Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 20.01.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 02.02.2026
+
ARB.P. 2018/2025
ONGC TRIPURA POWER COMPANY LTD
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Abhishek Puri, Mr. Sahil
Grewal & Ms. Surbhi Gupta,
Advocates.
versus
O AND M SOLUTIONS PVT LTD
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Priyabrat Tripathy, Mr.
Rajesh Gupta, Mr. Ayush
Acharjee & Mr. Nahush Khera,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
JUDGMENT
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
1.
The present petition has been filed under Section 11(6) of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 19961, seeking the appointment of
a sole arbitrator for the purpose of resolving disputes arising out of the
Agreement dated 16.12.2020.
2.
The disputes inter se the parties have arisen in relation to a
Contract for Operation & Maintenance dated 16.12.20202
executed between the parties, pursuant to which the Petitioner, in
terms of Clause 46 of the aforementioned contract, sought to resolve
Act
Contract/ Agreement
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
16:55:15
ARB.P. 2018/2025
the matter amicably by proposing a one-time settlement to the
Respondent.
3.
Upon refusal of the Respondent to the said amicable resolution,
the Petitioner, in accordance with Clause 46.4 of the Contract, issued
the notice dated 26.08.2025 under Section 21 of the Act, invoking the
Arbitration clause and calling upon the Respondent to concur in the
appointment of the Arbitrator. Clause 46.4 of the Contract reads as
under:
“46.4 Arbitration
46.4.1 All disputes or differences in respect of which the decision,
if any, of the Owner has not become final or binding as aforesaid,
shall be settled by arbitration, under and in accordance with the
provisions of the Indian Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996
(the "Arbitration Act") or any statutory modification, in the manner
hereinafter provided. The venue and seat of arbitration shall be
New Delhi, India.
46.4.2 The arbitration shall be conducted in accordance with the
Arbitration Act by 3 (three) arbitrators, (1) one each to be
nominated by the O&M Operator and the Owner and the third to be
nominated by the 2 (two) arbitrators nominated by the Parties at the
commencement of arbitration proceedings. The 3rd (third)
arbitrator so appointed shall act as the presiding arbitrator.
46.4.3 If one Party fails to appoint its arbitrator within 30 (thirty)
days after the other Party has named its arbitrator, the Party which
has named an arbitrator may request the President of the Institution
of Engineers to appoint the second arbitrator on behalf of such
Party. If the two arbitrators appointed by both Parties do not
succeed in appointing a third arbitrator within 30 (thirty) days after
the latter of the two arbitrators has been appointed, the third
arbitrator shall, at the request of either Party, be appointed by the
Chairman of ONGC.
46.4.4 The decision of the majority of the arbitrators ("Arbitral
Award") shall be final and binding upon the Parties. The expense
of the arbitration shall be paid as may be determined by the
arbitrators. The arbitrators may, from time to time, with the consent
of both the Parties increase the time for making the award. In the
event of any of the aforesaid arbitrators dying, neglecting,
resigning or being unable to act for any reason, it will be lawful for
the Party concerned to nominate another arbitrator in place of the
outgoing arbitrator.
46.4.5 The arbitrators shall have full powers to review and/or
revise any decision, opinion, directions, certification or valuation
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
16:55:15
ARB.P. 2018/2025
of the Owner in consonance with this Contract, and neither party
shall be limited in the proceedings before such arbitrators to the
evidence or arguments put before the Owner for the purpose of
obtaining the said decision.
46.4.6 No decision given by the Owner in accordance with the
foregoing provisions shall disqualify it from giving evidence
before the arbitrators on any matter whatsoever relevant to the
dispute or difference referred to the arbitrators as aforesaid.”
4.
The Respondent, however, vide its reply dated 24.09.2025,
refused to consent to the appointment of an Arbitrator, and further
informed the Petitioner that it had already raised certain claims before
the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council3, Cuttack,
vide Reference No. LC-11-MSEFC-64/2025/9368/IND of 2025 under
the provisions of the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises
Development Act, 20064.
5.
The Respondent‟s refusal to appoint an Arbitrator, coupled with
its invocation of proceedings before the MSEFC, Cuttack, has resulted
in a failure of the agreed arbitral mechanism, thereby necessitating the
present petition.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PARTIES:
6.
At the outset, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
Respondent would oppose the appointment of an Arbitrator and
would, in that context, raise various objections, as set out in the
submissions hereinafter.
7.
He would submit that at the relevant point in time, when the
Contract was entered into, the Respondent herein was a small-scale
industry and would therefore be entitled to the protection of the
provisions of the MSMED Act.
MSEFC
MSMED Act
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
16:55:15
ARB.P. 2018/2025
8.
Learned counsel for the Respondent would further submit that
the Respondent, being a registered MSME, has filed a reference under
Section 18(1) of the MSMED Act before the MSEFC, Cuttack. Notice
dated 18.10.2025 has already been issued by the MSEFC, and the
Petitioner has admittedly participated by filing its reply on 28.11.2025
before the MSEFC, Cuttack.
9.
He would thus submit that in view thereof, the present matter
would have to be referred to the MSEFC, Cuttack; and to support his
contention he would rely upon the judgment of this Court in Sterlite
Power Transmission Limited v. EPC Solutions LLP5 which held that
the applicability of the MSMED Act would be determined by the date
of the contract. He would, in particular, refer to and rely upon
Paragraph nos. 27, 29 & 31 of the said judgment and the same read as
under:
“27.Thus, what is relevant is the date of contract in order to
confirm as to whether the MSMED Act, 2006 would be applicable
or not.
*****
29. In view of the aforementioned judgements of Silpi Industries
(Supra) and Gujarat Civil Supplies (Supra) the relevant date in
order to confirm as to whether the MSMED Act, 2006 would be
applicable shall be the date of agreement between the parties and
the date of supply of goods/rendering of services.
*****
31. Going by the settled legal position, as also the fact that the
MSMED Act, 2006 is a beneficial legislation for Micro, Small and
Medium Enterprises and ought to be construed in a manner that is
beneficial to such enterprises. Thus, even if on the date when the
reference application was filed before the MSEFC, the supplier i.e.
Respondent No.1 had upgraded itself to the Medium Enterprises, it
cannot be deprived of the benefits of the provisions of the MSME
Act, 2006 and the impugned reference order would be liable to be
upheld.”
2023 SCC OnLine Del 3890
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
16:55:15
ARB.P. 2018/2025
10.
He would further contend that even during the subsistence of
some part of the term of the Contract as well as on the date when the
dispute was actually referred to the MSEFC, the RespondentCompany squarely fell within the statutory definition of a „Small
Enterprise‟ under the provisions of the MSMED Act, and resultantly,
the matter would have to be referred to the MSEFC under the
provisions of the MSMED Act.
11.
The second objection raised by learned counsel for the
Respondent would be that the contract between the parties is not a
works contract, but is essentially an agreement for the operation and
maintenance of an existing power plant. It would be contended that
the nature of work involved in the present case does not fall within the
definition of a “works contract” as provided under Section 2(119) of
the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, which defines a works
contract as follows:
“works contract” means a contract for building, construction,
fabrication, completion, erection, installation, fitting out,
improvement, modification, repair, maintenance, renovation,
alteration or commissioning of any immovable property where in
transfer of property in goods (whether as goods or in some other
form) is involved in the execution of such contract.”
12.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
Petitioner would submit that it is not the date on which the Contract
was entered into which is relevant but it is the date of supply of goods
and services which would be relevant and for the said purpose, he
would rely upon the judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Silpi
Industries & Ors. v. KSRDC6 and, in particular Paragraph nos. 41, 42
& 44 thereof, which read as under:
“41. In CAs Nos. 1620-22 of 2021, the High Court, while negating
(2021) 18 SCC 790
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
16:55:15
ARB.P. 2018/2025
the plea of the appellant, on the maintainability of counterclaim,
has allowed the application filed by the respondent under Section
11(6) of the 1996 Act and appointed the second arbitrator. Though,
we are of the view that counterclaim and set-off is maintainable
before the statutory authorities under the MMED Act, the appellant
in this set of appeals is not entitled for the relief, for the reason that
on the date of supply of goods and services the appellant did not
have the registration by submitting the memorandum as per Section
8 of the Act. The bids were invited on 23-2-2010, the appellant
submitted its bid on 17-5-2010, the respondent awarded contract to
the appellant on 24-9-2010 and the parties signed the contract
documents for supply of material, installation, commissioning of
the power plant on 29-7-2011. Thereafter, supplies were made and
the appellant has raised first invoice on 2-11-2011 for supply
contract and also raised the first invoice pursuant to contract for
installation on 7-7-2012 and the appellant has raised the last
invoice in furtherance of contract for supply of material, on 29-32014. The appellant also claims to have raised last invoice on 29-32015 in furtherance of contract for installation. It is to be noticed
that the appellant approached the District Industrial Centre for
grant of entrepreneur memorandum only on 25-3-2015.
42. Though the appellant claims the benefit of provisions under the
MSMED Act, on the ground that the appellant was also supplying
as on the date of making the claim, as provided under Section 8 of
the MMED Act, but same is not based on any acceptable material.
The appellant, in support of its case placed reliance on a judgment
of the Delhi High Court in GET&D India Ltd. v. Reliable Engg.
Projects & Mktg.°, but the said case is clearly distinguishable on
facts as much as in the said case, the supplies continued even after
registration of entity under Section 8 of the Act. In the present
case, undisputed position is that the supplies were concluded prior
to registration of supplier. The said judgment of the Delhi High
Court relied on by the appellant also would not render any
assistance in support of the case of the appellant. In our view, to
seek the benefit of provisions under the MMED Act, the seller
should have registered under the provisions of the Act, as on the
date of entering into the contract. In any event, for the supplies
pursuant to the contract made before the registration of the unit
under provisions of the MMED Act, no benefit can be sought by
such entity, as contemplated under the MMED Act.
*****
44. The appellant cannot become micro or small enterprise or
supplier, to claim the benefits within the meaning of the MMED
Act, 2006, by submitting a memorandum to obtain registration
subsequent to entering into the contract and supply of goods and
services. If any registration is obtained, same will be prospective
and applies for supply of goods and services subsequent to
registration but cannot operate retrospectively. Any other
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
16:55:15
ARB.P. 2018/2025
interpretation of the provision would lead to absurdity and confer
unwarranted benefit in favour of a party not intended by
legislation.”
13.
He would further submit that the present Contract as between
the parties is essentially a works contract and relies upon Clauses 3.1
& 3.3 of the Contract between the parties, which sets out the scope of
the Contract and which reads as under:
“3.0 SCOPE
3.1 The O&M Operator shall provide all the services required for
the operation, maintenance and repair of the Plant during the
Takeover Phase and Operational Phase, including but not limited
to:
3.1.1 operating and maintaining the Plant along with the Existing
O&M Contractor during Takeover Phase, including mobilization of
staff and resources as per the Staffing Plan for Takeover Phase
which is attached herewith as Annexure 1 (Staffing Plan);
3.1.2 taking over of the Plant including tools & tackles, Spare
Parts, materials, drawings, documents, manuals, reports, operation
& maintenance records etc. from the Existing O&M Contractor
during Takeover Phase;
3.1.3 upon taking over of the Plant from the Existing O&M
Contractor, operating and maintaining and repairing the Plant as
per Prudent Utility Practice in conformity with this Contract, the
Project Agreements and any other agreements which Owner has
entered into or will enter into in relation to the Plant and in
accordance with all Applicable Laws during the Operational Phase;
3.1.4 generating electricity from the Plant on behalf of Owner;
3.1.5 scheduling, coordinating and handling deliveries of Fuel and
perform all duties and responsibilities (other than payment
responsibilities) of the Owner;
3.1.6 operating, maintaining and repairing of all the associated
facilities of the Plant and RWIS;
3.1.7 maintenance and repair of major equipment at the Plant under
supervision of OEM, for which supervision of OEM shall be hired
at O&M Operator's cost; In case any OEM refuses to give offer to
the O&M Operator, Owner shall obtain the offer from the OEM,
which shall be binding on and acceptable to the O&M Operator
unconditionally.
3.1.8 preparing Operation & Maintenance Plan and Procedure,
Inventory Management and Procurement Procedure and Annual
Operating Plan & Budget;
3.1.9 operation of Plant Maintenance Module and Material
Management Module under SAP installed by the Owner at the
Plant;
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
16:55:15
ARB.P. 2018/2025
3.1.10 maintenance and repair of all buildings (except housekeeping of these buildings) at the Site such as, security hostel,
training centre, administrative building, training hostel, medical
centre etc. and such area at the Site where these buildings are
situated and as demarcated in Annexure 6 (Site), including
maintenance and repair of electrical system, HVAC system, water
system, sewage system of these buildings;
3.1.11 notifying the Owner promptly upon becoming aware of any
warranty claim which may be asserted against the Existing O&M
Contractor during the 12 (twelve) months period commencing from
the Operational Phase in relation to the Services provided by such
Existing O&M Contractor for the operation and maintenance of the
Plant. However, this provision will not dilute in any manner the
obligation of the O&M Contractor under the Contract to provide
the Services required for operating and maintaining the Plant;
3.1.12 procurement and supply of chemicals, gases , consumables,
oils, lubricants, filters (except gas turbine inlet air filter), electrical
accessories, construction material and other materials (except
Spare Parts), required from time to time for operation,
maintenance, inspection, repairing and testing of the Plant, which
will be consumed during operation and maintenance (including
inspection, repairing and testing) of Plant and will then need to be
replenished, starting from start of Operational Phase till expiry of
the Term in accordance with the terms and conditions specified in
this Contract and as set out in detail in the Technical Specifications
(the "Consumables");
3.1.13 transportation and marine insurance of the Consumables
from the Loading Point to the Site;
3.1.14 performance of all obligations required to be performed by
the Owner under the LTSA including the services required to be
performed by the Owner during the scheduled maintenance events
as identified under the LTSA; and
3.1.15 preparing required reports documenting the operation and
maintenance of the Plant, including but not limited to the Daily
Reports, Monthly Reports and Annual Reports and such other
reports as specified in Annexure – 13 hereto, as set out in further
detail in the Technical Specifications (such services, the
"Services")
*****
3.3 As part of the scope of its obligations under this Contract, the
O&M Operator shall procure and pay for, in its own name as an
independent contractor and not as an agent of the Owner, all
materials, equipment, supplies, manufacturing, fabrication
necessary in connection with the Services in accordance with this
Contract. All such items shall be new, fit for purpose and free from
any improper workmanship or defects and properly warranted or
guaranteed to the extent required by Clause 24.0 (Warranty and
Warranty Period) and comply with all Applicable Laws.”
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
16:55:15
ARB.P. 2018/2025
14.
He would thus submit that since there is evidently a transfer of
goods involved, the said contract would have to be construed as a
works contract and would not be amenable to reference to the MSEFC
under the MSMED Act. He would rely upon the judgment of this
Court in TATA Power Co. Ltd. v. Genesis Engineering Co.7, and, in
particular, Paragraph nos. 19, 20 & 21, thereof, which reads as under:
“19. In order to ascertain whether the scope of work as awarded to
Petitioner would qualify as a „work contract‟ or „composite
supply‟, the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India
in Kone Elevator India Private Limited v. State of Tamil
Nadu, (2014) 7 SCC 1 is relevant to appreciate the categories of
contract, i.e. (a) Contract for work to be done for remuneration and
for supply of materials to be used in the execution of work for a
price (b) Contract for work in which the use of the materials is
necessary or incidental to the execution of the work (c) Contract
for supply of goods where some work is required to done as
incidental to the sale. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has opined that
category (a) as composite contract consisting of two contracts, one
of which is for the sale of goods and the other which is for work
and labour. It was held that the involvement of supply of goods and
material as well as installation of the lift had concluded that the
contracts awarded to Kone Elevators satisfy the characteristics of
Works Contract and held that it cannot be considered as contract of
sale.
20. Applying the judgment to the instant case, the Works Orders as
executed by the parties in the instant case falls within category (a)
as it comprises of two contracts which include supply of goods
such as Cables, wire, connectors, street lights and poles and
subsequent involvement of work and labour for its installation.
Further, the element of both supply of goods and element of labour
and service is involved in the Work Orders. It is also a settled
principled of law that that dispute/claims arising from Works
Contract are not amenable to the jurisdiction of Facilitation
Council constituted under the MSME Act.
21. In terms of Section 11 of the MSME Act, Central Government
had to notify policies in respect of procurement of goods and
services produced and provided by Micro and Small Enterprises.
Accordingly, on 23.03.2012, Public Procurement Policy for Micro
and Small Enterprises was notified which envisaged that Central
2023 SCC OnLine Del 2366
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
16:55:15
ARB.P. 2018/2025
Ministry or Department or Public Sector Undertaking shall set an
annual goal of procurement of products produced and services
from Micro and Small Enterprises. Thereafter, on 25.03.2022,
Office of Development Commissioner, Government of India issued
an Office Memorandum clarifying that Public Procurement Policy
is not applicable to Works Contracts. In view of the aforesaid and
considering the definition of Enterprise and on a combined reading
of the said Policy and subsequent clarification issued by the
Ministry, it is evident that benefit of MSME Act and Policies
issued thereunder can only be availed by enterprises which fall
within the ambit of goods and services which are manufactured and
reproduced by the enterprises.”
15.
In rejoinder, learned counsel for the Respondent would contend
that the issue as to whether the contract in question constitutes a works
contract is, in any event, a matter that can be appropriately referred to
the MSEFC itself. In support of this submission, reliance would be
placed on the judgment of the learned Co-ordinate Bench of this Court
in Idemia Syscom India Private Limited v. M/s. Conjoinix Total
Solutions Private Limited8, particularly Paragraph nos. 15 and 16
thereof, which read as under:
“15. The petitioner has not denied the factum of the respondent
being registered as an MSME at the time of entering into the
contract. It has also not denied that the respondent has approached
the MSME facilitation council under Section 18 of the Act. It is the
petitioner's case that the subject contract is a works contract and
hence not covered under the MSMED Act. He has relied on a
number of decisions to that effect. However, the respondent has
denied that the contract is a works contract. Since the parties are at
odds about the nature of the contract, this becomes a triable issue
requiring adjudication and the same would involve detailed
appreciation of evidence. The scope of enquiry vested with the
Court under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act is
no longer Res integra. The same is limited to forming a prime facie
opinion as to the existence of an agreement between the parties.
(Ref: SBI General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Krish Spinning8) Since
the dispute in question would require detailed appreciation of
evidence and interpretation of the terms of the contract, it would
not be appropriate for this Court at the stage of a petition under
Section 11 of the A&C Act to undertake the same. It may very well
2025 SCC Online Del 1023
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
16:55:15
ARB.P. 2018/2025
happen that the parties resolve their issues in the conciliation and
the question becomes merely an academic one. Even if the
conciliation fails, the parties would still have recourse to arbitration
under the MSMED Act and the AT so constituted would be the
most suited forum for the parties to put forth their respective
contentions
16. Looking from another angle, even if the petitioner's contention
regarding works contracts can be said to have some merit, the same
essentially becomes a question regarding the jurisdiction of the AT
constituted under Section 18 of the MSMED Act. It is no longer
Res integra that the AT would be competent to rule on its own
jurisdiction. The same has been reiterated by the Supreme Court in
Mahakali Foods (Supra) in the context of an AT constituted under
MSMED Act:"48. When the Facilitation Council or the institution or the
centre acts as an arbitrator, it shall have all powers to
decide the disputes referred to it as if such arbitration was
in pursuance of the arbitration agreement referred to in
sub-section (1) of Section 7 of the Arbitration Act, 1996
and then all the trappings of the Arbitration Act, 1996
would apply to such arbitration. It is needless to say that
such Facilitation Council/institution/centre acting as an
Arbitral Tribunal would also be competent to rule on its
own jurisdiction like any other Arbitral Tribunal appointed
under the Arbitration Act, 1996 would have, as
contemplated in Section 16 thereof. "”
ANALYSIS & DECISION:
16.
This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties at
length and, with their able assistance, has carefully perused the paper
book as well as the judgments relied upon by them.
17.
Upon a careful consideration of the pleadings, the material
placed on record, and the precedents cited by the learned counsel for
the parties, as cited in preceding paragraphs, this Court is of the
considered view that the contract between the parties was admittedly
executed on 16.12.2020. In view of the settled legal position,
particularly the ratio laid down by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Silpi
Industries (supra) and the judgment of the learned Co-ordinate Bench
of this Court in Sterlite Power (supra), this Court finds no impediment
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
16:55:15
ARB.P. 2018/2025
in referring the present dispute to the MSEFC, Cuttack. Such a
reference would necessarily include an examination and determination
of the preliminary issue as to whether the contract in question is a
“works contract”.
18.
Insofar as the determination of whether the contract constitutes
a “works contract” is concerned, this Court is of the view that the said
issue squarely falls within the jurisdiction of the MSEFC. As held by
the learned Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Idemia Syscom
(supra), such a question is not only amenable to adjudication by the
MSEFC but is one which can, and indeed ought to, be examined by
the Council while considering the dispute between the parties.
19.
It has been brought to the notice of this Court that disputes
between the parties are already the subject matter of proceedings
pending before the MSEFC, Cuttack, and that the said proceedings are
presently at the stage of pleadings.
20.
In these circumstances, this Court is of the considered opinion
that, since the parties are already before the MSEFC, Cuttack, the said
forum constitutes the appropriate and competent authority for the
settlement and adjudication of the disputes between the parties.
21.
Accordingly, the present Petition is dismissed, in view of the
facts that the proper forum for raising and adjudicating the disputes is
the MSEFC, and not this Court by way of invocation of its jurisdiction
under Section 11 of the Act.
22.
The present Petition, along with pending application(s), if any,
is disposed of in the above terms.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
FEBRUARY 02, 2026/rk/jk
Digitally Signed
By:HARVINDER KAUR
BHATIA
16:55:15
ARB.P. 2018/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review