Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
132571
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE SECOND DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENry SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE JUWADI SRIDEVI
WRIT PETITION NOs: 38209 and 38211 of 2025
WRIT PETITION NO:38209 OF 2025
Between:
Nookathota Anjali Goutam, D/o Dr. Uday Goutam Nookathota, Age 21, Occ.
Medical Student, R/o Flat No. A-310, Kalpataru Residency 8-4-300/1/A, Ashok
Marg Prem Nagar, Enagadda, Medchal Malkajgiri Dist.,
...PETlTIONER
ANO
Union of lndia, Represented by its Secretary, National Medical Commission
Pocket 14, Sector 8, Dwaraka Phase-1 New Delhi 1 '10077
Under Graduate Medical Education Board, Represented by its Director,
Pocket 14, Sector-8, Dwaraka Phase-1 New Delhi 't 10077
3. University Grants Commission (UGC), Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi 1 10002.
4. Malla Reddy Vishwavidyapeeth, Deemed to be University, represented by its
Vice Chancellor, Suraram, Medchal Malkajgiri District, Telangana 500055
5. CONTROLLER OF EXAMINATIONS, Malla Reddy Vishwavidyapeeth
Deemed to be University, represented by its Vice Chancellor, Suraram,
Medchal Malkajgiri District, Telangana 500055
...RESPONOENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue an Order, writ or direction more particularly in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus or any other appropriate Writ declaring the inaction of the respondents
in considering the email request of the petitioner dated 27.11.2025 to conduct
revaluation of petitioner's Biochemistry Answer Scripts in First Year MBBS
Supplementary University Examinations, October-2025 in Roll No2024001001015
and 3rd respondent stating that only a re-totaling is permiss t le and final but not
re-valuation of exam sheets, as illegal, arbitrary, violative ,,f the principles of
natural justice, prejudiced, unconstitutional, against Artickr 14 and 21 of the
Constitution of lndia coupled with flagrant violation of the rules. )f University Grants
Commission and consequently direct the 3'd respondent to cc nduct a revaluation
of the petitioner's Biochemistry Answer Scripts in First Year full iBS Supplementary
University Examinations, October-2025 in Roll No.2024001(r( 1015 with different
set of evaluators.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the cirr; rmstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court mav re pleased Pending
disposal of the above writ petition, it is most respectfully pra) sd that this Hon'ble
Court may direct the 3rd respondent to conduct a revaluat r n of the petitioners
Biochemistry Answer Scripts in First Year MBBS Supptr mentary University
Examinations, October-2025 in Roll No. 2024001001015 r,ith different set of
evaluators.
WRIT PETITION NO: 38211 OF 202s
Between:
Mahalle Sushrut Ranjit, S/o Ranjit Suresh Mahalle, Age 20, ( cc: Medical Student,
Rl/o.Duplex No.1'1, Har Ram Hara Krishna Society , App. Ur: av Mangal Karyalay,
Akola District, Maharashtra State.
,..PETITIONER
AND
Union of lndia, Represented by its Secretary, National fuk dical Commission
Pocket 14, Sector 8, Dwaraka Phase-1 New Delhi 11OO7 '.
Under Graduate Medical Education Board, Representec )y its Director,
Pocket 14, Sector-8, Dwaraka Phase-1 New Delhi 11OO7 t.
University Grants Commission (UGC), Bahadur Shah Zir * Marg, New Delhi 110002.
Malla-Reddy.Vishwavidyapeeth, Deemed to be Universiir , Represented by its
Vice Chancellor, Suraram, Medchal Malkajgiri District, Te langana 500055.
CONTROLLER OF EXAMINATIONS, Malla Reddy Vishv avidyapeeth
Deemed to be University, Represented by its Vice Chanc :llor, Suraram,
Medchal Malkajgiri District, Telangana 500055.
.,.RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue an order, Writ, or direction more particularly in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus or any other appropriate Writ declaring the inaction of the respondents
in conducting revaluation of petitioner's Anatomy Answer Scripts in First Year
MBBS Supplementary University Examinations, November-2025 in Roll
No.2024001001094 and 3rd respondent stating that only a re-totaling is
permissible and final but not re-valuation of exam sheets, as illegal, arbitrary,
violative of the principles of natural justice, prejudiced, u nconstitutional, against
Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution of lndia coupled with flagrant violation of the
rules of University Grants Commission and consequently direct the 3rd respondent
to conduct a revaluation of the petitioners Biochemistry Answer Scripts in First
Year MBBS Supplementary University Examinations, November-2O25 in Roll No.
2024001001094 with different set of evaluators.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased may
direct the 3rd respondent to conduct a revaluation of the petitioners Anatomy
Answer_scripts in First Year MBBS Supplementary University Examinations, Nov2025 in Roll No. 2024001001 094 with different set of evaluators
Counsel for the Petitioner in both the writ petitions: SR!. SRIKANTH CHINTALA
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 ln Both the Writ Petitions :
SRI N. BHUJANGA RAO, DEPUWSOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA
Counsel for the Respondents No.2 & 3 in both the writ petitions:
SRI P. I-AXMAN RAO
Counsel for the Respondent Nos 4 & 5 in both the writ petitions:
SRI RAVINDER REDDY MUPPU
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TEI- \NGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE JUWADI SII DEVI
WRIT PETITION Nos.38209 and 38211 ot ','.O25
2No APRIL 2026
W.P. No.38209 of 2025
Between:
Nookathota Anjali Goutam
. P -. itioner
W.P. No. 38211 of 2O25
Mahalle Sushrut Ranjit
AND
Union of lndia,
Rep. by its Secretary,
National Medical Commission
And 4 others
R(x pondents
COMMON ORDER:
These writ petitions are filed seeking the following elief
"issuc al order. ulit, or direction more particularly in l :
llature ol Writ of \4andamus or any other appropri I e
wrrt. dr'claring, thc ir.raction ol thc respondents. l
considelinq thc crnlil request of the pctitioncr da t J
27. I 1.2015 to conduct rcvaluation of petitioner s
Biochemistry Answcr Scriprs in F-irst Year Mll I j
supplcmentary [,tnivcrsity Examinations. October-](l 5
in Roll \o.202400 1001015 in W.P.No.l8209 oi t( . j
and in conducting rcvaluation of petitioner's Hunrt n
Anatomr .{nsrrel Scripts in First Year Ii.{ll Ll j
Supplenrcntary University ExaminaLions. Novembe2025 in liotl No.l0l-100 I 001094 in W.P.No.i82 t I f'
201I and 3'd respondcnt stating that only a re-totalinl s
pennissiblc and final but not rc-valuation of exam shcr:t ;.
as illegal. arbitrarv, violativc of principles oI narr r rl
justice. prciudiced. Lrnconstitutiona[, against Article 4
und 2l ol tltc Crr stitrrtion rrl lndia coupletJ with llagr r rr
r iolation irl thc nrlcs ol' [ ]nivcrsity Grants Comntiss r n
and conscqLrcntlr dircct thc i"l rcspondent to cou(lu(t a
revaluarion of the pctitioncrs Answer Scripts in I r il
.I
Year N4BBS Supplernentar; [Jniversitl, Examinations in
Biochemistry and I{uman.\natomy, r.vith dif'ferent set of
evaluators and pass such other order . . "
2.
Since the relief prayed for in both the writ petitions is similar in
nature, these writ petitions are disposed of by way of this common
order
3.
Heard Mr.Chintala Srikanth, learned counsel for the
petitioners, Mr. N.Bhujanga Rao, learned Deputy Solicitor General
appearing on behalf of respondent No.1 and Mr.Ravinder Reddy
Muppu, Iearned counsel appearing on behalf of respondent Nos.4
and 5. Perused the record
4.
Case of the petitioners is that despite having made adequate
preparation for the examinations and being confident of their
performance, they were declared unsuccessful in the MBBS First
Year examinations in the subject of Biochemistry and Human
Anatomy. Being aggrieved by the said result and belaeving that their
answer scripts were not properly evaluated, they approached the
respondent authorities seeking access to their answer scripts and
requesting revaluation by a second set of valuators. However, the
respondent authorities rejected their request and instead directed
them to apply for re-totaling of marks.
.s
,"!
5.
Further case of the petitioners is that as per lt e applicable
rules, a student who fails in any subject in the First year MBBS
course, is not eligible for promotion to the next acaderr .ric year and
will be detained in the same year Notably, such a st- .rgenl rule is
not applicable to the subsequent four academic years rf the MBBS
course. ln these circumstances, the petitioners cont 3 rd that they
have no opportunity to clear backlogs, while progressing
academically, as promotion to the next year is strrct y contingent
upon passing all subjects Therefore, they specifically pleaded the
respondents to re-evaluate their answer scripts, but t rere was no
response from the respondents. Subsequenily, when 1t e petitioners
approached the respondent-university, they were oli lly informed
that re-evaluatron is not permissible and only re_total 19 of marks
can be done. Hence, lhe writ petition rs filed.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits :hat despite
repeated requests for revaruation of the petitioners' e r swer scripts
pe(aining to the MBBS First year theory examina:ions in the
subjects of Biochemistry and Human Anatomy by a ciferent set of
evaluators, the respondent-university has failed to ;onsider the
same. He further submits that the respondent-L r iversity has
conducted the valuation of the answer scripts only. thrc
Jgh a single
evaluator, unlike other State Universities where
"raluation is
r
undertaken by multiple evaluators, typically three, to ensure
accuracy and fairness. Such a system of single valuation increases
the likelihood of errors and any erroneous assessment would attain
finality without further scrutiny, thereby depriving the petitioners of
any opportunity for correction. Hence, learned counsel prayed this
Court to direct the respondents to re-evaluate the answer scripts of
the petitioners by a different set of evaluators and also permit the
petitioners to verify their answer scripts of MBBS First Year
Biochemistry and Human Anatomy personally, subject to payment of
requisite fee, as Per the Rules.
7.
On the other hand. learned Standing Counsel appearing for
respondent Nos.4 and 5, by way cf filing an Evaluation Response
Sheet, ffied 08 01.2026, submits that the double valuation of the
petitionerA' theory answer scripts was carried out independently by
two eligible external examiners, who were not affiliated with Malla
Reddy Vishwavidyapeeth, in compliance with the norms prescribed
by the National Medical Commission (NMC) He fu(her submits
that recounting of the petitioners answer scripts was already done
andtherewas..nochange''inthemarks'HefurtherSubmitsthatif
the petitioners are still aggrieved by the result of the recounting' they
are at liberty to approach the Grievance Committee of respondentUniversity by submitting an application in the prescribed form along
with the requisite fee. However, learned Standing Cour;el reported
no objection in directing the respondent-University to e-verify the
petitioners answer scripts relating to the MBBS First year
Biochemistry and Human Anatomy and in permitting th ) petitioners
to verify their answer scripts of MBBS First year Bioctemistry and
Human Anatomy personally, subject to payment of the -, rquisite fee.
8.
ln view of the submissions made by the lear red counsel
appearing on both sides. this Court deems it approp-i rte to direct
respondent-U niversity to re-verify the petitioners an;wer scripts
relating to the MBBS First year theory examinations irr the subjects
of Biochemistry and Human Anatomy forthwith and als I permit the
petitioners to verrfy their answer scripts of MBB:! p;1s1 y""r.
Biochemistry and Human Anatomy personally, on payment of
requisite fee, as per the Rules.
9.
With the above directions, both the Writ F etitions are
disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs.
Miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand clo ;ed.
SD/- A. JAYASREE
AS:; STANT REGISTRAR
//TRI'E COPY//
(,
SECTION OFFICER
To,
The Secretary, National tVled.ical C_ommission
Union of I dia, pocket 14,
sector B, Dwaraka phase_.l ruew b"ini i-r-ti6i7""'""
"'
The Director, Under Graduate-M_e-dical Education
Boarc, pocket 14, Sector_g,
Dwaraka Phase-.| New Delhi 11OO7l
-i& I :... ..
...o..
-*J
I
3. University Grants Commission (UGC), Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi 110002.
4. The Vice Chancellor, Malla Reddy Vishwavidyapeeth, Deemed to be
University, Suraram, Medchal Malkajgiri District, Telangana 500055
5. The Vice Chancellor, CONTROLLER OF EXAMINATIONS' Malla Reddy
Vishwavidyapeeth Deemed to be University, Suraram, Medchal Malkajgiri
District, Telangana 500055
6. One CC to SRl. SRIKANTH CHINTALA , Advocate IOPUCI
7. One CC to SRl. N BHUJANGA RAO, Deputy Solicitor General of
lndia [OPUC]
6. One CC to SRI RAVI NDER REDDY MUPPU, Advocate IOPUC]
7. One CC to SRI P. LAXMAN RAO, Advocate [OPUCI
8. Two CD Copies
DAN Ek
HIGH COURT
(
)C TODAY
DATED:0210412026
I
COMMON ORDER
'..::
. "', i.,\ ) l L: .'
/.,
WP.Nos.38209 AND 38211 ot 2025
/' .:'
li'r
ti
-
ii 11:
\,\ i:
0 fr Xi,n
Cr
lrw lril
\l,r I
l:- i/
',,-..
DISPOSING OF THE BOTH WRIT PETIT'IONS
WITHOUT COSTS
J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review