Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.04
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No.12/2018
Date of Order: 09.02.2021
North Eastern Hill University
Teachers’ Association & ors
Coram:
Vs.
Union of India & ors
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Biswanath Somadder, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. BK Sharma, Sr.Adv with
Mr. HK Das, Adv
: Mr. R Deb Nath, CGC for R/1
Mr. S Chakrawarty, Sr.Adv with
Ms. A Baruah, Adv for R/2-6
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
Yes/No
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
This appeal arises in respect of a judgment and order dated 20 th
December, 2017, rendered by a learned Single Judge in WP (C) No.186 of
2017 (North Eastern Hill University Teachers’ Association & ors Vs.
Union of India & ors).
The appellants before us were the writ petitioners before the
learned Single Judge.
The appellants/writ petitioners had approached the First Court
essentially against withdrawal of Hill Area Special Allowance (for short,
HASA) which according to them, the teachers and staff of North Eastern
Hill University (for short, NEHU) were receiving since the year 1995. It
was also alleged by the writ petitioners that initially NEHU did not agree on
the proposition to discontinue with HASA, but later the Vice Chancellor of
NEHU attempted to act against the real state of affairs in order to please the
respondent No.1 (Union of India) while bypassing the North Eastern Hill
University Act, 1973 (for short, the Act of 1973) and the Statutes framed
thereunder and even went on to the extent of manipulating the resolution of
the Executive Council.
The matter was considered at length by the learned Single Judge,
which is evident from a plain reading of the impugned judgment and order.
In fact, while dealing with the matter, the learned Single Judge, after
considering the submissions of the parties had framed four issues. Relevant
portion of the impugned judgment and order dated 20th December, 2017 is
set out hereinbelow:“ ..... On the submissions of the parties, the principal questions
arising for determination in this case are: (i) as to whether the
respondent No.4 Vice Chancellor had manipulated the minutes of
the Executive Council and the decision of the Visitor was based
on such manipulated minutes; (ii) as to whether the Visitor has the
power and authority to direct the University to repeal its
Ordinance; (iii) as to whether the Ordinance relating to HASA has
not been repealed by the procedure prescribed by law; and (iv) as
to whether such discontinuance of HASA to the prejudice of the
petitioners has been in violation of the principles of natural
justice?
As regards the first question as to whether the respondent No.4
Vice Chancellor had manipulated the minutes of the Executive
Council, on a comprehension of the facts available on record, this
Court is clearly of the view that such allegations have
unnecessarily been blown out of proportion and there appears no
reason to accept that the respondent No.4 had indulged in any
such act of manipulation. During the course of submissions, in
view of such contentions, this Court had requisitioned the original
records relating to the meetings of the Executive Council. It is
noticed from the record that draft resolution of the meeting dated
15.05.2017 was indeed drawn up, suggestive of the resolution to
take action for repeal of Ordinance while also stating that the
matter be placed before the Academic Council. However, it
appears that after circulation of the draft, the final minutes were
those as drawn and signed on 23.05.2017 whereby, only the
matter was resolved to be placed before the Academic Council. It
remains the fact that the earlier draft resolution was forwarded to
the respondent No. 1, which suggested as if action would be taken
for repeal of Ordinance although, as on the said given date, no
such decision was taken for any action to repeal the Ordinance.
The error was attempted to be rectified by way of the
communication dated 15.06.2017. Be that as it may, in the
opinion of this Court, nothing much turns upon this aspect of the
matter because the entire action was being taken under the
directions of the Visitor and if the Vice Chancellor, in his
understanding had earlier drawn up the draft minutes suggestive
of compliance of the directions of the Visitor, such drafting by
itself cannot be said to be malafide.
Forwarding of such draft minutes in place of correct minutes also
does not carry much relevance because the decision of the Visitor
was not dependent on any such minutes. In fact, the Visitor had
taken his decision even prior to the said meeting of Executive
Council dated 15.05.2017. It is also noticed that the Vice
Chancellor in the first place in his communication dated
27.04.2017 referred to the decision taken by the Executive
Council in its 47th Emergent Meeting and made a request to the
Hon’ble Visitor to reconsider the matter by allowing the NEHU
employees to continue to avail HASA. In the face of the material
available on record, it is difficult to accept the suggestion that the
Vice Chancellor had any otherwise intention in the matter so as to
manipulate the minutes of the Executive Council.
The decisions in the cases of N.K. Singh and Naseem Bano (supra)
on the requirement of specific counter averments as regards
allegation of mala fide do not make out a case for any finding
against the respondent No.4. In the given set of facts and
circumstances of the present case, this Court finds no reason to
accept the contention that there had been any manipulation or
mala fide intent on the part of the respondent No.4 Vice
Chancellor. It is also not correct a suggestion on the part of the
petitioners that the decision of the Visitor was based on the
alleged manipulated minutes. Question No.(i) in this case, is
therefore, decided against the petitioners.
Taking up question No.(ii) on the power and authority of the
Visitor, it is not in dispute that the impugned notification dated
14.06.2017 had its genesis in the directions issued by the Hon’ble
President of India in his capacity as a Visitor of NEHU. The
question definitely arises on the scope of the powers of the Visitor
and his authority to issue directions to the Executive Council to
repeal an Ordinance. The rights, powers and authority of the
Visitor are specified in Section 8 of the Act of 1973 that reads as
under:“Visitor 8. (1) The President of India shall be the Visitor of
the University.
(2) The Visitor shall have the right to cause an inspection
to be made by such person or persons as he may direct, of
the University, its buildings, laboratories and equipment,
and of any College or Institution maintained by the
University or admitted to its privileges; and also of the
examinations, teaching and other work conducted or done
by the University and to cause an inquiry to be made in like
manner in respect of any matter connected with the
administration or finances of the University, Colleges or
Institutions.
(3) The Visitor shall, in every case, give notice of his
intention to cause an inspection or inquiry to be made:(a) to the University, if such inspections or inquiry is to be
made in respect of the University, College or Institution
maintained by it, or
(b) to the management of the College or Institution, if the
inspection or inquiry is to be made in respect of a College
or an Institution admitted to the privileges of the
University, and the University or the management, as the
case may be, shall have the right to make such
representations to the Visitor, as it may consider necessary.
(4) After considering the representation, if any, made by the
University or the management, as the case may be, the
Visitor may cause to be made such inspection or inquiry as
is referred to in sub-section (2).
(5) Where any inspection or inquiry has been caused to be
made by the Visitor, the University or the management, as
the case may be, shall be entitled to appoint a
representative who shall have the right to be present and be
heard at such inspection or inquiry.
(6) The Visitor may, if the inspection or inquiry is made in
respect of the University or any College or Institution
maintained by it, address the Vice-Chancellor with
reference to the result of such inspection or inquiry, and the
Vice-Chancellor shall communicate to the Executive
Council the views of the Visitor with such advice as the
Visitor may be pleased to offer upon the action to be taken
thereon.
(7) The Visitor may, if the inspection or inquiry is made in
respect of any College or institution admitted to the
privileges of the University, address the management
concerned through the Vice-Chancellor with reference to
the result of such inspection or inquiry, his views thereon
and such advice as he may be pleased to offer upon the
action to be taken thereon.
(8) The Executive Council or the management, as the case
may be, shall communicate through the Vice- Chancellor to
the Visitor such action, if any, as it is proposed to take or
has been taken upon the result of such inspection or
inquiry.
(9) Where the Executive Council or the management does
not, within a reasonable time, take action to the satisfaction
of the Visitor, the Visitor may, after considering any
explanation furnished or representation made by the
Executive Council or management, issue such directions as
he may think fit and the Executive Council or management,
as the case may be, shall comply with such directions.
(10) Without prejudice to the foregoing provisions of this
section, the Visitor may, by order in writing, annul any
proceeding of the University which is not in conformity
with this Act, the Statutes or Ordinances: Provided that
before making any such order, he shall call upon the
University to show cause why such an order should not be
made, and if any cause is shown within a reasonable time,
he shall consider the same.
(11) The Visitor shall have such other powers as may be
prescribed by the Statutes.”
It has been strenuously argued on behalf of the petitioners that
under sub-Section (2) of Section 8 ibid., the Visitor could cause
an inquiry to be made in the matters of administration and in the
matters of finances which are within the powers and functions of
the Executive Council under the Statute 13 (1) and 13 (2) of the
NEHU Statutes; but then, the matters of legislation like those in
the form of Ordinances are not covered under sub-Section (2) of
Section 8 of the Act of 1973 and hence, directions of the Visitor
to repeal the Ordinance have no statutory validity. This Court is
not inclined to accept these submissions for a variety of reasons.
As noticed, per sub-Section (2) of Section 8 of the Act of 1973 the
Visitor has the powers to cause an inquiry to be made in respect of
any matter connected with the administration or finances of the
University. Any matter like payment of allowance, which has
direct financial implications, cannot be said to be not connected
with the finances of the University. Per sub-Section (6) of Section
8 ibid., the Visitor is entitled to issue advice and the Vice
Chancellor is under obligation to communicate to the Executive
Council the views of the Visitor with such advice. The fact of the
matter remains that under sub-Section (9) of Section 8, the Visitor
has the power to issue such directions as he may think fit if the
Executive Council does not take action on the advice to his
satisfaction; and as per sub-Section (9), the Executive Council has
no option but to comply with the directions, if so issued by the
Visitor. On a purposive reading of the scheme of Section 8 of the
Act, this Court has no hesitation in accepting the contentions on
behalf of the respondents that the Visitor has the power to issue
mandate; and upon issuance of such a mandate, no option is left
with the Executive Council but to comply with the same.
In the present case, the Visitor in the first place got the inquiry
conducted as stated in the initial communication dated
03.04.2017. Then, the process contemplated by sub-Section (6) of
Section 8 of the Act of 1973 was also undertaken and the Visitor
issued his advice. Thereafter, the matter was indeed placed in the
meetings of the Executive Council as also the Academic Council.
The Academic Council resolved to maintain status quo in the
matter and to apprise the Visitor of its proposition to continue
with HASA. Similarly, the Executive Council also resolved to
continue with HASA. The Vice Chancellor indeed made the
request to the Hon’ble Visitor to continue with HASA pursuant to
such resolutions under his communication dated 27.04.2017.
However, the Visitor issued his mandate on 11.05.2017 while not
finding the explanation/representation submitted to him to be
satisfactory.
It is also note worthy that in fact, the Visitor has such overriding
powers per sub-Section (10) of Section 8 that he could annul any
proceeding of the University. Moreover, it is also noticed that the
Visitor has final powers relating to Ordinances too as seen in
Statute 41 and has the powers even to disallow an Ordinance. In
the face of such provisions, it is difficult to say that the Ordinance
in question was beyond the purview of the powers of the Visitor.
Therefore, question No.(ii) is also answered against the
petitioners.
In the given set of facts and circumstances, in the opinion of this
Court, the attempts on the part of Executive Council or Academic
Council to avoid compliance of the Visitor’s mandate were of no
avail. The later resolution of the Academic Council and of the
Executive Council, to the extent not standing in conformity with
the decision of Visitor, were not acceptable to the respondent
No.1 and thus, by the communication dated 12.06.2017, the Vice
Chancellor was rather put under compulsion to take the action as
per Statute 2 (B) (2) of the University by issuing notification for
repealing of the Ordinance OE-10 and with further warning that
failure to comply with the directions of the Visitor and continued
payment of HASA would amount to intentional misappropriation
of Government funds.
In the given set of circumstances, this Court finds no error or
illegality on the part of the Vice Chancellor in issuing the
notification aforesaid. Though it is noticed that the resolution of
the Executive Council dated 14.06.2017 is yet to be placed for
approval and the matter has not been placed before the Academic
Council but in the opinion of this Court, all such steps could
hardly be of any avail in the face of the mandate of the Visitor
that remains binding and overriding in view of the scheme of the
Act of 1973.
In the aforesaid view of the matter, the suggestion that repeal has
not been carried out in the manner prescribed by the statute also
does not make out a case for interference. There is not and there
cannot be any quarrel with the basic proposition that when a
particular action is required by the statute to be taken in a
particular manner, the prescribed manner is to be followed as held
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases of Ambay Cements
and Singhara Singh (supra). However, the said decisions do not
make out a case for interference because the scheme of statute is
required to be read as a whole; and when there are overriding
powers available with the Visitor, the same cannot be ignored.
Question No.(iii) is also answered against the petitioners.
As regards question No.(iv), of course, it appears that by the
decision aforesaid the petitioners are being put to financial
prejudice inasmuch as they would be deprived of receiving HASA
but it cannot be said that for the purpose of dealing with a
particular allowance as earlier allowed over and above other
allowances, any opportunity of hearing was required to be
extended to any person. It may be observed that in the advice and
decision of the Visitor, cogent reasons have been stated for not
continuing with HASA, particularly after availability of SDA and
other benefits pursuant to the recommendations of 6th Pay
Commission. In the opinion of this Court, in the ultimate analysis,
where NEHU is a fully funded University, there is no scope for it
to take any decision in the financial matter, particularly that
relating to HASA, against the advice and mandate of the Visitor.
In the facts and circumstances of the case, the other decisions
referred by the learned counsel for the petitioners for continuance
of particular allowance, proceeding on their own facts, have no
application herein. Question No.(iv) is also answered against the
petitioner.”
While addressing us, the learned senior counsel representing the
appellants/writ petitioners has sought to highlight the manner in which the
Vice Chancellor of NEHU had not only manipulated the minutes of the
Executive Council but also how the decision of the Visitor was based on
such manipulated minutes.
Learned counsel representing NEHU and its authorities including
the Vice Chancellor, on the other hand, has taken us through the operative
portion of the judgment and order in order to highlight as to how the issues,
as sought to be raised by the appellants, have been addressed.
It is now required to be noticed as to how the learned Single Judge
has dealt with the matter. It is evident that during the course of proceeding
before the learned Single Judge, the Court had requisitioned the original
records relating to the meetings of the Executive Council. The records
revealed that a draft resolution of the meeting dated 15 th May, 2017, was
indeed drawn up, suggestive of the resolution to take action for repeal of the
Ordinance while also stating that the matter be placed before the Academic
Council. The learned Single Judge, however, has also noticed that after
circulation of the draft, the final minutes where those that were drawn and
signed on 23rd May, 2017, whereby only the matter was resolved to be
placed before the Academic Council. Even though the fact remains that the
earlier drawn resolution was forwarded to the respondent No.1 (Union of
India), no decision was taken on the basis of the same to repeal the
Ordinance. This has been clearly recorded in the findings of the learned
Single Judge, as quoted hereinbefore. In fact, the learned Single Judge has
observed that this error was even attempted to be rectified by way of a
communication dated 15th June, 2017. The learned Single Judge was also of
the clear opinion that nothing much turns upon this aspect of the matter
because the entire action was being taken under the directions of the Visitor
and if the Vice Chancellor, in his understanding, had earlier drawn up the
draft minutes suggestive of compliance of the directions of the Visitor, such
drafting by itself cannot be said to be malafide. The learned Single Judge
has also held that forwarding of such draft minutes in place of correct
minutes also does not carry much relevance because the decision of the
Visitor was not dependent on any such minutes. The learned Single Judge
has held that, in fact, the Visitor had taken his decision even prior to the
meeting of the Executive Council dated 15th May, 2017. The learned Single
Judge has also taken notice of the fact that the Vice Chancellor, in the first
place, in terms of the communication dated 27th April, 2017, referred to the
decision taken by the Executive Council in its 47 th Emergent Meeting and
made a request to the Visitor to reconsider the matter by allowing the
NEHU employees to continue to avail HASA. The learned Single Judge,
thus, concluded that in the face of the materials available on record, it was
difficult to accept the suggestion that the Vice Chancellor had any
otherwise intention in the matter so as to manipulate the minutes of the
Executive Council.
Before we conclude, we must hasten to add that in an Intra-Court
Mandamus appeal, interference is usually warranted only if palpable
infirmities or perversities are noticed on a plain reading of the impugned
judgment and order. In the facts of the instant case, on a plain reading of the
impugned judgment and order, we did not notice any such palpable
infirmity or perversity. That apart and in any event, the judgment and order
is supported with cogent and justifiable reasons.
For reasons stated above, the impugned judgment and order does
not warrant any interference and the appeal is liable to be dismissed and
stands dismissed accordingly.
(H.S. Thangkhiew)
Judge
(Biswanath Somadder)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
09.02.2021
“Lam AR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review