury and
loss of his salary in terms of future employment in coming years, be set aside
and appropriate Relief be granted.
Submissions heard and record perused.
30.
Admittedly, the Plaintiff was appointed as Manager (1) in the Credit
Card Collection Division at the Defendant Bank vide Appointment Letter
dated 29.10.2007 Ex. PW1/A. It provided that, he could be terminated
during the probation period by the Bank without assigning any reason and
RFA 976/2025
KUMAR BHATT
18:26:51
without giving any Notice. However, after confirmation, his service was
liable to be terminated by the Bank by giving him 90 days’ Notice or on
payment of an amount equivalent to 90 days gross salary, in lieu of Notice
period.
31.
It is not in dispute that the Plaintiff received Termination Letter on
07.07.2009 though, it was dated 05.06.2009 along with a cheque of
Rs.99,634/-, towards 03 months’ salary, in lieu of the Notice of 90 days.
Admittedly, this cheque was encashed by the Plaintiff. Once, he himself had
accepted the termination and encashed the cheque in lieu of the Notice
period, he cannot assert that his termination was not in terms of the
appointment.
32.
The Ld. District Judge, thus, rightly concluded that by accepting and
encashing the cheque, he was left with no ground to subsequently question
the grounds of termination. Therefore, the Suit of the Plaintiff denying him
reinstatement and compensation as claimed, has rightly been dismissed
while granting him salary @ Rs.35,000/- along with 6% interest for the
month of June, 2009, during which he had worked, since the Letter of
Termination was served upon him later on 07.07.2009.
33.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed
along with pending Application(s), if any.
34.
The Appeal is accordingly Dismissed.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
MARCH 13, 2026
N
RFA 976/2025
KUMAR BHATT
18:26:51
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review