Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
13257 |
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE JUWADI SRIDEVI
tlq
NN
Between:
P.Sheela, d/o P.M Mahesh Aged 36 years' Occ student H.No' 1-75 /3,
Srinivas nagar, Boduppal Municipality, Mandal, Medchal-Malkajgiri District'
...PETITIONER
D
1. The State of Telangana, rep. by its principal Secretary, Higher Education
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The Osmania University, Rep by its Registrar, O.U'Campus, Hyderabad
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 o1 lhe constitution of lndia praying that in the
pleased
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
to pass an order, or issue any directions or issue any appropriate writ more
particularly in the nature of wRlT oF MANDAMUS declaring the action of the 2nd
respondent in rejecting the petitioner's representation dated 25.04.2022 through vide
MR.No. llzlPvAcadtFlout2o22 dated 30.06.2022, which was submitted in
in
compliance with the directions of this Hon',ble court in its order dated 18.04.2022
wP No. 16934 of 2022, as illegal. This rejection has resulted in the cancellation of
the petitioner's PhD admission, effectively nullifying her 8 112 years of effort due to
circumstances beyond her control, such as the coVlD-19 pandemic and the
a
discontinuation of her supervisor due to health issues. The petitioner had sought
one-year extension to submit her PhD thesis, which was unjustly denied. This
rejection is unlawful, arbitrary, discriminatory, and contrary to the principles of natural
justice, as well as violative of Articles 14 and 21 of the constitution of lndia'
Consequently, set aside the impugned Speaking Order issued under MR'No'
1!lFI!!'Fr.E.Pr!F't7
117lPNAcadlFlOUl2022 dated 30.06.2022, and direct tl'e 2nd respondent to
appoint a new supervisor to enable the petitioner to compllte her remaining PhD
thesis work, and further extend the deadline for submitting the petitioner's PhD thesis
by at least one year from the date of assigning the new supenrisor
l.A. NO: 1OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in suppcrt of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend
the impugned Speaking Orde.,r issued under MR.No. 117lPV,\cadlFlaU2022 dated
30.06.2022
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may b,-. pleased to direct the
2nd respondent to appoint a new supervisor to enable the petitioner to complete her
remaining PhD thesis work, and further extend the deadline for submitting the
petitione/s PhD thesis by at least one year from the date of assigning the new
supervisor
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRl. RAMESH CHILLA
Counsel for the Respondent No. 'l : SRI M. VAMSHI KIRAN,
GP FOR EDUCATIOII
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI MALIPEDDI SRINI\AS REDDY,
SC FOR OU
The Court made the following: ORDER
}
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE JUWADI SRIDEVI
1of2
A
DATED:2hJUNE. 2026
Between
... Petitioner
P.Sheela
AND
The State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Higher
Education Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad and another
... Respondents
ORDER:
This Writ Petition is filed by the petitioner seeking the
following relief:
"...fo pass an order or issue any directions or
issue any appropriate writ more particularly in the
nature of WRIT OF MANDAMUS declaring the
action of the 2nd respondent in rqecting the
petitioners representation dated 25.04.2022
through vide MR No.117/PNAcad/F/OU/2022
dated 30 06 2022 which was submitted in
compliance with the directions of this Honble
Court in ifs order dated 18.04.2022 in
W.P.No.16934 of 2022 as illegal This reiection
has resulted in the cancellation of the petitioners
PhD admission effectively nullifying her I
1/2
years of effort due to circumstances beyond her
controlsuch as the COVlDl9 pandemic and the
discontinuation of her supervisor due to health
lssues Ihe petitioner had sought a oneyear
extension to submit her PhD thesis w,hich was
unjustly denied This rejection is unlawful afuitrary
discriminatory and contrary to the principl,ts of
natural justice as well as violative of Arlicles 14
and 21 of the Constitution of lndia Cctnsequently
sel asrde the impugned Speaking Order issued
under MR No 117/PR/Acad/F/OU/2022 dated 30
06 2022 and direct the 2nd respondent to appoint
a new supervisor to enable the petition* to
complete her remaining PhD thesis work and
fufther extend the deadline for submittinl1 the
petitioners PhD thesis by at least one year from
the date of assigning the new supervisor and
pass. . . "
02. Heard Mr. Ramesh Chilla, learned counsel for the
petitioner, Sri Vamshi Kiran.tvl, learned Assistant Government
Pleader appearing for respondent No.1 , and Sri Malipeddi
Srinivas Reddy, learned Standing Counsel appearing for
respondent No.2. Perused the record.
03(a) Aggrieved by the action of the 2nd respondent in
rejecting the representation dated 25.04.2022 submitted by the
petitioner pursuant to the directions issued by tltis Court in W.P.
No 16934 of 2022. vide order dated 18.0t 2022, and the
consequential cancellation of her Ph.D. adrnission, thereby
1.
rendering futile her academic efforts spanning more than eight
and a half years, the petitioner has flled the present writ petition
03(b). Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
petitioner was admitted to the Ph.D. Programme in the
Department of Genetics, Osmania University, on 06.02.2013
pursuant to proceedings dated 30.01.2013. lt is contended that
the petitioner diligently pursued her research under the
supervision of Professor A. Jyothi and successfully completed the
substantial portion of her research work, besides complying with
all academic and procedural requirements prescribed by the
Unlversity.
03(c). Learned counsel further submits that during the
course of her doctoral research, the petitioner and her family
members were severely affected by the COVID-19 pandemic
Owing to the resultant health complications, particularly the post-
COVID ailments suffered by the petitioner, she was unable to
complete and submit her thesis within the period of six months'
extension granted by the University to research scholars admitted
prior to the year 2016 Thereafter, the University extended the
deadline for submission of theses up to 31 .O1 .2022. According to
the learned counsel, after recovering from her health issues, the
petitioner resumed her etforts to complete the thesis and was
entitled to avail the benefit of a further extension up to
31 .03.2022, which was granted as a one-time rreasure in view of
the extraordinary circumstances arising from the pandemic
03(d). lt is further contended that, at a cr.rcial stage of the
research programme, the petitioner's Supervis;or, Professor A.
Jyothi, who herself was facing serious health i:;sues, expressed
her inability to continue as Supervisor and advir;ed the petitioner
to seek a change of supervisron Accordingly, on 27.02.2022, the
Supervisor issued a No Objection Certificate (NOC) consenting to
the transfer of supervision. The said communicalion was received
by the petitioner just one day prior to her scheduled Research
Progress Seminar on 28.02.2022
03(e) Learned counsel submits that the petitioner, being
left without a Supervisor, immediately submitted a representation
dated 15.03.2022 lo lhe Vice-Chancellor seeking appointment of
a new Supervisor and grant of extension of time 'br completion of
her Ph.D. programme. However, no action wars taken by the
University on the said representation, thereby compelling the
petitioner to approach this Court by filing W.p. No 16934 ot 2022
--
)
03(f). lt is further submitted that the University Grants
Commission (UGC), through its Public Notice dated 01.12.2021,
extended the last date for submission of theses by terminal
M.Phil./Ph.D. students up to 30.06.2022 in view of the disruptions
caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. Despite the said relaxation,
the University failed to extend the benefit thereof to the petitioner.
Learned counsel contends that closure of laboratories and
restrictions imposed during the pandemic had severely hampered
the progress of the petitioner's research work, thereby preventing
her from completing the thesis within the stipulated time.
03(g). Learned counsel further submits that the petitioner
had already completed more than 80% of her research work and
had invested over eight and a half years in pursuit of her doctoral
programme. However, due to circumstances beyond her control,
namely the pandemic-induced disruptions and the sudden
relinquishment of supervision by her Guide, she was unable to
submit the thesis within the prescribed period. lt is contended that
the absence of a Supervisor effectively prevented the petitioner
from proceeding with the remaining academic formalities,
including presentation of the requisite seminar and final
submission of the thesis
03(h). lt is further submitted that this Court, while disposing
of W.P. No.16934 of 2022, directed the University to consider the
petitioner's request for appointment of a new Supervisor and
grant of extension of time Pursuant thereto, the petitioner
submitted a detailed representation dated 26.04.2022. ln lhe
meanwhile, the UGC issued a notification dateri 01 .02.2021 and
subsequently passed a Resolution dated 06.05.2022 authorising
Universities and Higher Educational lnstitutions to grant further
extensions to research scholars on a case{o-crase basis in view
of the pandemic situation. However, accordinr3 to the learned
counsel, the respondents failed to consider the petitioner's case
in the light of the aforesaid UGC guidelines arrd the directions
issued by this Court and instead proceeded to reject her
representation by relying upon outdated regulaticns.
03(i). Learned counsel contends that the 2nd respondent
failed to appoint a new Supervisor despite tlre No Objection
Certificate issued by the erstwhile Supervisor anc notwithstanding
the specific directions issued by this Court. Such inaction on the
part of the University deprived the petitioner of the opportunity to
complete the remaining academic requirements ernd continue her
research work. Consequently. the petitioner has been unjusfly
denied the opportunity to complete her Ph.D. programme despite
having made substantial progress in her research.
03(J). lt is also contended that the action of the respondents
is arbitrary and discriminatory inasmuch as, while seeking to
cancel the petitioner's admission after a period of eight and a half
years, the University had allegedly permitted several other
research scholars to submit their theses after considerably longer
periods ranging between 20 and 29 years. According to the
learned counsel, such differential treatment is violative of Article
14 of the Constitution of lndia and cannot be sustained in law.
Hence, according to the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
petitioner ls entitled to a further extension of one year for
submission of her Ph.D. thesis and completion of the doctoral
programme. lt is therefore prayed to set aside the impugned
proceedings rejecting the petitioner's representation and direct
the respondents to appoint a new Supervisor and grant
reasonable extension of time to enable the petitioner to complete
and submit her Ph.D. thesis.
04(a). Respondent No.2 has filed a counter affidavit
opposing the writ petition and contending that the relief sought by
\
I
the petitioner is contrary to the Ph.D. Rules and Regulations of
Osmania University. lt is stated that, pursuant tc the interim order
dated 18 04 2022 passed by this Court in W.P.lrlo.16934 ot 2022,
the representation submitted by the petitioner ,seeking extension
of the duration of her Ph.D. registration by one year was duly
considered by the competent authorities. Hcwever, the same
could not be acceded to in view of the statutory provisions
governing Ph.D. admissions and registrations
04(b). lt is contended that, under Rule 12(2) of the Ph.D
Rules and Regulations of Osmania Univerrsity, upon the
recommendations of the Superviso(s), the Chairperson and the
Head of the Department, the Dean may grant extension of the
Ph.D. registration of a candidate for a period n,)t exceeding one
year at a time, subject to an overall maximum extension of four
(4) years in the case of full-time research scholars and three (3)
years in the case of part-time research scholars. The said Rule
further stipulates that the registration of a rrlsearch scholar,
whether full{ime or part{ime, shall automaticalll, stand cancelled
upon expiry of the maximum permissible period cf eight (8) years.
04(c). Respondent No.2 further submits that, after the
expiry of the maximum period of eight years, the Ph.D. thesis of a
candidate cannot be accepted under any circumstances. lt is
stated that a candidate whose registration stands automatically
cancelled upon completion of the prescribed maximum period
may seek fresh admission into the Ph.D. programme by
undergolng the admission process afresh, including attendance of
Ph.D. course work and completion of the prescribed course work
examination. Such a candidate, however, forfeits any claim to
hostel accommodation.
04(d). lt is further stated that, in view of the extraordinary
circumstances arising out of the COVID-19 pandemic and
pursuant to the UGC Public Notice bearing F.No.1-1012020 (CPP-
ll), dated 16.03.2021, the University had extended the last date
for submission of M.Phil./Ph.D. theses vide proceedings dated
31.12.2021 in respect of all candidates who were eligible to
submit their theses by 31 .12.2020 and thereafter, subject to
compliance with the applicable Rules and Regulations governing
their respective batches.
04(e). Respondent No.2 further submits,:hat, in the interest
of research scholars, the University issued proceedings dated
28.11.2021 extending the last date for submission of ph.D.
theses by one month, i.e., up to 31.01 .2022, lty way of a grace
period. Thereafter. vide proceedings dated 2AOj.2022, the said
deadline was further extended from 31 .01 .2022 to 31 .03.2022 as
a "one{ime chance" in view of the continuirrg effects of the
COVID-19 pandemic.
04(0 lt is contended that, despite the Lniversity granting
sufficient opportunities and extensions for submission of the
thesis, the petitioner failed to submit her thesis within the
stipulated time. Therefore, having failed to comply with the
prescribed time limits, the petitioner cannot c:laim any further
extension as a matter of right. Respondent No.2 further relies
upon the remarks furnished by professor A. Jyo.:hi, the Research
Supervisor of the petitioner, According to the said remarks, the
petitioner had not been attending the lnstitute r;ince December,
2018. lt is stated that the petitioner had presentr:d her Research
Design Seminar in March, 2015, however, she did not present the
subsequent'Seininar as her research work had not been
completed within the prescribed time frame.
7\
Oa(g). lt is further contended that the petitioner remained
absent for nearly three years without informlng her Research
Supervisor. Thereafter, after a considerable lapse of time, she
reappeared and expressed her intention to submit the thesis
solely on account of the deadline fixed by the University
authorities. The Research Supervisor also informed the Dean
that, in the circumstances, it was not feasible to scrutinize, verify
and make necessary corrections to the thesis within a period of
two weeks. Hence, the petitioner failed to comply with the
mandatory requirements of the Ph.D. programme and the
applicable Rules and Regulations governing thesis submission. lt
is therefore submitted that no illegality or arbitrariness can be
attributed to the action of the University in rejecting the
petitioner's request for extension and that the writ petition is
devoid of merit. Accordingly, he prayed for dismissal of the writ
petition.
05. Having considered the submissions made by the
learned counsel on either side and upon perusal of the material
available on record, the undisputed facts reveal that the petitioner
was admitted into the Ph.D. programme in the Department of
Genetics, Osmania University, pursuant to proceedings.dated
30 01.2013. As per Rule 12(2) of the ph.D. Rules and
Regulations of Osmania University, the registration of a research
scholar automatically stands cancelled upon expiry of the
maximum permissible period of eight years; and, thereafter,
submission of a Ph.D, thesrs cannot be acc;epted under any
circumstances. The said Rule further provides that a candidate
whose registration stands cancelled may seek f.esh admission by
complying with the prescribed requirements.
06. lt is not in dispute that the petitioner completed eight
years from the date of registration during the year 2021
.
However, in view of the extraordinary situation arising out of the
COVID-19 pandemic, the University grantec relaxation and
extended the last date for submission of Ph.D. thesis from time to
time. lnitially, the benefit of the UGC public Notice dated
16.03.2021 was extended to eligible candidates. Thereafter, the
University granted a grace period up to 31 .01 .2022 and
subsequently by Order dated 28,0't .2022 exlen<jed the last date
for submission of thesis up to 31 .03.2022 as a ,,One Time
Chance". For proving her contention that she was affected by
COVID-19. the petitioner relied upon a medical certificate issued
by Shraddha Hospital. However, a perusal of thr-. said certificate
tr
reveals that she was merely advised to take bed rest for a period
of one week. Therefore, the certificate, by itself, is insufficient to
establish that the petitioner was incapacitated for such a
prolonged period as to prevent her from completing and
submitting her Ph.D. thesis within the extended time granted by
the University.
07. lt is the case of the petitioner that she was unable to
submit the thesis on account of the COVID-19 pandemic, health
complications suffered by her and her family members, closure of
laboratories, and the inability of her Supervisor, Professor A.
Jyothi, to continue supervision on medical grounds. However, the
material placed on record does not establish that the petitioner
was diligently pursuing her research work throughout the relevant
period. On the contrary, the counter affidavit discloses that, as
per the remarks of the Research Supervisor, the petitioner had
not attended the lnstitute since December, 2018. lt is further
stated that the petitioner had presented her Research Design
Seminar in March, 20'l 5 and thereafter did not present the
subsequent seminar on the ground that her research work was
not completed. The Supervisor specifically recorded that the
petitioner remained absent for nearly three years without
informing the Supervisor and, after a considerable lapse of time,
sought to submit the thesis only when the University had
prescribed a final deadline. l-hese factual assertions have not
been effectively controverted by the petitioner.
08. Further. the record discloses that the petitioner
sought change of Supervisor only at the fag end of the extended
period granted by the University. The inability of the existing
Supervisor to continue guidance at such a belerted stage cannot
confer upon the petitioner any vested right to s;eek an indefinite
extension of her registration contrary to the stertutory Rules and
Regulations governing the Ph.D. programme. Therefore, the
contention of the petitioner that she was prevented from
submitting her thesis solely because her Supen,isor issued a No
Ob.lection Certificate on 27.02.2022, has no water.
09 The communications issued by the UGC merely
enabled Universities to consider grant of extelsion of time in
appropriate cases. They neither mandated grant of extension as
a matter of right nor overrode the statutory F,h.D. Rules and
Regulations framed by the University. The question as to whether
a particular candidate is entitled to extension of time squarely falls
within the academic domain of the University authorities.
10. lt is a settled principle of law that Courts exercising
jurisdiction under Article 226 of lhe Constitution of lndia ordinarily
refrain from interfering with academic decisions unless such
decisions are shown to be arbitrary, mala fide, irrational, or in
violation of any statutory provision. ln the present case, the
impugned proceedings dated 30.06.2022 disclose that the
representation submitted by the petitioner was duly considered by
the competent authorities in the light of the applicable Rules and
Regulations. The request was rejected primarily on the ground
that the maximum permissible period prescribed under the Ph.D
Regulations had already expired and that no further extension
could be granted under the governing Regulations.
11. lt is also pertinent to note that the petitioner had
earlier initiated contempt proceedings in C.C.No.829 ol 2022
alleging deliberate violation and wilful disobedience of the order
dated 18.04.2022 passed in W.P.No.16934 of 2022. The said
contempt case was subsequently closed by order dated
12 10.2022. This fact further demonstrates that the grievance
1.6
regarding non-consideration of her representation had already
been agitated before the approprtate forum
12. ln view of the above discussion, tl'ris Court is of the
considered opinion that the petitioner has failetj to establish any
illegality, arbitrariness, mala fides or violatiorr of principles of
natural justice in the impugned proceedtngs rlated 30 06.2022
warranting interference under Article 226 of tlre Constitution of
lndia
13. Accordingly, this Writ Petition is dismissed. There
shall be no order as to costs
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous aplrlications, if any,
shall stand closed
SD/. A.I.I.S.GOWRI SHANKAR
AS:3ISTANT REGISTRAR
/TRUE COPY/
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. One CC to SRl. RATMESH CHILLA Advocate [OPUC]
2.]woCCstoGF,r'onEDUCAT|oNHighcourtfortheStateofTelirngana,at
HyclerrabacJ IOUTI
^ ^ FF^n\, 6,
OU [OPUCI
,Ore
to Sni. illnltprOD SRINIVAS REDDY SC FOR
CC
3.
CD CoPies
Two
4.
BNT
TKS
@
CC TOD
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2410612026
1 ttE S'Ia I€r
ORDER
J
)
J
I JUr 2026
a
-h
*
WP.No.28421 of 2024
D
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION WITI.IOUT COSTS
6)
,
i
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review