The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. The contention that the transportation charge ten years before was Rs.1.25/- per Kilogram cannot be countenanced since that plea is based on Annexure 3 which does not form part of the prosecution records. Therefore, that contention cannot be considered. Dehors that, the materials produced by the prosecution Crl.Rev.Pet. No.753 of 2020 2025:KER:27646 are insufficient to have a presumption that the petitioner had committed the alleged offences. Framing of charge against the petitioner and asking him to stand trial will only be an abuse of the process of law. Therefore, the impugned order in relation to the petitioner is liable to be set aside. Accordingly, this revision petition is allowed. The impugned order, insofar as the petitioner is concerned, is set aside. The petitioner is discharged under Section 239 of the Code. Sd/- P.G. AJITHKUMAR, JUDGE
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.753 of 2020
2025:KER:27646
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P.G. AJITHKUMAR
TUESDAY, THE 1ST DAY OF APRIL 2025/11TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.REV.PET NO.753 OF 2020
CRIME NO.3/2012 OF VACB, WAYANAD
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 20.03.2020 CMP No.589 OF 2018 IN CC
NO.163 OF 2016 OF COURT OF ENQUIRY COMMNR. & SPECIAL JUDGE,
THALASSERY
REVISION PETITIONER/2ND ACCUSED:
P.A.DEEPTHESH
AGED 39 YEARS
S/O. ANTONY, ALATHUMTHALAKKAL HOUSE,
DWARAKA, NALLOORNAD P.O,
MANANTHAVADY, WAYANAD (GREEN TEA LEAF AGENT)
BY ADVS.
K.P.SATHEESAN (SR.)
SRI.P.MOHANDAS (ERNAKULAM)
SRI.K.SUDHINKUMAR
SRI.S.K.ADHITHYAN
SRI.SABU PULLAN
SRI.GOKUL D. SUDHAKARAN
RESPONDENTS/STATE & COMPLAINANT:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM,
KOCHI 682 031
THE DEPUTY SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE,
VIGILANCE AND ANTI CORRUPTION BUREAU,
WAYANAD 673 591
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.753 of 2020
2025:KER:27646
ADV.SMT REKHA S – SENIOR PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
ADV.SRI A RAJESH - SPECIAL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (VIG)
THIS CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
01.04.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.753 of 2020
2025:KER:27646
P.G. AJITHKUMAR, J
------------------------------------------------Crl.Rev.Pet. No.753 of 2020
------------------------------------------------Dated this the 01st day of April, 2025
ORDER
In this revision petition filed under Section 397 read with
Section 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 the 2nd
accused in C.C. No.163 of 2016 assails the order dated 20.03.2023
of the Court of Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge,
Thalassery. Accused Nos.1 and 2 together filed CMP No.589 of 2018
seeking discharge. The Special Court as per the impugned order,
dismissed that petition and directed framing of charge against
them.
2.
Crime No.57 of 2011 was registered by the Station
House Officer, Mananthavady Police Station. The 2nd respondent
took over the investigation on finding that an offence punishable
under Section 13(1)(c) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention
of Corruption Act, 1988 (PC Act) also was involved. After
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.753 of 2020
2025:KER:27646
investigation, the 2nd respondent filed two final reports resulting in
the institution of C.C. Nos.162 of 2016 and 163 of 2016. The
allegations that form part of the accusation in C.C. No.163 of 2016
are the following:
3.
The 1st accused was the Secretary and the 3rd accused
was the Managing Director of Mananthavady Tribal Plantation Cooperative Society Ltd. W-26, during the relevant period. The 2nd
accused-petitioner was the contractor for the supply of green tea
leaves to the Society. An agreement in that regard was entered
into between accused Nos.2 and 3 on 21.04.2004. The price agreed
as per the said agreement for green tea leaves was more than the
price offered by the forest department. Rs.1/- per kilogram was
paid as transportation charges for the supply of green tea leaves.
Further, the agreement incorporating such unconscionable rates
was entered into without obtaining administrative sanction. By
doing so, the Society sustained a loss of Rs.28,02,411/- from
2004-2005 to 2005 - 2006.
4.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and the
learned Senior Public Prosecutor.
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.753 of 2020
5.
2025:KER:27646
The contention of the petitioner is that during the
period 2002-2004, one Sri.T.C. Varghese was supplying green tea
leaves to the Society and as he stopped the supply, the petitioner
was engaged in terms of the agreement dated 21.04.2004 on the
same rate, and therefore the petitioner cannot be prosecuted for a
criminal offence. The case was initiated following an audit in the
Society. The finding that the Society sustained loss on account of
purchase of green tea leaves from the petitioner was based only
on the market fluctuations and as such, no dishonest intention
could be attributed against the petitioner. It is his further
contention that as per the agreement dated 21.04.2004 price for
the green tea leaves should be the price fixed periodically by
Tamilnadu Small Tea Growers' Industrial Cooperative Tea Factories'
Federation Limited (INDCOSERVE), and the transportation charge
should be Rs.1/- per kilogram. When the same were the terms of
the contract entered into by the previous contract, the only lapse
is to obtain administrative sanction, which is only a procedural
lapse; no criminal prosecution is possible. It is particularly so since
the petitioner was only a contractor.
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.753 of 2020
6.
2025:KER:27646
The learned counsel for the petitioner invited my
attention to the agreements executed by Sri.T.C.Varghese and the
petitioner, which forms part of the prosecution records. It fortifies
the contention that the same contract conditions were carried to
the agreement executed by the petitioner. It is submitted that there
was no offer from Kerala Forest Development Corporation (KFDC)
to supply green tea leaves to the Society as they stopped the
supply following nonpayment of the prices. So the price the KFDC
offered should not have been a criteria for assessing the profit or
loss. The audit in that regard therefore is wrong and the
prosecution based only on such an audit report is unsustainable in
law.
In
the
view
of
the
learned
counsel,
prosecution
is
misconceived.
7.
INDCOSERVE is a more authoritative institution and
when the price fixed by it was adopted, there was no scope for
attributing any foul play. It is also pointed out after referring to
Annexure 3, which is a copy of the file maintained by the Society
concerning payment of the cost of green tea leaves in the year
1993 transportation charge then was Rs.1.25/- per kilogram and
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.753 of 2020
2025:KER:27646
as such payment of transportation charge of Rs.1/- to the
petitioner can at any rate be an illegal act.
8.
The learned Senior Public Prosecutor, on the other
hand, would submit that the same were the terms in the earlier
agreement cannot be a reason for the petitioner to claim discharge
insofar as a prosecution was initiated in relation to the previous
contract as well. When no administrative sanction was obtained,
the clandestine way of executing the agreement is clear and, that
will establish the dishonest intention. The evidence proposed by
the prosecution is sufficient to prove that the loss to the Society
was only due to the illegal acts on the part of the petitioner and his
co-accused. Therefore, in the view of the learned Public Prosecutor,
the order rendered by the Special Court does not suffer from any
infirmity.
9.
The materials produced by the prosecution would show
that the agreement for the supply of green tea leaves between the
petitioner and the 3rd accused was entered into without obtaining
sanction from the Administrative Committee of the Society. To that
extent there occurred a lapse on the part of not only the 3rd accused
but also the 1st accused, who was the Secretary of the Society. That
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.753 of 2020
2025:KER:27646
by itself may not amount to an offence under Section 13(1)(c) of
the PC Act. If that to be an offence, public servant should have
acted dishonestly or fraudulently and as a consequence of the act,
there
occurred
misappropriation
or
obtaining
of
pecuniary
advantage by himself or any other person. If accused Nos.1 and 3
entered into the agreement with the petitioner without ensuring
purchase at the lowest price and that act was tainted with
dishonest or fraudulent intention, it might amount to an offence
inasmuch as the materials produced by the prosecution prima facie
would show that the Society sustained a loss. Of course, the loss
has been calculated based on the fluctuations in the market price
of green tea leaves. But, dishonest intention could be attributed on
the part of the petitioner, who was said to be the beneficiary, only
if the society could purchase green tea leaves from other sources
at a lower price.
10.
Witness No.17 was the Divisional Manager in charge of
the KFDC during the period 07.05.2013. He gave a statement to
the investigating officer based on the records available in his
offence. Going by his statement, green tea leaves were supplied by
KFDC to the Society till 2001 and as an amount of Rs.6,39,603/-
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.753 of 2020
2025:KER:27646
fell overdue, supply was stopped. It is seen that the KFDC could
obtain that amount at the intervention of the District Collector only
and KFDC did not supply green tea leaves after 2001. When the
allegations in the final report is to the effect that green tea leaves
could be purchased from the KFDC for a lesser amount than the
cost agreed as per the agreement in question which was the price
being notified by INDCOSERVE from time to time, the statement of
witness No.17 goes against the case of the prosecution. In the light
of the said statement, it cannot be said that the Society was in a
position to purchase green tea leaves from the KFDC.
11.
Of course, there are references to the effect that the
market value of green tea leaves was less during the period.
However, that cannot be a reason for a criminal prosecution when
terms of agreement have already been put in writing, and
subsequently only there occurred a fall in price.
No criminal
intention at the time of execution of the agreement can therefore
be attributed. Be noticed that the INDCOSERVE is a co-operative
federation under which so many co-operative societies in South
India have functioned. When such an authoritative body fixes the
price of green tea leaves, it cannot be said that agreeing to
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.753 of 2020
2025:KER:27646
purchase green tea leaves at the price fixed by INDCOSERVE is a
decision taken by the authorities in a mischievous manner.
12.
In regard to the transportation charges, the stipulation
in the agreement entered into with Sri.T.C.Varghese was carried in
the agreement with the petitioner as well. It is pertinent to note
that the Managing Director at the time of executing the agreement
with Sri.T.C.Varghese was not accused No.3 here. When accused
No.3 only followed the terms of the earlier agreement which was
executed by his predecessor in office, attributing dishonest
intention only on the basis of accepting such a term is without any
basis. At any rate, the allegation that there occurred dishonest or
fraudulent misappropriation of the fund of the Society on account
of agreeing to the terms in the agreement dated 21.04.2004 is
beyond reason. Prosecution of the petitioner on the basis of the
aforementioned materials would not be a successful one.
13.
The contention that the transportation charge ten years
before was Rs.1.25/- per Kilogram cannot be countenanced since
that plea is based on Annexure 3 which does not form part of the
prosecution
records.
Therefore,
that
contention
cannot
be
considered. Dehors that, the materials produced by the prosecution
Crl.Rev.Pet. No.753 of 2020
2025:KER:27646
are insufficient to have a presumption that the petitioner had
committed the alleged offences. Framing of charge against the
petitioner and asking him to stand trial will only be an abuse of the
process of law. Therefore, the impugned order in relation to the
petitioner is liable to be set aside.
Accordingly, this revision petition is allowed. The impugned
order, insofar as the petitioner is concerned, is set aside. The
petitioner is discharged under Section 239 of the Code.
Sd/-
SMF
P.G. AJITHKUMAR, JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review