Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 27TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.I.ARUN
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI
WRIT PETITION NO. 105785 OF 2023 (S-CAT)
BETWEEN:
1.
P.S.GURURAJA
S/O. LATE SANJEEVA MURTHY RAO,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
#118, MARUTHI NILAYAM,
6TH MAIN, 6TH CROSS, T.P.KAILASAM ROAD,
SAPTHAGIRI EXTN., TUMKURU – 572 102.
2.
B.N.MANJULA W/O. LATE SRIDHARAN,
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
PLATIN EXOTICA APARTMENT,
FLAT NO.004, 16/27, 1ST MAIN ROAD,
GNANABHARATHI, DUBASIPALAYA
KENGERI SATELITE TOWN,
BENGALURU – 560 060.
3.
VIJAYALAKSHMI C. D/O. LATE CHAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
2221, 6TH CROSS, SIDDARTHA
HOSTEL, MAIN ROAD, ASHOKAPURAM,
MYSURU – 570 008.
4.
C. PRAKASH S/O. K.N.C. SWAMY,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
26, 7TH CROSS, JNANAJYOTHINAGAR,
BENGALURU - 56.
VISHAL
NINGAPPA
PATTIHAL
Location: High
Court of Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench,
Dharwad
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
5.
C. LOKESHA S/O. M. CHANDRAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
66/B, VASANTHAPURA,
NEAR SAIBABA TEMPLE,
SUBRAMANYAPURA POST,
BENGALURU – 61.
6.
KUSUMA.V.G W/O. SASHIKUMAR,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
805, 31ST CROSS, 4TH T BLOCK,
TILAKNAGAR, BENGALURU – 41.
7.
ARUNA DINESH LINGAYATH
W/O. LATE DINESH LINGAYATH,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
15/21, LASHKARIBAGH, KAMAL CHOWK,
NAGPUR – 440 017.
8.
P. LIYAKATH ALI KHAN
S/O. P. GHOUSE KHAN,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
100/17/2/10, CMR PALLI
PROFESSOR COLONY, KADAPPA.
9.
T.S. SANTHANA GOPALA KRISHNA
S/O. T.V. SRINIVASA MURTHY,
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
717, 23RD CROSS, 4TH MAIN,
VIDYARANYAPURAM,
MYSURU – 570 008.
10.
A.C. RANI W/O. JOSEY. E.J.,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
EDEZHATHU HOUSE, BISHOP ROAD,
KUMBALANGHI POST, COCHIN – 682 007.
11.
LAKSHMIPATHY R.
S/O. M. C. RAJAMANICKAM,
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
NEW NO.12, OLD NO.26,
ANNA PILLAI STREET, 3RD LANE,
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
SOWCARPET POST,
CHENNAI – 600 001.
12.
MALA R. W/O. RAVISHANKAR,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
15/16, BANK COLONY, 2ND STREET,
MADHAVARAM MILK COLONY,
TIRUVALLUR, CHENNAI – 600 051.
13.
M.C. NAGARAJA
S/O. M.S. CHANDRASHEKAR,
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
9, 3RD MAIN, BRINDAVAN LAYOUT,
SUBRAMANYAPURA POST,
BENGALURU – 560 061.
14.
PUSHPALATHA S. NIKKAM
W/O. SRIKANT V. NIKKAM SAIDAPUR,
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS, DANDIN ONI,
NEAR AMBHABHAVANI TEMPLE,
DHARWAD – 580 008.
15.
RAMESH R. S/O. RAMASAMY,
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
1ST CROSS, NAGARAHOLE CIRCLE,
VEERABADRESHWARA NAGAR,
HEROHALLI, BENGALURU – 91.
16.
RAJALAKSHMI H.K.
W/O. DR. M.R. SUNDARARAJ,
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
4822 MALOLA, 2ND STAGE, SATAGALLI,
SHAKTHINAGAR POST, MYSURU – 570 019.
17.
RAVI P. W/O. PAPANNA C.,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
267, 2ND MAIN, 3RD CROSS, KOGILU LAYOUT,
YELAHANKA, BENGALURU – 64.
18.
SHOBHA P.R. C/O. ARUNAKSHI,
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS,
SHRUNGAGIRI SHARADA NILAYA,
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
PENSION MOHALLA, 2ND CROSS,
SHIVAMOGGA - 5.
19.
SHYAMALA.M.E. W/O. ANAND,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
SREE RANGA, 2ND CROSS,
MAHALAKSMI NAGAR,
BATWADI, TUMKURU – 572 103.
20.
M. MADHAVAN
S/O. LATE P.S. MURALI,
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS,
76, GOKULAM, 9TH CROSS, SIR M.V. NAGAR,
KOWDANAHALLI MAIN ROAD,
BENGALURU – 16.
21.
ANIMESH DAS,
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS,
BAHARDWAJ PALLI, BURNPUR,
WEST BENGAL -713 325.
22.
K. KUMAR S/O. K. RAMACHANDRAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
306, SRI KRISHNA RESIDENCY,
UPADAYA NAGAR, TIRUPATI – 517 501.
23.
KOPPU SUBRAMANYAM
S/O. LATE K. SUBBARATNAM,
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
17-714-B, THILAKNAGAR, GUNTAKAL – 515 801.
24.
D. NARAYANA RAO S/O. D. PEDDAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
17/560-B2, BSS COLONY, GUNTAKAL- 515801.
25.
J. ANNALAKSHMI W/O. ANAND KUMAR,
AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
5, N T BLOCK, OORAGAM POST,
KOLAR GOLD FIELD – 563 120.
26.
DILIP HEMBRAM,
W/O. LATE MANGAL CHANDRA HEMBRAM,
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
VILLAGE: BABUI GERIA, BAGHASTI POST,
MIDNAPORE WEST DISTRICT,
WEST BENGAL – 721 133.
… PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. K. SHIVAKUMAR, ADV. FOR
SRI. M/S HOLLA AND HOLLA, SRI. VIVEK HOLLA
& SRI. CHANDRASHEKHAR S., ADVS.
APPEARED THROUGH V.C.)
AND:
1.
UNION OF INDIA,
REPRESENTED BY ITS EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
(ESTABLISHMENT), RAILWAY BOARD,
RAIL BHAVAN, RAISINA ROAD,
NEW DELHI – 110 001.
2.
PRINCIPAL CHIEF PERSONNEL OFFICER,
SOUTH CENTRAL RAILWAY, RAIL NILAYAM
SECUNDERABAD, TELANGANA – 500 025.
3.
PRINCIPAL CHIEF PERSONNEL OFFICER,
SOUTH WESTERN RAILWAY, RAIL SOUDHA,
GADAG ROAD, HUBBALLI – 580 020.
4.
SENIOR DIVISIONAL PERSONNEL OFFICER,
SOUTH CENTRAL RAILWAY, DIVISIONAL OFFICE,
GUNTAKAL, ANANDAPUR DIST,
ANDHRAPRADESH – 515 801.
5.
SENIOR DIVISIONAL PERSONNEL OFFICER,
SOUTH WESTERN RAILWAY,
DIVISIONAL OFFICE, HUBBALLI,
KARNATAKA – 580 020.
… RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. M.B.KANAVI, ADV. FOR R1 TO R5)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND
227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, 1950, PRAYING TO ISSUE
A WRIT OF CERTIORARI OR ANY OTHER APPROPRIATE WRIT
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
ORDER OR DIRECTION, AND SET ASIDE THE ORDER OF THE
CENTRAL
ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL,
BANGALORE
IN
O.A.NO.170/00318/2023 DATED 17.07.2023 (ANNEXURE-B);
TO DECLARE THAT THE MEMORANDUM OF TERMINATION
BEARING NO.G/P.563/ RRB/SBC/ CLERKS/99 DATED 30.05.2002
ISSUED BY FOURTH RESPONDENT (ANNEXURE-A7) AND
MEMORANDUM OF TERMINATION BEARING H/P.563/I/1/VOL.4
DATED 27/28.01.2003 ISSUED BY FIFTH RESPONDENT
(ANNEXURE-A8) AS ARBITRARY, ILLEGAL, UNWARRANTED,
MISCONCEIVED AND NON-EST AND IN VIOLATION OF ARTICLES
14 AND 16 AND 21 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA; TO ISSUE
A WRIT OF CERTIORARI OR ANY OTHER APPROPRIATE WRIT
ORDER OR DIRECTION, AND QUASH THE MEMORANDUM OF
TERMINATION BEARING NO.G/P.563/ RRB/SBC/ CLERKS/99
DATED 30.05.2002
ISSUED
BY
FOURTH
RESPONDENT
(ANNEXURE-A7) AND MEMORANDUM OF TERMINATION BEARING
H/P.563/I/1/VOL.4 DATED 27/28.01.2003 ISSUED BY FIFTH
RESPONDENT (ANNEXURE-A8) TERMINATING THE SERVICES OF
THE PETITIONERS WITHOUT EXAMINING THE ASPECTS
REQUIRED AS PER THE OBSERVATIONS OF THE HON’BLE
SUPREME COURT IN CASE OF UOI AND OTHERS VS. O.
CHAKRADHAR AND WHEN THE ALLEGATIONS AGAINST THE
VERY MEMBERS AND STAFF OF THE RAILWAY RECRUITMENT
BOARD WERE DROPPED BY CLOSING THE CRIMINAL CASES
AGAINST THEM WHICH RESULTS IN EXONERATING THE
PETITIONERS FROM ALL THE CHARGES LEVELED AGAINST
THEM; TO DIRECT THE RESPONDENTS TO REINSTATE THE
APPLICANTS INTO SERVICE WITH IMMEDIATE EFFECT WITH ALL
CONSEQUENTIAL BENEFITS; AND TO ISSUE SUCH OTHER,
DIRECTION AS THIS HON’BLE COURT DEEMS FIT IN THE
CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE, IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE
AND EQUITY.
THIS WRIT PETITION, COMING ON FOR FURTHER HEARING
THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.I.ARUN
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. MURALIDHARA PAI
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
ORAL ORDER
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.I.ARUN)
1.
The petitioners herein were recruited to various posts
by the respondent - Indian Railways. On the ground of gross
illegalities
committed
by
several
persons
involved
in
the
recruitment process, the entire selection list itself got cancelled.
Some of the employees challenged the same and it reached the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Appeal (Civil) No.1326 of 2002 (Union of
India & Ors Vs. O. Chakradhar), wherein the Apex Court
upheld the decision of the Railway Board to cancel the selection
list on the ground that huge irregularities had taken place in the
process of selection. In the light of the said judgment, admittedly
the petitioners are not entitled to any relief. Based on the same,
Central
Administrative
Tribunal,
in
Original
Application
No.170/00318/2023, dismissed the application filed by the
petitioners.
2.
In the meanwhile, the petitioners also approached
the Hon’ble Apex Court in Writ Petition (C) No.913 of 2022,
wherein the Apex Court passed the following order:
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
“Having heard learned senior counsel appearing for
the petitioners, we do not propose to entertain this
petition under Article 32 of the Constitution of India.
However, notwithstanding the earlier judgment
dated 19.02.2002 passed by this Court in C.A. No.1326 of
2002, if the petitioners make out a case on merits before
an appropriate forum due to subsequent developments,
the appropriate forum may entertain and consider the
same on its own merits, in accordance with law.
With the above liberty to the petitioners to
approach the appropriate forum, the Writ Petition is
disposed of.
Pending application(s) shall stand disposed of.”
3.
On the strength of the order passed by the Apex
Court in Writ Petition (C) No.913 of 2022, the petitioners have
challenged
the
impugned
order
passed
by
the
Central
Administrative Tribunal.
4.
The case of the petitioners is that there were
allegations of malfeasance and misfeasance on the part of the
recruiting officers of the Indian Railways, which led to a CBI
inquiry
and,
consequently,
the
entire
selection
list
being
scrapped. It is submitted that, in the O. Chakradhar case
(supra), the Hon’ble Apex Court did not entertain the claims of
persons similarly situated to the petitioners herein, even though
no allegations of misconduct were made against them and no
inquiry was conducted against them individually. It is further
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
submitted that, pursuant to the said allegations of malfeasance
and misfeasance in the recruitment process, the proceedings
were initiated against certain accused persons, who were
employees
of
the
Indian
Railways
and
involved
in
the
recruitment process; however, all of them have been acquitted.
According
to
the
petitioners,
this
acquittal
constitutes
a
subsequent development which in view of the directions of the
Hon'ble Apex Court in Writ Petition (C) No.913 of 2022, warrants
reinstatement of the petitioners herein. It is submitted that the
petitioners are innocent and were recruited by the Indian
Railways on merit, without there being any irregularity in their
recruitment. It is submitted that if there is any irregularity, it is
in respect of other employees, who are recruited along with the
petitioners. It is submitted that, in the light of all the Officers
alleged to have been involved in the scam being acquitted, the
recruitment of the present petitioners is required to be upheld
and the Central Administrative Tribunal in the impugned order
had failed to take note of the same and has erroneously
dismissed the Application.
5.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents
submits that all the aforementioned factors were taken note of
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
by the Hon'ble Apex Court in O. Chakradhar case (supra). It is
submitted that there is no new event that has taken place after
the said decision. In the absence of any new development, the
observation of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Writ Petition (C) No.913
of 2022 does not come to the rescue of the petitioners. For the
said reason, it is prayed that there is no error committed by the
Central Administrative
Tribunal and that the
writ petition
deserves to be dismissed.
6.
the
Hence the question that arises for consideration in
instant
case
is
whether
there
have
been
any
new
developments subsequent to O. Chakradhar case (supra), of
which the petitioners herein can claim the benefit?
7.
Admittedly, the Apex Court in O. Chakradhar case
(supra) examined the irregularity committed by the Railway
Board and has come to the following conclusion:
“It first indicates that Railway Recruitment Board,
Bangalore has not laid down any set procedure for holding
of selection. The Chairman engages a printer for printing
of the question paper and computer firms are given the
job of scrutinizing the applications. The examination is
conducted at different centres and answer sheets are
sealed and put in boxes in custody of the Chairman in his
room. The answer-sheets are given to the computer firm
for evaluation. The Board carries on a manual random
check of the answer-sheets, and depending upon the
result, further call letters are prepared by the computer
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
firm. Since it was a recruitment for the post of Junior
Clerk-cum-Typist, a candidate was required to have a
typing speed of 30 words per minute in English or 25
words per minute in Hindi. As per relevant Circular the
typing test is to be conducted after the written test and
those who qualify in the typing test also, they alone are to
be called for final interview. In the present case, however,
according to the report the candidates during the course
of their personal interview were required to give typing
test before the members of the Interview Board within the
time limit set for the purpose. No separate marks were
awarded for typing nor the typing sheets have been
preserved by the Board. No candidate was qualified or
disqualified on the basis of the typing test. About 100
answer-sheets
did not
bear
the
signatures
of
Supervisor/Assistant Supervisor in the column provided
for the purpose. It however, bore the signatures of the
invigelator but none from the said candidates is reported
to be selected. According to the report, on scrutiny of
answer-sheets of 109 selected candidates, a clear
difference of hand-writing was noticed in many answersheets. Out of these answer-sheets 14 were particularly
taken out for the purpose of investigation. According to
the report, answer-sheet packets were stealthily opened
and the answers were filled up in the blank space left by
the examinees. This happened during the period the bags
of the answer-sheets were in the custody of the
Chairman. So far as the interview is concerned, it is
reported that the two Boards constituted for the interview
did not have technical personnel as its member as per
requirement. Each member was required to award marks
to the candidate in the individual assessment sheets
provided to them and ; average was to be worked out but
no average was worked out. The column for interview
marks was later on filled up as per wishes of the
Chairman and Member-Secretary of the Board and
signatures of the non official members were obtained on
the summary sheet later on.
It is mentioned in the report that huge amount of
money was taken for selecting the candidates but none is
coming forward to indicate as to who and how much one
paid for it for fear of being in trouble. It is further
reported that non official Chairman of the Board made
payment of printing of the examination paper etc. not to
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
any firm but to one Gaja Raja Yadav. It may also be
mentioned that according to the report a large number of
applications were missing and postal orders of the missing
applications were encashed and misappropriated and even
before the closing date of receiving the applications, it
started sending applications to the computer firm for their
scrutiny. The C.B.I. has named five persons as accused in
the report namely the Chairman of the Railway
Recruitment Board, Bangalore, who is a non-official, the
Member-Secretary of the Board, an officer of the
Railways, one Shri Hanumanth Bhaiya, a Senior Clerk of
the Railway Recruitment Board and Gaja Raja Yadav, the
private person to whom payment had been made for
printing of the question paper etc. As per the report of the
CBI whole selection smacks of mala fide and arbitrariness.
All norms are said to have been violated with impunity at
each stage viz. right from the stage of entertaining
applications, with answer-sheets while in the custody of
Chairman, in holding typing test, in interview and in the
end while preparing final result. In such circumstances it
may not be possible to pick out or choose any few
persons in respect of whom alone the selection could be
cancelled and their services in pursuance thereof could be
terminated. The illegality and irregularity are so intermixed with the whole process of the selection that it
becomes impossible to sort out right from the wrong or
vice versa. The result of such a selection cannot be relied
or acted upon. It is not a case where a question of
misconduct on the part of a candidate is to be gone into
but a case where those who conducted the selection have
rendered it wholly unacceptable. Guilt of those who have
been selected is not the question under consideration but
the question is could such selection be acted upon in the
matter of public employment? We are therefore of the
view that it is not one of those cases where it may have
been possible to issue any individual notice of misconduct
to each selectee and seek his explanation in regard to the
large scale widespread and all pervasive illegalities and
irregularities committed by those who conducted the
selection which may of course possibly be for the benefit
of those who have been selected but there may be a few
who may have deserved selection otherwise but it is
difficult to separate the cases of some of the candidates
from the rest even if there may be some. The decision in
the case of Krishna Yadav (supra) applies to the facts of
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
the present case. The Railway Board's decision to cancel
the selection cannot be faulted with. The appeal therefore
deserve to be allowed.
In the result, the appeal is allowed and the orders
passed by the Tribunal and the High Court are set aside
and the order of termination of the services of the
respondent is upheld. The copy of the CBI report has been
placed on record. The administration shall do well in
taking action pursuing the matter in the light of the report
of the CBI, so as to bring it to a logical conclusion.”
8.
In short, the Hon’ble Apex Court found that large-
scale irregularities had been committed in the recruitment
process of the Railways and, therefore, set aside the entire
recruitment process, without there being any requirement to
conduct an inquiry in respect of individual candidates selected
through such process. Further, the acquittal of certain employees
of the Indian Railways, against whom criminal prosecutions were
initiated, does not come to the rescue of the petitioners, as such
acquittal had taken place prior to the decision of the Hon’ble
Apex Court in O. Chakradhar case (supra) and were on account
of lack of evidence. Such acquittal does not establish that the
recruitment of the petitioners or other similarly situated persons
was carried out in accordance with law. The petitioners have
failed to point out any new fact which would confer upon them a
right to continue in the posts to which they were recruited or to
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:929-DB
WP No. 105785 of 2023
HC-KAR
claim the benefit of the observations made by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in Writ Petition (C) No.913 of 2022.
9.
Under
the
circumstances,
as
no
new
fact
or
subsequent development has arisen conferring any right upon
the petitioners, the writ petition is hereby dismissed.
Sd/(M.I.ARUN)
JUDGE
Sd/(B. MURALIDHARA PAI)
JUDGE
VNP / CT: ASC
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 36
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review