Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision : 11.03.2026
+
W.P.(C) 16771/2025
NO. 242500 HFO KC DOGRA RETD
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Manoj Kumar Gupta, Ms.
Devangana Sharma, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Subhra Parashar, SPC, Mr.
Virender Pratap Singh Charak, Mr.
Gaurav Khosla, Advocates, Ms.
Rupali Sinha, GP.
Sgt, Mritunjay and Sgt, Padam
Charan, for Union of India, DAV
Legal Cell, Air force
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J. (ORAL)
1.
The present writ petition has been filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, 1950 against the order dated 24.02.2025 [‘Impugned
Order’] passed by the Armed Forces Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi
[‘Tribunal’] in Original Application [‘O.A.’] No. 833/2019, whereby the
Petitioner’s application seeking the grant of disability element of the pension
was rejected. The Petitioner also impugns the order dated 04.09.2025
dismissing the review petition.
2.
The Petitioner joined the Indian Air Force (‘IAF’) on 22.01.1969.
During his service the Petitioner
was diagnosed with ‘Primary
Hypertension’ while posted in Jammu/23 wing (J&K) 29.04.1996 and was
placed in Low Medical Category (‘LMC’) in December 1997.
3.
The Release Medical Board [‘RMB’] held on 24.01.2008 assessed the
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:18.03.2026 18:36
W.P.(C) 16771/2025
disability i.e., Primary Hypertension at 30% for life. The RMB opined that
the disease is constitutional in nature and therefore, the aforesaid disability
was neither attributable to nor aggravated [‘NANA’] by the military service.
The Petitioner was discharged from IAF in low medical category on
01.01.2009 after completion of 39 years and 346 days of regular service.
4.
The Petitioner filed appeal(s) for grant of the disability pension,
which was rejected leading him to file the O.A. No. 833/2019. The Tribunal,
rejected the relief of disability pension vide impugned order dated
24.02.2025. The Tribunal after perusing the RMB opined that the Petitioner
was overweight and concluded that this was a causative factor leading to the
disability of Primary Hypertension.
Aggrieved by the impugned order passed by the Tribunal on
24.02.2025, the Petitioner filed a review petition which was also dismissed
vide order dated 04.09.2025.
5.
In these facts, the Petitioner has filed the present writ petition to seek
the grant of disability pension.
Submissions by the Petitioner
6.
Learned counsel for the Petitioner states that the Respondents
overlooked the fact that the Petitioner had joined the IAF in 1969 and was
medically and physically fit at the time of his enrolment, thereby attracting
the presumption of attributability under the Entitlement Rules 2008. (Re:
Dropadi Tripathi v. Union of India & Ors1 )
7.
He states that the Petitioner was diagnosed with Primary
Hypertension in April 1996 (i.e., after 27 years of service). He states that the
2025:DHC:8709-DB
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:18.03.2026 18:36
W.P.(C) 16771/2025
Petitioner during his tenure was posted in a high stress area which involved
long working hours, adverse climate thereby making the disability
attributable to or aggravated by the service conditions. He states Petitioner
was posted in Jammu and Kashmir as well as other field areas.
8.
He states that the Petitioner’s disability was incurred during active
service, which attracts the presumption under Regulation 423(a) of the
Regulations for the Medical Services of the Armed Forces, 2010 and thus
the disability shall be presumed to be attributable to or aggravated by
military service, unless proved otherwise by cogent evidence.
9.
He states that, post first onset of Primary Hypertension, due to several
restrictions coupled with prescription of lifelong medication Tab Atenolol (5
mg), the Petitioner started gaining weight. He states that Atenolol is a betablocker known to cause weight gain if consumed more than six months.
10.
He states that the findings of the Tribunal are contrary to the material
on record and ignore the applicable guidelines governing weight standards
in the Air Force. As per AFI 36-2905 (Air Force Instruction 36-2905),
which regulates physical fitness assessments including body composition
assessment (BCA), the determination of fitness is primarily based on
compliance with prescribed body fat percentage limits rather than mere body
weight. Significantly, there is no finding in the RMB that the Applicant was
suffering from obesity. Rather, the permissible 10%-20% overweight
tolerance falls within the acceptable limits under the applicable standards.
11.
He states that the Tribunal’s finding that being “overweight” is the
cause of the disability, is unsubstantiated from the RMB, and was not part of
the grounds for rejection pleaded by the Respondents. This was a new
ground recorded by the Tribunal on its own observations and thus could not
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:18.03.2026 18:36
W.P.(C) 16771/2025
have been a valid ground for rejecting the claim. He states that therefore the
Petitioner had no opportunity to explain its stand.
12.
He states that the Petitioner was always within the permissible weight
limits and was never issued with the advisory for reduction of his weight,
making the reason of overweight allegation and afterthought.
13.
In reply, learned counsel for the Respondents relies upon the stand
taken in the counter affidavit filed before the Tribunal as well as the reasons
set out in the impugned order. She states that in the Annual Medical
Examination held in December 1997, the Petitioner was diagnosed with
Primary Hypertension and Diabetes. She states that the Petitioner was
advised to gradually reduce weight. She states that these pleas were
specifically raised in the counter affidavit and therefore grounds raised in the
writ petition alleging that the Petitioner has been taken by surprise on the
findings of “overweight” returned in the impugned order is incorrect and
contrary to the record.
14.
She states that the Petitioner had initially raised a claim for disability
pension, which was rejected vide order dated 20.03.2008. The Petitioner
thereafter filed an appeal belatedly on 24.10.2018 which was not processed
as it was time barred and this fact was intimated vide communication dated
13.03.2019. The Petitioner filed a further appeal on 25.04.2019, which was
not maintainable in view of the rejection letter dated 13.03.2019 and this
was communicated vide letter dated 06.06.2019. It is stated that therefore
the claim of the Petitioner is time barred.
Case Analysis
15.
This Court has heard the learned senior counsel for the parties and
perused the record.
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:18.03.2026 18:36
W.P.(C) 16771/2025
16.
As noted above, the Petitioner joined the IAF on 22.01.1969, and
superannuated on 01.01.2009 in LMC after rendering a service for more
than 39 years. The Petitioner was diagnosed with Primary Hypertension
during routine annual medical examination in December 1997 while serving
at AF Stn. Amla.
17.
In his personal statement at PART I of the RMB, the Petitioner had
explicitly stated that he did not suffer from any disability or disease before
joining the service. This statement has not been disputed in the RMB, nor
has it been contested before the Tribunal or this Court. The RMB, in its
opinion, has given the following reasoning for declaring the disability
NANA by military service:
The RMB has opined that the disability is constitutional in its origin,
hence not connected with the service. No other causative factor has been
identified by the RMB in its opinion. Whereas the Tribunal, while rejecting
the relief of the disability pension formed an opinion that the Petitioner has
developed the said disability due to the lifestyle related factors, i.e., weight
gain and thus, concurred that the disability is NANA. It is noted that the
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:18.03.2026 18:36
W.P.(C) 16771/2025
reason recorded by the AFT, i.e., lifestyle related factors, weight gain, etc
are not identified/recorded in the RMB as the cause for concluding the
disability as NANA. In fact, the subject RMB categorically records that the
disability is not attributable to the officer’s own negligence or misconduct
recorded at internal page of the RMB2.
In this factual background, we will examine whether the reasons
recorded in the impugned order are sustainable.
18.
The Supreme Court in its recent judgment in the case of Bijender
Singh vs. Union of India3 has reiterated that it is incumbent upon the
Medical Board to furnish reasons for opining that a disease is NANA and
the burden to prove the same is on the Military Establishment.
The nature of reasons to be recorded by the Medical Board have been
succinctly explained by the Supreme Court in another recent decision of
Rajumon T.M. v. Union of India4. In the said decision, Supreme Court
stated that an opinion of the Medical Board stating ‘CONSTITUTIONAL
PERSONALITY DISORDER’ without giving reasons or causative factors
to support such an opinion, is an unreasoned medical opinion. The Supreme
Court explained that in the absence of enlisted causative factors the
aforesaid opinion of the Medical Board was merely a conclusion and would
not qualify as a reasoned opinion for holding the disease to be NANA.
19.
It is now well settled that under the Entitlement Rules 2008 for
opining NANA, the Medical Board is obligated to record cogent reasons i.e.,
the causative factors which in their opinion led to the personnel suffering
Page no. 56 of the paper-book
2025 SCC OnLine SC 895 [Paragraph Nos. 45.1, 46 and 47]
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1064 [Paragraphs 25, 26, 32 and 36]
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:18.03.2026 18:36
W.P.(C) 16771/2025
from the said disability or disease. If the Medical Board fails to identify the
causal connection, the presumption is that the disability or disease was
suffered by the personnel due to the stress and strain arising from the
military service.
20.
The statement of the Medical Board in the subject RMB that ‘the
disability is constitutional in origin’ without enlisting the causative factors is
not a legally valid ground for opining NANA.
21.
The Tribunal vide its impugned order has independently concluded
that the disability suffered was attributable to the Petitioner’s own lifestyle,
considering that the Petitioner failed to maintain ideal body weight. The
impugned order refers to the Petitioner’s weight gain while concluding that
the Petitioner was negligent and, on that basis, has rejected the claim for the
grant of the disability element of pension. However, in the present case, the
RMB has not recorded the Petitioner’s overweight or lifestyle as a reason for
the onset of the disability.
A Coordinate Bench of this Court in Dropadi Tripathi v. Union of
India and Ors.5 has opined that Tribunal cannot identify causative factors
to draw a causal connection with the disease, if these factors have not been
enlisted in the opinion of the RMB or the specialist.
22.
We are, therefore, of the considered opinion, in the absence of any
such reason (i.e., overweight) recorded in the RMB, the Tribunal could not
have independently drawn a causal connection between the Petitioner’s
disability and his weight. The Tribunal, in doing so, has travelled beyond the
medical opinion on record and attributed a cause that was never opined by
2025: DHC: 8709-DB [Paragraph Nos. 13 and 14]
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:18.03.2026 18:36
W.P.(C) 16771/2025
the RMB.
23.
At this juncture, it is also appropriate to refer to the decision of the
Coordinate Bench in the case of Union of India & Ors. v. Ex JWO
Dharmendra Prasad6, wherein the issue pertaining to the effect of the
personnel’s overweight condition came up for consideration, and it was held
by the Court that mere obesity, by itself, does not ipso facto render other
disability, such as Primary Hypertension, Diabetes Mellitus, and CAD,
suffered by Force personnel, as attributable to obesity.
24.
Therefore, the reasoning of the Tribunal in the Impugned Order for
denying the grant of disability pension in respect of the other disability,
solely on the ground that the Petitioner was overweight, cannot be sustained
in view of the judgment in Ex JWO Dharmendra Prasad (supra), as this
is not the causative factor recorded in the RMB.
25.
Thus, the opinion of the Tribunal holding that the Petitioner suffered
from the disability due to overweight cannot be taken into consideration.
The reason recorded in the RMB that the disability is constitutional in its
origin can also not form a reasonable ground for holding NANA as the RMB
fails to record the causative factors for opining that the disability is
constitutional. No other ground has been cited in the RMB report of the
Respondent for holding NANA. Therefore, in the absence of any other
identified causal connection for the said disability in the RMB, the rejection
of the claim for disability pension by the Military establishment cannot be
sustained and the Petitioner is entitled to disability pension.
26.
We therefore find merit in this writ petition. The OA 833/2019 filed
2025 SCC OnLine Del 2549
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:18.03.2026 18:36
W.P.(C) 16771/2025
by the Petitioner is entitled to succeed. The impugned order dated
24.02.2025 is accordingly quashed and set aside. Also, the impugned order
dated 04.09.2025 passed in the review petition is quashed and set aside.
27.
The RMB has determined the assessment of the disability at 30% for
life. The Respondents are directed to grant benefit of disability pension at
30% for life rounded off to 50% for life in view of the judgment of the
Supreme Court in Union of India v. Ram Avtar7. The Petitioner will be
entitled to benefit of rounding off with effect from 10.12.2014 i.e., the date
of the judgment in Ram Avtar (supra). The Petitioner was discharge in
2009, however he has approached the Tribunal in 2019, therefore keeping in
view the law laid down by Supreme Court in Union of India & Ors v.
Tarsem Singh8 , the arrears will be restricted to three years prior the OA,
i.e., 04.09.2025 payable to the applicant within four months of the receipt of
a copy of this order failing which it shall earn interest at 9% p.a. till the
actual date of payment.
28.
The petition is allowed, with no orders as to costs.
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MARCH 11, 2026/AJ
2014 SCC OnLine SC 1761
(2008) 8 SCC 648
Signed By:MOHIT
Signing
Date:18.03.2026 18:36
W.P.(C) 16771/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review