The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. Accused Nos.3 and 7 were the Village Extension Officer and Block Development Officer respectively. This Court, on the aspect of alleged conspiracy among the accused, held that materials are insufficient to hold that such a conspiracy was hatched. In the light of the said finding of this Court, it may be difficult to prove the charge that in furtherance of a conspiracy involving the said officials the act of misappropriation and mischief were committed. As pointed out by the learned Public Prosecutor, it may be possible to show that false documents were created and making use of such documents, the work in question was claimed to have been done. But when the public servants, who involved in the said acts are not available for trial, and in the light of the findings of this Court in Annexure A order that the materials are insufficient to establish prima facie the charge leveled against accused Nos.3 and 7, a fruitful Crl.Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024 2025:KER:26735 prosecution of the petitioners is not possible. In the said circumstances, I am of the view that the trial of the petitioners will only be an abuse of the process of court. The impugned order is therefore liable to be reversed. Accordingly, this Crl. Revision Petition is allowed. On setting aside the order dated 21.04.2021 of the Special Court, Crl. M.P. No.545 of 2020 in C.C. No.6 of 2018 is allowed. Petitioners are discha…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024
2025:KER:26735
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P.G. AJITHKUMAR
THURSDAY, THE 27TH DAY OF MARCH 2025/6TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.REV.PET NO. 1014 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 21.04.2021 IN CC NO.6 OF 2018 OF ENQUIRY
COMMISSIONER & SPECIAL JUDGE, KOTTAYAM
REVISION PETITIONER/ACCUSED 1, 4 & 6:
P.R SURESH
AGED 59 YEARS
(ACCUSED NO:1) PLAVIYAYIL HOUSE NOORANADU PANCHAYATH,
WARD NO:III
(FORMER BLOCK PANCHAYATH MEMBER,
NOORANADU DIVISION), PIN - 690504
PUSHPARAJAN
AGED 60 YEARS
(ACCUSED NO:4), KOZHIVILA VEEDU WARD NO: III,
NOORANADU GRAMA PANCHAYTH., PIN - 690504
R GANGADHARAN
AGED 78 YEARS
(ACCUSED NO:6) KALARICKKAL THARAYIL WARD NO:XI,
BHARANIKKAVU PANCHAYATH
(FORMER CHAIRMAN, STANDING COMMITTEE FOR DEVELOPMENT,
BLOCK PANCHAYATH, BHARANIKKAVU),
PIN - 690504
BY ADV B.VINOD
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENT:
DEPUTY SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE
VIGILANCE AND ANTI- CORRUPTION BUREAU,
ALAPPUZHA UNIT, PIN - 688001
STATE OF KERALA
REP.BY PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM,
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024
2025:KER:26735
PIN - 682031
ADV.SMT REKHA S- SENIOR PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
ADV.SRI A RAJESH - SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR(VIG)
THIS CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
27.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024
2025:KER:26735
P.G. AJITHKUMAR, J
------------------------------------------------Crl. Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024
------------------------------------------------Dated this the 27th day of March, 2025
ORDER
The petitioners are accused Nos.1, 4 and 6 in C.C. No.6 of
2018 pending before the Court of Enquiry Commissioner and
Special Judge, Kottayam. They along with four others were
charged by the 1st respondent with offences punishable under
Sections 13(1)(c) and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (PC Act) and Sections 409,
465, 468 and 471 read with Section 120B of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 (IPC). The petitioners filed Crl.M.P. No.545 of 2020
before the Special Court seeking discharge under Section 239 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Code). Accused Nos.3
and 7 earlier filed similar applications. The Special Court as per
the order dated 21.04.2021 dismissed those applications. The
petitioners filed this revision petition invoking the provisions of
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024
2025:KER:26735
Sections 438 and 442 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita,
challenging
the
order
dismissing
their
applications for discharge.
2.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners, the
learned Special Public Prosecutor (Vigilance) and the Senior
Public Prosecutor.
3.
Bharanikkavu Block Panchayat decided to undertake
maintenance work of Maneeneth Temple Road. The project was
to be carried out utilising the excess quantity of rice and wheat
allotted to the Block Panchayat during 2007-2008 under the
Sampoorna Grameen Rozgar Yojana (SGRY) Scheme. The 2nd
accused, who was the Assistant Engineer, Bharanikkavu Block
Panchayat prepared an estimate for the maintenance of the
road. The 5th accused, who was the Assistant Executive
Engineer, Poverty Alleviation Unit, Alappuzha verified the
estimate and accorded technical sanction. A member of
Bharanikkavu Block Panchayat was the Convener of the
Beneficiary Committee for the maintenance of the road. He is
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024
2025:KER:26735
the 4th accused. Accused No.7 was the then Block Development
Officer of the Block Panchayat. Accused No.3 was the then
Village Extension Officer of Nooranadu Grama Panchayat.
Accused No.1 was a member of the Block Panchayat. Accused
No.6 was the Chairman of the Standing Committee for
Development.
4.
The allegations are that accused Nos.1 and 6, being
the Chairman and Convener of the beneficiary committee and
accused No.4, being the person who executed the work based
on the agreement he had entered into with the Block Panchayat,
based on the conspiracy hatched among all the accused, created
false documents with a view to deceive the authorities and
convince that the work on the road in question was executed. In
fact, no such work was done. Thereby the accused together had
misappropriated Government funds of Rs.1,63,040.90/-.
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioners would submit
that having accused Nos.3 and 7 been discharged by this Court
as per Annexure A order and accused Nos.2 and 5 expired, no
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024
2025:KER:26735
prosecution against the petitioners, who are accused Nos.1, 4
and 6 is possible before the Special Court. It is urged that this
Court in view of the conclusions in Annexure A order, the
petitioners are liable to be discharged. The findings in Annexure
A are - (i) allegations in the final report concerning lack of
sanction for implementation of the project is incorrect, (ii) no
work was executed at all is against real facts, (iii) it is incorrect
that an amount of Rs.47,675/- was disbursed over and above
the estimated amount and, (iv) the allegation of submitting false
documents is unsupported by materials. The learned counsel
would submit that in the light of the above findings which are
based on the materials produced by the prosecution, a bar is
created against prosecution of the petitioners.
6.
It is also submitted by the learned counsel for the
petitioners that what could be seen from the materials is a
deviation from the estimate while implementing the work, but
not that the work was not executed at all. The learned counsel
accordingly would submit that the case, at the best, is an
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024
2025:KER:26735
instance of noncompliance of the contract provisions and not at
all
criminal
misconduct
whereby
obtaining
of
pecuniary
advantage, and a successful prosecution against the petitioners
is an impossibility.
7.
The learned Special Public Prosecutor, on the other
hand, would submit that from the materials produced by the
prosecution, deficiencies in carrying out the work and thereby
misappropriation of the money and materials provided by the
Block Panchayat for implementation of the work is quite evident.
The Special Public Prosecutor invited my attention to the report
prepared by the Assistant Executive Engineer as well as the
Executive Engineer, who is witness No.11 to substantiate that
contention. The report of both these witnesses go in tandem in
one respect that as against the projected length of 560 meters,
the actual work done was on 189 meters portion of the road
alone. Even if the contention of the petitioners that a 25 meters
portion of the road was washed away by the flood is accepted,
the length of the constructed road was only 214 meters. The
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024
2025:KER:26735
learned Special Public Prosecutor would submit that the fault on
the part of the accused would certainly be gathered from the
materials available on record.
8.
The learned counsel for the petitioners would point
out that the width of the road as per estimate was only 3.5
meters, whereas the completed road had a width of 6 meters.
After referring to the graph prepared by witness No.11, it was
submitted that the depth of the road work was much more than
that was estimated. Accordingly, it is submitted that the volume
of work done was practically more than what was estimated. It
is thus maintained that there occurred deviation from the
estimate, but there has not been any misappropriation.
9.
This Court, in Crl.Rev.Pet. No.24 of 2022 considered
the matter in detail. As regards the allegation that no work was
carried out at all, and Rs.47,675/- was disbursed in addition to
the wheat and rice this Court made, the following observations
in Annexure A:
“24. Thirdly, the investigating agency concluded that no
work was carried out. This finding is based on the statement
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024
2025:KER:26735
of certain witnesses (CWs 25 to 31), who live near the place
where the work was proposed. A perusal of pages 108 and
260 of the CD compilation would indicate certain stages of
work wherein there is mention that the gravel used is not as
proposed. The statement of CW11, who measured the road,
speaks of the difference in the levels that occurred on the
land before and after the work. Therefore, the allegation that
no work was carried out is against the materials relied on by
the prosecution.
25. The next allegation against the revision petitioner is that
he disbursed a value of Rs.1,62,049.90 as against an
estimate of Rs.1,20,000/-. The value was assessed in terms
of rice and wheat; more clearly, the value of the estimate
was assessed as equivalent to 97.96 Quintals of rice =
Rs.87,183/- and 48.98 Quintals of wheat = 32,817/(87183+32,817
=
1,20,000).
Page
of
the
CD
compilation shows that 47.90 Quintals of rice were not
available and the price of the same was substituted.
Therefore, the prosecution case that over and above the
quantity of rice and wheat a sum of Rs.47,675/- was also
disbursed is factually incorrect.”
10.
When this Court found so after apprising the
materials available on record and accused Nos.3 and 7 were
accordingly discharged, it is inappropriate for this Court to take
a different view. It is especially so when the aforesaid order,
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024
2025:KER:26735
Annexure A, stands confirmed by the Apex Court owing to the
dismissal of SLP Crl. No.5275 of 2023 as per the order dated
15.05.2023.
11.
Accused Nos.3 and 7 were the Village Extension
Officer and Block Development Officer respectively. This Court,
on the aspect of alleged conspiracy among the accused, held
that materials are insufficient to hold that such a conspiracy was
hatched. In the light of the said finding of this Court, it may be
difficult to prove the charge that in furtherance of a conspiracy
involving the said officials the act of misappropriation and
mischief were committed. As pointed out by the learned Public
Prosecutor, it may be possible to show that false documents
were created and making use of such documents, the work in
question was claimed to have been done. But when the public
servants, who involved in the said acts are not available for trial,
and in the light of the findings of this Court in Annexure A order
that the materials are insufficient to establish prima facie the
charge leveled against accused Nos.3 and 7, a fruitful
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024
2025:KER:26735
prosecution of the petitioners is not possible.
In the said
circumstances, I am of the view that the trial of the petitioners
will only be an abuse of the process of court. The impugned
order is therefore liable to be reversed.
Accordingly, this Crl. Revision Petition is allowed. On setting
aside the order dated 21.04.2021 of the Special Court, Crl. M.P.
No.545 of 2020 in C.C. No.6 of 2018 is allowed. Petitioners are
discharged under Section 239 of the Code.
Sd/SMF
P.G. AJITHKUMAR, JUDGE
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.1014 of 2024
2025:KER:26735
APPENDIX OF CRL.REV.PET 1014/2024
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure A
A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGEMENT DATED
6/12/2022 IN CRL R.P 582/2020
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review