Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:34557
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
CWP No. 15766 of 2024
Decided on 17.08.2026
Dr. Nivedita Sharma
…Petitioner.
Versus
Dr. Y.S. Parmar University of Horticulture and Forestry and
another
…Respondents.
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge
Whether approved for reporting? Yes
For the petitioner:
Mr. Adarsh Sharma, Advocate.
For the respondents: Mr. Ramesh Chand Sharma, Advocate.
Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge (Oral)
By way of this writ petition, the petitioner has,
inter alia, prayed for the following reliefs:(i) That writ in the nature of certiorari may kindly be issued to
quash and set aside Annexure P-10 order dated 21.11.2024;
(ii) That the respondents may kindly be directed to release the
Leave Encashment and Gratuity of the petitioner without any
deduction alongwith statutory interest.”
2.
The issue involved in this petition is in a very
narrow compass. The petitioner was engaged as an Assistant
Professor, Basic Science in the respondent-University in the
2026:HHC:34557
year 1995. According to the petitioner, after her appointment
as such, she applied for the post of Hostel Warden also being
fully eligible and was appointed as such. She continued to
serve as the Hostel Warden as from the year 1995 up to
15.05.2024, that is just a few days before her superannuation,
which fact was not disputed by learned counsel for the
University.
3.
The grievance of the petitioner is that in terms of
Annexure P-10, dated 22.11.2024, a notice for recovery of
overstay license fee has been issued to the petitioner and an
amount of Rs. 9,25,790/- has been demanded from the
petitioner on account of overstay license fee for the Hostel
Warden
accommodation
which
was
occupied
by
the
petitioner from 01.04.2017 to 15.05.2024.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the
demand of the said amount from the petitioner on account of
alleged
overstay
license
fee
for
the
Hostel
Warden
accommodation is totally unsustainable in law. Learned
counsel further submitted that the contention of the
2026:HHC:34557
University is that as in the month of March 2017, the
petitioner had constructed her own accommodation in
Shamti, District Solan, Himachal Pradesh, therefore, as per
the Rules and Regulations of the respondent-University
dated 26.10.2015, the petitioner was not entitled for the
Hostel Warden accommodation, as University employees,
who owned their houses at their place of posting were not
eligible for allotment of houses. He submitted that had it been
a case where the petitioner was serving as an Assistant
Professor etc., then probably this condition would have been
applicable upon her. He argued that herein, the Hostel
Warden accommodation was occupied by the petitioner
legally in her capacity as Hostel Warden. The work of a Hostel
Warden, that too in a girls' hostel, is such that the Hostel
Warden has to stay in the premises itself to perform the
duties of a Hostel Warden efficiently. The rider of a University
employee not being eligible for allotment of house, if such an
employee was having his/her own house at the place of
posting was not attracted in the case of the petitioner.
2026:HHC:34557
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner referred to
Annexure P-7 appended with the petition, which are the
Hostel Rules and by referring to Clause 14.1.2 thereof, he
submitted that the responsibilities of the Warden, which are
spelled out in the said clause cannot be performed until and
unless the Hostel Warden stays in the Hostel Warden
accommodation and that too during the night hours. He
submitted that the impugned order is completely arbitrary
and is a result of a colorable exercise of power, as there were
some issues between the petitioner and the then ViceChancellor. Therefore, he submitted that as the impugned
order is indeed completely arbitrary and is not sustainable in
the eyes of law, the petition be allowed by quashing Annexure
P-10.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the
impugned order is otherwise also not sustainable in law, as
the same has been issued by the authorities by wrongly
construing that the accommodation in possession of the
petitioner was a General Pool Accommodation.
2026:HHC:34557
7.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the
respondent-University submitted that there is neither any
arbitrariness in the issuance of the impugned order nor the
same is a result of colorable exercise of power. He submitted
that a complaint was received against the petitioner that
despite having constructed her own house in the month of
March 2017 at a place known as Shamti (Solan), she
continued to occupy the accommodation of the University,
which was against the House Allotment Rules.
Learned
counsel referred to the House Allotment Rules appended with
the
petition
along
with
Notification
dated
26.10.2015
(Annexure P-1), and submitted that in terms of Rule 3
thereof, University employees who own houses at their place
of posting shall not be eligible for allotment of house unless
essentially required to stay at the campus/research station.
He submitted that in the present case the presence of the
petitioner was not required in the Hostel 24x7.
8.
By referring to Annexure P-7, learned counsel for
the respondent-University submitted that the petitioner was
2026:HHC:34557
supposed to attend the office in her capacity as the Hostel
Warden only for one hour. He submitted that after the
petitioner had constructed her own house in the month of
March 2017, she concealed this fact from the respondentUniversity and continued to occupy the Hostel Warden
accommodation against House Allotment Rules. He further
submitted that the Authority took appropriate action against
the petitioner when the factum of her having own house in
Shamti, Solan came to the notice of the Authority by way of a
private complaint received from one Ram Singh. Therefore,
the petitioner indeed has overstayed in the accommodation
of the University. Annexure P-10 was issued to her after a
proper inquiry was held in the matter by the Estate Officer.
Accordingly, he submitted that as there is no infirmity in the
impugned order, the present petition be dismissed.
9.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
have also carefully gone through the pleadings as well as
documents appended therein.
10.
It is not much in dispute that the petitioner after
2026:HHC:34557
her appointment as an Assistant Professor in the year 1995,
continued
to
serve
as
a
Hostel
Warden
before
her
superannuation, i.e., up to 15.05.2024. It is further also not in
dispute that in her capacity as the Hostel Warden, she
continued to occupy the Hostel Warden accommodation from
the initial days of her appointment up to 15.05.2024. The
dispute is relatable to the period as from March 2017 up to
15.05.2024.
11.
The moot issue before this Court is whether after
the petitioner had constructed her own house at Shamti,
District Solan, her act of occupying the Hostel Warden
accommodation, entails penal consequences as have been
levied upon her vide Annexure P-10 or not.
12.
Annexure P-1 appended with the petition is
Notification
dated
26.10.2015,
with
which
the
House
Allotment Rules of the University are appended. Rule 3 of the
House Allotment Rules reads as under: “3 INELIGIBILITY OF OFFICERS/OFFICIALS OWN HOUSES
FOR ALLOTMENT UNDER THESE RULES
The University employees who own houses at their place of
posting shall not be eligible for allotment of house unless
2026:HHC:34557
essentially required to stay at the campus/research stations.
For this purpose, the Solan city and its surroundings shall be
treated the same place and for other sides eight kilometers
from the campus/Research & Training Station or SubStation/KVK.
The decision would apply equally whether the house is owned
by the officer/official or his/her wife/husband or by his/her
dependent children.”
13.
A perusal of Rule 3 (supra) demonstrates that
those University employees who own houses at their place of
posting shall not be eligible for allotment of houses, unless
essentially required to stay at the campus/research station.
This demonstrates that there is not a mandatory bar that any
University employee, who owns his/her own house at the
place of posting shall not be eligible for allotment of house
under any circumstance whatsoever. Rule 3 itself has carved
out an exception and the same reads that an employee may be
eligible for the allotment of a house under the 2015 Rules if
the
employee
is
essentially
campus/research station.
required
to
stay
at
the
Now, the House Allotment Rules
have come into force vide Notification dated 26.10.2015. This
Notification has been issued in supersession of all previous
notifications on the subject matter. As observed hereinabove,
2026:HHC:34557
the petitioner was in occupation of the Hostel Warden
accommodation since the initial days of her appointment as
an Assistant Professor in the year 1995. She vacated the said
premises on 15.05.2024, when she was on the verge of her
superannuation. She retired in the month of June 2024 from
the post of Professor and Head of the Department, Basic
Sciences.
14.
Besides holding the above office,
she was also
performing the duties of a Hostel Warden up to 15.05.2024.
The duties of the Hostel Warden, in terms of Annexure P-7
appended with the petition are as under:“14.1.2 The Warden will have the following responsibilities:i) He/she will be responsible for the allotment of hostel rooms
in accordance with the hostel rules and for the maintenance of
discipline in the hostel;
ii) He/she will attend the hostel office daily for one hour at a
specified time, which will be notified on the notice board for
the information of the students;
iii) He/she will be responsible for administration of the staff
placed under him/her. He/she will report to the Students'
Welfare Officer for disciplinary action, for dereliction of duty or
negligence or misbehaviour on the part of his/her staff;
iv) He/she shall report to the Medical Officer all cases of illness
or accidents and ensure that the Students' concerned get
proper medical care. He/she will also inform the Students'
Welfare Officer of all such cases;
v) He/she will inspect the kitchen, dining room, common room
2026:HHC:34557
and other facilities, etc. regularly and when any defect is
noticed, he/she will get it set right by his/her staff. If the defect
is such as cannot be remedied by his/her staff, he/she will
report to the Estate Officer under intimation to the Students'
Welfare Officer;
vi) He/she will appoint the Prefects of the hostel as prescribed
in the relevant rules and supervise their work;
vii) He/she shall ensure that no un-authorized person stay in
the hostel and will issue permits for the stay of guests;
i) He/she shall, with the help of his/her staff, check the unauthorized use of electrical appliance; and
ii)He/she will be responsible for the proper organization and
conduct of hostel functions. festivals, etc.
Within the hostel, the Warden will be responsible to the
Students' Welfare Officer for the maintenance of discipline and
good behaviour and will keep the Dean informed of all acts of
indiscipline and misbehavior and the action taken by him/her.
Where the Warden is of the view that a punishment should be
imposed heavier than that what he/ she is competent to award,
he/she will report the case to the Students' Welfare Officer/
Dean with his/her recommendations and the Students' Welfare
Officer/ Dean may then pass an order as he/she may deem fit.”
15.
A perusal of the responsibilities of the Warden of
the respondent-University demonstrates that the Warden
shall, inter alia, be responsible for the allotment of Hostel
rooms, maintenance of discipline in the hostel. Additionally,
the Warden will attend the Hostel daily for one hour at a
specified time and will be responsible for administration of
staff placed under him/her. The Hostel Warden shall report to
the Medical Officer all cases of illness or accident and ensure
2026:HHC:34557
that students get proper medical care.
The Hostel Warden
will inspect the kitchen, dining room, common room and
other facilities regularly and ensure that the defects, if any,
are rectified. The Hostel Warden shall ensure that no
unauthorized person stays in the Hostel and will issue
permits for the stay of guests. The Hostel Warden will also,
with the help of staff, check unauthorized use of electrical
appliances
and
shall
be
responsible
for
the
proper
organization and conduct of hostel functions, festivals, etc.
Besides this, it is also the responsibility of the Hostel Warden
to maintain discipline and good behavior, etc., in the hostel.
16.
Now,
obviously,
these
functions
cannot
be
performed by a Hostel Warden in absentia. In order to ensure
that there is maintenance of proper discipline in the hostel,
obviously a Hostel Warden is required to stay in the hostel
premises. This is more so for the reason that during the
daytime, majority of the students would be attending their
classes, and the hostel premises are occupied primarily only
when class work is not ongoing in the University.
2026:HHC:34557
17.
Even with regard to ensuring that there are proper
facilities in the kitchen, dining room, and common room, this
work can be done by a Warden, who is present at the time
when food is being cooked in the kitchen and is being served
in the dining room or common room.
18.
Someone who is not present in the Hostel at the
time when the food is being cooked obviously cannot inspect
whether there is any defect in the food, etc., which is being
provided to the students or not.
19.
Further, the responsibility which has been cast
upon a Hostel Warden to take care of the health of the
students and ensure that proper medical care is available to
them, can also not be performed by a Hostel Warden in
absentia. For this also, the personal presence of the Hostel
Warden within the hostel premises is required.
20.
The personal presence of a Hostel Warden is also
required to check as to whether there is any unauthorized
person staying in the hostel, etc., and whether there is any
unauthorized use of electrical appliances etc., or not.
2026:HHC:34557
21.
Therefore, in light of the responsibilities with
which the Warden has been entrusted under the relevant
Rules of the respondent University, a Hostel Warden is not
supposed to nor can be expected to perform all these duties
either in absentia or from a distant location. For this, the
personal presence of the Hostel Warden within the hostel
premises is required and
a Hostel Warden can obviously
perform his/her responsibilities to the best of his/her abilities
if he/she resides in an accommodation within the hostel
premises.
22.
Therefore, in these circumstances, a Hostel
Warden
is
required
to
stay
in
the
Hostel
Warden
accommodation and the exception carved out under Rule 3 of
Notification dated 26.10.2015 in the House Allotment Rules
framed by the University in terms of Notification dated
26.10.2015, comes to the rescue of the petitioner.
23.
The petitioner in her capacity as a Hostel Warden
and that too of a girls hostel essentially was required to stay
at the campus because the hostel is indeed a part of the
2026:HHC:34557
campus. Therefore, in these circumstances, the stay of the
petitioner in the accommodation of the Hostel Warden
cannot be termed as either in breach or violation of Rule 3 of
the House Allotment Rules or an overstay in terms of notice
dated 22.11.2024.
24.
This Court further finds merit in the contention of
learned counsel for the petitioner that the accommodation of
a Hostel Warden cannot be equated with the General Pool
Accommodation of a University. This is for the reason that
any other employee of the University, be it teaching or nonteaching faculty, if he/she has a house in the vicinity of the
University and if he/she resides in his/her own house, then
the accommodation of the University, which otherwise was to
be occupied by such an incumbent can be given to some other
employee. However, as far as a Hostel Warden is concerned,
because there is only one Hostel Warden and as there is an
earmarked accommodation for him/her, if the Hostel Warden
is forced to stay in his/her own house, the hostel
accommodation otherwise cannot be allotted to any other
2026:HHC:34557
person. Therefore, also, the issuance of Annexure P-10 is not
sustainable in law.
25.
Accordingly, in light of the observations made
hereinabove, as this Court is of the considered view that the
notice of recovery that has been issued to the petitioner is not
sustainable in law, as it cannot be said that the continuation
of the petitioner to occupy Hostel Warden Accommodation
after she had constructed her own house in Shanti, District
Solan was in violation of Rule 3 of the House Allotment Rules,
this petition is allowed. Office order dated 22.11.2024
(Annexure P-10) is quashed and set aside. No recovery shall
be effected from the petitioner on the basis of impugned
officer order. It is further ordered that any post-retrieval
benefits to which the petitioner is entitled to, which have
been withheld on account of the pendency of this writ
petition, shall be forthwith released in favour of the
petitioner without making any deduction, reference whereof
is given in relief No (ii) in the writ petition. Pending
miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand disposed of
2026:HHC:34557
accordingly.
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
August 17, 2026
(Guleria)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review