Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 05.12.2025
Pronounced on: 29.01.2026
Uploaded on: 29.01.2026
+
MAC.APP. 999/2013
ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO LTD
..... Appellant
Through: Mr. Pradeep Gaur, Mr. Amit Gaur,
Ms. Sweta Sinha, Advocates.
versus
SMT PRINCY MISRA & ORS
..... Respondents
Through: Mr. Manish Maini, Ms. Aastha
Chauhan, Ms. Anjali Singh and
Mr. R.K. Jain, Advocates for R-1
to 3.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PRATEEK JALAN
JUDGMENT
1.
The appellant – Oriental Insurance Company Limited [“Insurance
Company”] challenges an award dated 21.09.2013, passed by the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal [“the Tribunal”] in MACT No. 205/2011. By
the said award, the Tribunal granted compensation at Rs. 69,48,600/-,
alongwith interest at the rate of 9% per annum.
A. FACTS AND IMPUGNED AWARD
2.
The proceedings before the Tribunal arose from a fatal accident,
which took place on 10.03.2011 at about 8:30 PM, resulting in the death
of one Mr. Naveen Kumar Misra. The deceased was riding his
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
motorcycle [bearing No. DL-9S-V-8687], when a tanker [bearing
registration No. 1G-B-3778] [“the insured vehicle”] struck him from
behind, causing him to fall. He was subsequently run over by the insured
vehicle. He was taken to Bhagwan Mahavir Hospital, where he was
declared brought dead.
3.
An FIR was lodged against the driver of the insured vehicle,
bearing FIR No. 100/2011 in Police Station Mangol Puri, under Sections
279 and 304A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. A chargesheet has also
been filed in the criminal proceedings under Section 173 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973.
4.
The deceased was 32 years old at the time of the accident, and is
survived by his wife, two children, and parents [respondent Nos. 1 to 5
herein]. In addition to the Insurance Company, the driver and owner of
the insured vehicle [respondent Nos. 6 and 7 herein] were arrayed as
respondents before the Tribunal.
5.
Upon submission of a Detailed Accident Report [“DAR”], the
Tribunal returned a finding of rash and negligent driving against the
driver of the insured vehicle, and assessed compensation payable to the
claimants at Rs. 69,48,600/-, alongwith interest at the rate of 9% per
annum, under the following heads:
S.No. Heads
Award
Pecuniary Damages
1.
Loss of dependency
Rs. 66,63,600/-
2.
Funeral charges
Rs. 25,000/-
3.
Loss of estate
Rs. 10,000/-
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
4.
Loss of consortium
Rs. 1,00,000/-
Non-Pecuniary Damages
5.
Loss of love, company and Rs. 1,00,000/affection
6.
6.
Loss of gratuitous services
Rs. 50,000/-
TOTAL
Rs. 69,48,600/-
The Insurance Company is in appeal. The claimants, as well as the
driver and owner of the insured vehicle have been impleaded as
respondent Nos. 1 to 7 respectively in this appeal. During the pendency of
the appeal, respondent Nos. 4 and 5 herein [parents of the deceased]
passed away, and were accordingly deleted from the array of parties vide
order dated 28.08.2024.
7.
The appeal is limited to the question of quantum of compensation.
B. SUBMISSIONS BY THE LEARNED COUNSEL FOR PARTIES
8.
I have heard Mr. Pradeep Gaur, learned counsel for the Insurance
Company, and Mr. Manish Maini, learned counsel for the claimants.
9.
Mr. Gaur challenged the impugned award on the following
grounds:
A. The Tribunal erred in assessing loss of dependency by taking the
monthly income as reflected in the last salary slip of the deceased.
Mr. Gaur submitted that the deceased had a variable income and
had been in employment for only about five months. He, therefore,
contended that an average of all his salary slips ought to have been
taken. He further submitted that the Tribunal ought to have
excluded allowances and tax liability, which did not form part of
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
the deceased's income.
B. The Tribunal deducted only 25% of the income towards personal
and living expenses of the deceased. He submitted that, having
regard to the fact that the mother of the deceased was receiving
rental income and had an independent source of livelihood
sufficient for her sustenance, a higher deduction towards personal
expenses was warranted.
C. The Tribunal erred in awarding future prospects at 50%, which is
contrary to the judgment of the Constitution Bench in National
Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi & Ors.1. He submitted
that future prospects ought to have been taken at 40%.
D. The Tribunal granted interest on the component of future income
from the date of filing of the DAR, whereas it ought to have been
confined to the post-award period only.
E. The amounts awarded under the non-pecuniary heads require
adjustment, so as to bring them in conformity with the principles
laid down in Pranay Sethi.
10.
Mr. Maini, on the other hand, submitted as follows:
A. The deceased’s income was variable as it was contingent upon field
incentives. He further submitted that the Tribunal correctly
refrained from deducting allowances and tax liability, since the
allowances constituted a part of the deceased’s salary, and no tax
liability arose as the said salary was not taxable.
B. The deceased’s mother has rightly been treated as a dependent, as
the rental income cannot be regarded as an independent source of
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
income and, in fact, formed part of the deceased’s service-related
entitlements.
C. As the deceased was a permanent employee, the Tribunal was
justified in awarding 50% towards future prospects.
D. The issue concerning grant of interest on future income is no
longer res integra, as the Supreme Court in Oriental Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Niru @ Niharika & Ors.2, dismissed the aforesaid argument,
and granted interest on the entire awarded amount.
E. Mr. Maini was agreeable to certain adjustments under nonpecuniary heads, in conformity with the principles laid down in
Pranay Sethi.
11.
Each of the aforesaid aspects are taken up in turn.
C. LOSS OF DEPENDENCY
i) QUANTUM OF INCOME
12.
The deceased was working as a Regional Manager at M/S Fullerton
India Credit Company Limited, which was established in evidence by a
representative of the employer – Mr. Rajiv Verma [PW3]3. He exhibited
the appointment letter dated 28.09.2010, and salary slips of the deceased
[PW3/1].
13.
A perusal of the appointment letter dated 28.09.2010 shows that
the deceased’s remuneration structure comprised both fixed and variable
components. The fixed component included a base salary of Rs.
1,02,000/- per annum and a personal allowance of Rs. 97,560/- per
(2017) 16 SCC 680 [hereinafter, “Pranay Sethi”].
2025 SCC OnLine 1431 [hereinafter, “Niru”].
As recorded by the Tribunal in paragraph 11 of the impugned award, the employer’s representative
has been incorrectly marked as PW-3, but in fact should be read as PW-2.
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
annum, in addition to transport allowance and housing allowance of Rs.
45,000/- per annum, applicable to Delhi and NCR. The appointment letter
further contemplated performance and profitability linked pay, contingent
upon achievement of specified parameters, which was to become
applicable only after completion of six months of service. Significantly,
the deceased was placed on probation for the initial six months.
14.
The salaries drawn by the deceased from October 2010 to March
2011 are tabulated as follows:
Head of
Payment
October
20104
November
December
January
February
March
20115
Basic
Rs. 5,758/-
Rs. 8,500/-
Rs. 8,500/-
Rs. 8,500/-
Rs. 8,500/-
Rs. 2,742/-
House Rent
Allowance
Rs. 2,540/-
Rs. 3,750/-
Rs. 3,750/-
Rs. 3,750/-
Rs. 3,750/-
Rs. 1,210/-
Personal
Allowance
Rs. 5,507/-
Rs. 8,130/-
Rs. 8,130/-
Rs. 8,130/-
Rs. 8,130/-
Rs. 2,623/-
Conveyance
Allowance
Rs. 542/-
Rs. 800/-
Rs. 800/-
Rs. 800/-
Rs. 800/-
Rs. 258/-
Field Incentive
Payout
N/A
Rs. 6,334/-
Rs. 14,220/-
Rs. 6,232/-
Rs. 9,365/-
Rs. 10,869/-
Field Incentive
Payout Sales
Support Staff
N/A
N/A
Rs. 150/-
Rs. 200/-
Rs. 400/-
Rs. 750/-
TOTAL
Rs.14,347/-
Rs.27,514/-
Rs.35,550/-
Rs.27,612/-
Rs.30,945/-
Rs.18,452/-
15.
The Tribunal fixed the monthly income at Rs. 30,850/-, which was
the deceased’s salary for the month preceding the accident, after
deducting a nominal amount towards mobile recovery.
16.
The evidence shows that the deceased joined the services of the
The petitioner joined only on 11.10.2010.
The petitioner worked until the date of accident, i.e. 10.03.2011.
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
employer on 11.10.2010 and passed away on 10.03.2011, having
rendered services for a period of approximately five months. The salaries
drawn during this period varied considerably on account of field incentive
payouts, indicating that his income was neither uniform nor static.
Further, the remuneration structure itself, as reflected from the
appointment letter providing for Performance & Profitability Linked Pay
reinforces that the nature of employment contemplated variable,
performance-linked earnings, rather than a fixed or static salary. It is also
evident that, during this entire period, the deceased was still within the
probationary tenure prescribed by the appointment letter. In such
circumstances, reliance on a single month’s salary, particularly where
earnings are performance-linked and the employment itself was of short
duration, would not yield a fair or realistic assessment of earning
capacity.
17.
Having regard to the probationary status of the deceased, the short
span of service, and the variable nature of remuneration reflected in the
salary slips, I am of the view that it would be more appropriate to assess
income on the basis of an average of the last three complete months
immediately preceding the accident, i.e. December 2010 till February
2011, which would represent a more balanced and reasonable estimate of
the deceased’s earning capacity. The average monthly income for this
period works out to Rs.31,369/-.
ii) DEDUCTION ON ACCOUNT OF ALLOWANCE AND TAXES.
18.
The next issue that arises for consideration is whether any part of
the income so assessed is liable to be excluded on account of allowances
and taxes.
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
19.
Mr. Gaur submitted that personal expenses of Rs. 8,130/-, and
conveyance allowance of Rs. 800/- per month, as reflected in the salary
slips, ought to have been deducted from the emoluments for the purposes
of loss of dependency.
20.
In Kavita Devi & Ors. v. Sunil Kumar & Anr.6, the Supreme Court
considered the question of deductibility of allowances, as follows:
“17. This Court has consistently held in case of the allowances which
are included in the component of salary of the deceased, Tribunal has
to take into consideration these allowances as they were used for
supporting the family. The claimants have to show that these
allowances were regularly received and used for the family's benefit.
Further, while determining whether the allowances form a part of
the salary or not, the Tribunal by looking into the facts of each case
and by considering the extent of dependency of the claimants on the
salary of the deceased including the allowances, have to determine
whether these allowances should be excluded from determination of
the income of the deceased. If the answer of the Tribunal is in
affirmative, then the allowances may be excluded for determination of
loss of dependency. If the Tribunal answers the above point in
negative, then the Tribunal has to include the allowances for
computation of income of the deceased, thus determining the loss of
dependency.
18. Applying the above principle to the case on hand, it can be seen
that it is the consistent plea of the claimant that the deceased was
earning Rs. 6,500/- and the same is evidenced by producing Ex. P6.
No contrary evidence is produced by the Respondents to dispute the
fact that the allowances which is about 50% of the salary of the
deceased should be excluded from determination of the actual
income. Further, it can be seen that after the accident, the entire
burden of taking care of two minor children and herself fell on
Appellant No. 1. Therefore in view of the changing economic situation
of the family after the death of the deceased, we are of the opinion that
income which the deceased was earning at the time of the accident was
Rs. 6,500/- p.m and same ought to have been taken into
consideration.”7
The aforesaid principle was also recently followed by this Court in
(2025) SCC OnLine SC 1639 [hereinafter, “Kavita Devi”].
Emphasis supplied.
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
Shriram General Insurance Company limited v. Surila & Ors.8.
21.
The question whether a particular allowance is liable to be
excluded while computing loss of dependency is, therefore, no longer res
integra, and must be determined on the facts of each case.
22.
In the present case, the evidence regarding the salary structure of
the deceased has been led both through the employer’s representative,
and the wife of the deceased. The wife of the deceased categorically
deposed that the deceased was drawing a monthly salary alongwith
allowances and that she, her children, and parents of the deceased were
fully dependent on his income. This testimony remained unchallenged in
cross-examination by learned counsel for the Insurance Company. The
position is further fortified by the cross-examination of the employer’s
representative, who clearly stated that the personal allowance and other
allowances formed a part of the salary. He further denied the suggestion
that the allowances would not go to the family.
23.
The aforesaid evidence, therefore, does not cast any serious doubt
on the quantum of salary as reflected in the salary slips. No testimony has
been elicited, either from the wife of the deceased or from the employer’s
representative, to contradict or undermine the said components. The
argument of the Insurance Company with regard to deduction of
allowances is, therefore, rejected.
24.
Turning next to Mr. Gaur’s argument concerning deduction of tax
liability, on this question, the Tribunal held as follows:
“One of the contentions before the Tribunal is at what stage the income
tax is to be deducted whether from the income which is taken to be the
MAC.APP. 173/2014, decided on 03.12.2025.
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
monthly income before adding future prospects or after adding the future
prospects if any. It is his case that as per the judgment of Shyamwati Vs.
Karan Singh reported in 2010 VII AD (SC) 309 cited at bar of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India wherein it was held that income tax if
any it will be deducted from the net income of the deceased and thereafter
50% from the relevant percentage is to be added. It is submitted by
counsel for the insurance company that as per the calculation in
Shyamwati's case, Hon'ble Supreme Court adjudicated the income tax
after adding the amount of relevant percentage on account of future
increment then the tax is deducted. In the present case no deducted tax has
been shown to have been deducted from the salary of the deceased, so the
issue became irrelevant there is no other evidence except the income tax
return filed after the death of the deceased which cannot be looked into for
the purpose of showing whether any income tax was paid or not. The
witness from the employer of the deceased has specifically stated perhaps
according to his estimate it was a non-taxable salary. His salary was not
enough hence no tax was deducted a source.”
25.
The Tribunal proceeded on the premise that no income tax was
deductible, primarily on the ground that no tax deduction at source was
reflected in the salary slips of the deceased, as well as the testimony of
the employer’s representative, stating that the salary was non-taxable, and
the fact that the income tax return had been filed after the death of the
deceased. In my view, this approach is erroneous and not borne out by the
evidence on record.
26.
The affidavit of evidence of the wife of the deceased, read with the
documentary evidence, clearly establishes that during the relevant
assessment year 2011–12, the deceased had income from two separate
employments. Form-16 issued by the previous employer, M/s D.D.
Industries Ltd., reflected a gross income of Rs. 98,014/-, while Form-16
issued by the current employer M/s Fullerton India Credit Company Ltd.
reflected a gross income of Rs. 1,54,420/-. Both documents were placed
on record as "Mark B". On the basis of the consolidated income from
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
these two employments, the deceased filed his Income Tax Return
[“ITR”] for assessment year 2011–12 [Ex. PW-3/4], which discloses a
total income of Rs. 1,73,458/- after permissible deductions, and a tax
liability of Rs. 1,386/-.
27.
At the outset, it may be noted that the documents placed on record
as “Mark B” are liable to be considered, having regard to the settled
position that the strict rules of pleadings and evidence do not apply to
claim cases. Further, the fact that the ITR was filed after the death of the
deceased also does not render it irrelevant, particularly when it pertains to
the same assessment year, is supported by Form-16s issued by both
employers, and quantifies the actual liability. The ITR, in the present
case, is not being relied upon to inflate income, but only to ascertain the
actual tax payable on income, which is corroborated through independent
employer records.
28.
While it is true that no tax may have been deducted at source
during the period the deceased was employed with Fullerton, the
evidence shows that, upon addition of income from both employments
during the financial year, a tax liability did in fact arise. Accordingly,
while computing the annual income of the deceased for the purpose of
loss of dependency, a deduction of Rs. 1,386/- towards income tax
liability is warranted.
29.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the annual income of the
deceased is calculated at Rs. 3,75,042/- [(Rs. 31,369/- x 12)-Rs. 1,386/-].
iii) DEDUCTION TOWARDS PERSONAL AND LIVING EXPENSES
30.
The next issue which arises for consideration concerns the
appropriate deduction towards personal and living expenses of the
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
deceased. The deceased was survived by his wife, two children, and
parents, all of whom were treated as dependants by the Tribunal.
31.
Mr. Gaur contended that the Tribunal erred in treating the mother
of the deceased as a dependent in view of her independent rental income.
The Tribunal dealt with the said argument as follows:
“13. As per the petition, the deceased was married and he left behind his
widow, two minor children, mother and father, as held above father is
normally not taken to be financially dependent upon his deceased son in
the normal course of nature. It is submitted by the counsel for insurance
company that as per the record submitted by the LRs of deceased, the
mother of deceased was having income as she had let out the house to her
deceased son and was getting Rs. 8000/- per month on account of house
rent. Since the deceased has left heavenly abode and there is no proof of
income thereafter. Even if it is taken that Rs. 8000/- per month rental
income which the mother of deceased was getting from her son is
continuing, it cannot be said that she was not financially dependent
because Rs. 8000/- in today’s circumstances is too low a sum for
maintaining the house hold expenses and other things connected with the
same and keep the body and soul together. Hence there are four
dependents upon the deceased at the time of his death.”9
32.
As far as this aspect is concerned, the evidence by the wife of the
deceased, and representative of the deceased’s employer are relevant. As
noted above, the wife of the deceased in her affidavit of evidence stated
that she, the children, and the parents of the deceased were fully
dependent on his income. She also stated that the deceased was paying
house rent at Rs. 6,000/- per month in order to reduce his tax liability.
She was cross-examined by learned counsel for the Insurance Company,
where she stated as follows:
“Q. Besides the deceased husband your father and mother in law are
having how many children?
Objected to not relevant to the controversy in question. Matter in issue.
Emphasis supplied.
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
Objection sustained for the reasons mentioned.
My father in law had not been doing any work to maintain himself.
Court question – His expenses were being met by both brothers i.e. my
husband and my jeth namely, Anup Kumar Mishra.
Mr. Anup Kumar Mishra, my jeth is an accountant but I do not
know how much he earns. I do not know the house in which we are staying
along with my mother in law and father in law in the name of whom.
Q – I put it to you that house in which the entire family including your
mother and father in law staying is in the name of Kamlesh Mishra and
she is having rental income.
Ist part of suggestion is disallowed as the witness is already stated
that she does not know in whose name the houses, Reply to second part of
suggestion my mother in law is not having any rental income,
It is wrong to suggest that petitioner no. 4 and 5 were not
financially dependent upon the income of my deceased husband at the time
of the accident.
It is wrong to suggest that I am deposing falsely.”
33.
The evidence on record indicates that the rental payment was being
made by the deceased himself to his mother and was linked to the
conditions of his employment. The wife of the deceased, in her affidavit
of evidence, specifically deposed that the deceased was paying house rent
of Rs. 6,000/- per month in order to reduce his tax liability. This assertion
was not challenged in her cross-examination. Significantly, she was not
confronted on the purpose or nature of the rental arrangement, and she
categorically denied the suggestion that her mother-in-law had any
independent rental income. The only line of cross-examination pursued
was with respect to her knowledge of ownership of the house, which she
stated she did not know. The testimony of the wife of the deceased clearly
established that she, her children and the parents of the deceased were
financially dependent upon him at the time of the accident. This assertion
was reiterated during her cross-examination, and the suggestion that the
parents were not dependent was categorically denied.
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
34.
This evidence is further strengthened by the testimony of the
employer’s representative, who stated that such tenancy arrangements are
permissible to enable employees to avail allowances and tax benefits.
Viewed thus, the payment of house rent by the deceased to his mother,
was simply a service-related arrangement, and cannot be equated with an
independent source of income so as to negate the mother's financial
dependency on the deceased.
35.
In view of the above discussion, the Tribunal was justified in
treating the mother of the deceased as a dependent. The deduction of
25%, applied by the Tribunal towards personal and living expenses, is
applicable in cases where the deceased is a married person with four to
six dependants. For the reasons aforesaid, this deduction is upheld.
iv) FUTURE PROSPECTS
36.
On the question of future prospects, the judgment in Pranay Sethi
states as follows:
“59.3 While determining the income, an addition of 50% of
actual salary to the income of the deceased towards future
prospects, where the deceased had a permanent job and was
below the age of 40 years, should be made. The addition should
be 30%, if the age of the deceased was between 40 to 50 years.
In case the deceased was between the age of 50 to 60 years, the
addition should be 15%. Actual salary should be read as actual
salary less tax.
59.4 In case the deceased was self-employed or on a fixed
salary, an addition of 40% of the established income should be
the warrant where the deceased was below the age of 40 years.
An addition of 25% where the deceased was between the age of
40 to 50 years and 10% where the deceased was between the
age of 50 to 60 years should be regarded as the necessary
method of computation. The established income means the
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
income minus the tax component.”10
37.
The deceased was admittedly less than 40 years of age. The
question is, therefore, whether his case will fall within paragraph 59.3 or
59.4 of Pranay Sethi.
38.
Mr. Gaur submitted that the deceased could not be regarded as
having a permanent job within the meaning of paragraph 59.3 of Pranay
Sethi, as he was still undergoing probation at the time of the accident, and
had not been confirmed in service. It was contended that the deceased’s
appointment was expressly subject to satisfactory completion of the
probationary period and performance review.
39.
I find merit in this submission of Mr. Gaur. The appointment letter
unequivocally stipulates that the deceased was on probation for the first
six months of service, and that permanent placement was contingent upon
satisfactory completion of the probationary period and fulfilment of other
conditions. It is undisputed that the deceased had rendered service for
only about five months at the time of his death and had not yet been
confirmed. In these circumstances, the deceased cannot be treated as a
permanent employee for the purposes of assessing future prospects under
paragraph 59.3 of Pranay Sethi.
40.
Mr. Maini placed reliance on the judgment of the Supreme Court in
K. Anusha v. Regional Manager11, wherein the addition towards future
prospects was enhanced to 50%, relying on Pranay Sethi, in respect of a
deceased aged 32 years, who was employed as a Senior Design Engineer.
However, the said decision, in my view, does not support the case of the
Emphasis supplied.
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
claimants, as the judgment does did not consider the issue of probationary
status.
41.
Having regard to the above, the case would fall within paragraph
59.4 of Pranay Sethi. Consequently, an addition of 40% towards future
prospects is warranted.
v) COMPUTATION OF LOSS OF DEPENDENCY
42.
There is no dispute with regard to the applicability of a multiplier
of 16. However, in view of the modifications hereinabove with respect to
the quantum of income and the addition towards future prospects, the loss
of dependency requires to be re-computed as follows:
S.No. Heads
Amount
1.
Annual income of the deceased [A]
Rs. 3,75,042/-
2.
ADD: future prospects [40% of A = B]
Rs. 1,50,016.8/-
3.
Income of the deceased (including future Rs. 5,25,058.8/prospects)
[A+B = C]
4.
MINUS: personal expenses [25%] [D]
Rs. 1,31,264.7/-
5.
Annual loss of dependency
Rs. 3,93,794.1/-
[C – D = E]
6.
Multiplier [F]
Total loss of dependency [E x F]
Rs.63,00,705.6/[Rs.
63,00,706/-
approx.]
2021 SCC OnLine SC 3339.
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
43.
Loss of dependency is, therefore, reduced from Rs. 66,63,600/- to
Rs. 63,00,706/-.
D. FUNERAL CHARGES AND LOSS OF ESTATE:
44.
The judgment in Pranay Sethi12 stipulates compensation for funeral
charges and loss of estate of Rs.15,000/- each. The award is accordingly
modified, and the compensation for funeral charges and loss of estate are
awarded at Rs.15,000/- each, instead of Rs.25,000/- and Rs. 10,000/-,
respectively.
E. LOSS OF CONSORTIUM:
45.
The judgment in Pranay Sethi provides for loss of consortium of
Rs.40,000/-. Furthermore, it is clear from the judgments in Magma
General Insurance Company Limited v. Nanu Ram Alias Chuhru Ram
and Ors.13 and United India Insurance Company Limited v. Satinder
Kaur alias Satwinder Kaur & Ors.14, that loss of consortium is payable
under three distinct heads: loss of spousal consortium, loss of parental
consortium, and loss of filial consortium, to the spouse, children, and
parents of the deceased, respectively. The judgment of the Supreme Court
in National India Assurance Company Limited v. Somwati15 is authority
for the proposition that loss of consortium is to be separately awarded to
each entitled claimant.
46.
In the present case, there were five claimants, who all fall within
these categories being the wife, two children, and parents of the deceased.
The award on this account is, therefore, enhanced to Rs. 2,00,000/-.
Paragraph 52.
(2018) 18 SCC 130.
(2021) 11 SCC 780 [hereinafter, “Satinder Kaur”].
(2020) 9 SCC 644.
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
F. LOSS OF LOVE AND AFFECTION AND GRATUITOUS SERVICES:
47.
Compensation for loss of love and affection and loss of gratuitous
services has been awarded by the Tribunal at Rs.1,00,000/- and Rs.
50,000/- respectively. The Supreme Court, in Satinder Kaur16, has made
it clear that no amount is to be awarded on these heads separately. The
award on this account is, therefore, deleted.
G. INTEREST
48.
The only issue left for consideration is whether interest on future
income needs to confined only to the post-award period.
49.
Mr. Gaur submitted that the amount awarded towards future
prospects represents a notional enhancement of income and does not
constitute earnings as on the date of the accident. It was contended that
since such income is only an estimation of future earnings, interest
thereon ought to run only from the date of the award. In support of this
submission, reliance was placed on the judgment of the Supreme Court in
R.D. Hattangadi v. Pest Control (India) (P) Ltd.17, and of this Court in
Arvind Pathak v. Parshant Kumar18.
50.
Mr. Maini, however, drew my attention to a recent judgment of the
Supreme Court in Niru, in which the Court held as follows:
“9. A very relevant issue agitated by the Insurance Company is the
illegality in awarding interest for future prospects, which in any event is
an amount received in advance, normally inuring to the benefit of the
claimants only in future. This is the only contention taken in the connected
appeal bearing SLP(C) No. 22136 of 2024. We find absolutely no reason
to accept this argument. In SLP(C) No. 11340 of 2020, the multiplier
applied looking at the life span of the deceased and the claimants is 13.
Before the Tribunal itself, the case was pending for 12 years and the only
Paragraphs 34 and 35.
(1995) 1 SCC 551 [hereinafter, “ R.D. Hattangadi”].
2016 SCC OnLine Del 2675 [hereinafter, “ Arvind Pathak”].
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
amount received by the claimants was Rs. 50,000/-. Hence though
amounts are awarded for future prospects taking the multiplier of 13; in
effect, the money is received only after the period for which the multiplier
is adopted. Similar is the case in SLP(C) No. 22136 of 2024 where the
accident occurred in 2018, the multiplier applied is 17 and we are seven
years from the date of accident.
10. We cannot but observe that there was nothing stopping the Insurance
Company from settling the claim on a computation, on receipt of
intimation of the accident, especially since the determination of
compensation for loss of dependency, on death being occasioned in a
motor vehicle accident, can be determined as evident from the judicial
precedents; at least provisionally.
11. In fact, it is due to the repudiation of or refusal to consider the claim
that the claimants are driven to the Tribunal. When the matter is pending
before the Tribunal or in appeal before the higher forums, the claimants
are deprived of the compensation for future prospects. If they are paid in
time, it could be utilized by the claimants and on failure, the loss of
dependency would force the claimants to source their livelihood from
elsewhere. This is sought to be compensated at least minimally by award
of interest, which oftener them ever is nominal also since only simple
interest is awarded. If the amounts were disbursed to the claimants on a
rough calculation, on intimation of the accident to the Insurance
Company, subject to the award of the Tribunal, necessarily there would
not have been any interest liability atleast to the extent of the
disbursement made. Hence, we reject the contention and direct that the
entire award amounts would be paid with interest at the rate of 9% from
the date of filing of the claim till the date of disbursement, deducting only
Rs. 50,000/- granted as interim compensation, in SLP(C) No. 11340 of
2020 and 6% in SLP(C) No. 22136 of 2024 as awarded by the High
Court; deduction to be made for the amounts already paid.”
51.
I am of the view that the judgment in Niru is more apposite to
the facts of the present case. The present matter also arises out of a
fatal motor vehicle accident and concerns compensation for loss of
dependency, where the multiplier method is applied. In contrast, the
decisions in R.D. Hattangadi and Arvind Pathak were rendered in
the context of injury cases, and in any event stand on a different
footing.
52.
In light of the aforesaid, I find no merit in the contention that
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
interest on future prospects ought to be restricted to the post-award
period. Accordingly, interest on the entire awarded amount shall be
payable at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of institution of
the DAR till the date of disbursement.
H. RE-COMPUTATION OF AWARD
53.
As a result of the above discussion, the award of the Tribunal is
modified to the following extent:
Heads
Sr.
No.
1. Loss
of
dependency
2. Funeral
Charges
3. Loss
of
Estate
4. Loss
of
consortium
5. Loss
of
love
and
affection
6. Gratuitous
Services
TOTAL
Awarded by
the Tribunal
Rs. 66,63,600/-
Awarded by
Difference
the Court
Rs.63,00,706/- (-) Rs. 3,62,894/-
Rs. 25,000/-
Rs.15,000/-
(-) Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
(+) Rs. 5,000/-
Rs. 1,00,000/-
Rs.2,00,000/-
(+)Rs. 1,00,000/-
Rs. 1,00,000/-
DELETED
(-) Rs. 1,00,000/-
Rs. 50,000/-
DELETED
(-) Rs. 50,000/-
Rs. 69,48,600/-
Rs.65,30,706/- (-)Rs. 4,17,894/-
I. CONCLUSION
54.
The Tribunal’s award, therefore, stands reduced by Rs. 4,17,894/-,
i.e. from Rs. 69,48,600/- to Rs. 65,30,706/-.
55.
By order dated 01.11.2013, 80% of the awarded amount, alongwith
up-to-date interest, was directed to be deposited with the Registrar
General of the Court, as a condition for stay of the award. Upon such
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
deposit, 40% of the award was directed to be released in accordance with
the directions of the Tribunal. The remaining amount was to be kept in
fixed deposits.
56.
As far as disbursement of the amount is concerned, the Tribunal
granted fixed sum of Rs. 15,00,000/- each to the minor son and minor
daughter of the deceased for the period till the son attains majority and
the daughter attains the age of 21 or the date of her marriage, whichever
is earlier.
The Tribunal further granted Rs. 10,00,000/- and Rs.
5,00,000/- to the mother and father of the deceased in the form of fixed
deposits for a period of five years each. Lastly, the Tribunal granted a
nominal amount be released to the wife immediately, and the rest to be
kept in the form of ten equal fixed deposits to be released within a period
of ten years.
57.
I am informed that the children of the deceased have not yet
attained majority. It is further noted that the parents of the deceased have
since passed away, as recorded in the order dated 28.08.2024, which also
records that they left behind no Class-I legal heirs other than the wife of
the deceased and his children. The maximum period of ten years for
which the fixed deposits were directed to be maintained has also since
elapsed.
58.
The Registry is directed to transmit the balance amount lying with
it to the Tribunal.
59.
The Insurance Company is directed to deposit the remaining
amount, alongwith up-to-date interest, at the rate of 9% per annum as
granted by the Tribunal, from the date of filing of the DAR, i.e.
30.05.2011, within a period of 8 weeks from today, with the Tribunal.
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
60.
Having regard to the fact that the awarded amount has been
reduced, and the parents of the deceased have since passed away, I am of
the view that the disbursement and apportionment of the remaining award
will require modification. The claimants will appear before the Tribunal
on 09.02.2026 for consideration of this issue.
61.
The appeal stands disposed of with the aforesaid directions.
62.
Statutory deposit be refunded to the Insurance Company.
PRATEEK JALAN, J
JANUARY 29, 2026
SS/‘Ainesh’/
Signed By:DAMINI
YADAV
20:35
MAC.APP. 999/2013
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review