Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 24th March 2026
%
+
MAC.APP. 1041/2014
ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Pradeep Gaur, Mr. Amit Gaur
and Ms. Sweta Sinha, Advocates.
versus
RAJESH PANWAR & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. S.N. Parashar, Mr. Ritik Singh,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed by Insurance Company seeking
modification of final award dated 30th August 2014, passed by the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Shahdara District, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
[‘MACT”] in MACP No.92/2013, whereby compensation of Rs.23,55,580/along with interest @ 9% per annum was awarded.
2.
Accident occurred on 12th May 2013, where Naresh Pal Panwar
[deceased] alongwith one Ved Prakash was travelling to his native village
Paldai, Baghpat from his house at Sahibabad. When deceased reached near
Ladhwadi More, Baghpat, a truck bearing no. HR-55G- 6159 [“offending
vehicle”] being driven by respondent no. 1 at a high speed in a rash and
MAC.APP. 1041/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:00:24
negligent manner came from Baraut side and hit the car. Due to the said
impact deceased suffered fatal injuries and died on the spot. FIR No.
215/2013 under Sections 279/337/338/304A/427 Indian Penal Code 1860
[IPC] was registered against respondent no. 1 [driver] at Police Station Kot
Baghpat. Deceased was 59 years old at the time of accident and was an exservice man (Air Force) and was getting pension of Rs. 16,000 p.m. and
besides that the deceased was also doing the work of property dealer from
which he was earning Rs. 15,000/- to Rs. 20,000/- p.m.
Compensation awarded
3.
MACT vide the impugned award held the death of Naresh Pal Panwar
occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle and,
taking the monthly income of deceased as Rs. 22,765/- (including pension
and minimum wages), adding 15% towards future prospects, applying
multiplier of ‘9’, and deducting 1/4th towards personal expenses, assessed
loss of dependency at Rs. 21,20,580/-; further awarding Rs. 1,00,000/towards loss of consortium, Rs. 1,00,000/- towards loss of love and affection,
Rs. 10,000/- towards loss of estate, and Rs. 25,000/- towards funeral
expenses, the MACT granted a total compensation of Rs. 23,55,580/- with
interest @ 9% p.a. from the date of filing of the petition till realization,
payable by the insurer.
Analysis
4.
Challenge raised by Mr. Pradeep Gaur, counsel for Insurance
Company, is on the following grounds:
i.
That for calculation of loss of dependency, the pension being
received by deceased who was 59 years of age on the date of
MAC.APP. 1041/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:00:24
the accident, was considered along with the minimum wages of
‘skilled’ worker, since he was doing additional work as a
property broker. It is stated by Mr. Gaur that this would be
duplicated with the family pension which the family was
receiving post the death of the deceased.
ii.
That future prospects were granted at 15% by the MACT, which
ought to have been granted at 10%, considering he was 59 years
of age, as per the principles enunciated in National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680.
iii.
That the deduction for expenditure on self, towards personal
and living expenses should have been taken at 1/3rd, since at best
there were two dependents i.e. the widow and one of the
daughters, who was also widowed and was living with them.
The other two children i.e. a daughter and a son, were major in
age and there was no evidence placed on record by claimants
that they were continuing studies.
iv.
That non-pecuniary damages which have been granted, have to
be aligned with principles enunciated in National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (supra).
5.
Mr. S.N. Parashar, counsel for claimants, however, contents that, as
regards the issue of deduction of pension, the matters stands settled, inter
alia, by the decision of the Supreme Court in Pramod Kumar Tiwari v.
Premlal Gautam & Ors. in SLP (Civil) No. 26620/2023, vide order on 8th
April 2025, where the Supreme Court has held as under:
“3) In the facts of the case, the short question that arises
for our reconsideration is whether on death of an employee
during subsistence of employment due to vehicular
MAC.APP. 1041/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:00:24
accident, the amount of family pension can be deducted
from his/her salary while calculating compensation under
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988?
………
5) The issue whether deduction of pension amount from the
salary can be made has been settled by the judgment of this
Court in the case of ‘Helen C. Rebello (Mrs.) and Others
Vs. Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation and
Another, (1999) 1 SCC 90’, wherein, this Court drawing
an analogy in para 35 observed as under –
“35. Broadly, we may examine the receipt of the
provident fund which is a deferred payment out of the
contribution made by an employee during the tenure
of his service. Such employee or his heirs are entitled
to receive this amount irrespective of the accidental
death. This amount is secured, is certain to be
received, while the amount under the Motor Vehicles
Act is uncertain and is receivable only on the
happening of the event, viz., accident, which may not
take place at all. Similarly, family pension is also
earned by an employee for the benefit of his family in
the form of his contribution in the service in terms of
the service conditions receivable by the heirs after his
death. The heirs receive family pension even
otherwise than the accidental death. No corelation
between the two. Similarly, life insurance policy is
received either by the insured or the heirs of the
insured on account of the contract with the insurer,
for which the insured contributes in the form of
premium. It is receivable even by the insured if he
lives till maturity after paying all the premiums. In the
case of death, the insurer indemnifies to pay the sum
to the heirs, again in terms of the contract for the
premium paid. Again, this amount is receivable by the
claimant not on account of any accidental death but
otherwise on the insured's death. Death is only a step
or contingency in terms of the contract, to receive the
amount. Similarly any cash, bank balance, shares,
fixed deposits, etc. though are all a pecuniary
MAC.APP. 1041/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:00:24
advantage receivable by the heirs on account of one's
death but all these have no corelation with the amount
receivable under a statute occasioned only on
account of accidental death. How could such an
amount come within the periphery of the Motor
Vehicles Act to be termed as “pecuniary advantage”
liable for deduction. When we seek the principle of
loss and gain, it has to be on a similar and same plane
having nexus, inter se, between them and not to which
there is no semblance of any corelation. The insured
(deceased) contributes his own money for which he
receives the amount which has no corelation to the
compensation computed as against the tortfeasor for
his negligence on account of the accident. As
aforesaid, the amount receivable as compensation
under the Act is on account of the injury or death
without making any contribution towards it, then how
can the fruits of an amount received through
contributions of the insured be deducted out of the
amount receivable under the Motor Vehicles Act. The
amount under this Act he receives without any
contribution. As we have said, the compensation
payable under the Motor Vehicles Act is statutory
while the amount receivable under the life insurance
policy is contractual.”
6) Later, in a recent judgment in the case of ‘Sebastiani
Lakra and others Vs. National Insurance Company
Limited and Another, (2019) 17 SCC 465’, this Court
observed that deductions cannot not be allowed from
amount of compensation either on account of insurance or
pensionary benefits or gratuity or grant of employment to
kith and kin of the deceased. The Court in para 12 noted
as thus –
“12. The law is well settled that deductions cannot be
allowed from the amount of compensation either on
account of insurance, or on account of pensionary
benefits or gratuity or grant of employment to a kin of
the deceased. The main reason is that all these
MAC.APP. 1041/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:00:24
amounts are earned by the deceased on account of
contractual relations entered into by him with others.
It cannot be said that these amounts accrued to the
dependents or the legal heirs of the deceased on
account of his death in a motor vehicle accident. The
claimants/dependents are entitled to “just
compensation” under the Motor Vehicles Act as a
result of the death of the deceased in a motor vehicle
accident. Therefore, the natural corollary is that the
advantage which accrues to the estate of the deceased
or to his dependents as a result of some contract or
act which the deceased performed in his lifetime
cannot be said to be the outcome or result of the death
of the deceased even though these amounts may go
into the hands of the dependents only after his death.
7) In view of the settled proposition of law, the question
posed above is answered in negative. Hence, order
impugned passed by High Court affirming the findings
recorded by the MACT is hereby set-aside.”
(emphasis added)
6.
On this issue, the decision of this Court in Cholamandalam MS
General Insurance Co. Ltd v. Usha Gupta & Ors. 2025:DHC:332, is also
relied upon, where the Court has considered a case where loss of dependency
was calculated taking into account the pension in sum of Rs.41,737/-, despite
family pension in the sum of Rs.20,000/- per month being received by the
wife. Yet again relying upon the decisions in Mrs. Helen C. Rebello & Ors.
v. Maharashtra State Road Transport Corpn. & Anr. AIR, 1998 SC 3191,
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. etc. v. Patrica Jean Mahajan & Ors. 2002
(6) SCC 281, Lal Dei & Ors. v. Himachal Road Transport (2007) 8 SCC
319, Vimal Kanwar & Ors. v. Kishore Dan & Ors. AIR 2013 SC 3830 and
Sebastiani Lakra v. National Insurance Company Ltd. AIR 2018 SC 5034,
MAC.APP. 1041/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:00:24
the Court held that the Tribunal had rightly not deducted the family pension
while calculating the compensation.
7.
In this view of the matter, the Court is not inclined to allow the plea of
the Insurance Company on the ground, on the issue of deduction of pension.
8.
On the second issue of future prospects, to be aligned with the
principles in Pranay Sethi (supra), considering deceased was 59 years of
age, 10% would have to be allowed.
9.
On the third issue of deduction of expenses, reliance has been placed
on the testimony of the wife of deceased, Rajesh Panwar [PW-1], who stated
that she is a widow and 53 years of age, with children named Pinki Panwar
(aged 27 years), Rinki Panwar (aged 27 years) and son, Arjun Panwar (aged
20 years) being dependents of the deceased and were relying on the income
of the deceased. There is no proof placed whether the daughter (Rinki
Panwar) and the son (Arjun Panwar) were studying at that point of time,
even though they were major in age, all were dependent on the income of the
deceased. Accordingly, deduction towards personal income should have
been taken in the category of two-three dependents and as 1/3rd of the
income, in terms of the principles in Pranay Sethi (supra).
10.
For non-pecuniary damages, since there were four family members,
the loss of consortium stands enhanced to Rs.1,60,000/- [Rs.40,000× 4 family
members] as per the principles enunciated Pranay Sethi (supra) and Magma
General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram (2018) 18 SCC 130.
11.
Loss of estate and funeral expense shall be granted at Rs.15,000/- each
as per the principles in Pranay Sethi (supra).
12.
Despite there being no cross-appeal, considering the decision passed
by the Supreme Court in Ningamma v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.
MAC.APP. 1041/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:00:24
(2009) 13 SCC 710 and a decision of this Court Oriental Insurance co Ltd.
v. Mamta Kumari & Ors. 2012:DHC:5522, it is open for the Court to
enhance the compensation on certain components which are considered as
just and reasonable.
Accordingly, the component of income which was attributed to the
13.
work of deceased as a property dealer, also requires to be considered. Rajesh
Panwar [PW-1] stated that deceased was earning approximately Rs.15,000/to Rs.20,000/- per month from such vocation, which testimony remained
unrebutted by the Insurance Company. MACT, however adopted minimum
wages of an ‘unskilled’ worker for this component of income. Considering
the deceased was an ex-serviceman from the India Air Force, and was
engaged in property dealings post-retirement, adoption of minimum wages
of a ‘skilled’ worker would be more appropriate and realistic for the relevant
period. Accordingly, minimum wages of a ‘skilled’ worker in the State of
Uttar Pradesh prevailing in the year 2013 are taken as Rs.7,265.1/- per month
(Rs.242.17 per day) for computation of loss of dependency.
Accordingly, compensation is recomputed as under:
14.
S. NO.
HEADS
AWARDED BY
THE TRIBUNAL
AWARDED BY THIS
COURT
Income of deceased (A)
(less Income Tax)
Rs. 22,765/-
Rs.24,112.1/-
[Rs.16,847+Rs.5918]
[Rs.16,847+Rs.7265.1/]
15%
10%
1/4th
1/3rd
Rs. 26,180/-
Rs. 17,684/-
Add Future Prospects
(B)
Less Personal expenses
of the deceased (C)
Monthly loss of
dependency [(A +B)-C
= D]
MAC.APP. 1041/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:00:24
Annual loss of
dependency (Dx12)
Multiplier (E)
Total loss of
dependency (Dx12xE =
F)
Medical expenses (G)
Compensation for loss
of consortium (H)
(40,000 x 4)
Compensation for loss
of love and affection (I)
Compensation for loss
of estate (J)
Compensation towards
funeral expenses (K)
Total compensation
(F+G+H+J+K = L)
Interest
15.
Rs. 2,35,620/-
Rs. 2,12,208/-
Rs. 21,20,580/-
Rs.19,09,872/-
Nil
Rs.1,00,000/-
Nil
Rs.1,60,000/-
Rs.1,00,000/-
Nil
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 25,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 23,55,580/-
Rs.20,99,872/-
9%
9%
In view of the above recomputation, total compensation payable to the
claimants stands reduced to Rs.20,99,872/- along with interest @ 9% per
annum as awarded by MACT.
16.
Since 50% of the awarded amount had already been directed to be
deposited before the Registry of this Court vide order dated 17th November
2014, the deposited amount shall be adjusted against the recomputed
compensation. In case any excess amount has been deposited by the
appellant, same shall be refunded to the appellant along with accrued interest
thereon. The balance amount, if any remaining payable, shall be deposited
by the appellant within four weeks from today. The claimants shall be
entitled to release of the amount in terms of the directions contained in the
impugned award.
17.
Accordingly, the appeal stands disposed of in above terms.
MAC.APP. 1041/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:00:24
18.
Statutory deposit, if any, be refunded to the appellant.
19.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
MARCH 24, 2026/ak/tk
MAC.APP. 1041/2014
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:00:24
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review