Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CWP-39172-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
CWP-39172-2025
Date of Decision: May 22, 2026
OM PARKASH
........Petitioner
Versus
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
........Respondents
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARKESH MANUJA
Present:
Mr. Chanderhas Yadav, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. Abhinav Kalia, DAG, Haryana.
****
HARKESH MANUJA, J. (ORAL)
By way of present writ petition, the short prayer made on
behalf of the petitioner/landowner is for release of statutory interest in his
favour on account of delayed disbursal of the amount of compensation,
besides award of annuity benefits to him in accordance with the award
dated 04.07.2014 passed by the Land Acquisition Collector, Urban Estate
Department, Rohtak, (for short ‘the LAC’).
2.
Briefly stating, some land owned by the petitioner, situated
within the revenue estate of Village Jhajjar, District Jhajjar was acquired
vide notifications dated 07.07.2011 and 06.07.2012 issued under
Sections 4 and 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short ‘the Act’)
respectively,
for the public purpose namely, for development of
Institutional and partly Commercial, road widening and green belt of
Sector 10, Jhajjar. Award under Section 11 of the Act was announced on
04.07.2014, thereby determining the market value of the land besides
awarding annuity scheme benefits @ Rs.21,000/- per acre per annum for
a period of 33 years in accordance with the government gazette
notification dated 09.11.2010. The relevant para 4 of the award is
extracted hereunder:“4. MARKET VALUE:The Deputy Commissioner-cum-Collector, Jhajjar was requested
to supply the market value of land under acquisition. The Deputy
TEJWINDER SINGH
2026.05.29 16:43
I agree to specified portions
of this document
CWP-39172-2025
Commissioner-cum-Collector, Jhajjar supplied the market value of the
land under acquisition as per provisions of LARR Act-2013 vide his
memo No. DRA/628-34 dt. 17.06.2014 as Rs. 30 Lacs per acre for all
kinds of land and after that rate identify vide order dt. 01.07.2014 of the
P.S.U.E 28,13,951/- per acre for all kinds of land. As per section 26(2) of
LARR Act-2013, the awarded market value shall be multiplied by a factor
to be specified in the first scheduled. But so far the govt. has notified the
factor, as such after notification by the government, the difference of
compensation is applicable, shall be awarded.
I have inspected the land under acquisition along with the revenue
staff of my office before announcement of the Award. Keeping in view
the location, situation and all other factors, I observe that the market
value, i.e. 28,13,951/- per acre for all kinds of land, supplied by the
P.S.U.E, Haryana are fair and adequate, and I award the same
alongwith the Annuity Scheme of 21,000/- per acre per annum for a
period of 33 years, published vide government gazette dated 9-11.2010
which will be increased by a fixed sum of Rs. 750/- per acre every year.”
3.
In the award, the petitioner/landowner was also recorded to
be entitled for the benefits of Land Pooling Scheme. Clause 8 of the
Award in this regard is extracted hereunder:“8.
LAND POOLING SCHEME:- The landowner(s) opting for the Land
Pooling Scheme will be provided developed residential site in the form of
residential plots measuring 1000 sq. yards and commercial site
measuring 100 sq. yards against each one acre of land acquired in lieu
of the compensation package and all the benefits admissible under the
R & R Policy’ of the Government, at the time of first floatation of the
residential sector for which land of the applicant has been acquired:
The landowner(s) would be eligible to participate in the Land
Pooling Scheme only if a minimum of 1000 sq yards or more of his/their
land is acquired. The details of the land pooling scheme are given in the
Haryana Govt. Urban Estate Department notification dt. 10 Spt. 2012.”
4.
Leaned counsel for the petitioner submits that in terms of the
award dated 04.07.2014, the petitioner submitted application before the
LAC for seeking benefit of Land Pooling Scheme and the same remained
TEJWINDER SINGH
2026.05.29 16:43
I agree to specified portions
of this document
CWP-39172-2025
pending consideration; whereas on the other hand, the possession of the
acquired land was taken over by the respondents on the date of passing
of the Award itself. He points out that compensation in terms of the
aforementioned
award
was
neither
released
in
favour
of
the
petitioner/landowner at the time of passing of the award nor even when
the possession was taken over. Learned counsel contends that despite
repeated reminders and requests, when no action was taken on the
application submitted by the landowner against their claim towards the
Land Pooling Scheme, the petitioner visited the respondents and was
then informed that the Land Pooling Scheme benefit was not even
applicable to the acquisition in hand as the same was for institutional and
commercial purposes. He further points out that it was thereafter only the
petitioner was released the compensation amount by the respondents on
06.10.2015 and thus there was delay in disbursal thereof on the part of
respondents and the petitioner was thus entitled for award of statutory
interest in terms of Section 34 of the Act. He also submits that earlier the
petitioner was not paid the amount of compensation lying deposited with
the LAC as his application for grant of benefits under Land Pooling
Scheme was pending consideration with the respondents. Learned
counsel also submits that the respondents even failed to award the
annuity benefits to the petitioner/landowner in accordance with the award
and thus the necessary directions in this regard need to be issued as
well.
5.
On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent State submits that the amount of compensation was lying
deposited with the LAC and the petitioner never approached the
authorities concerned for release thereof and thus, was not entitled to
any statutory benefits of interest in this regard. Learned counsel also
submits that in terms of the policy dated 09.11.2010 regarding Annuity
Scheme, the landowner was required to make appropriate application
within six months of the award and since no such application was made
by him; he was not entitled for release of any benefit under the Annuity
Scheme and therefore, the present writ petition filed at the instance of the
petitioner deserves to be dismissed.
TEJWINDER SINGH
2026.05.29 16:43
I agree to specified portions
of this document
CWP-39172-2025
6.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and gone
through the paper-book.
7.
As per the record, the award under Section 11 of the Act was
passed by the LAC on 04.07.2014. In the said Award, under the heading
of market value, landowner was held entitled for grant of Annuity Scheme
benefits @ Rs.21,000/- per acre per annum. Thus, the said annuity
benefits were not only payable in terms of the policy dated 09.10.2011
but also formed an integral part of the award dated 04.07.2014 passed
by the LAC in exercise of powers under Section 11 of the 1894 Act. In
such circumstances, once the annuity benefits stood incorporated in the
award itself, a statutory obligation was cast upon the respondents to
release the same in favour of the landowner, without requiring them to
submit any application in this regard.
8.
Moreover, this issue with respect to the application by landowner
for award of annuity benefits to be made within six months from the date
of award of the LAC in terms of Notification/Policy dated 09.11.2010
issued by the Govt. of Haryana already stands adjudicated upon by this
Court vide decision dated 20.12.2023 passed in CWP No. 16737 of
2023, titled “Om Parkash and others Versus The State of Haryana
and others”, while recording that the period of six months specified
under the aforesaid notification needs to be treated as directory in nature.
Relevant paras-13 & 19 of the aforesaid decision dated 20.12.2023 are
re-produced hereunder:[13]
An examination of sub-clauses (i) to (iii) of Annuity Scheme, as
specified under Clause-4, reveals that there is no exclusion clause in this
policy and all the landowner, whose land has been acquired by the State are
eligible for the benefits under this policy. In clause (vii), it has been stipulated
that landowner would be required to submit the Annuity claim in the prescribed
form (application form-2), alongwith the supporting documents, within a period
of six months of the Award, though no consequences have been provided, in
case a landowner fails to submit his application within 6 months and thus, any
such condition, at best, has to be considered and treated as directory in
nature.
[19]
Thus, in the absence of any consequences being provided, if the
application with regard to grant of annuity benefits is filed beyond a period of
TEJWINDER SINGH
2026.05.29 16:43
I agree to specified portions
of this document
CWP-39172-2025
six (06) months of the award; and specifically taking into consideration the fact
that it is a beneficial policy implemented by the Government on account of
being a welfare State, and the condition being merely related to a procedure,
this condition cannot be considered as a mandatory condition. At best, if
landowner applies for the benefits under this Scheme after a delay despite of
being specifically informed in this regard, State could withhold the amount of
annuity schemes pertaining to specific years only and not for the entire
duration of 33 years.”
9.
Furthermore, even the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court vide
decision dated 01.12.2016 passed in CWP No. 3123 of 2016, titled
“Jagdish Rai and others Versus State of Haryana and others”,
directed the respondents to grant annuity benefits in favour of the
landowner despite their claim being rejected by the authorities on the
ground that the applications were submitted beyond six months. The
aforesaid decision dated 01.12.2016 being relevant is extracted
hereunder:“ Petitioner are residents of villages Kanheli & Mania, Tehsil & District
Rohtak. Their land was acquired vide Award dated 04.01.2011 for
development of Sector 25 at Rohtak. As per R&R Policy of the State
Government, they are entitled to be paid `Annuity'. The instant writ petition has
been filed alleging that for two years they were paid the `Annuity amount' but
thereafter it was stopped without assigning any reason. Land Acquisition
Collector has filed the reply-affidavit taking a plea that payment of `Annuity'
was stopped as the petitioner did not allegedly submit the application form
within six months.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties. The plea taken by the
Land Acquisition Collector appears to be a lame excuse for his failure to
release the ‘Annuity' to which the petitioner are admittedly entitled to in lieu of
acquired land. The application form, if any, ought to have been obtained by the
Land Acquisition Collector in the very beginning.
Once the Authority started paying `Annuity', there could possibly be no
occasion for the petitioner to submit further applications. We, thus, dispose of
this writ petition with a direction that the arrears of `Annuity' be released to the
petitioner alongwith interest @ 7% per annum within three months from the
date of receipt of certified copy of this order. Hitherto also the `Annuity' shall be
paid to the petitioner uninterruptedly and in the event of any delay, they shall
TEJWINDER SINGH
2026.05.29 16:43
I agree to specified portions
of this document
CWP-39172-2025
be entitled to interest @7% per annum which shall be personally recoverable
from the Officers/officials found responsible for such delay.
10.
In view of the aforesaid position of law and the respondents
having failed to discharge their statutory obligation towards the release of
annuity benefits granted under the Award are directed to disburse the
same in favour of the landowner/petitioner within two months from today
without waiting for any application been made in this regard by the
landowner.
11.
Furthermore, the award in the present case was passed on
04.07.2014 and the possession of the acquired land was taken by the
respondents on the same very date. However, the payment was released
in favour of the petitioner only on 06.10.2015. Initially, the compensation
was withheld to the petitioner as he had applied for the benefit under the
Land Pooling Scheme in terms of the specific stipulation made in the
award dated 04.07.2014 by the LAC. Significantly, in his cross
examination, the LAC has himself admitted that despite the fact that
certain landowners had applied under the said scheme, no record thereof
was available on file. He further conceded that the scheme was
subsequently
rendered
inapplicable
to
Sector
10,
being
partly
commercial in nature, however, no intimation regarding such nonapplicability was ever communicated to the landowner.
12.
Apparently, on account of specific stipulation been made in
the award dated 04.07.2014 by the LAC regarding extension of the
benefit of land pooling to the landowner, the respondents misguided and
misrepresented him by making him apply under the aforesaid scheme.
Thereafter, the respondents kept the said applications pending for years
together, neither taking any decision thereupon nor informing the
landowner that the said policy had, in fact, been rendered inapplicable to
the acquisition proceedings in question. In such circumstances, the delay
in disbursal of compensation in favour of the landowner is purely
attributable to the respondents and thus they are found obligated to pay
interest to the landowner/petitioner from the date of award i.e.
04.07.2014 till the date of actual release of payment i.e. 06.10.2015, in
accordance with Section 34 of the Act.
TEJWINDER SINGH
2026.05.29 16:43
I agree to specified portions
of this document
13.
CWP-39172-2025
In view of the discussion made hereinabove, the present writ
petition is allowed. Petitioner/landowner are held entitled for award of
annuity benefits in terms of Notification/Policy dated 09.11.2010 issued
by the Revenue and Disaster Management Department, Haryana
Government. Further, the petitioner/landowner is also held entitled for
release of statutory interest in his favour for the delay period i.e. from
04.07.2014 which is the date of taking over of possession of land till
06.10.2015 i.e. the date of disbursal of compensation.
14.
Pending misc. application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed
of.
22.05.2026
Tejwinder
TEJWINDER SINGH
2026.05.29 16:43
I agree to specified portions
of this document
(HARKESH MANUJA)
JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned
Yes/No
Whether reportable
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review