Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010601082025
Bench Sr.No:-5
[3584]
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
WRIT PETITION NO: 31035 of 2025
Orsu Sri Harshith and another
...Petitioner(s)
Vs.
All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS)
and Others
...Respondent(s)
**********
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 10th September 2026
Present:
Advocate for Petitioner:
RAMA MOHAN RAO KOTHA
Advocate(s) for Respondent(s): JUPUDI V K YAGNADUTT
VIVEK CHANDRA SEKHAR S
ORDER: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
Petitioners assail Medical Certificate-cum-Seat Cancellation
letter
dated
01.11.2025
issued
by
1st
respondent,
with
consequential direction not to cancel the allotment/admission in
MBBS course pursuant to provisional allotment letter dated
23.10.2025 and to confirm admission under the reserved category
of Persons with Benchmark Disabilities (PwBD).
2.
(a)
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31035 of 2025
1st petitioner was issued Unique Disability ID by
Government of India certifying disability type as low vision with
50% disability. 1st Petitioner appeared for NEET UG 2025 and
secured All India Rank of 413261, and within category of PwBD,
secured rank of 642. In terms of the judgment of Hon'ble Apex
Court in Om Rathod vs. Union of India1, 4th respondent issued
interim guidelines on assessment method for granting admissions
in MBBS course to PwBD candidates for academic year 2025-26,
and also notified list of disability certification centres that would
issue disability certificates. 2nd petitioner is the father of
1st petitioner.
(b)
1st petitioner appeared before one of such designated
medical assessment boards as enlisted and was issued certificate
dated 30.09.2025 assessing the disability type as low vision with
50% disability.
(c)
In the process of counselling, petitioner got selected for
admission under OBC-PwBD quota, accordingly was issued
provisional allotment letter dated 23.10.2025 granting admission at
1st respondent college. When 1st petitioner reported before
1st respondent, he was once again subjected to reassessment of
2024 SCC OnLine SC 4000
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31035 of 2025
specified disability and by impugned proceedings, the admission
was cancelled on the ground that 1st petitioner was found not to
have possessed any visual or other disability as mentioned in
UDID, hence, would not qualify for admission under PwBD
category.
(d)
Aggrieved by the same, present writ petition is preferred.
3.
By order dated 07.11.2025, coordinate Bench of this Court,
while issuing notice in the writ petition, directed 1st respondent to
admit and permit 1st petitioner to pursue the course inasmuch as
provisional admission was granted based on disability certificate
dated 30.09.2025 issued by Medical Board of Goa Medical
College, however, it was made clear that the admission based on
the interim order will be subject to result in main writ petition and
that writ petitioner shall not claim any equities in case decision in
main writ petition goes against him.
4.
For better understanding, we reproduce the operative
portion as under:
“Therefore, in the said facts and circumstances of
the case, there shall be interim direction to the 1st
respondent to admit and permit the 1st petitioner pursuant
to the provisional allotment letter dated 23.10.2025
issued by the 3rd respondent on the basis of the disability
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31035 of 2025
certificate dated 30.09.2025 issued by the Medical Board
of Goa Medical College to pursue his MBBS course by
attending the classes in All India Institute of Medical
Sciences, Mangalagiri. The said admission of the 1st
petitioner in MBBS course in AIIMS pursuant to the
interim direction given will be subject to the result of the
main writ petition. The 1st petitioner shall not claim any
equities in case the decision in main writ petition goes
against him.”
5.
Based on aforesaid interim order, 1st petitioner was admitted
and he continues to pursue the course. Subsequently, when the
matter was listed on 09.12.2025, this Court was confronted with
assessment of disability of 1st petitioner by two medical boards, one
in favour of 1st petitioner and the other going against him. In that
background,
since
there
existed
serious
doubt
whether
1st petitioner at all suffers from any benchmark disability, learned
counsel for petitioners was suggested to seek instructions whether
1st petitioner would be willing to undergo further medical
examination by an independent medical board. In response,
learned
Senior
instructions,
Counsel
expressed
appearing
for
petitioners,
willingness
to
undergo
upon
medical
examination. In those circumstances, the following directions came
to be issued:
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31035 of 2025
“Be that as it may, since doubts have been created as
to whether petitioner No.1 at all suffers from any
benchmark disability, it is suggested to the learned
counsel for the petitioners to take instructions as to
whether petitioner No.1 is willing to undertake a medical
examination by any independent Medical Board.
Thus, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
petitioners would suggest that candidate is willing to
undergo medical examination by one of the authorized
Medical Assessment Boards and in this case, he
suggested the Medical Board constituted in Atal Bihari
Vajpayee Institute of Medical Sciences & RML Hospital,
New Delhi.
Be that as it may, we direct the Director of the above
mentioned Institute to have petitioner No.1 medically
examined to determine his benchmark disability by a duly
authorized
and
constituted
Medical
Board
with
specialists from the concerned field to determine as to
whether petitioner No.1 suffers from any visual disability
and the extents thereof. Petitioner No.1 shall be present
himself for medical examination on 15.12.2025.”
6.
Subsequently, when the matter was listed on 30.12.2025, it
was brought to notice of this Court that the medical board
constituted at Atal Bihari Vajpayee Institute of Medical Sciences
and RML Hospital, New Delhi, could not conduct the assessment
due to lack of requisite machinery, medical examination of
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31035 of 2025
1st petitioner was directed to be conducted by Medical Board
constituted in Madras Medical College (MMC), Chennai. The
directions issued thus read as under:
“9.
In the aforesaid circumstances, we direct the
medical examination of petitioner No.1 by the Medical
Board constituted in Madras Medical College (MMC),
Chennai.
10.
Principal of the said medical college shall ensure
that the petitioner is examined by a duly constituted
Medical Board constituted by the Medical Counselling
Committee of India.”
7.
1st petitioner did subject himself to assessment in terms of
aforesaid directions. The Medical Board vide certificate dated
12.01.2026 assessed with remarks, "(BE) Compound Myopic
Astigmatism (Malingering test Positive)". Thus, 1st petitioner was
held to be not eligible for MBBS course under PwBD quota.
Further, the Medical Superintendent of 1st respondent, by interoffice file No.AIIMS/MG/OPH/ MSO/2026/06/03, decoded medical
terminology as mentioned in aforesaid report in following terms:
“Remarks column mentions (BE) Compound myopic
astigmatism [Malingering test positive].
Explanation of the terms:
1. (BE) stands for Both Eyes
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31035 of 2025
2. Compound myopic astigmatism is a common refractive
error where both of the eye's main meridians are
nearsighted (myopic) but to different degrees. Standard
eyeglasses containing both spherical and cylindrical
lenses are used to correct the vision.
3. Tests for malingering (functional visual loss) in
ophthalmology are used to identify patients who are
exaggerating or faking vision loss. Ophthalmologists
expose the exaggeration by relying on involuntary
reflexes that bypass the patient's conscious control.”
8.
When aforesaid report, along with inter-office file, was
supplied to petitioners, learned counsel appearing for them sought
time to get instructions on various occasions.
9.
Sri Rama Mohan Rao Kotha, learned counsel appearing for
petitioners, vehemently contended that the impugned seat
cancellation letter issued by 1st respondent is without jurisdiction,
and further that when already 1st petitioner has been subjected to
assessment by the Medical Board at Goa, question of yet again
examining 1st petitioner to determine the disability factor either by
1st respondent or any other medical assessment board does not
arise, therefore, urged to allow the writ petition.
10.
(a)
Mr.Jupudi VK Yagnadutt, learned counsel appearing
for 1st respondent, while refuting aforesaid submissions, contended
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31035 of 2025
that firstly, 1st respondent would not come under the purview of
National Medical Commission, therefore, even if a provisional
admission is granted and student is sponsored to 1st respondent, it
is well within the powers of 1st respondent to assess the benchmark
disability to be in conformity with the provisions of PwBD Act for
the purpose of granting admission, therefore, rightly 1st petitioner
has been refused admission as he was found to be ineligible.
(b)
He further contended that the very provisional allotment
letter dated 23.10.2025 itself clearly specifies that any such
allotment is purely provisional and the seat of candidate is liable for
cancellation in case candidate does not fulfill the eligibility criteria
on verification of original documents at the time of reporting or any
time thereafter, therefore, as 1st petitioner was found to be
ineligible, the seat allotment was rightly cancelled.
(c)
He lastly contended that when 1st petitioner himself has
come forward to undergo medical assessment before independent
medical body other than the one which has first assessed or by the
1st respondent, 1st petitioner cannot disown the contents of the
report merely because the same went against him.
11.
The undisputed facts of the case are that 1st petitioner
initially claimed disability type of low vision with 50% visual
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31035 of 2025
impairment, he was assessed and issued certificate dated
30.09.2025 by Medical Assessment Board, Goa Medical College,
which is one of enlisted medical assessment boards in terms of
NMC guidelines. Based on the same, provisional allotment letter
dated 23.10.2025 was issued, allotting seat in favour of
1st petitioner in OBC-PwBD All India quota at 1st respondent
college. When 1st petitioner reported for admission and verification
of documents, 1st respondent subjected 1st petitioner once again
for medical test. As per the medical assessment, the remarks
offered are as under:
“Candidate
has
secured
admission
under
PwBD
Category. Our assessment does not reveal any visual or
any other disability as mentioned in the UDID.
The
candidate is medically fit to pursue the MBBC Course but
not qualify for this MBBS seat under PwBD Category.”
12.
Therefore, the seat allotted to 1st petitioner was cancelled by
impugned proceedings. When this Court was confronted with two
medical assessments, as this Court is not an expert body to take
any view on the same, with consent of petitioners, 1st petitioner was
referred to an independent medical board for further medical
assessment. The Medical Board at Madras Medical College, after
having assessed the petitioner, opined that he was not eligible for
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31035 of 2025
MBBS course under PwBD quota, since he did not possess the
benchmark disability. The medical terminology was further
decoded by the Department of Ophthalmology at 1st respondent.
Though petitioners tried to dispute the same, no explanation
whatsoever has been offered to discard the third report.
13.
The basis for granting admission in favour of 1st petitioner
was that he possessed benchmark disability of 50% low vision,
being eligible for reservation under PwBD quota. In view of the third
report, the claim of petitioners pales into insignificance, thus,
becoming ineligible to claim any reservation under PwBD quota.
Insofar as the contention that 1st respondent is not empowered to
examine and subject 1st petitioner to medical assessment at the
time of verification of documents, we are afraid that there is no such
hard and fast rule.
14.
In the given facts and circumstances, if there is any doubt
with regard to the genuineness or otherwise of the certificates
produced, it is always open to the institution admitting the students
to verify the same, which even includes subjecting candidate to
re-examination. We are not oblivious of the fact that 1st petitioner
was granted admission by virtue of interim orders and that he
continued to pursue the course, however, as the very same order
HCJ & CGR, J
W.P. No.31035 of 2025
clearly stipulated that the admission so granted would be subject
to result in the main writ petition and that 1st petitioner would not
claim any equities, we have no other option than confirming the
seat cancellation letter.
15.
This writ petition, therefore, lacks any merit and accordingly
the same is dismissed. No costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending consideration,
if any, in this case shall stand closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J
SS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review