Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 20-02-2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE M. NIRMAL KUMAR
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
AND
CRL MP Nos.2183 and 2184 of 2026
NR. Raghuraman
S/o.Late. Narayana Rao,
Having Office at Flat No.L4C,
1st Floor, Indira Nagar,
Second Avenue, 6th Cross Street,
Adyar, Chennai - 600 020.
Petitioner(s)/A4
Vs
1. State Rep. by,
The Deputy Superintendent of Police,
Central Bureau of Investigation,
Anti-Corruption Branch (ACB),
Chennai.
2.Aswath Durai Selvam DC
Regional Manager,
State Bank of India,
Regional Business Office,
No.27/8, Kaushikan Complex,
Kamarajar Street, West Tambaram,
Chennai - 600 064.
Respondent(s)
CRL MP No. 2183 of 2026
1. NR. Raghuraman
S/o.Late. Narayana Rao, Having Office
1/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
at Flat No.L4C, 1st Floor, Indira Nagar,
Second Avenue, 6th Cross Street,
Adyar, Chennai - 600 020.
Petitioner(s)
Vs
1. State Rep. by, The Deputy
Superintendent of Police,
Central Bureau of Investigation, AntiCorruption Branch (ACB), Chennai.
2.Aswath Durai Selvam DC
Regional Manager, State Bank of India,
Regional Business Office, No.27/8,
Kaushikan Complex, Kamarajar Street,
West Tambaram, Chennai - 600 064.
Respondent(s)
CRL MP No. 2184 of 2026
1. NR. Raghuraman
S/o.Late. Narayana Rao, Having Office
at Flat No.L4C, 1st Floor, Indira Nagar,
Second Avenue, 6th Cross Street,
Adyar, Chennai - 600 020.
Petitioner(s)
Vs
1. State Rep. by, The Deputy
Superintendent of Police,
Central Bureau of Investigation, AntiCorruption Branch (ACB), Chennai.
2.Aswath Durai Selvam DC
Regional Manager, State Bank of India,
Regional Business Office, No.27/8,
Kaushikan Complex, Kamarajar Street,
West Tambaram, Chennai - 600 064.
Respondent(s)
2/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
PRAYER: Criminal Original Petition filed under Section 528 of BNSS, 2023
praying to call for the records in Charge Sheet in C.C.No.2229 of 2025 on the
file of Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Egmore, Chennai and quash
the same.
For Petitioner :
Mr.Mukunth, Senior Counsel
For Mr.K.Venkatasubban for
M/s.Sarvabhauman Associates
For Respondent-1:
Mr.K.Srinivasan
Special Public Prosecutor (CBI Cases)
ORDER
The petitioner/A4 in C.C.No.2229 of 2025 facing trial along with five
others for offence under Sections 120-B r/w 420 of I.P.C., filed this quash
petition.
2.The learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner submitted that in this
case, the petitioner an approved valuer having wide range of services including
international valuation, bank approved valuation, Chartered Civil Engineering
and Class-1A Panel of Engineering services. The petitioner is one of the Panel
valuers of the second respondent/bank, namely, State Bank of India (SBI). In
December, 2016, one Jayagiri, a Loan Counsellor for various banks approached
the petitioner for valuation assignments. During the said period, the petitioner
3/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
completed more than 40 assignments sourced through him, one of them
pertained to the valuation of assets belonging to M/s.Duraiappa & Co. The
petitioner raised invoice for a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- for the service rendered for
valuing 15 properties belonging to S.Murugan and Gopal, the partners of
M/s.Duraiappa & Co, including the following properties:
a. Property measuring an extent of 5390 sq.ft. of land
with a residential building at Door No.425, MKN Road,
Adambakkam Village, Alandur, Chennai.
b. Property measuring an extent of 3200 sq.ft. along with
920 sq.ft. Of undivided share of land at Sri Duraiappa Complex,
New Door No.20, Old No.38, Karpaga Vinayagar Koil Street,
Alandur, Chennai.
c. Residential Flat measuring 4050 sq.ft. at Door No.38,
Flat No.S-1, II and III Floor, Sri Duraiappa Complex, Karpaga
Vinayagar Koil Street, Alandur, Chennai.
It was Jayagiri, who was actively involved in arranging loans for his clients. The
petitioner on the request of Jayagiri given a valuation report dated 28.02.2017
for the subject property to SBI, Alandur Branch, SBI, Uthiramerur Branch and
4/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
SME, Thirumudivakkam Branch. The said Jayagiri was well known to various
bank officials. According to the petitioner, the valuation report was given in the
year 2017. Thereafter loanees availed loan on 20.06.2017 and later the loan
account became NPA on 28.02.2019. Three years thereafter, the defacto
complainant, Regional Manager, SBI to absolve Bank officials for their
misdeeds, made false complaint as though the valuation given by the petitioner
was not commensurate to the real value of the property. Hence, F.I.R. registered
on 29.12.2022 and thereafter charge sheet filed in this case on 17.04.2024 and
taken on file in C.C.No.2229 of 2025.
3.The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the petitioner is
having experience of several decades in valuation and so far his report has not
come under any adverse scrutiny. In this case A1, a borrower diverted the loan
amount availed, to A2 and it is alleged that amount was siphoned out and they
have not repaid loan. After loan became NPA, a case projected as though the
petitioner gave an inflated false report. The petitioner’s report does not form the
sole basis for granting loan. The petitioner’s report is scrutinised by the bank
officials and the bank officials conduct physical verification on the property and
to act on the report. The bank officials if found that the report of the petitioner
to be inflated they can reject the report but having considered the report and
5/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
after independent scrutiny acted on the report and now projecting the report is
false, is not proper and that to, after the account became NPA. In this case the
petitioner is primarily charged for offence of conspiracy. There is no iota of
material to show that petitioner at any point of time met or had acquaintance
with A1 and A2, the borrowers in this case. It is the Loan Counsellor Jayagiri
who approached the petitioner and none else. Further valuing the property is a
subjective satisfaction of the individual and it depends upon various factors. The
subjective satisfaction may vary between person to person and now claiming
that the Bank engaged one D.Parthasarathy and A.Shoba to value the same
property who gave different valuation report. It is pertinent to note that CPWD
valued the property and gave valuation which is much less than the valuation
given by the bank appointed valuers, which would confirm subjective
satisfaction varies, and now it is blown out of proportion. Since the loan became
NPA, the petitioner is being prosecuted. In the absence of any material to even
remotely infer that the petitioner conspired with the main accused, charging him
along with the other accused in this case is nothing but an improper
investigation and victimisation. Utmost the petitioner could have been a good
witness to speak about valuation and in any event not as an accused. Hence,
prayed to quash the charge sheet.
6/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
4.The learned Special Public Prosecutor filed his counter and refers to
para (g) and (j) of the counter, which are extracted hereunder:
“(g) The assertion that valuation standards and market
factors were duly followed is a disputed and contentious question
of fact. Whether the valuation adhered to prescribed norms or was
deliberately skewed is a matter requiring detailed evidence and
expert examination, which cannot be adjudicated in proceedings
seeking quashment. Significantly, the petitioner assessed the land
value of all three properties at an exorbitant rate of ₹20,000/- to
₹22,500/- per sq. ft. during February-March 2017, without any
justifiable basis. In stark contrast, Shri Sadasivam, s/o Shri S.R.
Varadhan (LW-24), who valued a comparable property situated in
the very same locality, assessed the land value at ₹9,375/- per
sq. ft. based on prevailing market rates as on 24.04.2017 (Doc
No.164). Further, the oral evidence of Shri R.Shyam Sundar
(LW-2), coupled with documentary evidence in the form of
subsequent
independent
valuation
reports,
reinforces
the
abnormality of the petitioner's valuation-Shri D.Parthasarathy
(Doc Nos. 44, 51 & 59) valued the property at ₹13,000/- per sq. ft.
as on August 2021, while Smt.A.Shoba (Doc Nos. 45, 52 & 58)
assessed it at ₹12,500/- per sq. ft. on 11.09.2021. These stark and
unexplained disparities prima facie demonstrate that the
petitioner's valuation was grossly inflated, raising serious and
triable issues and conclusively ruling out any interference under
Section 482 CrPC/528 BNSS.
7/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
(j) At the stage of framing of charge or consideration of a
petition for quashment, the prosecution is not required to establish
guilt beyond reasonable doubt. It is sufficient if the charge sheet
discloses prima facie material indicating the involvement of the
petitioner in the transaction. In the present case, the charge sheet
contains ample material demonstrating the petitioner's role. The
mere absence of direct evidence of forgery does not preclude the
commission of offences under Sections 120-B and 420 IPC, which
can be established through circumstantial and corroborative
evidence. The investigation has revealed that Shri.Sadasivam, son
of Shri S. R. Varadhan (LW-24), who valued a comparable property
situated in the very same locality, assessed the land value at
₹9,375/- per sq. ft. based on the prevailing market rates as on
24.04.2017 (Document No.164). Further, the oral evidence of Shri
R.Shyam Sundar (LW-2), read in conjunction with documentary
evidence in the form of subsequent independent valuation reports,
clearly establishes the abnormality of the petitioner's valuation. In
this regard, Shri D.Parthasarathy assessed the value of the
property at ₹13,000/-per sq. ft. as on August 2021 (Document Nos.
44, 51 and 59), while Smt.A.Shoba assessed the value at ₹12,500/per sq. ft. as on 11.09.2021 (Document Nos. 45, 52 and 58).
Further, the oral evidence of Shri Mallikarjuna, Assistant Engineer,
CPWD (LW-230), coupled with documentary evidence (Document
Nos. 171 to 174), would clearly establish that the valuation
furnished
by
the
petitioner
was
exorbitant
disproportionate to the prevailing market value.”
8/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
and
grossly
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
5.The learned Special Public Prosecutor further submitted that from the
statement of witnesses and documents it is clear that the petitioner inflated, gave
valuation report, facilitating A1 and A2 to avail loan more than their eligibility.
Added to it, loan account now became NPA and further in the charge sheet the
inflation has been given by way of a tabulation for each property.
9/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
6.Thus the prosecution collected sufficient materials and filed the charge
report, conspiracies are hatched in secrecy which cannot be apparent and it has
to be only found out or infer during the trial. Hence, the contention of the
petitioner can be decided during trial not in this quash petition.
10/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
7.Considering the submission made and on perusal of the materials, it is
seen that the points raised by the petitioner are disputed facts. Though the
valuation report are subjective satisfaction of the valuer, there cannot be
abnormality in the valuation report. As could be seen from the tabulation report,
vast difference between the valuation given by the petitioner and by the valuers
appointed by the bank and by the CPWD officials found. These facts has to be
necessarily considered during trial and not in this quash petition. Hence, this
Court is not inclined to entertain this petition.
8.In view of the same, the Criminal Original Petition stands dismissed. It
is made clear that the observations made herein are only to the limited purpose
in deciding the above petition. The petitioner is at liberty to raise all points
during trial. The trial Court to independently consider the case and dispose of
the same on its own merits, uninfluenced by the observations made herein.
Consequently, the connected Criminal Miscellaneous Petitions are closed.
20-02-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking / Non-speaking order
rsi
11/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
M. NIRMAL KUMAR, J.
rsi
To
1.The Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate,
Egmore, Chennai.
2.The Deputy Superintendent of Police,
Central Bureau of Investigation,
Anti-Corruption Branch (ACB),
Chennai.
3.The Public Prosecutor
High Court, Madras.
CRL OP No. 3148 of 2026
AND
CRL MP Nos.2183 and 2184 of 2026
20.02.2026
12/12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review