Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment reserved on: 22.04.2026
Judgment delivered on: 03.07.2026
Judgment uploaded on: As per Digital Signature~
LPA 65/2014
NTPC LTD
.....Appellant
versus
M P TIWARI AND ORS
+
.....Respondents
LPA 759/2014
MP TIWARI
.....Appellant
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS
.....Respondents
Advocates who appeared in this case
For the NTPC
:
Mr. Rajesh Gupta, Advocate.
For M P Tiwari
:
Ms. Richa Kapoor, Mr. Kunal Anand and
Ms. Aditi Rathore, Advocates
For the UOI
:
Ms. Radhika Bishwajit Dubey, Mr. Vivek
Sharma, Advocates for UOI.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
JUDGMENT
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J.
1.
These cross intra Court appeals have been filed, whereby, National
Thermal Power Corporation (for short ‘NTPC’) has challenged the order
dated 06.11.2013 in W.P.(C) No.6521/1998 in LPA 65/2014 and M.P.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 65 and 759 of 2014
Tiwari has challenged the order dated 22.08.2014 in LPA 759/2014 whereby
the learned Single Judge has dismissed his application for modification of
order dated 06.11.2013.
2.
The learned Single Judge vide order dated 06.11.2013 has allowed the
aforesaid writ petition by stating in paragraphs 10 to 12 the following
manner:“10. I may also note that there is no delay and laches in
filing this petition because once the recommendations of
DPC became final, and documents were issued in the office
of respondent no.3 itself to this effect, and filed at running
pages 286-287 showing that petitioner was in fact promoted
as an Assistant Engineer w.e.f 1.7.1983, I would not like to
hold the petition as barred by delay and laches unless there
was a specific refusal issued to the petitioner denying the
benefits of the post of Assistant Engineer, and only when
cause of action would have accrued to the petitioner to
approach the Court. In the absence of any refusal addressed
to the petitioner, that he would not be promoted to the post
of Assistant Engineer in spite of his being put on the merit
list panel as per the DPC of February, 1984, there was no
need of the petitioner to approach the Court, albeit the
petitioner will only be entitled to monetary emoluments for
the promoted post for a period not more than three years
prior to filing of the present writ petition.
11. The issue then arises is that what should be the relief
which should be granted to the petitioner in this case. I have
put to learned senior counsel for the petitioner, and who has
accordingly taken instructions from the petitioner who is
present in Court, that petitioner will be satisfied on his
getting 1/3rd of the monetary emoluments as payable to an
Assistant Engineer for 3 years prior to filing of the present
writ petition. This entitlement of 1/3rd of the monetary
emoluments as payable to the Assistant Engineer will of
course be payable till the time the petitioner retired on
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 65 and 759 of 2014
30.6.2003. Therefore, applying the ratio of E.K. Bhaskaran
Pillai’s case (supra) I hold that in the facts of the present
case since petitioner without any fault of his has been
denied the promotion post of Assistant Engineer, and at no
point of time the petitioner refused to work at the post of
Assistant Engineer, petitioner will be entitled to 1/3rd of
monetary emoluments payable for the post of Assistant
Engineer for the period of 3 years prior to the filing of the
writ petition and till the date of his retirement on 30.6.2003.
12. In view of the above, the writ petition is allowed.
Petitioner will be granted 1/3rd of the monetary emoluments
payable to him as if he was an Assistant Engineer for the
period of 3 years prior to the filing of the writ petition and
which monetary emoluments will be payable till the
retirement of the petitioner on 30.6.2003. The monetary
package be paid to the petitioner within a period of three
months from today, and if not paid within three months, then
petitioner thereafter will be entitled to interest at 7 ½ % per
annum simple till the amount is paid. Parties are left to bear
their own costs.”
3.
In LPA 65/2024, the NTPC has challenged the decision of the
learned Single Judge on its merit whereby the NTPC was directed to
promote M.P. Tiwari to the post of Assistant Engineer as per the
recommendation of the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) held in
the month of February 1984 and granted 1/3rd of the monetary emoluments
payable to him on his promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer for the
period three years prior to the date of filing of the writ petition.
4.
In LPA 759/2014, M.P. Tiwari has challenged the order whereby the
learned Single Judge has dismissed the application seeking modification of
the order dated 06.11.2013 in the manner that he has not given any consent
regarding the emoluments to the extent of 1/3rd of the sum payable to him
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 65 and 759 of 2014
for the period of three years prior to the date of filing of the writ petition.
5.
The facts as noted are that, M.P. Tiwari had earlier worked in the
Indian Air Force and joined the Badarpur Thermal Power Station (BTPS) in
the year 1972. However, on the project coming to an end, and on account of
a settlement between the workers and the management, M.P. Tiwari was
relieved from his duties as Electrician from BTPS and joined the NTPC on
the post of Operator. On the recommendation of the Departmental
Promotion Committee (DPC), he was appointed Foreman Grade-III in the
pay scale of Rs.425-700, with effect from 01.07.1977 with a probation
period of two years. He was designated as Forman Grade-III (Temporary).
Vide agreement dated 12.04.1978; the management of BTPS was transferred
/ handed over to NTPC. In a pending Industrial Dispute, a settlement was
arrived at and the workmen (employees) were absorbed in NTPC. M.P.
Tiwari was offered regular employment on the post of Foreman Grade-III
vide letter dated 20/21.11.1978, which was accepted by M.P. Tiwari vide his
letter dated 16.04.1979.
In that sense, M.P. Tiwari became a regular
employee of the NTPC on the post of Foreman Grade-III. He was later
promoted to Foreman Grade II and thereafter Foreman Grade I.
6.
His case was forwarded to the DPC for consideration for promotion as
Assistant Engineer. As part of the offer, his name was included in 31 names
sent to the DPC for consideration. He was called for test and interview on
02/03.02.1984 for the post of Assistant Engineer, which he qualified. The
DPC recommended his selection with effect from 01.07.1983. The selection
process for the said post was concluded on 7/8.02.1984.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 65 and 759 of 2014
7.
According to him, despite his name being in the select list as a
successful candidate, he was denied promotion. Being aggrieved, he filed
the aforesaid writ petition, seeking promotion as Assistant Engineer with
effect from 01.07.1983.
8.
The plea of the NTPC before the learned Single Judge was that, M.P.
Tiwari is not entitled for promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer
because he had not accepted the terms of settlement as conveyed vide letter
dated 08.06.1984. On the contrary, he had modified the terms vide letter
dated 18.06.1984. In other words, M.P. Tiwari had not accepted the terms of
the settlement which disentitle him to seek promotion to the post of
Assistant Engineer.
9.
The learned Single Judge in paragraphs 7 to 12 of the impugned order
dated 06.11.2013, has held that:“7. In my opinion, the argument urged on behalf of
respondent no.3 by contending that since there was no
finality to the terms and conditions of the settlement in view
of the letter dated 8.6.1984 of the respondent no.3 and the
response thereto of the petitioner dated 18.6.1984, is an
argument without merit inasmuch as the promotion of a
person takes place not because of the exchange of
correspondence but because of that person being successful
in the selection process for the post in question. Petitioner,
as stated above, was successful for being promoted to the
post of Assistant Engineer in terms of the selection process
of February 1984 and therefore even if there was no
settlement as is being contended by respondent no.3 that
will not take away the finality of the recommendations of the
DPC. Once the recommendations of the DPC are final then
all the necessary consequences thereof flow including of
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 65 and 759 of 2014
giving the petitioner promotion to the post of Assistant
Engineer, and which promotion post has been given to
various other persons in terms of the selection process of
February, 1984. At best, if the settlement was not final,
however that settlement only will not be final, but the same
cannot mean that the recommendations of DPC are also not
final. Recommendations of DPC are necessarily final, and
all that I may state is that it is not even the case of
respondent no.3 as per the pleadings in this Court that the
recommendations of DPC are not final, more so because
various other persons have been promoted to the posts of
Assistant Engineers in terms of the same recommendations
of the DPC.
8. The issue then arises is that has the petitioner refused
appointment to the promotion post of the Assistant Engineer
as argued on behalf of respondent no. 3 by refusing to join
the place of posting. Even this argument is without merit
because there is admittedly no promotion order issued
against the petitioner asking him to join at a particular
place. If the petitioner in terms of the promotion order had
refused to join at a particular place and that was the precondition to the grant of promotion, then the respondent
no.3 could have argued before me that petitioner is
estopped from claiming promotion to the post of Assistant
Engineer, but once no promotion order or any other order
is issued against the petitioner asking him to join at a
particular place then I fail to understand how failure of the
petitioner to join at a particular place can be taken against
the petitioner to deny him benefit of the selection which
became final in terms of the DPC of February 1984.
9. So far as the issue of application of principle of 'no pay
for no work is concerned', this has been clarified by the
Supreme Court in the judgment of State of Kerala & Ors.
Vs. E.K. Bhaskaran Pillai (2007) 6 SCC 524 wherein
Supreme Court has said that principle of 'no pay for no
work' is not an absolute principle and it depends on facts of
each case as to what reliefs can be granted to a person. It
has been held that the rule of 'no pay for no work' is not an
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 65 and 759 of 2014
inflexible rule and if a person because of fault of the
management is denied the benefit of promotion post it
cannot be held that the person will not be entitled to benefits
of the particular post. The ratio of this judgment will
squarely apply because there is no fault attributable to the
10. I may also note that there is no delay and laches in filing
this petition because once the recommendations of DPC
became final, and documents were issued in the office of
respondent no.3 itself to this effect, and filed at running
pages 286-287 showing that petitioner was in fact promoted
as an Assistant Engineer w.e.f 1.7.1983, I would not like to
hold the petition as barred by delay and laches unless there
was a specific refusal issued to the petitioner denying the
benefits of the post of Assistant Engineer, and only when
cause of action would have accrued to the petitioner to
approach the Court. In the absence of any refusal addressed
to the petitioner, that he would not be promoted to the post
of Assistant Engineer in spite of his being put on the merit
list panel as per the DPC of February, 1984, there was no
need of the petitioner to approach the Court, albeit the
petitioner will only be entitled to monetary emoluments for
the promoted post for a period not more than three years
prior to filing of the present writ petition.
11. The issue then arises is that what should be the relief
which should be granted to the petitioner in this case. I have
put to learned senior counsel for the petitioner, and who has
accordingly taken instructions from the petitioner who is
present in Court, that petitioner will be satisfied on his
getting 1/3rd of the monetary emoluments as payable to an
Assistant Engineer for 3 years prior to filing of the present
writ petition. This entitlement of 1/3rd of the monetary
emoluments as payable to the Assistant Engineer will of
course be payable till the time the petitioner retired on
30.6.2003. Therefore, applying the ratio of E.K. Bhaskaran
Pillai's case (supra) I hold that in the facts of the present
case since petitioner without any fault of his has been
denied the promotion post of Assistant Engineer, and at no
point of time the petitioner refused to work at the post of
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 65 and 759 of 2014
Assistant Engineer, petitioner will be entitled to 1/3 rd of
monetary emoluments payable for the post of Assistant
Engineer for the period of 3 years prior to the filing of the
writ petition and till the date of his retirement on 30.6.2003.
12. In view of the above, the writ petition is allowed.
Petitioner will be granted 1/3rd of the monetary emoluments
payable to him as if he was an Assistant Engineer for the
period of 3 years prior to the filing of the writ petition and
which monetary emoluments will be payable till the
retirement of the petitioner on 30.6.2003. The monetary
package be paid to the petitioner within a period of three
months from today, and if not paid within three months, then
petitioner thereafter will be entitled to interest at 7½ % per
annum simple till the amount is paid. Parties are left to bear
their own costs.”
(emphasis supplied)
10.
The claim of M.P. Tiwari to grant promotion by limiting benefits to
1/3rd of the monetary emoluments as payable to the post of Assistant
Engineer for three years prior to the date of the filing of the writ petition, is
clear from paragraphs 10 & 11 of the impugned order. The learned Single
Judge has noted that, M.P. Tiwari was recommended for promotion by the
DPC to the post of Assistant Engineer w.e.f 01.07.1983, which was required
to be implemented by the NTPC. It is on that basis the learned Single Judge
has disposed of the writ petition. Hence, in these facts, the challenge by
NTPC is devoid of any merit.
11.
One of the submissions on behalf of M.P. Tiwari is that the learned
Single Judge should not have confined the claim of monetary emoluments as
he is entitled to the benefits upto the post of Deputy General Manager in
terms of the relief sought in the amendment application being CM
No.2195/2013, which was allowed by the learned Single Judge.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 65 and 759 of 2014
12.
According to him, the writ petition was disposed of without
considering his prayer. He stated that, he had filed an application being C.M.
No. 8820/2014 seeking modification of the relief that, he be given the
monetary benefits upto the post of Deputy General Manager on the basis of
the promotions that would accrue in his favour from time to time from
22.07.1977 (i.e., the date when the Govt. of India had recognised the
examination qualified by the petitioner in the Trade of Electrical
Engineering as Diploma Course). In this regard, we reproduce the impugned
order dated 22.08.2014, wherein, the learned Single Judge has from
paragraph 5 onwards, has held as under:“5. Consent of the petitioner to the period of the grant of the
monetary emoluments is found in para 1of the judgment
dated 06.11.2013, and which reads as under
"1. Irrespective of the cause of action pleaded in
the writ petition and the prayer made in the same,
before me today on behalf of the petitioner what is
argued and relief claimed, is the entitlement of the
petitioner to stand promoted as an Assistant
Engineer with the respondent no.3/employer in
terms of the selection process of February 1984.
Since the petitioner has retired on 30.6.2003, a
higher monetary emolument package taking the
petitioner as having been promoted w.e.f 1.7.1983
as an Assistant Engineer is claimed. During the
course of argument it is agreed that the monetary
package to the petitioner be granted from a
period of three years prior to filing of the present
writ petition and till the petitioner retired i.e on
30.6.2003."
6. The petitioner claims that he never gave his consent to his
counsel who had appeared and argued the case on
06.11.2013, and in support of this plea a reason given is
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 65 and 759 of 2014
that the petitioner is very old and slightly hard of hearing
and so he did not 'understand' what his earlier counsels told
him, however, I am constrained to observe that the
averments now being made against the earlier counsels that
no consent was taken is clearly and unfortunately a
dishonest act on the part of the petitioner. In many cases,
courts simply record the statement of the counsel without
recording specific instructions of the litigant, but in this
case, the specific instructions given by the petitioner who
was present in person on 06.11.2013 were recorded while
pursuing the judgment. Therefore, the endeavour of the
petitioner, especially at a long time after 06.11.2013 to
withdraw from a specific consent is absolutely unacceptable
and smacks of malafides.
7. Learned counsel for the petitioner/applicant very
vehemently sought to canvass that actually the petitioner
will end up paying a huge amount to the respondent even if
the writ petition is allowed, but I have totally failed to
understand this argument because if petitioner's writ
petition is allowed and he has been granted promotion,
surely he will get the higher pay of the promotion post and it
is not petitioner's case and cannot be his case that the pay
scale of the higher promotion post is lower than the lower
post. If however there is an issue of satisfaction of the dues
of the petitioner in terms of the judgment dated 06.11.2013,
ie whether the petitioner has received monetary benefits
granted to him by the judgment dated 06.11.2013, the same
will be an issue to be looked into an appropriate
proceeding, but definitely not by this review petition.
8. Dismissed.”
13.
At this stage, we reproduce the prayers made by M.P. Tiwari in CM
APPL. 8820/2014, in the following manner:“a) allow the present application;
b) modify that part of the impugned judgment and order
dated 06.11.2013 of this Hon'ble Court in W.P. (Civil) No.
6521 of 1998, whereby this Hon'ble Court did not extend
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 65 and 759 of 2014
any monetary benefit to the applicant petitioner beyond the
post of Assistant Engineer and moreover granted the
monetary benefits to the applicant-petitioner even to the
post of Assistant Engineer only 1/3rd of the monetary
benefits payable to him to the said post from 3 years prior to
the filing of the said writ petition by the applicant-petitioner
(i.e., the year 1995) till his superannuation on 30.6.2003
and substitute the relief that in the facts and circumstances
of the present case, the applicant-petitioner would be
entitled of the monetary benefits payable to him from the
post of Asstt. Controller upto the post of Deputy General
Manager respectively in terms of promotional benefits
accrued in his favour from time to time from
22.07.1977(i.e., the date when the Govt. of India had
recognized the examination qualified by the petitioner in the
Trade of Electrical Engineering as Diploma Course) till his
superannuation.
c) direct The R nos. 2 and 3 to clear up applicantpetitioner’s entire monetary benefits payable to him from
the post of Asstt. Engineer up to the post of Deputy General
Manager accrued in his favour from time to time till his
superannuation on 30.6.2003 in terms of promotional
benefits accrued in his favour from time to time w.e.f.
01.07.1983;
d) award cost of the litigation in favour of the applicantpetitioner and against the R nos. 2 and 3
e) pass such other/further order/direction as this Hon'ble
Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and
circumstances of the present case.”
(emphasis supplied)
14.
Suffice to state, no prayer has been made by M.P. Tiwari seeking
promotion upto the post of Deputy General Manager. In the absence of any
prayer made, M.P. Tiwari could not have been given emoluments as payable
on the posts upto Deputy General Manager. Promotion(s) being a prerequisite to get emoluments, the learned Single Judge has rightly granted the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 65 and 759 of 2014
emoluments as payable to the post of Assistant Engineer only because he
was recommended by DPC for promotion to said the post. There is no such
recommendation to the posts upto Deputy General Manager by the DPC.
Therefore, the impugned order dated 22.08.2014 passed by the learned
Single Judge is justified in the facts.
15.
The plea of M.P. Tiwari that, he has not consented to limiting his
monetary emoluments to 1/3rd for the post of Assistant Engineer has been
rightly rejected by the learned Single Judge.
16.
In view of our above discussions, we find no merit in both the
appeals. Accordingly, they are dismissed.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
JULY 03, 2026
M
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
11:13:37
LPA 65 and 759 of 2014
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review