Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 08th January 2026
%
+
MAC.APP. 465/2015
ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
versus
ASHA RANI & ORS
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Pradeep Gaur, Advocate with Mr.
Amit Gaur, Advocate.
.....Respondent
Mr. Ramesh Chander and Ms. Divya,
Advs. for R-1 along with R-1 in
person.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J: (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed by the appellant/Insurance Company
challenging the final award dated 04th April 2015, passed by the Motor
Accident Claim Tribunal [“MACT”] (North West District) Rohini Courts,
Delhi in MACT Petition no. 336/2009 titled as “Asha Rani v. Sukhdev
Singh & Ors”.
2.
The claim petition was filed under Section 163A of the Motor
Vehicles Act 1988 [‘MVAct’] by the claimant [respondent no. 1 herein],
who was the mother of Sh. Mannu @ Munnu [the deceased], against Sh.
Sukhdev Singh [respondent no.2 herein], the driver of the offending vehicle,
and Shri Pardeep Singh [respondent no. 3 herein], the registered owner of
the offending vehicle, and the Oriental Insurance Company [appellant
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:20
MAC.APP. 465/2015
1 of 9
herein], the insurer of the offending vehicle. She claimed compensation to
the tune of Rs.15,00,000/- in her favour from the date of filing of the petition
till realization.
3.
The incident occurred on 29th June 2006 at about 2:00 P.M., when the
deceased was working as a conductor on the offending vehicle along with
two drivers and was on duty. The offending vehicle suffered an accident on
the highway in Bangalore; the driver of the offending vehicle having driven
it in a rash and negligent manner. The vehicle climbed the divider and fell
on the left side, due to which the deceased sustained injuries and died on the
spot.
4.
FIR was registered at Police Station Nelamangla, Bangalore. During
the pendency of the proceedings, Sh. Sukhdev Singh/respondent no.2, the
driver, passed away, and his name was deleted from the array of parties. The
owner of the offending vehicle, Shri Pradeep Singh/respondent no.3. was
proceeded ex parte.
5.
The Insurance Company/ appellant filed its written statement and the
matter was adjudicated by the Tribunal. An objection was raised by the
Insurance Company/ appellant before the Tribunal that there was no valid
insurance policy in relation to the offending vehicle. For this purpose,
evidence was led on behalf of Insurance Company/ appellant by R3W1, Mr.
Rajesh Arya, Assistant Manager, stating that the Cover Note had been
supplied to the owner of the vehicle, Shri Pardeep Singh, and a cheque No.
785944 for Rs. 1,23,720/- drawn on Canara Bank, Rohini Branch, was
issued towards the payment of premium for various vehicles including the
offending vehicle.
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:20
MAC.APP. 465/2015
2 of 9
6.
The cheque, however, was returned unpaid due to insufficient funds
on 24th June 2006, and, accordingly, the Cover Note was cancelled and the
owner and Regional Transport Office [RTO] was duly informed. A copy of
the cancelled policy had been placed on record along with the original
cheque, return memo and the cancelled policy cover note.
7.
R3W1, Mr. Rajesh Arya, was cross-examined by the claimant’s
counsel but was not cross-examined by the owner.
8.
This aspect was assessed by the Tribunal as part of Issue no.2. Based
on the contention made by the owner of the vehicle/respondent no.3, that he
had deposited the amount in cash towards the insurance of the offending
vehicle, the Tribunal was of the opinion that the owner was under a genuine
impression that his vehicle was validly insured and that he would have paid
the premium had he received intimation regarding dishonour of the cheque.
9.
Based on these facts and circumstances, the Tribunal concluded that
the offending vehicle was duly insured and decided the issue against the
Insurance Company/appellant. As regards the quantum of compensation, the
Tribunal assessed the same as under:
Sl. No.
10.
Compensation under various heads
Amount awarded
1.
Loss of dependency
Rs.4,16,000/-
2.
Funeral expenses
Rs. 2,000/-
3.
Loss of estate
Rs.2,500/-
4.
Total
Rs. 4,20,500/-
Counsel for the respondent no.1/claimant states that the “multiplier of
16” was used by the Tribunal even though the age of the deceased was ‘18
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:20
MAC.APP. 465/2015
3 of 9
years’, and no loss of consortium or compensation for future prospects was
granted.
11.
Mr. Pradeep Gaur, counsel for the appellant, submits that they have
no objection to the compensation amount being released in favour of
respondent no.1, considering that this is an old case and respondent no.1 is
65 years of age, being the mother of the deceased, and that there is no one
else alive in the family including her husband and two sons. However, this is
subject to a direction from this Court that the Insurance Company/appellant
shall have a right of recovery against the owner of the vehicle.
12.
Counsel for respondent no.1 has no objection to this extent and
makes a statement to this effect on instructions (respondent no.1, Smt. Asha
Rani, being present in Court).
13.
On the examination of the evidence in-chief filed on behalf of
respondent no.3, it transpires that cheque no.785944 was returned unpaid
due to insufficient funds on 24th June 2006, and the cheque return memo was
exhibited as Ex. R3W-1/D along with the cancelled policy/cover note
exhibited as Ex. R3W-1/E.
14.
It has been noted in the impugned award that the owner of the vehicle
had deposited the amount in cash in the bank for insurance of the offending
vehicle on 30th June 2006. However, since the accident occurred on 29th
June 2006, the deposit of cash on a later date would not validate the policy
retrospectively.
15.
In this regard, counsel for appellant has placed reliance on a decision
of the Supreme Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Yellamma, (2008)
7 SCC 526, delivered on 6th May 2008. The facts of the case were that an
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:20
MAC.APP. 465/2015
4 of 9
insurance policy was sought to be taken by the owner of a mini bus and the
cheque was issued towards insurance premium. However, the Cover Note
was later returned and the cheque was taken back. The question as to
whether the policy would be valid despite the non-payment of premium was
considered up by the Supreme Court. Relevant findings are extracted as
under:
“13. The question came up for consideration recently before
this Court in Deddappa v. National Insurance Co.
Ltd. [(2008) 2 SCC 595 : (2008) 1 SCC (Cri) 517] wherein
upon noticing the precedents which were operating in the
field, it was clearly held: (SCC pp. 599-600, paras 18-20)
“18. The ratio of the said decision was, however,
noticed by this Court in New India Assurance Co.
Ltd. v. Rula [(2000) 3 SCC 195 : 2000 SCC (Cri) 601].
It was held that ordinarily a liability under the contract
of insurance would arise only on payment of premium,
if such payment was made a condition precedent for
taking effect of the insurance policy but such a
condition which is intended for the benefit of the
insurer can be waived by it. It was opined: (SCC p.
200, para 13)
‘13. … If, on the date of accident, there was a policy
of insurance in respect of the vehicle in question, the
third party would have a claim against the insurance
company and the owner of the vehicle would have to
be indemnified in respect of the claim of that party.
Subsequent cancellation of the insurance policy on
the ground of non-payment of premium would not
affect the rights already accrued in favour of the
third party.’
The dicta laid down therein clarifies that if on the
date of accident the policy subsists, then only the
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:20
MAC.APP. 465/2015
5 of 9
third party would be entitled to avail the benefit
thereof.
19. Almost an identical question again came up for
consideration before this Court in National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Seema Malhotra[(2001) 3 SCC 151 : 2001
SCC (Cri) 443] and a Division Bench noticed both
the aforementioned decisions and analysed the same
in the light of Section 64-VB of the 1938 Act. It was
held: (SCC pp. 156-57, paras 17-20)
‘17. In a contract of insurance when the insured
gives a cheque towards payment of premium or part
of the premium, such a contract consists of
reciprocal promise. The drawer of the cheque
promises the insurer that the cheque, on
presentation, would yield the amount in cash. It
cannot be forgotten that a cheque is a bill of
exchange drawn on a specified banker. A bill of
exchange is an instrument in writing containing an
unconditional order directing a certain person to
pay a certain sum of money to a certain person. It
involves a promise that such money would be paid.
18. Thus, when the insured fails to pay the premium
promised, or when the cheque issued by him towards
the premium is returned dishonoured by the bank
concerned the insurer need not perform his part of
the promise. The corollary is that the insured cannot
claim performance from the insurer in such a
situation.
19. Under Section 25 of the Contract Act an
agreement made without consideration is void.
Section 65 of the Contract Act says that when a
contract becomes void any person who has received
any advantage under such contract is bound to
restore it to the person from whom he received it.
So, even if the insurer has disbursed the amount
covered by the policy to the insured before the
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:20
MAC.APP. 465/2015
6 of 9
cheque was returned dishonoured, the insurer is
entitled to get the money back.
20. However, if the insured makes up the premium
even after the cheque was dishonoured but before
the date of accident it would be a different case as
payment of consideration can be treated as paid in
the order in which the nature of transaction required
it. As such an event did not happen in this case, the
Insurance Company is legally justified in refusing to
pay the amount claimed by the respondents.’
20. A contract is based on reciprocal promise.
Reciprocal promises by the parties are condition
precedents for a valid contract. A contract
furthermore must be for consideration.”
14. In today's world payment by cheque is ordinarily
accepted as valid tender but the same would be subject
to its encashment. A distinction, however, exists
between the statutory liability of the insurance
company vis-à-vis the third party in terms of Sections
147 and 149 of the Motor Vehicles Act and its liability
in other cases but it is clear that if the contract of
insurance had been cancelled and all concerned had
been intimated thereabout, the insurance company
would not be liable to satisfy the claim.
15. In this case, there cannot be any doubt or dispute
whatsoever that no privity of contract came into being
between the appellant and the second respondent and
as such the question of enforcing the purported
contract of insurance while taking recourse to Section
147 of the Motor Vehicles Act did not arise.”
(emphasis added)
16.
The Supreme Court has held that where the insured fails to pay the
promised premium or where the cheque issued towards premium is
dishonoured, the insurer is not required to perform its part of the promise,
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:20
MAC.APP. 465/2015
7 of 9
and even if any amount had been disbursed under the policy, the insurer
would be entitled to recover the same.
17.
A contract for insurance does not crystallize if made without
consideration. Considering that the accident took place on 29th June 2006
and there was no consideration provided for the insurance policy as on that
date, and even as per the owner of the vehicle who deposited cash only on
30th June 2006, the tenets of the above decision shall fully apply in the
present case. The Insurance Company would thus be entitled to seek a right
of recovery against the owner of the vehicle, respondent no.3 herein.
18.
As regards the quantum of compensation, granted through the
claimant, it is noted that the compensation has been awarded as per the
structured formula under Section 163A of MV Act, and the multiplier must
be applied as per the Second Schedule, which prescribes a multiplier of 16
for age group above 15 years and below 20 years.
19.
Accordingly, reliance placed on Sarla Verma v. DTC, (2009) 6 SCC
121, to show that for the age group of 15 to 20 years, the applicable
multiplier would be 18 cannot be accepted.
20.
In terms of the discussion above, it is therefore directed that the
Insurance Company/appellant shall have a right of recovery against the
owner of the vehicle.
21.
It is further directed that entire compensation amount alongwith
accrued interest be released in favour of respondent no.1, by Registry of this
Court/UCO Bank Delhi High Court Branch, New Delhi, where the amount
was deposited pursuant to directions passed by this Court on 28 th May 2015.
A copy of this order be sent to the Assistant General Manager, UCO Bank
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:20
MAC.APP. 465/2015
8 of 9
for compliance and processing.
22.
Statutory amount along with accrued interest shall be released to the
appellant.
23.
The appeal stands disposed of accordingly.
24.
Pending applications, if any, are also rendered infructuous.
25.
Order be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL, J
JANUARY 8, 2026/RK/tk
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
16:08:20
MAC.APP. 465/2015
9 of 9
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review