Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 23RD DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 2181 OF 2011 (MON)
BETWEEN:
P V ANAND KISHORE
MAJOR PROP: MOTOR CYCLE COMPONENTS
NO.16, BEHIND S B I,
J C ROAD CROSS, J C ROAD,
BANGALORE-560 002.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. MITHUN GERAHALLI A., ADVOCATE)
AND:
M/S BHATT ELECTRONICS (P) LTD.,
REP BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR
SRI K C BHAT
NO. 8/1, PALMGROVE ROAD
BANGALORE.
Digitally signed
by SUMA B N
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. Y K NARAYANA SHARMA ., ADVOCATE)
THIS RFA IS FILED U/SEC.96 OF CPC, AGAINST THE
ORDERS DATED 05.06.2011 PASSED IN FDP.NO.37/1991 ON
THE FILE OF THE XXVII-ADDL. CITY CIVIL JUDGE, BANGALORE,
ALLOWING THE PETITION FILED U/O-20, RULE-17, R/W,
SEC.151 OF CPC.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL
-2NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
This appeal is by the defendants in O.S.No.3085/1985
aggrieved by the order dated 05.06.2011 passed in F.D.P.
No.37/1991 on the file of XXVII Additional City Civil Judge,
Bengaluru, (hereinafter referred to as 'FDP Court') in terms of
which,
while
allowing
the
petition
filed
by
the
plaintiff/respondent herein under Order XX Rule 17 read with
Section 151 of CPC, defendants/appellants herein have been
held liable to pay Rs.3,00,000/- towards the sale of electronic
goods (Nite Honda) by the defendant No.1/appellant No.1,
payable to the plaintiff/respondent with interest at 8% per
annum from the date of petition till realisation.
2. Brief facts of the case leading upto filing of the present
appeal are that, the above suit in O.S.No.3085/1985 filed by
the plaintiff/respondent herein under Section 105 of the Trade
and Merchandise Marks Act,1958 and Section 53 of the Designs
Act, 1911 read with Section 26, and Order VII Rule 1 of CPC,
for the following reliefs:
''(a) Manufacture or marketing emergency lights or torches
bearing the impugned design as per Exhibit No.2, hereto or any
other design which is either a fraudulent or obvious imitation of
the plaintiff's registered design Nos. 151581 in class 1 (one)
and 151582 in Class 3 (Three) or by use of impugned mark
-3NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
'NITE HONDA' or any other on or in relation to such goods
which is in any manner deceptively or confusingly similar to the
plaintiff's trademark "NITESUN', and from passing off
emergency lights or torches (not of the plaintiff's manufacture)
as or for the plaintiff's emergency lights or torches as per
Exhibits No.1 hereto by the use of the impugned design as per
Exhibit-2 hereto or any other design which is in any manner
deceptively or confusingly similar to the plaintiff's design as per
Exhibit No.1, hereto and
OR
Directing the first and second defendant to render on oath a
true and faithful account of the offending emergency lights or
torches sold by them with full particulars of each sum ad may
be determined by this Hon'ble Court as damages for the piracy
of design and passing off committed by the defendants.
(ii) Directing the first and second defendants to surrender to
the plaintiff. For destruction, all offending emergency lights or
torches all pamphlets, trade literature and the like and all
implements used in the manufacture of preparation of the same
including blocks, dies moulds and the like.
(c) Directing the defendant to pay to the plaintiff the costs of
this suit; and
(d) granting such other relief or relief's as this Hon'ble Court
may deem fir to grant in the circum stances of the case in the
interest of justice.''
3. The said suit after the contest was decreed by the
judgment and order dated 30.08.1989 as under:
ORDER
''The suit of the plaintiff is decreed with costs.
Defendant 1 and 2 are herby permanently restrained
from manufacturing and marketing the said emergency lights or
torches like Ex.P-16 which is the imitation of the plaintiff's
registered design No.151581 in class-I, and 151582 in Class-3.
Defendant 1 and 2 or any one claiming under them are
hereby permanently restrained from using the impugned mark
NITEHONDA or may other mark in relation to the goods
manufactured by them.
-4NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
There shall be an enquiry into the sale of the emergency
lights or torches sold by defendant 1 and 2 claiming to be the
goods of the plaintiff under the name and style NITEHONDA.
Draw decree accordingly.''
4. Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree, appellant
herein
Appeal
in
M.A.No.330/1993, which was dismissed on 09.10.2001.
As
against
had
which,
preferred
a
a
Miscellaneous
Miscellaneous
First
Appeal
in
MFA
No.6943/2001 was filed and same was also dismissed on
30.06.2005. Thus, judgment and decree dated 30.08.1989
attained finality. In furtherance to the said judgment and
decree, plaintiff/respondent herein filed an application under
Order 20 Rule 17 of CPC seeking determination of damages.
Objections to the same were filed.
5. One Sri. K. C. Bhatt, who is the plaintiff/respondent
herein examined himself as PW1 and exhibited 38 documents
as Ex.P1 to Ex.P38. One Sri. P.V. Anand Kishore-defendant
No.1/appellate
No.1
herein
examined
him
as
RW1.
No
documentary evidence was led in. On appreciation of the
evidence, the FDP Court passed the following order:
''Petition filed by the petitioner under Order 20 Rule 17
R/w/S 151 of CPC 151 of CPC is allowed with costs.
-5NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
The mesne profits is determined at Rs.3 lakhs towards the
sale of the electronic goods (Nite Honda) by respondent No.1.
Petitioner is held entitled for the said mesne profits of Rs.3
lakhs together with interest at the rate of 8% pa from the date
of petition till realisation.
The petitioner to pay the requisite court fee on the amount
determined.
There shall be final decree in the above terms.
Office to draw the final decree after collecting necessary
court fee.''
6. Aggrieved by the same, the present appeal is filed.
7. Sri. Mithun Gerahalli, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant taking this Court through the records, vehemently
submits that the impugned judgment and order passed by the
FDP Court is unsustainable as the same runs contrary to the
settled principles of law. That unless and until a direct nexus is
pleaded, proved and established with regard to manufacturing
of the alleged product and selling of the same, a relief of
damages can neither be considered nor ascertained. That
legally acceptable cogent evidence is required to be presented
and proved and it cannot be left for mere inference from the
facts and circumstances of the case. He refers to document at
Exs.P2 and P3 produced by the plaintiff/respondent herein, in
support of the allegation of defendant/appellant involving in the
sale of the product to contend that the said documents are
-6NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
hardly of any use, inasmuch as there is neither any name of
the appellant nor the indication of appellant manufacturing and
selling the product. Therefore, he submits that the FDP Court
has grossly erred in fastening the liability of damages on the
appellant in the absence of any acceptable evidence, resulting
in perversity in the impugned judgment.
8. In support of his contention, he relies upon the
judgment of the Delhi High Court in the case of Infosys
Technologies Ltd., Vs. Prak Infosys and others1, referring
to paragraph Nos.42 and 43 of the said judgment, he insists
that in terms of the law which is settled, unless direct cogent
evidence is produced to establish the loss which has resulted on
account of direct link or nexus of manufacture and selling of the
product of the appellate, plaintiffs are not entitled for the relief
as sought for. Hence, seeks for allowing of the appeal.
9. In response, Sri. Y.K. Narayana Sharma, learned
counsel for the plaintiff/respondent herein taking this Court
through the record, submits that the preliminary decree passed
by the trial Court in O.S.No.3085/1985 having attained finality.
(2007) 137 DLT 349
-7NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
Wherein a categorical finding has been rendered with regard to
defendant/appellant
having
involved
not
only
in
the
manufacturing of the product but also of its sale, it is not open
for the appellants now to re-agitate the said issue. He submits
there is an admission on the part of the respondent witness of
he purchasing the product from the plaintiff which is sufficient
enough
to
indicate
manufacturing
but
that
he
imitating
was
not
the
only
involved
in
product
of
the
plaintiff/respondent herein, but was also involved in selling of
the product.
As regards, the proof of loss sustained by the
plaintiff, he submits as many as 38 documentary evidence have
been produced including the balance sheets and account
statements indicating declining sales of the product by the
plaintiff/respondent herein, which are solely attributable to the
illegality committed by the defendant/appellant herein.
He
further submits that on the contrary, no documentary evidence
has been produced by the defendant/appellant herein with
regard to the nature of sales of their business and the quantum
though he had admitted to have maintained such accounts,
which the FDP Court has taken note of. Thus he submits that
no error or irregularity can be attributed in FDP court coming to
-8NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
the conclusion in fastening the liability or payment of the
damages as done in the instant case.
10. Heard and perused the records.
11. The only point that arise for consideration is;
(1). Whether the FDP Court was justified in accepting
the plea of the plaintiff/respondent herein in fastening the
liability of payment of Rs.3,00,000/- as damages together
with interest rate 8% per annum from the date of petition
till realisation?
12. Facts with regard to filing of the suit, unsuccessful
challenge to the decree passed therein by the respondent as
noted hereinabove do not require reiteration. However, for the
limited purpose of appreciating the contentions urged by the
learned counsel
by the appellant and the respondent, the
averments in the plaint and the written statement, evidence led
therein and the findings given by the trial Court are adverted to
as hereunder.
13. At paragraph No.10 of the plaint, the plaintiff has
specifically averred as under:
'' It is submitted that the 1st defendant was a dealer in
Automobile spare parts and he started the business in
-9NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
dealing in Emergency Lights and Torches at the instance
of the plaintiff and commenced the said business with the
sales of the plaintiff's products. However, later on after he
found that the business in dealing with the sales of
plaintiffs' produced was lucrative, the 1st defendant, for
fraudulently made use of the good will established by the
plaintiff in the sales of plaintiff's produced, for the sale of
the defendant's won produced by infringing the rights of
the plaintiff and putting the plaintiff to loss.''
14. Perusal of the written statement would indicate that
there is neither any express nor there is any implicit denial to
the aforesaid pleading. It is settled position of law, averment
made in the plaint have to be specifically denied, failing which,
same would amount to admission. The Apex Court in the case
of Thangam vs Navamani Ammal, wherein at paragraph
Nos.24 to 27 held as under:
24. In the absence of para-wise reply to the plaint, it
becomes a roving inquiry for the Court to find out as to
which line in some paragraph in the plaint is either
admitted or denied in the written statement filed, as there
is no specific admission or denial with reference to the
allegation in different paragraphs.
25. Order 8 Rules 3 and 5 CPC clearly provides for specific
admission and denial of the pleadings in the plaint. A
general or evasive denial is not treated as sufficient.
Proviso to Order 8 Rule 5 CPC provides that even the
admitted facts may not be treated to be admitted, still in
its discretion the Court may require those facts to be
proved. This is an exception to the general rule. General
rule is that the facts admitted, are not required to be
proved.
26. The requirements of Order 8 Rules 3 and 5 CPC are
specific admission and denial of the pleadings in the
plaint. The same would necessarily mean dealing with the
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
allegations in the plaint para-wise. In the absence
thereof, the respondent can always try to read one line
from one paragraph and another from different paragraph
in the written statement to make out his case of denial of
the allegations in the plaint resulting in utter confusion.
27. In case the respondent-defendant wishes to take any
preliminary objections, the same can be taken in a
separate set of paragraphs specifically so as to enable the
plaintiff/petitioner to respond to the same in the
replication/rejoinder, if need be. The additional pleadings
can also be raised in the written statement, if required.
These facts specifically stated in a set of paragraphs will
always give an opportunity to the plaintiff/petitioner to
respond to the same. This in turn will enable the Court to
properly comprehend the pleadings of the parties instead
of digging the facts from the various paragraphs of the
plaint and the written statement.
15. Similarly, in the case of Jaspal Kaur Cheema vs.
Industrial Trade Links reported in (2017) 8 SCC 592 the
Hon'ble Apex Court at paragraph No.7 held as under:
7. In terms of Order 8 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (for short “the Code”), a defendant is
required to deny or dispute the statements made in the
plaint categorically, as evasive denial would amount to an
admission of the allegation made in the plaint in terms of
Order 8 Rule 5 of the Code. In other words, the written
statement must specifically deal with each of the
allegations of fact made in the plaint. The failure to make
specific denial amounts to an admission. This position is
clear from the decisions of this Court in Badat and
Co. v. East India Trading Co. [Badat and Co. v. East India
Trading Co., (1964) 4 SCR 19 : AIR 1964 SC 538] , Sushil
Kumar v. Rakesh Kumar [Sushil Kumar v. Rakesh Kumar,
(2003) 8 SCC 673] and M. Venkataramana Hebbar v. M.
Rajagopal
Hebbar [M.
Venkataramana Hebbar v. M.
Rajagopal Hebbar, (2007) 6 SCC 401] .
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
16. The trial Court, while answering issue Nos.2 and 3,
namely:
''2. Does he further prove that defendant has committed gross
piracy of the registered design and passing of his articles and
thereby causing loss and damage to him?
3. Is plaintiff entitled to injunction sought for?''
17. At paragraph No.11 of the judgment trial court has
categorically come to the conclusion that: ''in spite of giving
number of opportunities to the defendant No.1, he has not
disclosed the name of the manufacturer of Ex.P16 and there is
nothing on record to show whether there is a patent registered
any emergency light under the name of NITEHONDA. Ex.P17
and Ex.P18 are the two certificates issued by the plaintiff in
favour of defendant No.2 to show that he was working with the
plaintiff.''
18. This fact is not denied by the defendant No.2. Ex.P19
is a letter by the plaintiff to defendant No.2. The said letter is
also intimating defendant No.2, the imitation articles.
19. At paragraph Nos.12 and 13, the trial Court has held
as under:
''12. It is the case of the plaintiff that in the beginning, there
was lot of sales in the business of the emergency lights after
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
introducing Ex.P-15 and subsequent to imitation of Ex.P15 like
Ex.p16, there was a decline in the sale of the products of the
plaintiff and therefore, according to him he has suffered heavy
loss. The visiting card which was marked ad Ex.P-8 clearly goes
to show that subsequent to leaving the services of the plaintiff
concern, the 2nd defendant was a stockiest and dealer for
Honda articles. Either the 1st defendant or the 2nd defendants
have not disclosed the name of the manufacturer NITEHONDA.
Therefore, the Court has to presume that the defendant have
committed piracy of the registered design of the plaintiff and
have manufactured emergency lights like Ex.P-16 which is
exactly the imitation of Ex.P-15.
13. The affidavit of 3rd party at Ex.P-7 clearly goes to show
that public was under the impression that Ex.P-16 is the
product of the plaintiff concern which is of a changed variety. As
per the affidavit it clearly goes to show that emergency lights
NITEHONDA was not of a good quality. According to the plaintiff
there was a decline in his business on account of introduction of
imitation of emergency lights. There is no rebuttal evidence on
behalf of the defendants. The oral evidence of the plaintiff along
with other documentary evidence clearly goes to show that he
did suffer loss on account of piracy of the design committed by
the defendants 1 and 2. It there is no order of injunction, the
plaintiff would be put to irreparable loss and hardship and if
there is an order of injunction, defendants 1 and 2 would not be
put to any such hardship or irreparable loss and injury. Hence,
the Court is of the opinion that issue No.2 has to be answered
in the Affirmative and issue No.3 in the Negative. Accordingly
both these issues are answered.''
20. Clearly, it is based on the aforesaid material evidence
and admission on record, the trial Court had come to the
conclusion of defendants/appellant herein being guilty of
manufacturing the products as that of the plaintiff's and
committing piracy of the designs. The aforesaid pleading as
noted above, evidence and the finding not having been
disputed,
now
it
does
not
lie
in
the
mouth
of
the
defendant/appellants herein to contend that they were neither
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
connected directly nor indirectly, nor were they involved in
manufacturing or selling of the product.
21. Plaintiff in the plaint at paragraph No.11 has
extracted the statement of its sales and turnover in respect to
said emerging lights for the period of 1982-83 to 1984-85
indicating purported decline in its sales, which is as under:
PERIOD
SALES TURNOVER
(April-March)
1982-83
Rs.97,137-75/-
1983-84
Rs.49,163-96/-
1984-85
Rs.22,296/-
22. Plaintiff has also produced documents in support of
the said business turnover at Ex.P20. In addition to production
of Exs.P2 and P3, though which is vehemently disputed by
learned counsel for the appellant, has also produced affidavit of
one Rugmani Menon produced at Ex.P4 with regard to purchase
of the imitation product.
23. Reliance placed on by learned counsel for the
appellant
to
the
judgment
in
the
case
of
Infosys
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
Technologies
Ltd(referred
supra)wherein
at
paragraph
Nos.42 and 43 it is held as under:
''42. In an action for infringement of trademark, the profits
made by the defendant cannot always be the true criterion of
the damages awardable to the plaintiff as the defendant's gain
may not always be proportionate to the plaintiff's loss.
However, it is trite that the plaintiff's loss or the defendant's
gain will not be assumed in the absence of proof. The plaintiff is
required to prove some distinct damage from the infringement
of his trademark by defendant. The effect of the infringing acts
of the defendant may be evidenced by diminishing of the
quantum of goods sold by the plaintiff for the reason that the
defendant took away the plaintiff's customers. The defendant
may also impact the plaintiff's customers. The defendant may
also impact the plaintiff's business by causing him to sell its
products at a lower price. In either event, there would be a
reduction in either the total volume of the plaintiff's business or
lowering in the percentage increase of business as compared to
the previous years. Thus the measure of damage suffered by
the plaintiff is to be found by an assessment of the profits the
plaintiff would have made if the offending article had not been
introduced by the defendant in the market or if the defendant
had not undertaken the illegal activities complained of by the
plaintiff. Accordingly, the plaintiff is held to be entitled to the
decree of injunction as well as an order for delivery up forthwith
of all goods and stationery bearing the trademark or capable of
reproducing the trademark. These facts have to be proved by
the evidence on record either relating to the business of the
defendants or which could be assessed from a decline in the
business of the plaintiff on account of the activities of the
defendant which could be gathered from the figures of sales
over the period of time during which the plaintiff has continued
with the activities complained of and an assertion of such loss
by the plaintiff in its evidence.
43. Upon a consideration of the plaint and the affidavit by way
of the evidence filed before this Court, I find that the plaintiff
has failed to prove either the profits derived by the defendant
from its illegal activities or such sales record to establish the
loss which has resulted to the plaintiff by establishing a decline
in the value of its business or a fall in the percentage increase
in the business as compared to preceding years. The only
material which has been placed by the plaintiff on record is the
value of its international sales over different years. Bald figures
without even an assertion of loss or diminution in business and
without any submission in this behalf do not establish the
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
essential features noticed above which would have entitled the
plaintiff to damages. Therefore, while holding that the
defendants cannot be permitted to continue with its illegal
activities, however, I find that no award of damages can be
made in favour of the plaintiff.''
24. The said judgment in the opinion of this Court would
be more helpful to the plaintiff than the defendants. In that, as
observed in paragraph No.4, the assessment of the decline in
the business of the plaintiff can be gathered from the accounts
activities and the figures of sale over the period of time during
which the plaintiff has continued with the activities complained
and assertion of such loss to the plaintiff in its evidence. As
already noted above, there is no denial directly, expressly or
implied by the defendant of he indeed, selling the product of
plaintiff as asserted at paragraph No.10 of the plaint. There is
also no denial or any rebuttal evidence by the defendant of he
or anybody else manufacturing the said product. Sale is only
consequential of it, which can be inferred from the fact and
circumstances of this case.
Though Exs.P2 and P3 may not
bear the name of the manufacturer, pleading at paragraph
No.10 and the finding of the trial court for issue Nos.1 and 2
has to be read in the light of the evidence led by the plaintiff
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:4403
RFA No. 2181 of 2011
HC-KAR
with regard to decline of his sale product, which has been
appreciated by the FDP Court.
25. Therefore, this Court under facts and circumstances,
do not find any illegality or irregularity in the conclusion arrived
at by the FDP Court.
Appeal is dismissed. Order passed by
the FDP Court is confirmed.
Sd/(M.G.S. KAMAL)
JUDGE
RL
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review