Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:4662
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT
SHIMLA
CWP No.20062 of 2025
Decided on 27th February 2026
Pankaj Chauhan
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh and other
Coram
…Petitioner
…Respondents
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge
Whether approved for reporting? Yes
For the petitioner:
Mr. Hirdaya Ram, Advocate.
For the respondents: Mr. Rajat Chauhan, Assistant Advocate
General.
Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge (Oral)
Notice confined to respondents No.1 to 5 and 7.
No notice is being issued to respondents No.6, 8 and 9.
2.
Heard.
3.
Brief facts necessary for the adjudication of this
petition are that in a process initiated by the Authorities to fill up
the post of Part Time Multi Task Workers at Government
Primary School Rajaina,
District Sirmour, H.P., the private
respondent was selected vide Annexure P-5 dated 18.08.2023.
In this process, the petitioner also participated. Feeling
2026:HHC:4662
aggrieved by the appointment of the private respondent, the
petitioner preferred an appeal under Rule 19 of the Part Time
Multi Task Workers Scheme, 2020. The main ground agitated in
the appeal, as is evident from the order passed by the Authority
on the said appeal dated 07.05.2025 (Annexure A-4) was that
the private respondent had once failed in 8th class in
Government Senior Secondary School, Koti Dhiman in the
month of March, 2008 and, thereafter, he arranged to qualify 8th
class examination illegally from Himalayan Public Senior
Secondary School, Chowri, District Chamba, H.P., during the
session 2011-12 by taking admission in the said School. This
according to the petitioner violated the terms and conditions of
the Right to Education Act, 2009.
4.
Said appeal of the petitioner was dismissed by the
Authority by returning the following reason:“The appellant and all the respondents
were summoned. The respondents filed their
respective replies to the memo of appeal. The
respondent No.5 averred in his reply that the
alleged certificate, annexed with (Annexure P-6)
is genuine and has been issued in favour of the
respondent No.6 after qualifying 8th class. It is,
further averred that there is no any bar in law to
obtain education or to continue the education
and the Right to Education Act does not prohibit
2026:HHC:4662
the respondent to continue his education. The
appellant filed rejoinders to the replies filed by
the respondents. Lastly arguments were heard.
The contents of memo of appeal, replies,
rejoinders and the records, stand found placed
on the record of this case file was perused and
the arguments lead by the learned counsel for
the parties were given due consideration.
Nothing material has been found in the grounds
of appeal, rather the statement, made by
respondent No.5 in his reply is quite appealing
and genuine. In view of the above findings, the
present appeal is dismissed. The case file be
consigned to the General Record Room after
due completion.”
5.
Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner preferred a further
appeal under Rule 19 of the policy before the Director of School
Education. Said appeal of the petitioner has been dismissed by
the
Director
School
Education
vide
Annexure
P-1,
dated 18.07.2025 by returning the following findings:“The main contention of the appellant in the
present appeal is that Respondent No. 7 has
obtained Middle standard certificate from
Respondent No. 6 during the session 2011-12 in
illegal manner. The appellant contends that the
provisions of the RTE Act make it very clear that
a child means a male or female of the age of six
to fourteen years and the elementary education
means the education from 1" Class to 8th Class,
and Respondent No.7 was not a child after failing
8 class examination in GSSS Koti Dhiman
because he had attained age of 14 years one
month and 19 days on 31.03.2008. The counsel
for the appellant further contends that had the
2026:HHC:4662
Respondent. No. 7 been covered under the
definition of "child" then as per section 5 of RTE
Act, Respondent No. 7 could move from Govt.
Senior Secondary School Koti Dhiman to another
school, but not to Himalyan Public Senior
Secondary School Chowari, District Chamba,
because Himalyan Public Senior Secondary
School, Chowari is an unaided school. The
appellant also asserts that since Respondent No.
7 was 17 years old in 2011, he no longer falls
under the definition of "child" under the RTE Act
and therefore should not have been allowed to
pass the 8th Class without a board examination
as per Section 30 of the RTE Act, which requires
only a "child" to be exempt from such
examination. The appellant prays that the
impugned order dated 07.05.2025 be quashed
and set aside along with the appointment of
Respondent no. 7, and the appellant be selected
for the post of PTMTW in the said school.
On the other hand, Respondent No. 7
submitted that his 8th Class certificate is genuine
and his appointment to the said post has been
made in accordance with the policy guidelines
and after Scrutiny of documents.
The arguments presented by the counsel
for the appellant, and Respondent No. 7 were
thoroughly considered, and the case record was
carefully examined. The primary issue to be
decided in this case is whether the 8th Class
certificate submitted by Respondent. No. 7 at the
time of his selection is valid. Upon examination of
the record, it was found that, to verify the
authenticity of the 8th Class certificate, the BEEO
Dadahu wrote to Respondent No. 6, the Principal
Himalayan Public Senior Secondary School,
Chowari, District Chamba. In response,
Respondent No. 6, vide letter dated 28.06.2022,
verified that the details mentioned in the
2026:HHC:4662
certificate are correct according to the school
record. Furthermore, I find no merit in the
appellant’s argument that respondent No.7’s 8th
Class certificate is invalid simply because he had
crossed the age of 14 years at the time of his
passing of the 8th Class in the session 2011-12.
The Right to Education Act does not prohibit the
continuation of education beyond the age of 14
years. As such, the appellant’s contention that
respondent No.7’s certificate illegal is unfounded.
In view of the above, I find no infirmity in
the order passed by the First Appellate Authority
and the same is upheld. Accordingly, the present
appeal is found to be devoid of merit and is
hereby dismissed after due consideration. The
orders be conveyed accordingly.”
6.
These two orders are under challenge before this
Court.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the
orders passed by the authorities are not sustainable in the eyes
of law as both the authorities have erred in not appreciating that
as the 8th class certificate was fraudulently obtained by the
private respondent, his appointment on the strength of the said
certificate was bad in law. Learned counsel argued that
because the appointment of the private respondent was on the
basis of an invalid 8th class certificate, therefore, his
appointment being void ab-initio could not have been sustained
in law and in this backdrop, the dismissal of the appeals of the
2026:HHC:4662
petitioner is not sustainable in law. Learned counsel also
argued that the petitioner was more eligible and had a right to
be offered appointment, therefore, he prayed that the present
petition be allowed by quashing the impugned orders. He also
argued that the admission, if any, taken by the petitioner in the
private school to obtain the 8th class certificate was in violation
of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act,
2009.
8.
On the other hand, learned Assistant Advocate
General took the Court through the orders passed by the
Authorities and submitted that as concurrently both the
authorities have come to the conclusion that the 8th class
certificate presented by the private respondent was a genuine
certificate and the petitioner could not prove to the contrary
except making bald allegations that the certificate was obtained
fraudulently and same was no certificate in the eyes of law, the
present petition deserves to be dismissed. Learned Assistant
Advocate General referred to the order passed by Director
School Education and submitted that the issues raised by the
present petitioner stand decided in detail by the said authority
2026:HHC:4662
and there is a complete misreading and misinterpretation of the
provisions of the RTE Act, 2009 on behalf of the petitioner. Due
verification of the certificate was done by the authority as is
evident from Para-6 of the order passed by Director School
Education and same demonstrated that the certificate was
strictly in accordance with the record of the School, which
issued the certificate. Accordingly, the appeals of the petitioner
were rightly rejected and as there is no merit in the petition, the
same be dismissed.
9.
I have heard learned counsel for the petitioner as
also learned Assistant Advocate General and have also
carefully gone through the petition as well as the documents
appended therewith.
10.
Primarily, the challenge of the petitioner to the 8th
class certificate submitted by the private respondent, on the
basis whereof, the said respondent was offered appointment as
a Part Time Multi Task Worker, is that as the private respondent
was more than 14 years of age as on the day when he was
admitted in the School from where he passed the 8th class
examination, therefore, the certificate was a fraudulent, illegal
2026:HHC:4662
and invalid certificate.
11.
Besides bald allegations, there is no material
placed on record by the petitioner against the veracity of the
certificate in issue of the private respondent. Indeed, here, it is
not a case, where, the petitioner assailed the veracity of the
certificate of the petitioner before a Court of law and despite
there being a favourable finding in favour of the petitioner that
the certificate of the private respondent was not a genuine
certificate, the appeals of the petitioner were dismissed.
12.
The Right of Children to Free and Compulsory
Education Act, 2009 has been enacted to provide for “free and
compulsory education to all children of the age of six to
fourteen years”. This act is in furtherance of Article 21-A of the
Constitution of India, which provides that the State shall provide
free and compulsory education to all children of the age of six
to fourteen years in such manner as the State may, by law,
determine. Therefore, the purpose of the Act is to provide
compulsory education to all children between the age of six to
fourteen years so that financial barriers do not become an
impediment in the way of a child from completing eight year of
2026:HHC:4662
schooling. However, a close perusal of the provisions of this Act
demonstrates that there is no statutory bar that a person above
the age of fourteen years is not to be admitted to any School,
be it public or private in Class 8th. This Court again reiterates
that the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education
Act, 2009 is a statute, which has been enacted to ensure that
compulsory eight years of schooling is provided to a child
without any financial barriers, by making it imperative upon the
State to ensure that free and compulsory education to all
children between the age of six to fourteen years is provided,
but, this act is neither restrictive qua the classes nor does it
create any impediment that a student who in routine has failed
in a Class-8th examination, may be from a Government School
or other School, is barred beyond the age of fourteen to get
admission in any School, may be Government or private, to
pursue his further studies in Class 8th. Therefore, the contention
of the petitioner that the admission of the petitioner in the
private school after the age of fourteen in Class 8th was in
violation of the provisions of the 2009 Act is completely
fallacious and not sustainable in law. This Act nowhere comes
2026:HHC:4662
in the way of the private respondent in having obtained
admission in some other school after having failed in Class 8th
examination so as to pursue his studies in Class 8th.
13.
Incidentally, it is not the case of the petitioner that
after the private respondent had failed in Class 8th examination,
thereafter he obtained or procured a higher certificate of
matriculation etc., from some other School. His allegations are
confined to the point that he failed in a School in District
Sirmour in Class 8th and thereafter, obtained a certificate of 8th
Class from some other School i.e., a private School from
District Chamba which was bad. In this backdrop, if now we
peruse the orders that have been passed by the authorities on
the appeals preferred by the petitioner, the order passed by
Director School Education demonstrates that in order to verify
the veracity of the 8th Class Certificate submitted by the private
respondent at the time of his selection, the record was called
for. To verify authenticity of the said certificate, BEEO Dadahu
wrote to the Principal of Himalayan Public Senior Secondary
School, Chowari, District Chamba and in terms of the response
thereto vide letter dated 28.06.2022, verification was done and
2026:HHC:4662
the details mentioned in the certificate submitted by the private
respondent were found to be correct according to the School
record. Now, during the course of the hearing of this petition, it
could not be demonstrated by the petitioner that these findings
returned by the authorities were perverse and not borne out
from the record.
14.
In the backdrop of the above discussions, this Court
concurs with the findings returned by the authorities that the
petitioner was not able to substantiate that the 8th Class
Certificate submitted respondent No.7 was an invalid certificate
and it also concurs with the findings returned by the authorities
that the said certificate cannot be held to be invalid simply
because the private respondent had crossed the age of
fourteen years at the time of his admission or passing of 8th
Class in the session 2011-12.
15.
In fact, this Court would also like to observe that on
one hand, learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the
certificate has been obtained fraudulently by the private
respondent, but, in the same breath, he also argued that said
certificate cannot be relied upon, because, the same was
2026:HHC:4662
obtained by the petitioner after getting admitted in the School
having crossed the age of fourteen years. The above
demonstrates that impliedly the petitioner also admits that the
private respondent took admission in a School and it was as a
result of said admission that he passed 8th Class examination.
16.
In light of this fact, especially considering that the
petitioner has failed to demonstrate that there was any
embargo in any law that a minor who had crossed the age of
fourteen years could not have gained admission in 8th Class
after having failed in some other School, as this Court does not
find any merit in the present petition, the same is dismissed.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, also stand disposed
of.
February 27, 2026
(Vinod)
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review