Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Appeal From Order No. 382 of 2024
Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
….....Appellant
Versus
Narayan Singh and others
.….Respondents
Present:Mr. Deepak Rawat, Advocate for the appellant.
Mr. Harsh Vardhan Dhanik, Advocate for the respondent
nos. 1, 2, 3 and 5.
None for the respondent no.4.
Hon’ble Ravindra Maithani, J. (Oral)
Instant appeal is preferred against the order dated
12.07.2024, passed in ECA Case No. 17 of 2023, Sri Narayan Singh
and others Vs. Sri Ravindra Singh Chauhan and another (“the
claim
petition”)
by
the
court
of
Employees
Compensation
Commissioner, Dehradun. By it, the respondent nos. 1, 2 & 3/the
claimants have been awarded Rs.16,01,775/- as compensation.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
3.
Notices of the appeal was served on the respondent
no.4, but he is not represented.
4.
The claimants filed a claim petition on the ground that
Tilak Singh (claimant Narayan Singh is father, claimant Km.
Karishma Chauhan is unmarried sister and claimant Harish
Chauhan is unmarried brother of the deceased Tilak Singh) was
driver of the Bolero Vehicle bearing Registration No. UK 16 TA 0334
(“the vehicle”) owned by the respondent no.4 Ravindra Singh
Chauhan. He was an employee of the respondent no.4. On
31.07.2023, the deceased was driving the vehicle from Village Sarni
to Tyuni, when at about 08:30 in the morning, near Village Nayli
Daragad Road Tyuni, the vehicle met with an accident and the
deceased died. According to the claim petition, the deceased Tilak
Singh was getting Rs.15,000/- per month and Rs.200/- per day
allowances. Based on these allegations, total Rs. 18 Lakh
compensation was claimed.
5.
The owner of the vehicle did file his objections in the
claim petition. He admitted the employment of the deceased by him
and the factum of the accident. According to him, the deceased
Tilak Singh had a valid driving license and if there is any liability
to
pay
compensation,
it
falls
with
the
appellant/Insurance
Company.
6.
The appellant/Insurance Company has also filed its
objections. It has also been pleaded that no FIR of the incident was
lodged; there is no material on record which reveals that the
deceased was driver with the respondent no.4 and was getting
salary as claimed; multiple other grounds were also taken in its
objections by the appellant.
7.
Based on pleadings of the parties, the following issues
were framed in the claim petition:-
“1.
Whether the death of the deceased employee Tilak
Singh occurred during the course of employment of
respondent no. 1 due to his vehicle Bolero No. UK 16
TA/0334 being uncontrolled and falling in a deep
gorge on 31.07.2023 at the time of coming from
village
Sarni
to
Tyuni?
If
yes,
then
to
what
benefit/compensation the claimants are entitled to
and with which other details?
2.
8.
Any other relief?
Parties led evidence in the claim petition, after hearing
the parties by the impugned judgment and order, the claimants
were awarded compensation against which the appeal has been
preferred under Section 30 of the Employees Compensation Act,
1923. On 07.10.2024, when the appeal was admitted, the following
questions of law were formulated:-
“(1)
Whether
the
learned
Commissioner
was
justified in granting compensation to the
claimants when it was clearly proved that the
Driver of the vehicle in question did not have a
transport as well as hill endorsement on his
driving license which would have authorized
him to drive a transport/commercial vehicle?
(2)
Whether the Commissioner was justified in
fastening the liability upon the Insurance
Company when a similar controversy regarding
the issue of transport endorsement in "M/s
Bajaj Alliance General Insurance Company
Ltd. Vs Rambha Devi and others", in Civil
Appeal No.841 of 2018, 2022 Live Law SC 270,
has been referred to a bench of five judges and
the same is awaiting adjudication?
(3)
Whether the Commissioner was justified in
fastening the liability upon the Insurance
Company when it was admitted before the
learned Commissioner that the owner of the
vehicle was the real brother of the deceased 2
and the claimants were the real brother and
his children who would not come within the
definition of dependent as contemplated under
the Employees Compensation Act?
(4)
Whether the learned Commissioner was justified
in assessing the income of the deceased at Rs.
15,000 per month for the purposes of granting
compensation as the same is clearly on a
higher side and not in consonance of the
provisions of the Employees Compensation Act
1923. (5) Whether the learned Commissioner
was justified in fastening the liability upon the
Insurance company when the employment of
the relationship of employer/employee was not
categorically
established
which
is
a
prerequisite for grant of compensation in
Employees Compensation Act 1923?”
9.
Learned counsel for the appellant/Insurance Company
submits that the deceased was driving a transport vehicle, but the
driving license did not have the transport and hill driving
endorsement on it. Therefore, it cannot be said that the driver has a
valid driving license and accordingly, the liability cannot be
fastened upon the appellant/Insurance Company. Though, he fairly
concedes that post filing of the appeal, the issue with regard to the
transport vehicle has already been decided by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court
in the case of Bajaj Alliance General Insurance Company
Limited Vs. Rambha Devi and others, (2025) 3 SCC 95 and now it is
no more required for a vehicle in the gross vehicle weight under
7,500 Kilograms. He submits that this ground is not available to
the appellant/Insurance Company. He also submits that, in fact,
the deceased was brother of the respondent no.4, the owner of the
vehicle.
10.
Learned counsel for the claimants submits that the
issue with regard to the endorsement of the transport vehicle is no
more available to the appellant in view of the principle of law laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Bajaj Alliance
General Insurance Company Limited (supra).
11.
Insofar as, hill endorsement on the driving license is
concerned, learned counsel for the claimants submits that in the
case of The New Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Smt. Kala Devi alias Kala
Devi and others, 2008 (2) UC 821, this Court has already held that
the driving license cannot be invalidated merely on the ground that
it has not recommended for driving in hills. He submits that this
has been so quoted in the impugned judgment.
This Court has to record the finding on the questions of
law. Question nos. 1 and 2 are co-related, they are as follows:-
“(1)
Whether
the
learned
Commissioner
was
justified in granting compensation to the
claimants when it was clearly proved that the
Driver of the vehicle in question did not have a
transport as well as hill endorsement on his
driving license which would have authorized
him to drive a transport/commercial vehicle.
(2)
Whether the Commissioner was justified in
fastening the liability upon the Insurance
Company when a similar controversy regarding
the issue of transport endorsement in "M/s
Bajaj Alliance General Insurance Company
Ltd. Vs Rambha Devi and others", in Civil
Appeal No.841 of 2018, 2022 Live Law SC 270,
has been referred to a bench of five judges and
the same is awaiting adjudication.”
13.
The question no.1 relates to what is the effect if the
driver of the vehicle in question did not have a transport as well as
the hill driving endorsement on his driving license and question
no.2 is with regard to the judgment in the case of Bajaj Alliance
General Insurance Company Limited (supra), which then was
referred to the Larger Bench.
14.
Insofar as transport vehicle is concerned, in the case of
Bajaj Alliance General Insurance Company Limited (supra), the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has settled the law and in para 181.1 has
held as follows:“181.1. A driver holding a licence for light motor
vehicle (LMV) class, under Section 10(2)(d) for vehicles with
a gross vehicle weight under 7500 kg, is permitted to
operate a “transport vehicle” without needing additional
authorisation under Section 10(2)(e) of the MV Act
specifically for the “transport vehicle” class. For licensing
purposes, LMVs and transport vehicles are not entirely
separate classes. An overlap exists between the two. The
special eligibility requirements will however continue to
apply for, inter alia, e-carts, e-rickshaws, and vehicles
carrying hazardous goods.”
15.
In view of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, this ground is no more available to the appellant and merely
because the transport vehicle endorsement is not made on the
driving license of the deceased, his driving license cannot be said to
be invalid.
16.
Insofar as, the hill endorsement is concerned, the
impugned judgment itself records that in the case of Kala Devi
(supra), this Court has held that merely because hill endorsement is
not made on the driving license, it does not invalidate the driving
license. Therefore, question nos. 1 and 2 are decided accordingly.
17.
Question no.3 is with regard to the fact that the owner
of the vehicle was the real brother of the deceased and claimants
include the real brother and his children would not come within the
definition of dependent.
18.
Learned counsel for the appellant/insurance company
submits that this question of law was formulated to rule out any
collusion between the claimants inter se.
19.
Merely because the owner of the vehicle happens to be
the brother of the deceased does not make a ground for rejection of
the claim. It has been proved that the deceased was employee of the
respondent no.4, the owner of the vehicle.
20.
A substantial question No.4 is to the effect that as to
whether the income of the deceased has rightly been assessed at
Rs. 15,000/- per month on its higher side. It has been the case of
the claimants that the deceased Tilak Singh was working as driver
on a vehicle owned by the respondent no.4 at a salary of
Rs.15,000/- per month. It has been admitted by the respondent
no.4. There is no evidence adduced on behalf of the appellant to
doubt it. Therefore, this Court does not find any error in the
impugned judgment, which holds that the income of the deceased
was
Rs.15,000/-
per
month
for
the
purpose
of
granting
compensation.
21.
Substantial question of law no.4 is decided accordingly.
22.
Respondent no.1 Narayan Singh is the claimant, who is
father of the deceased and he was 70 years of age when the claim
was filed. Respondent no.2/claimant Km . Karishma Chauhan was
24 years of age, who was unmarried sister of the deceased.
Respondent no.3/claimant Harish Chauhan was 20 years of age
and unmarried brother of the deceased. The respondent no.5 in the
appeal has been shown as opposite party no.3 in the claim petition,
she is mother of the deceased of 68 years of age.
23.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that under
Section 2 (1) (d) of the Employees Compensation Act, 1923 only
minor brother would fall under the definition of dependant.
Whereas, the appellant no.3, Harish Chauhan, the brother of the
deceased was 20 years of age when claim was filed. He is not
entitled to compensation. This is not disputed by learned counsel
appearing for the respondent nos. 1, 2, 3 and 5. Therefore, while
affirming the impugned judgment and order, slightest modification
is to be done with regard to the entitlement and apportionment of
the amount of compensation.
24.
The impugned judgment and order is upheld insofar as
it fastens liability on the appellant to pay Rs. 16,01,775/- as
compensation to the claimants @ 12% interest w.e.f. the date of
death of the deceased.
25.
The respondent no.1 Narayan Singh, respondent no.2
Km. Karishma Chauhan and respondent no.5 Smt. Urmilla are
entitled to the compensation. Out of the entire amount of
compensation, the respondent no.5 Smt. Urmilla, the mother of the
deceased shall get 50% of the amount of compensation; respondent
no.1 Narayan Singh, the father of the deceased shall get 30% of the
amount of compensation amount and respondent 2 Km. Karishma
Chauhan shall get 20% of the amount of compensation.
26.
The impugned judgment and order is modified to the
extent, as indicated above.
27.
The appeal stands disposed accordingly.
(Ravindra Maithani, J.)
Jitendra
30.05.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review