Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 24th July 2026
+
MAC.APP. 635/2015
ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Pradeep Gaur, Ms. Sweta Sinha
Advocates.
versus
SUMAN DEVI & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Naresh Gupta, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed by the Insurance Company seeking
reduction of compensation awarded at Rs.28,45,000/- along with interest at
9% by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, North District, Rohini Courts,
Delhi (‘MACT/Tribunal’) vide impugned award dated 16th May 2015.
2.
The accident occurred on 4th July 2008 at 80 Foota Road near Kasturi
Ram School, Narela when Anil Kumar (hereinafter, ‘deceased’), riding on a
motorcycle as a pillion rider with his colleague, Sompal, was hit by a truck
bearing no. HR-42D-0411 (hereinafter, ‘offending vehicle’). Due to the
accident, both of them fell down on road and suffered grievous injuries and
were taken to M.B. Hospital, where Anil Kumar was declared as ‘brought
dead’.
MAC.APP. 635/2015
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
3.
Mr. Pradeep Gaur, counsel for Insurance Company, has challenged
the impugned award on three counts; first, that notional income has been
wrongly calculated at Rs.10,000/-, since no proof was placed with respect to
the deceased’s employment ; second, future prospects have been wrongly
awarded at 50% and ought to have been 40%, considering that the deceased
was 29 years of age on the date of the accident and was working in a private
job after applying the principles enunciated in National Insurance Co. Ltd.
v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680 and; third, an amount of Rs.1,00,000/has been awarded towards love and affection, in view of United India
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur, (2021) 11 SCC 780, which needs to
be aligned.
4.
As regards notional income, MACT relied upon the salary slip dated
15th September 2008 provided by the employer, which showed that the
deceased was drawing monthly salary of Rs.10,000/- and was working as a
Sales Executive with M/s Oyster International. Mr. Pramod Jain, proprietor
of M/s Oyster International tendered his evidence as PW-3 and in the cross
examination, he stated that did not have any other documentation to
substantiate the salary slip. Income Tax Return (‘ITR’) of M/s Oyster
International was tendered as Ex.PW3/R1 to which, Mr. Gaur pointed out
that the entry of wages paid does not synchronise with the kind of salary
mentioned for the deceased.
5.
Perusal of the testimony of PW-3 would show that he had voluntarily
said that he had only employed one person in his firm who used to do all
chores of his business, including repairing and sales. An additional worker
had been employed one and a half months prior to the date of the accident.
It was further stated in the testimony that due to the small size of the firm
MAC.APP. 635/2015
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
there was no formal documentation and no records of salary had been
maintained which was paid in cash. It was also stated in the salary slip that
the deceased had been working for the last five years.
6.
In the opinion of this Court, MACT was not amiss in considering the
testimony of PW-3 as credible and holding that the notional income was
Rs.10,000/- for calculating loss of dependency.
7.
Mr. Gaur, counsel for Insurance Company, pointed out that MACT
had also taken note of minimum wages of skilled labour applicable in 2008
when the accident took place, which were in the range of Rs.4,000/- to
Rs.7,000/-, therefore, Rs.10,000/- was an exaggerated amount.
8.
Reliance may be placed upon decision of this Court in Savita & Ors.
v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., 2026:DHC:3626 where the Court noted
scenarios where there is no documentary proof of income in an informal
sector and oral testimony of family members has been provided, therefore,
some amount of guesswork can be done and the Courts should not be
constrained to consider wages from the lowest tier. Relevant paragraphs of
the decision are extracted as under:
“Guideposts
30. Principles which may be culled out from these cases
cited above, and be used as guidepost for assessment of
benchmark income, can be summarised as under:
A. Lack of documentary proof
i. In the informal sector, it may not always be
possible to produce documentary proof of
employment and payment of wages, which are
usually paid in cash.
ii. Where there is lack of documentary proof to
support that the victim was working in Delhi,
reliance may be placed on facts and circumstances
MAC.APP. 635/2015
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
of the case to determine whether, the victim was
residing in Delhi on the date of accident, in
conjunction with documents such as driver’s
license, voter ID card, etc. Minimum wages of
place of work will be then considered.
iii. If documentary proof has not been filed, the
Court can use the minimum wage benchmark of an
appropriate category i.e., unskilled, skilled,
matriculate, etc., as a benchmark for assessment,
but not be constrained to grant the lowest tier.
B. Oral testimony of family members, employers
i. Assessment of income can also be done on the
statement of the immediate legal heir of deceased,
i.e., wife, father, or immediate family member,
along with a statement of the employer, if any.
Testimonies of the above-mentioned persons
should be consistent and there should be an
unsuccessful rebuttal by the Insurance Company
or the contesting party.
ii. If the testimonies are not reliable, the Court can
use the minimum wage benchmark of an
appropriate category i.e., unskilled, skilled,
matriculate, etc., as a benchmark for assessment,
but not be constrained to grant the lowest tier.
C. Proof of employment
i. If documents in support of employment inter alia,
Salary/Wage Certificate, Income Tax Returns
(‘ITRs’) have been filed, same shall be considered.
ii. In the absence of such proof, assessment done
by the Court has to be based on some intelligent
guesswork and may not be restricted to the
minimum wage parameter after taking into
account a holistic analysis of the evidence on
record. For example, place of employment,
testimony of co-workers, or any other person who
testifies in favour of the injured/deceased
employee.
iii. The entire assessment is ultimately imbued with
an element of approximation and guesswork, as
MAC.APP. 635/2015
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
part of the inquiry proceedings and not on
exactitude….”
(emphasis added)
In these circumstances, the Court is not inclined to displace the
9.
benchmark income which has been taken at Rs.10,000/-, though grant
towards future prospects will have to be aligned at 40%, in view of the
principles enunciated in Pranay Sethi (supra) considering it was private job
and not a permanent employment.
10.
The amount of Rs.1,00,000/- awarded towards love and affection shall
be deleted, since it has been subsumed under the head of loss of consortium
as discussed by the Supreme Court in Satinder Kaur (supra).
11.
Other alignments towards funeral expenses and loss of estate each will
be granted at Rs.15,000/- and loss of consortium will be granted at
Rs.2,00,000/- (40,000 × 5 dependents) in view of the principles enunciated
in Pranay Sethi (supra).
12.
Accordingly, revised compensation is as under:
Heads
S.
No.
Awarded by the
Tribunal
Awarded by this
Court
Income of deceased (A)
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 10,000/-
Add: Future Prospects (B)
Rs. 5,000/-
Rs. 4,000/-
Less: Personal expenses of
deceased (C)
Rs. 3,750/-
Rs. 3,500/-
Loss of dependency (A+B)-C=D Rs. 11,250/-
Rs. 10,500/-
Annual loss of dependency (D x
12)= (E)
Multiplier (F)
Rs. 1,35,000/-
Rs. 1,26,000/-
MAC.APP. 635/2015
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
Total loss of dependency (E x
F)= (G)
Compensation for loss of
consortium (H)
Rs. 22,95,000/-
Rs. 21,42,000/-
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 2,00,000/-
Loss of love and affection (I)
Rs. 5,00,000/-
Nil
Compensation for loss of estate
(J)
Compensation towards funeral
expenses (K)
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 30,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Total compensation
(G+H+I+J=K)= L
Rate of Interest Awarded
Rs. 28,45,000/-
Rs. 23,72,000/-
9%
9%
Directions
13.
Accordingly, compensation has been reduced by Rs. 4,73,000/-
[‘reduced compensation’]
14.
By order dated 07th August 2015, this Court directed the Insurance
Company to deposit the entire amount of compensation with the Registrar
General of this Court and further directed release of 50% amount to
claimants in terms of the directions of MACT in the impugned award.
15.
Considering that compensation has been reduced, it is directed that the
excess compensation (original compensation – reduced compensation),
along with accrued interest, be refunded to Insurance Company. Balance
amount, along with accrued interest, be released to claimants as lump sum
considering the appeal is of 2015 and the accident is of 2008. This will be as
per the apportionment directed by the MACT.
16.
Appeal is disposed of in the above terms.
17.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
MAC.APP. 635/2015
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
18.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the Bank for information and
compliance.
19.
Statutory deposit, if any, shall be refunded to Insurance Company,
only if the order of deposit has been complied with.
20.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
JULY 24, 2026/ak/sp
MAC.APP. 635/2015
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:27:35
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review