Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02 & 03
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
AB. No. 5 of 2023 with
AB. No. 6 of 2023
Date of Decision: 31.03.2023
Shri Bijoy Saha
Shri Om Prakash Tanwar
Vs.
Vs.
State of Meghalaya
State of Meghalaya
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
Dr. N. Mozika, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv.
Mr. R. Gurung, GA and
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
COMMON ORDER
1.
An FIR dated 02.03.2023 was filed before the Officer-In-Charge
Baghmara, Police Station South Garo Hills by Sub-Inspector A. Wahlang,
with the information that that on 01.03.2023 at around 9:54 PM, on receipt
of confidential information, one Bolero pickup truck No. AS25 EC 4493
was intercepted and on being searched, underneath grocery items which
were loaded on the said pickup truck, alleged contraband substance was
recovered from the storage compartment of the said vehicle being 1393
bottles of Phensedyl weighing 139.3 kg and 2864 strips of Tapentadol
tablets weighing 2864 grams which were seized. The occupants of the
vehicle by the name of Dilbar Ali and his helper Monowar Ali were detained
in this regard. In course of enquiry it was revealed that, the said consignment
was meant to be delivered to one Subash Barman who was also detained.
All the three suspects were arrested.
2.
On receipt of the said FIR, a cognizance case was registered being
Baghmara PS Case No. 9(3)2023 under Section 21(c)/25/29 NDPS Act. The
investigation was accordingly launched.
3.
The petitioner Shri Bijoy Saha in AB. No. 5 of 2023 and the
petitioner Shri Om Prakash Tanwar in AB. No. 6 of 2023 have separately
approached this Court with an application under Section 438 Cr.PC praying
for grant of pre-arrest bail in connection with the said Baghmara PS Case
No. 9(3)2023.
4.
These two petitions pertains to the same FIR and the same criminal
case, therefore, it is found expedient that a common order be passed.
5.
Heard Dr. N. Mozika, learned Sr. Counsel who has submitted that
the petitioner Shri Bijoy Saha is a business man engaged in selling
wholesale grocery items at Krishnai, Golpara District, Assam. In course of
his business, the petitioner purchased bulk quantities of drinking water,
nimbupani and fresh mango juice from M/s B.N. Choudhury & Sons and
M/s Hanuman Store for delivery to Smti Sillarin D. Shira of Rongra village,
Baghmara. The said items were transported from Krishnai to Baghmara in
the said bolero pickup No. AS25 EC 4493.
6.
This petitioner was however surprised to learn that the police from
Krishnai Police Station went to his residence on 03.03.2023 and again on
05.03.2023 with the intention to arrest him, however, the petitioner was not
present at his residence at the relevant time.
7.
On enquiry, the petitioner came to know that the case being
Baghmara PS Case No. 9(3)2023 was registered and he was impleaded in
the case as one of the suspects. Immediately on 14.03.2023, the petitioner
had approached the Special Court (NDPS) at Baghmara with a prayer for
grant of pre-arrest bail, upon which, pending final decision of the same, he
was granted interim bail. During the intervening period, the petitioner had
appeared before the I/O and his statement was duly recorded. However, the
said pre-arrest bail application was dismissed by the learned Spl. Judge
NDPS on 21.03.2023, hence this application.
8.
The learned Sr. counsel has further submitted that the petitioner is
nowhere involved in the case since he is a businessman who has transacted
his business in grocery items and is not connected or has no knowledge of
what has been allegedly done by the driver or the helper of the said Bolero
pickup. Since the police had come looking for him, the petitioner being
apprehensive of imminent arrest in connection with the aforementioned
case has therefore approached this Court with a prayer for grant of pre-arrest
bail with any condition that may be imposed by this Court.
9.
Coming to the case of the petitioner Shri Om Prakash Tanwar, the
learned Sr. counsel has submitted that the petitioner is the registered owner
of the said Bolero pickup No. AS25 EC 4493 and is also a businessman by
profession. He has rented out the vehicle to Shri Dilbar Ali, the driver and
as such, has no knowledge or control on the use of the said vehicle.
10.
This petitioner was however surprised to know that the police from
Krishnai PS had come to his residence looking for him on 03.03.2023 and
05.03.2023. Later on, on enquiry, the petitioner came to know of the said
criminal case being Baghmara PS Case No. 09(03)2023 and that his vehicle
was seized in connection herewith.
11.
The petitioner then approached the Special Court (NDPS) at
Baghmara with a prayer for grant of pre-arrest bail, upon which, pending
final decision of the same, he was granted interim bail. During the
intervening period, the petitioner had appeared before the I/O and his
statement was duly recorded. However, the said pre-arrest bail application
was dismissed by the learned Spl. Judge NDPS on 21.03.2023, hence this
application.
12.
The learned Sr. counsel has submitted that generally, the two
petitioners herein were neither named in the FIR nor their involvement with
the suspected transport of the alleged contraband goods have been
established. Therefore, no nexus can be linked between the petitioners and
the accused driver and helper and as such, there is no reason to apprehend
the petitioners as far as the case is concerned.
13.
Even otherwise, the learned Sr. counsel has submitted that the
alleged contraband seized being Phensedyl and Tapentadol tablets does not
figure in the list of psychotropic substances detailed in the Schedule to the
NDPS Act, 1985, accordingly, there could be no case made out under the
NDPS Act.
14.
The petitioners being justified in their apprehension of imminent
arrest, they may be enlarged on bail if arrested with any conditions to be
imposed by this Court as deemed fit and proper and the interim bail granted
may be made absolute it is finally submitted.
15.
Per contra, Mr. R. Gurung, learned GA has opposed the prayer made
by the petitioners and has submitted that the contraband seized, irrespective
of the name that they carry contained a psychotropic substance called
‘Codeine’ which may contain 0.75 mg in one bottle of Phensedyl, however
if taken cumulatively, the amount of seizure made in this case would exceed
0.75 mg or rather falls within the scope of commercial quantity.
16.
Another argument advanced by the learned GA is that preliminary
investigation has revealed that the petitioners herein are in constant touch
and contact with the arrested accused person Dilbar Ali and Subash Barman.
The Call Details Record (CDR) of the communication between the
petitioners and the said accused person have also been collected and
compiled by the I/O which clearly shows a link and nexus between them.
17.
In view of the seriousness of the offence and the provision of Section
37 of the NDPS Act, the learned GA has submitted that the prayer of the
petitioners may not be allowed.
18.
The submission of the parties have been duly considered and the
petition as well as the contents of the case diary have been perused by this
Court. The fact that the case has been registered with one of the Sections
being Section 21(c), which section provides a punishment for contravention
of any provision of the Act in relation to manufactured drugs and
preparations, encompassing a wide arc to include possession, sale,
purchase, transport, import and export or use of such manufactured drugs,
Sub-Section (c) qualifying the said contravention involving commercial
quantity, attracts the provision of Sub-Section (b) of Section 37 of the said
Act as far as grant or refusal of bail is concerned.
19.
Coming to Section 37, a number of judicial pronouncement in this
regard has been rendered by the Apex Court as well as the High Court and
the approach to bail is always in the negative which is opposite to the oft
repeated principle of ‘bail and not jail’ since the provision starts with a nonobstante clause.
20.
It is well settled that for granting bail under Section 37, the court
must be satisfied on the basis of the record produced before it that there are
reasonable grounds for believing that the accused is not guilty of the
offences for which he is charged with and that if enlarged on bail he is not
likely to commit the same offence. The conditions for grant of bail under
Section 37 are in addition to the limitations provided under the Code of
Criminal Procedure regulating grant of bail.
21.
This means that apart from what is generally taken into account
while considering grant or refusal of bail, that is the seriousness and gravity
of the offence alleged, the fact that the accused if enlarged on bail may
abscond or tamper with the evidence etc, in Section 37, the standard
prescribed for grant of bail is “reasonable grounds to believe” that the
person is not guilty of the offence. The expression ‘reasonable grounds’
means something more than ‘prima facie grounds’. Plainly understood, it
means in accordance with reasons.
22.
In the case of the petitioners herein, at this stage this Court, mostly
based on the findings as regard the CDR has reasonable grounds to believe
that the petitioners are guilty of the offence alleged, subject to evidence in
due course.
23.
This being the case, the consideration for grant of pre-arrest bail does
not subsist. Accordingly, both these petitions are dismissed as devoid of
merits.
24.
The interim bail granted is discharged.
25.
Let the case diary be returned.
26.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
31.03.2023
“N. Swer, Stenographer”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review