Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC011448132013
+
MAC.APP. 864/2013
ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Pradeep Gaur, Mr. Amit Gaur and
Mr. Kaarrtikey Parashar, Advs.
versus
SMT ASAMEEN & ORS
Through: None.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
%
1.
.....Respondents
ORDER
10.08.2026
This appeal has been filed by the Insurance Company assailing
impugned award dated 09th July 2013 passed by the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi (‘MACT/Tribunal’) in MACT No.
25/2012, whereby compensation of Rs.9,11,968/- along with interest at the
rate of 7.5% per annum was awarded.
2.
The accident in question occurred on 04th January 2012, when Mr.
Hifajul Rehman (hereinafter, ‘deceased’), was travelling in a Maruti Wagon R
car from Meerut to Ghaziabad. When he reached near Masuri, Ghaziabad,
U.P. a Tata Sumo/offending vehicle hit the Maruti Wagon R car resulting in
fatal injuries to deceased. He was 36 years of age, working as a halwai and
claimed to be earning Rs.10,000/- per month. Claim was filed by his legal
representatives and compensation was awarded.
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 18/08/2026 at 11:34:18
3.
Mr. Pradeep Gaur, counsel for appellant/Insurance Company, pleads
that there was contributory negligence on behalf of deceased. FIR No.
3A/2012 was registered at the behest of respondent no.8/driver of Tata Sumo
-offending vehicle, who testified as R3W1 stating that the Maruti Wagon R
car had actually jumped over the divider and collided with the Tata
Sumo/offending vehicle.
4.
Mr. Gaur has drawn attention of this Court to two different site plans.
The one which has been filed under FIR No. 3/2012, which was registered on
behalf of the complaint made by legal representatives of deceased and the
other site plan which was prepared under FIR No. 3A/2012. The two site
plans seem to have a completely contradictory perspective, seemingly
supporting the narration of facts given by respective claimants.
5.
MACT relied upon the testimony of an eye witness, Mr. Yusuf Khan
(‘PW3’). He stated that he was travelling along with the deceased and two
other passengers in the Wagon R car. Tata Sumo/offending vehicle was being
driven on the wrong side and hit the Wagon R car, as a result of which,
multiple injuries were received by the passengers and the deceased passed
away. The cross-examination of PW3 only elicits questions posed by counsel
for appellant/Insurance Company, that it was the Wagon R car which jumped
over the divider and hit the Tata Sumo/offending vehicle. These have been
comprehensively denied by PW3 in the cross-examination.
6.
No other evidence has been brought forth by the appellant/Insurance
Company in order to support their plea that the accident occurred due to the
negligence of Maruti Wagon R car. There is no Mechanical Inspection Report
(‘MIR’) on record. It was also noted by the MACT in paragraph 12 that the
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 18/08/2026 at 11:34:18
site plan was not proved by respondent no. 8/driver of Tata Sumo-offending
vehicle, which had been placed on record. Moreover, these documents were
not put to the witness (PW3), in order that the same could have been
examined. PW3 was also not cross examined by respondent no.8/driver of
Tata Sumo/offending vehicle, who preferred to remain absent from the
proceedings after filing his written statement.
7.
Negligence is proved on the test of preponderance of probabilities and
not the criminal burden of beyond reasonable doubt. Reliance on FIRs can
only provide an extra lens to the courts but cannot be determinative,
particularly when facts and circumstances of the case suggest otherwise.
8.
Reliance may also be placed upon the decision of this Court in
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v Shehnaj Begum & Ors. 2026:DHC:13169,
where the Court traversed the law on res ipsa loquitor in motor accident
cases. It was held that the proceedings before MACT are in the nature of an
inquiry and therefore, assessment of negligence has to be conducted on the
test of preponderance of probabilities. Relevant findings are noted as under:
“Summarizing
38. From the above discussion relating to the nature of
inquiry before the Tribunal, the operation of the
doctrine of res ipsa loquitur, and the applicable
standard of proof, three aspects emerge clearly.
39. First, that the proceedings before the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal are in nature of an inquiry
and are not hemmed in by rules of procedure or
evidence. The Supreme Court in Shila Datta (supra)
[passages extracted in paragraph 20 (a) above], has
elaborated on this aspect. Essentially, a claim under
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 18/08/2026 at 11:34:18
Section 165 of the MV Act, is neither a suit nor an
adversarial lis.
40. Tribunal holds an inquiry and makes an award to
determine compensation, which ought to be just and
reasonable. The procedure to be followed is
summarised in the best discretion of the Tribunal. It has
the power under Section 169 of MV Act to summon
persons possessing special knowledge of the matters
relevant to the inquiry.
41. In Anita Sharma (supra), the Supreme Court
emphasised that fault may not be found merely because
Tribunals do not examine some of the best eyewitnesses,
as in a criminal trial, but should do their best to analyse
the material placed on record by the parties.
42. Having clearly sketched the contours of the
procedure undertaken by a Tribunal, it brings us to the
second issue, which is determination of negligence. The
nature of the accident and the basic facts surrounding
the same are presented before the Tribunal in the form
of a DAR (Detailed Accident Report), or through an
FIR, or a recording in a police diary, along with the
claim for compensation. In order to arrive at an
assessment of negligence and, therefore, consequential
liability in tort law, the principle of res ipsa loquitur,
particularly in accident cases, is often brought into
play.
43. Doctrine of res ipsa loquitur constitutes an
exception to the general rule that the burden of proving
negligence lies upon the claimant. The facts, “tell its
own story” and “speak for itself”. The fact of the
accident itself sometimes constitutes evidence of
negligence. The principal function of the maxim is to
prevent injustice, that would be caused to a plaintiff
who would otherwise be compelled to prove the precise
cause of the accident and responsibility of the
defendant, when the facts are unknown to plaintiff but
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 18/08/2026 at 11:34:18
lie only within the knowledge of defendant. The burden
then shifts to the defendant, who can, by leading
evidence, rebut the inference drawn by the Court based
on the doctrine.
…
45. Therefore, for application of the principle, it must be
shown that the offending vehicle was under the
management of the defendant and that the accident was
such that, in the ordinary course of things, it would not
have happened if those who were in management had
used proper care. Having reached a reasonable
inference based on the facts of the accident and being
presented with a defence raised by defendants that they
exercised care to avert foreseeable harm, the issue
before the Tribunal would be how to balance the two
aspects and what parameter is to be applied in
measuring this balance, or in assessing which side the
scales tilt.
46. This brings us to the third aspect, which is the test to
be applied. It is well settled that the test or the burden of
proof which applies is not that of beyond a reasonable
doubt (as in criminal cases), but on the test of
preponderance of probabilities.”
(emphasis added)
9.
Therefore, the MACT has rightly reached its conclusion on the basis of
testimony of PW3 i.e. injured eyewitness. Therefore, the Court finds no
reason to sustain the plea of appellant/Insurance Company in this regard.
10.
Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed.
11.
By order dated 25th September 2013, this Court had directed the deposit
of the entire awarded amount, along with accrued interest with the Registrar
General of this Court and release of 50% in favour of respondents/claimants
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 18/08/2026 at 11:34:18
as per the terms and conditions fixed by the Tribunal through UCO Bank,
High Court Branch.
12.
In view of the dismissal of this appeal, balance amount be released to
respondents/claimants as lump sum amount, considering that the accident
occurred in 2012 and the appeal has been pending since 2013.
13.
Statutory deposit, if any, shall be refunded to appellant/Insurance
Company, only if the order of deposit has been complied with.
14.
Order be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL, J
AUGUST 10, 2026/ak/sp
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 18/08/2026 at 11:34:18
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review