Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
LPA 571/2025 & CM APPL. 56791/2025
OSWAAL BOOKS AND LEARNINGS PRIVATE
LIMITED
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Abhishek Malhotra, Sr.
Adv with Mr. Yashwardhan Singh, Mr.
Angad Singh Dugal, Mr. Govind Singh and
Ms. Anukriti Trivedi, Advs.
versus
THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Gaurav Barathi SPC with
Mr. Chirantan Priyadarshan, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE OM PRAKASH SHUKLA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
10.02.2026
%
OM PRAKASH SHUKLA, J.
1.
The present intra-court appeal is directed against the judgment
dated 28.05.2025, whereby the learned Single Judge dismissed
C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 19/2024 preferred by the appellant under
Section 91 of the Trade Marks Act, 19991 and affirmed the refusal
order dated 14.12.2023 passed by the Registrar of Trade Marks
rejecting Trade Mark Application No. 4711190 for registration of the
mark “ONE FOR ALL” in Class 16.
“the Act” hereinafter
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
2.
The appellant, Oswaal Books and Learnings Private Limited, is
engaged in the business of publication and sale of educational books
and allied academic material. It is claimed by the appellant that since
20.08.2020, they adopted the mark “ONE FOR ALL” in relation to its
educational publications falling under Class 16.
3.
The appellant filed Trade Mark Application No. 4711190 on
20.10.2020, seeking registration of the mark “ONE FOR ALL” in
Class 16. The application was examined and an Examination Report
dated 04.11.2020 came to be issued, raising objections under Section
92 of the Act, specifically Section 9(1)(a) and calling upon the
appellant to establish that the mark was capable of distinguishing its
goods from those of others.
4.
After replying to the FER3 and attending the hearing, the
appellant’s trademark application for “ONE FOR ALL” was refused
vide order dated 14.12.2023 under Section 9(1)(a) of the Act on the
ground that it is a common, non-distinctive expression and that the
appellant
failed
to
prove
that
its
mark
has
acquired
distinctiveness/secondary meaning.
5.
The appellant assailed the refusal by way of an appeal under
Absolute grounds for refusal of registration. – (1) The trade marks – (a) which are devoid of any distinctive
character, that is to say, not capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one person from those of
another person; (b) which consist exclusively of marks or indications which may serve in trade to designate
the kind, quality, quantity, intended purpose, values, geographical origin or the time of production of the
goods or rendering of the service or other characteristics of the goods or service; (c) which consist exclusively
of marks or indications which have become customary in the current language or in the bona fide and
established practices of the trade, shall not be registered: Provided that a trade mark shall not be refused
registration if before the date of application for registration it has acquired a distinctive character as a result of
the use made of it or is a well-known trade mark.
First Examination Report
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
Section 91 of the Act, being C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 19/2024, before
this Court. By the impugned judgment dated 28.05.2025, the learned
Single Judge dismissed the appeal and affirmed the refusal. The
learned Single Judge held that the mark “ONE FOR ALL” was a
common, laudatory phrase, that it conveyed the impression of the
appellant’s books being a universal or “one-stop” solution for all, and
that the mark was, therefore, descriptive and lacking in inherent
distinctiveness. The learned Single Judge further held that the
appellant had failed to discharge the burden of establishing acquired
distinctiveness or secondary meaning, and that the documents relied
upon by the appellant predominantly related to the appellant’s house
mark “OSWAAL BOOKS” rather than to the applied mark “ONE
FOR ALL”. The learned Single Judge also noted that in most
instances the mark was not used in isolation but with prefixes or
suffixes, and concluded that the appellant had not shown that the
expression “ONE FOR ALL” was recognised by the relevant
purchasing public as a standalone indicator of trade origin.
6.
The learned Single Judge additionally relied upon the
proposition that words of ordinary English usage cannot be
monopolised, and observed that allowing registration of such
expressions would result in impermissible restriction of language.
Reliance was placed, inter alia, on decisions emphasising that
common phrases face a heightened threshold for registration unless
secondary meaning is clearly established. The learned Single Judge
also noticed the submission that “ONE FOR ALL” is popularly
associated with the phrase “All for one and one for all”, traditionally
linked to “The Three Musketeers”, and treated the said association as
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
indicative of the common and widely known character of the
expression.
7.
The appellant is, therefore, before this Court by way of the
present Letters Patent Appeal, submitting that the impugned judgment
suffers from errors of law and that the conclusions returned therein are
unsustainable on a proper application of the Act and settled principles
of trademark jurisprudence.
8.
Mr. Abhishek Malhotra, learned Counsel for the appellants
urges that the mark is inherently distinctive, particularly as the
examination report cited no similar marks on the Register. Reliance is
placed on Abu Dhabi Global Market v. Registrar of Trade Marks4,
to submit that in the absence of similar marks in the relevant class,
non-distinctiveness cannot ordinarily be presumed merely because the
mark appears common.
9.
Without prejudice, it is contended that the mark has acquired
distinctiveness under the proviso to Section 9(1) of the Act. The
appellant disputes the finding of descriptiveness, submitting that
“ONE FOR ALL”, taken as a whole, does not describe the kind,
nature, quality, purpose or characteristics of books and requires a
mental pause to connect it with the goods. Reliance is placed on Anil
Verma v. R.K. Jewellers5and Disruptive Health Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v.
Registrar of Trade Marks.6
2023:DHC:3476
2019:DHC:2276
2022:DHC:2545.
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
10.
It is further urged that even descriptive marks may be protected
if they have become distinctive and no other trader has used them,
relying on Procter & Gamble Manufacturing (Tianjin) Co. Ltd. v.
Anchor Health & Beauty Care Pvt. Ltd.7
11.
The appellant submits that the impugned judgment applied a
legally flawed test for secondary meaning by requiring association by
the “public at large”, whereas the correct test is association by the
relevant consumer class, namely students, parents and teachers.
12.
It is contended that the learned Single Judge wrongly rejected
the mark merely because it comprises common English words, despite
precedent protecting such combinations. Reliance is placed on
decisions of the learned Single Bench of this Court inA Dot Limited v.
Registrar of Trade Marks8, Kohler Co. v. Registrar of Trade Marks9,
Grey Matters Educations Trust v. Examiner of Trade Marks10, and
in the decision of the Madras High Court in Just Lime My Child
Foundation v. Registrar of Trade Marks11.
13.
The appellant submits that the impugned judgment violates the
anti-dissection rule by dissecting the mark word-by-word instead of
assessing it as a whole. Reliance is placed on Grey Matters
Educations Trust (supra) and Ticona Polymers, Inc. v. Registrar of
Trade Marks.12
2016 SCC OnLine Del 5669
C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 25/2021
C.A.(COMM.IPD-TM) 34/2022
2024 SCC OnLine Del 7390
CMA (TM) No. 5 of 2024
2023 SCC OnLine Del 1234
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
14.
The appellant also submits that the refusal order is mechanical
and violates Section 18(5) of the Act and Rule 36 of the Trade Marks
Rules 2017. It is further contended that sub-brands remain
independently registrable, and that the goodwill of the house mark
extends to such sub-brands, relying on Pidilite Industries Ltd. v.
Jubilant Agri & Consumer Products Ltd.13. The Appellant further
submits that the mark was wrongly treated as a mere slogan, and that
reliance on a literary phrase from The Three Musketeers is wholly
irrelevant.
15.
Therefore it is urged that the impugned order is to be set aside.
16.
Per Contra, Mr. Gaurav Barathi learned SPC for the
respondents submits that to overcome Section 9(1)(a), the applicant
must prove acquired distinctiveness through long, continuous and
extensive use such that the mark is recognised by the public as an
exclusive source identifier. It is contended that adoption in 2020 and
the alleged sales and promotional figures are insufficient to confer
secondary meaning.
17.
Mr. Barathi relies on the order dated 08.04.2024, wherein the
Ld. Single Judge recorded a prima facie view that the Senior
Examiner may have been correct in holding the mark to be devoid of
distinctiveness, and that the appellant must cross the threshold of
proving significance and distinctiveness in its favour. It is contended
that “ONE FOR ALL” is a common, laudatory slogan, used
2014 SCC OnLineBom 50
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
descriptively in relation to books to convey that the appellant’s
publications cater to all boards and examinations, and that such
expressions carry a heightened threshold for registration; absent clear
secondary meaning, their monopolisation would impermissibly restrict
language in trade and confer an unwarranted monopoly on a single
trader.
18.
It is contended that the evidence relied upon by the appellant
was duly examined and correctly rejected in paragraphs 12-20 of the
impugned judgment. Mere sales figures and promotional expenditure,
without cogent documentary substantiation, cannot confer exclusivity.
The respondent submits that the mark is not shown to be used
prominently or independently; rather it appears sporadically, in
combination with the house mark “OSWAAL BOOKS” or as part of
promotional phrases.
19.
Reliance is placed on Marico Limited v Agro Tech Foods
Limited14, to contend that trademark protection cannot be extended to
common descriptive expression which is not inherently distinctive
enough to grant an exclusive trademark right.
20.
Having heard Mr. Abhishek Malhotra, learned Counsel for the
appellants and Mr. Gaurav Bhatia learned Counsel for the respondents
and having perused the record, we proceed to weigh the rival
submissions and the legality of the impugned judgment.
21.
At the outset, we are conscious of the scope of review available
2010:DHC:5337-DB
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
within this intra-court appeal.
22.
To begin with, we find that this appeal does not entail any
contentious factual inquiry nor any knotty question of law. This court
vide order dated 09.09.2025 had recorded that “The short issue that
arise for consideration, therefore, is whether the wordmark “ONE
FOR ALL” was disentitled to registration on the ground of want of
distinctiveness”
23.
The controversy in the present appeal lies in a narrow compass.
The appellant seeks registration of the mark “ONE FOR ALL” in
Class 16 for educational books and allied publications. The Trade
Marks Registry refused the application under Section 9(1)(a) of the
Act, holding the mark to be devoid of distinctive character and the
appellant
to
have
failed
in
establishing
acquired
distinctiveness/secondary meaning. The learned Single Judge, by the
impugned
judgment
dated
28.05.2025, affirmed
the refusal,
principally on the reasoning that the expression is a common,
laudatory phrase, descriptive of the appellant’s publications being a
“one-stop solution”, and that the evidence led by the appellant did not
demonstrate that the mark had acquired distinctiveness in trade.
24.
Needless to state, the legal position in such matters is well-
settled. Section 9(1)(a) proscribes registration of marks which are
incapable of distinguishing the goods of one person from those of
another. The proviso, however, statutorily preserves registrability
where, before the date of application, the mark has acquired a
distinctive
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
character as a result of use. The inquiry, therefore, is
twofold; (i) whether the mark is inherently distinctive; and; (ii) if it is
not, whether the evidence demonstrates acquired distinctiveness
sufficient to attract the proviso.
25.
Further, this court speaking through one of us (C.Hari Shankar
J) in the decision of Leayan Global Pvt ltd. vs Bata India Ltd.15had
laid down as follows :
“34.4.1Though Section 17(2)(b) does not permit any claim of
exclusivity over a mark which is not distinctive, it does not contain
any guideline as to how to decide whether a particular mark is, or
is not, distinctive. The Trade Marks Act is, however, thankfully not
silent in this regard, as the answer to this query is to be found in
Section 9(1)(a)46 of the Trade Maks Act. Section 9 contains the
absolute grounds on which registration of a trademark may be
refused. Clause (a) of Section 9(1) does not allow registration of
trademarks which are devoid of any distinctive character. The
expression “devoid of any distinctive character” is explained, in
the same clause, as “not capable of distinguishing the goods or
services of one person from those of another person”. There is no
reason as to why this explanation for the expression “devoid of any
distinctive character” should not be applied to understand the
expression “non-distinctive character” in Section 17(2)(b).
34.4.2Thus, by virtue of Section 17(2)(b), no exclusivity can be
claimed over a mark which is not capable of distinguishing the
goods of one person from those of another. The aspect of
distinctiveness, or the absence of it, has, therefore, to be assessed
not merely by referring to the mark in vacuo, but in the context of
the goods or services for which it is used. A common dictionary
word, which may be part of daily usage, may become distinctive
when used for goods or services with which it has no immediate
connection.
34.4.3We, in this context, are in entire agreement with the learned
Single Judge’s observation that the word “POWER” does not
evoke a connect, in the mind, between the mark and footwear, as it
may, for example, evoke, if it were to be used in the context of
boxing gloves. While the mark POWER may, therefore,
arguendo, not be distinctive when used for an item such a boxing
2025:DHC:11331-DB
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
gloves or, for that matter, an electric plug, it is distinctive when
used for footwear.
34.4.4Leayan’s contention that the mark POWER was lacking in
distinctiveness cannot, therefore, be accepted.
34.5 Re. plea that POWER FLEX is a descriptive mark, and cannot
be injuncted – Section 35
34.5.1In the impugned judgment, the learned Single Judge has also
gone on to distinguish between descriptive marks and suggestive
marks. Marks which are descriptive are not capable of being
registered, in view of Section 9(1)(b)47 and cannot be injuncted
because of Section 35; however, marks which, though not
descriptive, are merely suggestive, may be registered, and can be
injuncted. The position in law, in this regard, stands settled by the
judgment of the Supreme Court in T.V. Venugopal v. Ushodaya
Enterprises.16
34.5.2The learned Single Judge has referred to various tests that
have been evolved from time to time to decide whether a mark is
distinctive or suggestive. In the facts of the present case, we do not
deem any detailed discussion on that aspect to be necessary as, in
our view, the word POWER FLEX is not even suggestive of
footwear. The mark POWER FLEX does not bring, to mind,
footwear. It cannot, therefore, be regarded as “(descriptive) of the
character or quality” of the leather footwear of Leayan, within the
meaning of Section 35.
34.6 Even if it were to be assumed that Leayan’s POWER FLEX
footwear was flexible in nature, which is one of Mr. Bansal’s
contentions, that would, at the highest, render the mark POWER
FLEX suggestive of the characteristics of the leather footwear used
by Leayan, and not descriptive thereof. The applicable test, to
determine whether a mark is descriptive, or suggestive, of the
goods in respect of which it is used, or neither, is, to our mind,
the extent to which the imagination must be strained to draw a
connect between the mark and the goods. If the connect is
immediate, the mark is descriptive; if, by straining the
imagination, a connection can be found, the mark may be
suggestive; if, however, there is no connect at all – such as, for
example, the mark TODAY for perfumes – the mark is neither.
Illuminatingly, Pernod Ricard refers to marks such as Air India,
Mother Dairy, HMT, Windows, Doordarshan, LIC and SBI as
being descriptive.
(2011) 4 SCC 85
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
34.7 As the mark POWER FLEX is not descriptive of the
characteristics of the leather footwear for which it was used by
Leayan, Leayan cannot claim the protection of Section 35.“
26.
It could be understood from the above reading that a mark is
descriptive or not has to be assessed in the context of the goods and
services it is being used. Also, a common word may also become
distinctive if used for goods or services with which it has no
immediate connection.
27.
Additionally, it is undisputed that the slogans are clearly
capable of constituting a “trade mark” within the meaning of Sections
2(m) and 2(zb) of the Act. These slogans can be represented
graphicallyand can be used in distinguishing the goods of one person
from those of another. In some cases, these slogans are used to
indicate, in the course of trade, a connection between the goods and
the
28.
person
entitled
to
use
the
mark.
Also, with the rise of heavily digitised marketplace, with digital
marketing expanding rapidly, slogans and taglines often perform a
source-identifying function and, in many cases, may be more readily
recognised than the brand or trade name itself. Slogans, taglines, and
similar expressions have therefore become an integral component of
source identification.
29.
Adverting to the facts of the present case, the learned Single
Judge, in the impugned judgment, has proceeded substantially on the
premise that “ONE FOR ALL” is a combination of common English
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
words, and that permitting its registration would result in
monopolisation of language.
30.
The learned Single Judge has held the mark to be descriptive,
on the reasoning that it conveys the impression that the appellant’s
books cater to all boards and examinations and are a universal
solution. The finding of the learned single judge on the aspect of the
applied mark in context of books are as follows:
“27. In the present case, the phrase “ONE FOR ALL” is a
common, laudatory slogan, clearly suggestive of the appellant’s
intention to project its books as a universal solution for various
academic needs. The appellant’s own submission that its‟
publications cater to multiple school boards and national level
competitive examinations, when juxtaposed with the applied mark
“ONE FOR ALL”, confirms that the mark functions descriptively
conveying that the appellant’s books are suitable for everyone,
across all exams and boards. Such use of the phrase directly
describes the intended utility of the goods, and hence, is not
arbitrary in the context of the appellant’s business.”
31.
In this regard, we respectfully disagree with the findings of the
learned Single Judge, we find that the applied mark “ONE FOR
ALL” in any manner cannot be associated with the trade or business
of books or any other goods or services related to class 16. As
mentioned above, the applied mark is used when a singular remedy is
capable of dispensing with the requirement of multiple or parallel
processes.
32.
The intended use of applied mark/slogan “ONE FOR ALL” is
for goods falling under class 16. Class 16 covers tangible printed and
paper-based goods. As mentioned above, “ONE FOR ALL” slogan is
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
used when a singular remedy is capable of dispensing with the
requirement of multiple or parallel processes. The applied mark “ONE
FOR ALL” is not a common-way or slogan used in class 16 to
describe goods and services.
33.
In addition, the respondent has failed to showcase the
commercial use of any mark either identical or deceptively similar to
the applied mark, especially in class 16. Moreover, there was no
objection raised under Section 11 of the Act by the respondent in its
Examination Report.
34.
We find that the applied mark “ONE FOR ALL” does not
evoke a connect, in the mind, between the mark and books. The mark
has no relation with books and can be used in any situation to
communicate broad coverage or universality. “ONE FOR ALL” does
not directly and unequivocally describe books. The applied mark is, at
the highest, suggestive in nature. Therefore, satisfies the statutory
requirement and is capable of registration.
35.
Additionally, applying the test mentioned above, the connect
between books and “ONE FOR ALL” is not immediate. Even
assuming that the appellant’s intention is to project its books as a
universal solution for various academic needs, that would, at the
highest render the mark suggestive and not descriptive.
36.
Therefore, according to us, the appellant cannot be refused
registration in view of Section 9(1)(a) of the Act.
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
37.
In view of the facts and circumstances, the impugned orders of
the learned Single Judge as well as of the Registrar of Trade Marks are
set aside.
38.
The application of the appellant for registration of the mark is
restored to the position as it was at the time when the order was passed
and shall, thereafter proceed from that stage onwards.
39.
The appeal stands allowed accordingly with no orders as to
costs.
OM PRAKASH SHUKLA, J.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
FEBRUARY 10, 2026/pa
Digitally Signed
By:AJIT KUMAR LPA 571/2025
Signing
Date:15.02.2026 20:58
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review