The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. Coming to the second impugned order dated 30.05.2023, wherein an application dated 23.03.2023 under Order 21 Rule 29 read with Section 47 CPC, and an application dated 15.03.2023 under Section 36 read with Section 34 of the A&C Act read with Section 151 CPC was filed by the petitioner/judgment debtor for stay of the award dated 05.06.2015, the learned Lower Court, it is seen, held that as per the scheme of Section 36 of the A&C Act, an unconditional stay would be granted only if cases of fraud and corruption are established, and had observed in the impugned order dated 30.05.2023, that the petitioner/judgment debtor had not shown any sufficient cause for stay of the award. Further it is noted that in the order dated 30.05.2023, the learned Commercial Court while rejecting the prayer for unconditional stay, has however provided that in the event the petitioner/judgment debtor deposits the entire award amount in Court within a period of one month, the stay would be considered. As such, in effect the application for stay filed by the petitioner under Section 36 read with Section 34 of A&C Act, subject to fulfillment of the condition for deposit of the awarded amount, is still open for consideration. As such, no orders are therefore necessary or any interference called for, with regard to this order dated 30.05.2023, more so, in consideration of the prevalent law as demonstrated by…
13. In the circumstances therefore, there being no grounds made out, nor the orders suffering from any perversity or grave irregularity, no case has been made out for exercise of powers under Article 227 of the Constitution of India and the instant revision application accordingly stands dismissed.
14. Before parting with the records, as it has also been stated at the bar, that the hearing of Section 34 application is proceeding and is on the final lap, it is therefore expected that the same be disposed of as expeditiously as possible.
15. There shall be no order as to costs. Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
CRP No. 13 of 2023
Date of Decision :21.08.2023
North Eastern Electric
Power Corporation Limited
Vs. M/s Astra Construction Pvt. Ltd.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. V.K. Jindal, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S. Jindal, Adv.
Ms. B. Jyrwa, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. P. Jain, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Yes/No
1.
The brief facts of the case are that on 05.06.2015, an
arbitral award was passed in favour of the respondent, to which the
petitioner filed an application under Section 34 before the learned
Commercial Court on 31.08.2015, for setting aside the said award.
Seven years after the passing of the award, the respondent on
14.12.2022, filed for execution of the award before the Commercial
Court. The maintainability of the petition for execution was raised by
the petitioner on the ground that when the application under Section 34
had been filed on 31.08.2015, the position of law existing then, as per
the un-amended A&C Act, of 1996 was that an automatic stay of the
award under challenge, immediately came into operation. It was
contended that though subsequent amendments had done away with the
automatic stay rule, however, the same would apply only prospectively
and the petitioner could not be divested of the benefit of automatic stay,
which had accrued to it as far back as on 31.08.2015. The learned
Commercial Court by the first impugned order dated 15.03.2023,
rejected the challenge to maintainability raised by the petitioner, who
then on the same day itself, filed another application under Section 34
read with Section 36 of the A&C Act, 1996 for stay of the award.
Thereafter, another petition on 23.03.2023 under Order 21 Rule 28 read
with Section 47 of the CPC, was filed by the petitioner for stay of the
execution proceedings in the Execution Case. Both these applications
dated 15.03.2023 and 23.03.2023, were then rejected by order dated
30.05.2023 by the learned Commercial Court. As such, these two
impugned orders dated 15.03.2023 and 30.05.2023 have now come to
be challenged before this Court by way of the instant application under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
2.
At the outset, the respondent counsel Mr. P. Jain, has
raised preliminary objections on the ground that the present petition is
premature, as the application for stay sought by the petitioner is yet to
be decided finally by the learned Commercial Court, and as such there
is no cause of action, let alone any grounds for interference under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India. It has also been contended that
the petitioner, has not established as to how the present common
petition is maintainable against first, the impugned order dated
15.03.2023 passed in deciding the maintainability of the petition under
Section 36 of the A&C Act, 1996 and secondly, against the order dated
30.05.2023 passed in the two applications filed under Order 21 Rule 29
read with Section 47 CPC and Section 36 read with Section 34
respectively, seeking stay of the Execution proceedings and the Arbitral
Award. No pleadings are present it is asserted, or any explanation
offered as to how orders passed under A&C Act could be challenged
under Article 227 as in any case, orders arising out of Section 34 or
related thereto, would lie exclusively under the A&C Act.
3.
It has also been submitted that the application of the
petitioner under Section 36 is yet to be decided, and the deposit as
directed by the learned Commercial Court, is in accordance with the
law laid down by the Supreme Court mandating 100% deposit as the
standard rule in case of execution of arbitral awards. In this context,
reliance has been placed upon the cases of (i) Toyo Engineering
Corporation vs. Indian Oil 2021 SCC Online SC 3455 (ii) SREI
Infrastructure Finance Ltd. vs. Candor Gurgaon Two Developers
and Projects Pvt. Ltd, SLP (C) Nos. 20895-20897/2018 and (iii)
Manish vs. Godawari Marthawada Irrigation Development Corp.
SLP (C) No(s). 11760-11761/2018.
4.
In reply to the question of maintainability, the learned
Senior counsel for the petitioner Shri. V.K.Jindal, submits that Article
227 is sought to be invoked, as the petitioner is aggrieved with the
manner in which the proceedings are being conducted by the learned
Court below, where on one hand while the hearing of the main Section
34 challenge is proceeding, on the other hand the petitioner is facing
demands for filing of details of assets under Order 21 Rule 41 (2) CPC,
and also for deposit of the entire awarded amount. This the learned
Senior counsel submits, occasioned the filing of the second petition
under Section 47 CPC, to determine question arising between the
parties by the Court executing the decree, which would include the
question of enforceability of the award, which is also a subject matter
of the Section 34 application. As such, he submits without deciding the
questions that have arisen between the parties, the executing Court
could not and should not have proceeded with the execution process,
such as the requirement of filing of list of assets and deposit of awarded
amount.
5.
It is also submitted that Rule 1 (iii) Chapter VII, Part-2 of
the Rules of the High Court of Meghalaya, 2013 require that in an
application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, the date or
dates of the decrees of the Lower Courts be specified and as such the
use of the plural in respect of dates and orders reflects that a single
petition is maintainable against multiple orders. It has been further
contended by the learned Senior counsel that the impugned orders not
being appealable under Section 37 of the A&C Act, nor under the
provisions of the CPC, in view of Section 13 of the Commercial Courts
Act, 2015, the only remedy is by way of revision under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India.
6.
On the merits of the matter, it has been submitted that
though the learned lower Court had recorded and acknowledged the
position of law with regard to amendment of the A&C Act, 2015 as to
its being prospective nature, had instead passed impugned orders under
the amended provision of the Act, by initiating execution proceedings
on an application under Section 36 of the amended A&C Act, filed by
the respondents on 14.12.2022. It has been argued that prior to the
amendment, the settled position of law under Section 36 was that, once
a challenge had been filed under Section 34 of the A&C Act, the same
acted as an automatic/deemed stay of the award under challenge and as
such, when the petition under Section 34 had been filed by the
petitioner on 30.08.2015, a stay of the award in question came into
operation. He submits that there was no necessity then to file any
petition for stay of the said award, and that it is only after the respondent
filed the petition dated 14.12.2022 for execution of the award, that the
petitioner then filed petition dated 15.03.2023, for stay of the award.
The learned Lower Court he contends by rejecting the prayer for stay
of the award has taken away the vested right which had accrued in
favour of the petitioner.
7.
In support of his contentions, the learned Senior counsel
has relied on the following judgments:i)
Board of Control for Cricket in India vs. Kochi
Cricket Pvt Ltd (2018) 6 SCC 287
ii)
Hindustan Construction Company vs. Union of
India (2022) 17 SCC 324
iii)
Union of India vs. Vedanta Ltd. (2020) 10 SCC 1
8.
iv)
Aravali Power Co. (P) Ltd. vs. Era Infra Engg.
Ltd. (2017) 15 SCC
v)
Ssangyong Engineering and Construction
Company Ltd. vs. National Highway Authority of
India (2019) 15 SCC 131.
It has been reiterated that the petitioner had filed two
applications, one on 15.03.2023 for stay of the award under Section 36
and 34 of the A&C Act read with Section 151 of the CPC, and the other
on 23.03.2023 under Order 21 Rule 29 read with Section 47 of the CPC
for stay of the impugned proceedings, and though they were on two
different footings, the same were disposed of by the same second
impugned order dated 30.05.2023, by combining the two different
prayers for stay of the award and for stay of the execution proceedings
to be a single issue. It has been further urged that the learned Court
below on the other minor issues has adopted unfounded and
unreasonable grounds and had totally ignored the fact that the
petitioner, had continued to enjoy the automatic stay by virtue of
operation of the earlier law.
9.
Heard learned counsels for the parties and also perused the
impugned judgments dated 15.03.2023 and 30.05.2023, passed in
Commercial Arbitration Execution Case No. 6 of 2022. First, it is noted
as submitted that the instant application under Article 227, has been
filed seeking interference against two orders dated 15.03.2023 and
30.05.2023. Though, it has been submitted on behalf of the petitioner
that the revision application would be maintainable, as it will reveal
before this Court the alleged illegal and irregular manner in which the
proceedings in the lower Court are being conducted, and also because
the two impugned orders are inter linked and in continuation thereof,
which reflects the approach being adopted by the learned Court below,
this Court though having grave reservations as to the maintainability of
the instant application, in view of the short question involved on merits,
will not dwell on this aspect.
10.
The basis of the entire challenge of the petitioner it can be
seen, is on the premise that prior to the amendment by the A&C Act,
2015, once an application had been filed under Section 34 of the A&C
Act, the same acted as an automatic stay of the award under challenge,
which however was removed by the amendment. As observed earlier,
the award had been passed in favour of the respondent on 05.06.2015,
and the Section 34 application had been filed on 31.08.2015. The
Section 34 application thereafter, was left for consideration for a
number of years, until an application for execution of the arbitral award
was filed by the respondent under Order 21 Rule 11 CPC read with
Section 36 of the A&C Act, 1996. As the respondent/decree holder had
sought execution of the award after more than two years from the date
when the award was made, the learned lower Court had issued notice
to the petitioner/judgment debtor to show cause as to why the award be
not executed. The provisions of section 36 as it stood prior to its
Amendment Act, 2015 and after its amendment by the Amendment Act
2015, being relevant is quoted below.
Prior to Amendment Act 2015
“Section 36. Enforcement. Where the time for making
an application to set aside the arbitral award under
Section 34 has expired, or such application having been
made, it has been refused, the award shall be enforced
under the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 in the same
manner as if it were a decree of this court.
After Amendment Act 2015:
Section 36. Enforcement.
1) Where the time for making an application to set aside
the arbitral award under Section 34 has expired, then
subject to the provisions of subsection (2), such award
shall be enforced in accordance with the provisions of
the Code of Civil Procedure 1908, in the same manner
as if it were a decree of a court.
2) Where an application to set aside the arbitral award
has been filed in the court under Section 34, the filing
of such an application shall not by itself render that
award unenforceable unless the court grants an order
of stay of the operation of said arbitral award in
accordance with the provisions of subsection (3) on a
separate application made for that purpose.
3) Upon filing of an application under Subsection (2) for
stay of the operation of the Arbitral award, the court
may subject to such conditions as it may deemed fit,
grant stay of the operation of such award for reasons
to be recorded in writing.
Provided that the court shall, while considering the
application for grant of stay in the case of an arbitral
award for payment of money, have due regard to the
provisions for grant of stay of a money decree under the
provisions of the Court of Civil Procedure 1908.
Provided further that where the Court is satisfied that a
prima facie case is made out that,(a) the arbitration agreement or contract which is
the basis of the award; Or
(b) the making of the award,
was induced or effected by fraud or corruption, it
shall stay the award unconditionally pending
disposal of the challenge under section 34 to the
award.
Explanation.- For the removal of doubts, it is
hereby clarified that the above proviso shall apply
to all court cases arising out of or in relation to
arbitral proceedings, irrespective of whether the
arbitral or court proceedings were commenced
prior to or after the commencement of the
Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act,
2015 (3 of 2016)”
11.
By the judgment dated 15.03.2023, the learned lower
Court had examined the contentions raised by the petitioner with regard
to the applicability of the A&C amendment Act, 2015 to the instant
case and after hearing the petitioner by the application of the settled
position of law as discussed in Hindustan Construction Co. Ltd. vs.
Union of India (2020) 17 SCC 324, and by quoting extensively from
paragraphs 33 to 41, rejected the arguments of the petitioner and
directed for disclosing of the assets both moveable and immovable of
the petitioner. By this judgment, it has been held by the Supreme Court
that on the question of automatic stay/suspension of execution on
challenging the award, the same was never envisaged by Section 36,
whether before or after its amendment, and that the amendment of
Section 36 was clarificatory in nature. This judgment has gone further
to record that it is incorrect, that an award when challenged under
Section 34 becomes un-executable merely by virtue of such challenge
being made because of the language of Section 36, inasmuch as, when
read together with Section 35, all that Section 36 states is that
enforcement of a final award will be under the CPC, and in the same
manner as if it were a decree of the Court. This aspect had also been
dealt with in the case of BCCI vs. Kochi Cricket (P) Ltd., (2018) 6 SCC
287, where it has been interpreted that no vested right arises, if the
Section 34 application was filed prior to the 2015 amendment, and that
no automatic stay of execution exists in these cases. It has also been
held in the same judgment at para 63, the extract whereof is quoted
below as follows:“Since it is clear that execution of a decree pertains to
the realm of procedure, and that there is no substantive
vested right in a judgment-debtor to resist execution,
Section 36, as substituted, would apply even to pending
Section 34 applications on the date of commencement of
the Amendment Act.”
As such, there being no illegality whatsoever in the
findings of the learned Commercial Court, the impugned order dated
15.03.2023 therefore, does not call for any correction or interference.
12.
Coming to the second impugned order dated 30.05.2023,
wherein an application dated 23.03.2023 under Order 21 Rule 29 read
with Section 47 CPC, and an application dated 15.03.2023 under
Section 36 read with Section 34 of the A&C Act read with Section 151
CPC was filed by the petitioner/judgment debtor for stay of the award
dated 05.06.2015, the learned Lower Court, it is seen, held that as per
the scheme of Section 36 of the A&C Act, an unconditional stay would
be granted only if cases of fraud and corruption are established, and had
observed in the impugned order dated 30.05.2023, that the
petitioner/judgment debtor had not shown any sufficient cause for stay
of the award. Further it is noted that in the order dated 30.05.2023, the
learned Commercial Court while rejecting the prayer for unconditional
stay, has however provided that in the event the petitioner/judgment
debtor deposits the entire award amount in Court within a period of one
month, the stay would be considered. As such, in effect the application
for stay filed by the petitioner under Section 36 read with Section 34 of
A&C Act, subject to fulfillment of the condition for deposit of the
awarded amount, is still open for consideration. As such, no orders are
therefore necessary or any interference called for, with regard to this
order dated 30.05.2023, more so, in consideration of the prevalent law
as demonstrated by the respondent in the judgments cited above at Para3 of this judgment.
13.
In the circumstances therefore, there being no grounds
made out, nor the orders suffering from any perversity or grave
irregularity, no case has been made out for exercise of powers under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India and the instant revision
application accordingly stands dismissed.
14.
Before parting with the records, as it has also been stated at
the bar, that the hearing of Section 34 application is proceeding and is
on the final lap, it is therefore expected that the same be disposed of as
expeditiously as possible.
15.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
21.08.2023
“V. Lyndem PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review