Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010653952025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
Bench Sr.No:-53
[3552]
WP(PIL) NO: 230 of 2025
Pamarthy Rathnakar
...Petitioner
Vs.
Union of India, Ministry of Law and Justice, rep. by its
Secretary, New Delhi & Others
...Respondent(s)
**********
Advocate for Petitioner:
Mr.GUNDALA SIVA PRASADA
REDDY
Advocate(s) for Respondent(s):
GP FOR HOME,
GP FOR GENERAL ADMN,
Mr.N V SUMANTH,
GP FOR LAW LEGISLATIVE
AFFAIRS
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE DHIRAJ SINGH THAKUR
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 4th February 2026
ORDER: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
Practising advocate preferred present writ petition purportedly in
public interest.
The petitioner essentially challenges inaction of
respondents in (a) ensuring mandatory and periodic training to all police
officers above the rank of Station House officer with regard to arrest
procedures under Sections 41 and 41-A of Cr.P.C. to be in compliance with
the directions of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Arnesh Kumar v. State of
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.(PIL) No.230 of 2025
Bihar1; Imran Pratapgadhi v. State of Gujarat2; (b) in conducting
structured and periodic judicial programmes for all judicial magistrates with
regard to compliance with the principles and guidelines enunciated by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Arnesh Kumar1; Imran Pratapgadhi2 and Lalita
Kumari v. Govt. of U.P.3, particularly, concerning the method and manner
of exercising power of remand contemplated under Section 167 Cr.P.C;
and further direction has been sought qua respondents to issue necessary
circulars, Standard Operating Procedures, handbooks and digital training
modules ensuring uniform implementation of aforesaid guidelines by all
police stations and Magistrate Courts in the State of Andhra Pradesh.
2.
The petitioner claims that despite clear and binding directions of the
Hon’ble Apex Court coupled with specific guidelines issued in Arnesh
Kumar1 and Imran Pratapgadhi2, the police machinery throughout the
State continued to embark on unlawful procedures of arrest contrary to
Sections 41 and 41-A of Cr.P.C., which clearly amounted arbitrary arrest,
violation of personal liberty, besides defiance of the binding directions.
Petitioner also claims that the police machinery has been loath in
registration of F.I.Rs, which otherwise held compulsory in terms of Section
154 Cr.P.C. on disclosure of a cognizable offence, despite authoritative
pronouncement of the Hon’ble Apex Court Lalita Kumari3. Going a step
1 (2014) 8 SCC 273
2 (2025) 3 SCR 1309
3 (2014) 2 SCC 1
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.(PIL) No.230 of 2025
further, petitioner also claims that even the Judicial Magistrates, who play
pivotal role in safeguarding liberty of citizens, while exercising powers
under Section 167 Cr.P.C. have been routinely remanding the accused to
judicial custody notwithstanding the fact that the judgments referred to
above coupled with the guidelines issued would not warrant such course
of action in respect of cases where the offences alleged were punishable
for a period less than 7 years.
With these general statements and
pleadings, petitioner has come with the present Public Interest Litigation
seeking for the reliefs, as mentioned supra.
3.
The pleadings in the writ petition do not specifically refer to any of
particular instance or the specific details of the cases in which the police
machinery across the State have refused to register F.I.Rs, that they in
defiance of the directions and guidelines issued by the Hon’ble Apex Court
did not adhere to procedure contemplated under Sections 41 and 41-A of
Cr.P.C. and the details of the cases where Judicial Magistrates subjected
the accused for remand without regard to the requirement of recording
satisfaction. Nevertheless, along with the writ petition, petitioner annexed
two undated representations stated to have been submitted by one
Mr.Munagala Hariswar Reddy and the other by Smt.Peddireddy Sudharani
to the Registrar (Judicial) of this Court, complaining of a specific violation
in their respective cases at the instance of the Courts’ mentioned therein.
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.(PIL) No.230 of 2025
Further, under Ex.P4, a list of cases consisting of 147 in number alleged
to be remanded cases, has also been furnished in support thereof.
4.
Initially, the matter was listed on 10.12.2025, on which date, upon
hearing the arguments of learned counsel for the petitioner, this Court has
ordered notice to the respondents. Learned Special Government Pleader
appearing for respondents 4 to 8 waived service, hence, notice was issued
only to other respondents, and the matter was directed to be listed on
04.02.2026. Today, when the matter was called, learned counsel for the
petitioner tried to advance arguments on merits of the matter. However,
learned counsel for respondents 4 to 8 sought for time to file response, so
also, learned counsel for respondents 9, 10 and 12.
5.
As the matter was listed only once after notice and that too the
respondents are yet to file their response, we initially intended to adjourn
the matter granting time for filing response by respective learned counsels
for the respondents. However, learned counsel for the petitioner opposed
granting any further time in the matter and rather insisted to proceed with
the hearing. Though we tried to make understand learned counsel for the
petitioner that the matter probably would require appropriate response
from the party respondents, without heeding to what has been expressed,
Sri G.Siva Prasada Reddy, learned counsel for the petitioner, by raising
voice, insisted the Court to conclude the hearing and pass orders on merits
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.(PIL) No.230 of 2025
today itself. The behaviour and manner in which learned counsel for the
petitioner tried to address the Court in the process requires specific
mention, hence, we propose to deal with the same in the later part of our
order to follow, after expressing our opinion on the merits of the matter.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner reiterated the averments made in
the petition and tried to highlight that the police machinery and as well as
the Judicial Magistrates across the State were really not following the
guidelines and directives issued by the Hon’ble Apex Court in in Arnesh
Kumar1; Imran Pratapgadhi2 and Lalita Kumari3 either with respect to
registration of F.I.R, the procedure to be adopted at the stage of arrest to
be in compliance with Sections 41 and 41-A of Cr.P.C. or exercising powers
under Section 167 Cr.P.C. by Judicial Magistrates on production of
accused for remand. When it was pointed out by us to show what material
petitioner gathered or collated before institution of present writ petition in
support of aforesaid claim, learned counsel has drawn our attention to
Ex.P3 and Ex.P4.
7.
Ex.P3 consists of two undated representations addressed by two
individuals, who were concerned with their individual grievance. The said
representations really do not contain any date nor the acknowledgement
that the same were received by the Registrar (Judicial). Ex.P4 is a list of
cases, which according to the learned counsel for the petitioner, in all the
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.(PIL) No.230 of 2025
cases mentioned therein, the Judicial Magistrates subjected the accused
to judicial remand. Except for these two documents, no other document
has been placed on record, and even these documents are also
unverifiable. Such unverifiable documents cannot be taken cognizance of
by this Court in any manner.
8.
The present writ petition coupled with the submissions made by the
learned counsel for the petitioner is required to be tested on the basis of
pleadings made therein and the documents exhibited in support thereof.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the petitioner has
contended that even as recently as day before, one of the Ex-Minister
namely Sri Ambati Rambabu has been arrested by police and produced
before the jurisdictional Magistrate for remand and that judicial remand
was ordered without even bothering to verify whether the procedure under
Section 41-A and directions of the Hon’ble Apex Court in in Arnesh
Kumar1; Imran Pratapgadhi2 were adhered to, hence, in that view of the
matter, insisted the Court to summon the Director General of Police and
the Director of A.P. Judicial Academy to appear before the Court. Aforesaid
submission neither emanates from the pleadings nor any additional
affidavit has been filed to bring the said aspect on record. The manner in
which learned counsel for the petitioner tried to address the Court in a way
putting pressure to hear the matter by bringing in the aspects which
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.(PIL) No.230 of 2025
otherwise not pleaded in the writ petition raises any amount of doubt
regards his craving for publicity.
9.
Before delving into the said aspects and testing the bona fides of the
petitioner in insisting to hear writ petition, it is fundamental to verify as to
what kind of homework really petitioner undertook to collate the material
information for him to come to a conclusion that the police machinery and
the Judicial Magistrates were in defiance to the guidelines and directions
of the Hon’ble Apex Court. As mentioned above, except for Exs.P3 and
P.4, there is nothing on record either pleaded or demonstrably exhibited.
One important aspect that needs emphasis is regarding the source of
information on which petitioner relied on in framing the petition. Para.8 of
the petition refers to the source of information to be from the website of
Ministry of Law and Justice (Legislative Department), paper publications
and news articles. However, in the affidavit that is filed in terms of Rule
4(e) of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh Public Interest Litigation Rules,
2015, in para.3, petitioner has stated that the source of information for filing
the writ petition was acquired through the authorities and villagers.
10.
Apparently, these two declarations run contrary to each other. Even
otherwise, Ex.P3 and Ex.P4 also do not correlate with the source of
information as declared above. It is not known as to how petitioner has
secured Ex.P3 representations, assuming the same to be genuine and
submitted by the respective persons therein to the Registrar (Judicial).
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.(PIL) No.230 of 2025
Likewise, the source of information set out in Ex.P4 also would not
emanate from the declared source of information. The declaration so
made in the petition and also in the affidavit filed in terms of Rule 4(e) and
the documents produced clearly amount to misleading statements. We
are of the opinion that petitioner was least bothered to do any homework
before instituting the present writ petition and rather chose to declare false
source of information in collating the information, which is clearly an abuse
of process of law.
11.
The conclusion arrived at by us is also fortified by the observations
of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Ashok Kumar Pandey v. State of W.B.4,
which incidentally also dealt with the requirements of applicant coming with
definitive and assertive material rather than resting the case based on
vague and indefinite information. Further, the Hon’ble Apex Court also
while explaining the circumspection with which the Courts have to exercise
the jurisdiction while dealing with matters under public interest litigation,
made the following observations:
<12. Public interest litigation is a weapon which has to be
used with great care and circumspection and the judiciary has to
be extremely careful to see that behind the beautiful veil of public
interest an ugly private malice, vested interest and/or publicityseeking is not lurking. It is to be used as an effective weapon in the
armoury of law for delivering social justice to citizens. The attractive
brand name of public interest litigation should not be used for
4 (2004) 3 SCC 349
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.(PIL) No.230 of 2025
suspicious products of mischief. It should be aimed at redressal of
genuine public wrong or public injury and not publicity-oriented or
founded on personal vendetta. As indicated above, court must be
careful to see that a body of persons or a member of the public,
who approaches the court is acting bona fide and not for personal
gain or private motive or political motivation or other oblique
consideration. The court must not allow its process to be abused
for oblique considerations. Some persons with vested interest
indulge in the pastime of meddling with judicial process either by
force of habit or from improper motives. Often they are actuated by
a desire to win notoriety or cheap popularity. The petitions of such
busybodies deserve to be thrown out by rejection at the threshold,
and in appropriate cases, with exemplary costs.
***
14. The court has to be satisfied about : (a) the credentials of
the applicant; (b) the prima facie correctness or nature of
information given by him; and (c) the information being not vague
and indefinite. The information should show gravity and
seriousness involved. Court has to strike balance between two
conflicting interests : (i) nobody should be allowed to indulge in wild
and reckless allegations besmirching the character of others; and
(ii) avoidance of public mischief and to avoid mischievous petitions
seeking to assail, for oblique motives, justifiable executive actions.
In such case, however, the court cannot afford to be liberal. It has
to be extremely careful to see that under the guise of redressing a
public grievance, it does not encroach upon the sphere reserved
by the Constitution to the executive and the legislature. The court
has to act ruthlessly while dealing with imposters and busybodies
or meddlesome interlopers impersonating as public-spirited holy
men. They masquerade as crusaders of justice. They pretend to
act in the name of pro bono publico, though they have no interest
of the public or even of their own to protect.=
12.
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.(PIL) No.230 of 2025
We also noticed from the pleadings made in the writ petition that the
non-compliance or violation of provisions and directives of the Hon’ble
Apex Court those that were specifically mentioned were tracing to the
provisions of Cr.P.C, in particular, Sections 41 and 41-A, 154 and 167
Cr.P.C.
Conspicuously the pleadings really do not refer to the
corresponding provisions under the new enactment Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short, <BNSS=), which repealed the Cr.P.C.
So, we would like to point out that the present writ petition has been filed
very casually.
13.
Be that as it may, insofar as the directions those that were issued by
the Hon’ble Apex Court in Arnesh Kumar1; Imran Pratapgadhi2, which
later were also followed by this Court in Bollineni Rajagopal Naidu v.
State of A.P.5, in relation to the Judicial Magistrates exercising the power
of remand, this Court on administrative side has already issued Circular
No.8/2025
in
Roc.No.99/SO/2023,
dated
05.07.2025
read
with
Corrigendum, dated 29.07.2025, reiterating the guidelines and it was
made clear that all the Judicial Magistrates should invariably follow the
circular instructions scrupulously and any violation of law laid down by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the above referred cases would render themselves
liable for departmental action. That apart, even one of the directions
5 2022 (3) ALT 407
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.(PIL) No.230 of 2025
issued in Arnesh Kumar1 also makes the erring police officials liable for
not only departmental action, but they shall also be proceeded for
contempt of court to be instituted before the High Court having territorial
jurisdiction and the persons aggrieved were entitled to move such an
application. The said circular has already been widely circulated to all
Judicial Officers across the State. We are also told that similar instructions
have already been issued by the Police as well.
14.
Seen from the aforesaid spectrum, we find that the issues those that
are raised in the writ petition are merely to gain publicity. The petitioner,
as a prudent person, also being an advocate, least expected was to make
an attempt in gathering the relevant and genuine information by resorting
to R.T.I. Further, ought to have represented concerned Departments to
elicit the required information, and also sensitized them to follow the
directions and guidelines, if at all they were in breach. Without undertaking
such an exercise, a fanciful attempt has been made to gain publicity under
the guise of the present writ petition.
15.
In this regard, it would be beneficial to refer to the relevant
observations of this Court in Mallavarapu Lakshmana Kumar v. State of
A.P.6, which read as follows:
6 Order, dated 19.02.2025, passed in W.P.(PIL) No.30 of 2025 (APHC)
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.(PIL) No.230 of 2025
<…In this regard, it would be beneficial to refer to the Apex
Court judgment in the case of State of Uttaranchal Vs. Balwant
Singh Chaufal : (2010) 3 SCC 402), wherein, it was held:
"181. ........ (8) The Courts should also ensure that the
petitions filed by busybodies for extraneous and ulterior
motives must be discouraged by imposing exemplary costs
or by adopting similar novel methods to curb frivolous
petitions and the petitions filed for extraneous
considerations."
4. In BALCO Employees' Union (Regd.) Vs. Union of
India : (2022) 2 SCC 333), the Apex Court held:
"79. There is, in recent years, a feeling which is not
without any foundation that public interest litigation is now
tending to become publicity interest litigation or private
interest litigation and has a tendency to be
counterproductive."
5. In Janata Dal Vs. H.S. Chowdary and others : (1992) 4
SCC 305), the Apex Court held:
"110. ..... The busybodies, meddlesome interlopers,
wayfarers or officious interveners having absolutely no
public interest except for personal gain or private profit
either for themselves or as proxy of others or for any other
extraneous motivation or for glare of publicity break the
queue muffling their faces by wearing the mask of public
interest litigation, and get into the Courts by filing vexatious
and frivolous petitions and thus criminally waste the
valuable time of Courts and as result of which the queue
standing outside the doors of the Court never moves which
piquant situation creates a frustration in the minds of the
genuine litigants and resultantly they lose faith in the
administration of our judicial system."
6. In Dattaraj Nathuji Thaware Vs. State of Maharastra :
((2005) 1 SCC 590), the Apex Court further held that the petitions
of such busybodies deserve to be thrown out by rejection at the
threshold, and in appropriate cases with exemplary costs.=
16.
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.(PIL) No.230 of 2025
As observed by us above, the present petition indeed had many
shortcomings in the nature of contradictory declarations amounting to
misleading statements, besides producing unverifiable documents
(Exs.P3 and P4) lacking their exact source. Petitioner also shown undue
haste in insisting hearing of the matter by exerting pressure on the Court,
referring to an incident of Ex-Minister being arrested and sent to remand a
day before, which otherwise, was neither part of original petition nor
subsequently pleaded by filing any additional affidavit. Hence, in our
opinion, this petition has been filed merely to draw greater publicity.
17.
We, therefore, find no merit in the writ petition. We are of the view
that this petition is frivolous and non-serious, besides being vexatious.
Petitioner also abused the process of the Court by making misleading
statements. We, accordingly, dismiss the writ petition with exemplary
costs of Rs.5,00,000/- (Rupees Five Lakhs only) to be deposited with the
Andhra Pradesh State Legal Services Authority to be utilized for the benefit
of children, who suffer from visual and hearing impairment. Costs to be
deposited positively within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt
of a copy of this Order.
18.
The Registry is directed to submit a compliance report to this Court
regarding payment of the aforesaid costs. If the costs are not paid, the
HCJ & CGR, J.
W.P.(PIL) No.230 of 2025
Registrar (Judicial) shall take steps for recovery of the same in accordance
with law.
19.
Before parting with the case, we would like to express our
displeasure regarding the behaviour, tone and tenor exhibited by the
learned counsel for the petitioner while arguing the case. It is very much
disappointing to note that learned counsel for the petitioner utterly failed to
maintain the decency and decorum meeting the expected standards and
rather his derogatory comments and aggression at the top of his voice,
intending to dictate the Court the manner in which proceedings are to be
conducted, clearly depicted his arrogance, defiance and contumacious
attitude which, in our opinion, undermine the dignity of the Court. Since
learned counsel for the petitioner is also an officer of the Court, is dutybound to be mindful of the limitations and always endeavour to uphold the
dignity of the Court. He should also maintain absolute professionalism,
besides extending respect to the Bench. With a word of caution to the
learned counsel for the petitioner, henceforth not to repeat such behaviour
and unprofessionalism in the Courts, we rest the matter.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending in this case, if any,
shall stand closed.
DHIRAJ SINGH THAKUR, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J
cs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review