Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.1
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Arb.A.No.1/2022
Date of Order: 15.03.2023
North Eastern Electric Power
Corporation Ltd. (NEEPCO)
Coram:
Vs.
M/s Om Metal India Ltd. and
JSC Ukrhydromech-Joint Venture
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellant
:
Mr. V.K. Jindal, Sr.Adv with
Mr. V. Kumar, Adv
For the Respondent
:
Mr. A. Kumar, Sr.Adv with
Mr. S. Saraogi, Adv
Mr. S.D. Upadhaya, Adv
Mrs. A. Synrem, Adv
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
It is a matter of deep anguish that government bodies tend to
mindlessly challenge arbitral awards and the Court is sought to be misled
at the appellate stage on matters of fact.
2.
The challenge here, in proceedings under Section 37 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, is to the dismissal of a petition
questioning the propriety of an arbitral award dated April 23, 2017. It is
evident from the award that of the two claims, only the second claim on
account of foreign exchange variation has been allowed. The fundamental
premise of the challenge to the award is that the contractor quoted the price
of materials in Indian rupees and nothing in the price bid of February 2,
2004 indicated any foreign exchange component therein. In short, the
suggestion by the appellant is that since prices had been quoted in Indian
rupees and the goods detailed in the bill of quantities were to be locally
obtained, there could not have been any claim on account of increased price
of the goods supplied as a consequence of the Indian rupee depreciating
against the US dollar or the Euro.
3.
This fundamental premise is completely flawed and is wholly
belied by a certificate issued by the Government of India on May 15, 2006
which indicated that the Kaming Hydro Electric Project (600 MW) was
declared as a mega project. Indeed, the arbitrator proceeded on the basis
that it was a mega project. The certification of the work as a mega project
entailed that no import duty was to be paid on the CIF component of the
goods to be supplied. Implicit in this was the recognition that goods had to
be imported for the purpose and supplied for the project.
4.
That is not the only aberration or the abject falsehood on which
the appellant hangs its case. There is more.
5.
On April 21, 2004, the contractor addressed two letters to the
appellant employer furnishing its alternate price bid. These letters were
issued in response to letters written by the employer requiring an alternate
price bid to be submitted in the event the project was certified as a mega
project. The clear indication in both the letters dated April 21, 2004 was
that steel of various grades of value of Rs.75 crore was to be imported along
with further imported components amounting to Euro 2,105,000 equivalent
to Rs.12 crore as on the relevant date. There is no dispute of the receipt of
such letter. Indeed, as noticed above, the Government of India certified the
power project to be a mega project in May, 2006 and the appellant herein
was aware that foreign goods worth Rs.87 crore as valued in 2004 were to
be supplied by the contractor for the project.
6.
In dealing with the claim on account of the foreign exchange
variation, the arbitrator noticed the pleadings of the parties and the
submission advanced. In such context, paragraph 4.5 of the award is
relevant. Such paragraph records the submission on behalf of the claimantcontractor that it had incurred a loss in excess of Rs.7.42 crore because of
the devaluation of the Indian rupee and the delay in the execution of the
contract and finalisation of design of penstock steel liner which resulted in
a rescheduled procurement of steel liner plates from abroad beyond the
original contract period. The further submission on behalf of the contractor
was that hydraulic cylinders had also to be imported beyond the contract
completion date and the falling rupee resulted in the increase in the cost of
hydraulic cylinders in excess of Rs.1.31 crore.
7.
The award then proceeds to notice that in the letter of April 21,
2004, the contractor had expressly indicated that it would be importing steel
components of value of Rs.75 crore and another set of components of value
of Rs.12 crore. The arbitrator was satisfied that the two components
referred to in the letter dated April 21, 2004 were steel liner plates and
hydraulic cylinders.
8.
On the merits of the claim, the arbitrator held, at paragraph 5.32
of the award, that the claimant was not responsible for the delay in the
completion of the project beyond the stipulated time and that the delay
beyond March 2, 2009 “was attributable to the respondent (the appellant
herein).” The arbitrator then went on to discuss the claim on account of
increased costs of the two components – steel plates and hydraulic cylinders
– and noticed that the original claim put forth on such account of Rs.9.13
crore was reduced to Rs.8.74 crore. This reduction was due to some of the
components having been procured and supplied during the original tenure
of the contract by March 2, 2009, for which the contract prohibited the
contractor from seeking any additional amount. As for the procurement of
the balance quantities of the two components beyond the contemplated
period of the contract, the arbitrator did not find any embargo in the contract
to disentitle the contractor from seeking such amount.
9.
It may do well, in this context, to notice the following lines from
the paragraph 5.27 of the award:
“5.27. ... The respondent (the appellant herein) at the same time
in Paragraph 12 has contended that delay was caused due to
magnitude of work, completion of which depends upon various
factors, such as, political, natural, geographical etc. and hence,
putting the blame, according to the respondent, on it alone for
such delay is apparently vindictive in nature and not in keeping
with the spirit of the contract. The respondent in the written
statement filed did not dispute the contention of the claimant
relating to the dates of issuance of PAC, dates of procurement of
the materials from abroad, the rate of foreign exchange, the
expenditure incurred by the claimant in procuring the materials,
which are to be procured from abroad, as well as the amount of
loss claimed to have been suffered by the claimant. The
contention of the claimant in that regard, therefore, remained uncontroverted.”
(Emphasis supplied)
10.
What is undeniable is that upon going through the records that
have been copiously referred to in the award and the submission of the
parties in support of their pleadings, the arbitrator came to a conclusion that
certain goods were to be supplied by the contractor upon procuring the
same from abroad and that even though the contract prohibited additional
amounts being sought on any account whatsoever if the supply was made
during the contract period, if the supply was made beyond the originally
contracted period, the embargo on the price would no longer operate. The
arbitrator was satisfied that there was a foreign component which was
involved and that the parties were aware of the same, inter alia, as evident
from the letters dated April 21, 2004 issued by the contractor to the
appellant herein.
11.
The appellant has referred to several clauses of the contract,
including clause 74 thereof pertaining to price adjustment/variation. There
are three parts to such clause of the contract: the first pertaining to price
variation on account of labour, the second dealing with price variation of
materials and the third covering fluctuating high-speed diesel prices. In
respect of both materials and high-speed diesel, there are formulae devised
to ascertain the total change in the contract price; and any price variation,
whether to the benefit of the contractor or to the benefit of the employer,
would be adjusted by adding a further component to what the contractor
was to get or by deducting a component from the contractually agreed price.
However, the entirety of clause 74 is governed by the general conditions
indicated at the end, including the stipulation that the clause “shall be
applicable only for the work that is carried out within the contract period
or any extended period attributable to the corporation only.”
12.
It is apparent that the arbitrator noticed that there was a
mechanism in the matrix contract for price variation in the real sense: both
for increase or reduction of price of material. However, clause 74 would be
inapplicable for imported material as the formula therein is founded on the
change in base price with reference to the wholesale price index or the
index in respect of the basket of goods to which the relevant material
belonged. In the absence of any specific clause in the contract expressly
providing for or prohibiting adjustment on account of currency fluctuation
in respect of imported material, the arbitrator was well within his domain
to read the contract to imply that either party would be compensated if it
suffered any prejudice due to currency fluctuation for procuring imported
goods. Further, in terms of the express stipulation in clause 74 quoted in
the immediate previous paragraph, since the extended period of completion
of the work was found to be “attributable to the corporation only”, the
arbitrator quite unexceptionably reasoned that the principle of price
variation recognised in the contract would come into play.
13.
According to the appellant herein, clauses 75 and 76 pertaining
to currency restrictions and rates of exchange were apparently struck out
from the contract as being irrelevant. Such position was accepted by the
arbitrator as is evident from the award. There is also no dispute that the
contract envisaged that the work would be completed within 51 months of
the date of the work order and the parties agree that such time ran out on
March 2, 2009.
14.
Thus, on the basis of the material available before the arbitrator,
particularly the detailed contract and the correspondence exchanged
between the parties which were expressly incorporated as part of the
contract, it was inescapably evident that there were certain foreign
components that were to be procured by the Indo-Ukrainian joint venture
contractor; that a substantial part of such procurement was after the contract
period was over; and, as a result of this delay and the Indian currency falling
against both the US dollar and the Euro, there was considerable increase in
the procurement prices for the imported components. Add to this, the fact
that the delay, in this case, of the work not being completed within the
stipulated time was solely attributable to the employer, the basis for the
second head of claim was established and only the quantum had to be
arithmetically ascertained.
15.
In view of such findings, particularly the one rendered on facts
that the delay was solely attributable to the employer, the arbitrator found
the claim on account of additional expenses for procuring the imported
components as a consequence of the falling rupee to be justified. The
premise and the reasoning are both unquestionable.
16.
There is a slight murmur on the part of the appellant that the
arbitrator apparently accepted the claim on account of the foreign exchange
variation without applying his independent mind to the matter. It may do
well, in this context to refer to the quoted paragraph from the award and the
recording therein that the employer in this case chose not to deal with the
calculations furnished by the contractor for the increased expenses incurred
for procuring the foreign components due to currency fluctuations.
17.
Once a claim is presented, particularly in adversarial
proceedings, it is for the other party to deal with the same in a methodical
manner. If there are several factors which go into the making of a claim,
each of the factors has to be dealt with individually, unless the principal
ground of objection would eliminate the very basis of the claim. Further, if
there are several assertions rolled up in a claim, each component has to be
specifically dealt with. In particular, when the basis of a claim is sought to
be justified by calculations, as in the present case, unless the calculations
are questioned on any reasonable premise, the bare or general denial of the
total amount would not pass muster. In this case, the calculations furnished
by the contractor did not involve any rocket science or advanced
mathematics. The contractor indicated the CIF values of the goods in the
foreign currencies paid therefor and the rates of exchange of the foreign
currencies qua the Indian rupee on the dates of issuance of the letters of
credit as compared to the value of the Indian rupee at the time of making
the bid. The CIF prices of the imported goods were matters of record. If the
contractor inflated the Indian rupee devaluation against the US dollar or the
Euro, the onus to demonstrate such overstated claim was on the appellant
herein. The appellant altogether failed to discharge such onus.
18.
As a consequence, once the arbitrator found that the basis of the
claim was justified, the arbitrator was not required to apply his mind to the
quantum of the claim in the absence of any denial in such regard or the
remotest of dispute being raised. The only situation where the arbitrator
could have looked into the quantum was if it appeared to be palpably absurd
or patently erroneous. Since the total value of the foreign components had
already been indicated to be to the tune of Rs.87 crore as at the time of
furnishing the bid or as at April 21, 2004, the notorious fact that the Indian
currency fell sharply in the interregnum was taken into consideration by the
arbitrator to find that the reduced claim of about Rs.8.74 crore due to the
foreign exchange variation was not absurd or outlandish.
19.
In view of the frivolous nature of the objections to the award
fashioned by the appellant in course of the appeal, the respondent was
constrained to rely on the original agreement and some of the
correspondence exchanged between the parties which were incorporated as
a part of the agreement. Ordinarily, in proceedings under Section 34 of the
Act of 1996 or in the rarified atmosphere under Section 37 when
considering the dismissal of a challenge, the Court is not required to look
into the primary documents or even the details of the agreement between
the parties. If a plausible view appears to have been taken on the face of the
award, the Court does not dig much deeper to seek any justification therefor
because of the limited authority that the Court wields in this jurisdiction.
Much of the time in this case has been wasted upon the appellant’s flawed
assertion that there was no foreign exchange component involved since the
price bid was made in Indian currency and the contract did not envisage
procurement of any component from outside the country.
20.
Whether for the fear of vigilance or for other more disagreeable
reasons, government bodies are disinclined in accepting awards or acting
in accordance therewith. Facile challenges are launched, sometimes based
on untenable or tenuous grounds or on erroneous facts as in the present
case. Much of court time and the tedium involved in sifting the truth from
the rest in such matters can be avoided if government departments adopt a
more rational course of action.
21.
There is no basis to the challenge to the arbitral award. The court
of the first instance acted in accordance with the letter and spirit of Section
34 of the Act to find no fault with the award. At the end of the day, it must
be kept in mind that the Court does not sit in an appeal over an award and
the Court is called upon to interfere with an arbitral award only when it sees
manifest injustice or something which is obviously opposed to public
policy or at blatant variance with the basic tenets of justice as followed in
this country.
22.
For the appellant’s efforts, the appellant will pay a sum of Rs.3
lakh by way of costs in addition to the principal sum awarded and the postaward interest. Such costs should be tendered in three months; in default
whereof it shall carry the same rate of interest as in the award.
23.
Arb.A.No.1 of 2022 is dismissed as aforesaid.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
15.03.2023
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review