Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 30TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
CRIMINAL PETITION NO. 17281 OF 2025
BETWEEN:
NISHAN ABDUL KAHDER
S/O ABDUL AZEEZ
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
R/AT 222/6, CHOKKABETLU
BEHIND MJM MARRIAGE HALL
KRISHNAPURA
MANGALORE - SURTHKAL
D.K. – 575 014.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI DINESHKUMAR RAO K., ADVOCATE)
AND:
Digitally
signed by
SANJEEVINI J
KARISHETTY
Location:
High Court of
Karnataka
1.
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY MANGALORE EAST POLICE STATION
COMPLAINANT, D.K. – 575 001
REPRESENTED BY
STATE BY PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
HIGH COURT BUILDINGS
BENGALURU - 560 001.
2.
SRI SOTTY POLICARD A. M.,
S/O MATHEW POLICARD
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS
R/AT CYARISH OFFICE
THALASH KANNUR
-2NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
KANNUR DISTRICT
KERALA – 670 001.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI VINAY MAHADEVAIAH, HCGP FOR R1)
THIS CRL.P IS FILED U/S 482 CR.PC PRAYING TO QUASH
THE ENTIRE PROCEEDINGS AGAINST THE PETITIONER IN CC
NO.3069/2013 (CHARGE SHEETED FOR OFFENCES P/U/S 143,
144, 504, 506 R/W 149 OF IPC AND PENDING ON THE FILE OF
THE JMFC (II COURT) AT MANGALURU D.K.
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
ORAL ORDER
The petitioner is before this Court calling in question
continuance of proceedings in C.C.No.3069/2013, pending
before the JMFC (II Court), Mangaluru, D.K., for the offences
punishable under Sections 143, 144, 504, 506 r/w. 149 of the
IPC.
2. Heard Sri Dineshkumar Rao K., learned counsel for
petitioner and Sri Vinay Mahadevaiah, learned High Court
Government Pleader for respondent No.1.
3. The petitioner is accused No.5, who gets embroiled in a
crime registered for the aforesaid offences.
The police after
-3NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
investigation file a charge sheet in C.C.No.2533/2006 for the
aforesaid offences. At the relevant point in time, the petitioner
was not available for trial and the other accused who were
available for trial, who are accused Nos.2, 4, 6 and 8 were tried
and have been acquitted of the offences in C.C.No.2533/2006,
by the judgment dated 05.10.2015, on the score that the
prosecution has miserably failed to prove the guilt beyond all
reasonable doubt.
4. The judgment of the concerned Court acquitting
accused Nos.2, 4, 6 and 8 reads as follows:
“R E A S O N S
12. POINT No.1 to 4:-C.W-1 is the victim of the
offence. C.W-2 to 4 are cited as eyewitnesses. But, none
of them are secured by the prosecution. Only evidence
that is available on record is that of the I.O. Admittedly,
he is not the eyewitness to the alleged incident.
Therefore, his evidence with regard to registration of
case, based on first information statement (Ex.P-1)
lodged by C.W-1; dispatching FIR (Ex.P-2) to the Court;
drawing of spot mahazar (Ex.P-3); arrest of accused;
recording of voluntary statement of accused No.1, leading
to seizure of knife (M.O-1) under Ex.P-4; recording of
statements of witnesses; and filing of charge-sheet, will
not render any sort of assistance to prove the alleged
incident. Admittedly, M.O-1 has not been recovered from
the accused herein. On the contrary, it was allegedly
recovered from accused No.1, based on the information
received through him in his confession statement. Hardly
any substantive evidence is available on record to show
that the accused herein had common object with co-
-4NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
accused in forming unlawful assembly; rioting; abusing
C.W-1 in filthy language; and threatening him with dire
consequences. Thus, there is dearth of evidence to prove
that the accused herein had common object with
remaining accused in committing the offence. Therefore,
the accused No.2, 4, 6 and 8 cannot be held guilty.
Therefore, this Court does not have any hesitation to hold
that the prosecution failed to prove the charges against
the accused No.2, 4, 6 and 8. In the result, I answer Point
No.1 to 4 in the Negative.
13. Point No.5:-In view of the above discussions, I
proceed to pass following:
ORDER
Acting under Sec. 248(1) of Cr.P.C., A-2, 4, 6
and 8 are acquitted of the offences punishable
under Sections 143, 147, 504 and 506 read
with Section 149 of IPC.
Their bail bond and the surety bond shall stand
Cancelled Preserve the entire records and the
case property till the disposal of split-up cases
registered against A-1, 3, 5, 7 and 9.
Since, A-2 has appeared in this case, trial held
and judgment is pronounced as against him,
split-up case registered in C.C.No.3069/2013,
in so far as A-2 is concerned, is ordered to be
closed.
Office is directed to place the records of
C.C.No.3069/2013 and C.C.No.2874/2015 for
passing suitable order in terms of observation
made in paragraph No.6 of this judgment.”
5. The petitioner since was not available for trial at the
relevant point in time, a split charge sheet has been drawn
against him in C.C.No.3069/2013 and the trial is now sought to
-5NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
be continued. The petitioner has escaped trial. Generally,
indulgence should not be shown to those who would escape
trial. But, today the precious judicial time cannot be permitted
to be wasted on impending acquittal that is going to happen in
the case at hand, as the petitioner was one of those accused
persons in the alleged unlawful assembly, against whom
judgment of acquittal is passed.
There cannot be a different
order in the case at hand against the petitioner.
6. In that light, to save precious judicial time, I deem it
appropriate to obliterate the proceedings. The view of mine, in
this regard, is fortified by the judgment of this Court dated
02.09.2022 passed in Crl.P.No.7720/2022, which reads as
follows:
“4.
The learned Sessions Judge, by his order
dated 01.12.2021, acquits accused Nos.1 to 11, 14, 16 to
18 and 21 in S.C.No.103/2018. At the relevant point in
time, when the trial was on, the petitioner was not
available for trial, as he was allegedly absconding and a
split charge sheet was issued against the petitioner in
S.C.No.87/2019 in terms of an order of the learned
Sessions Judge dated 10.06.2019. The continuation of
proceedings in S.C.No.87/2019 is what drives the
petitioner to this Court in the subject petition.
5.
Learned counsel, Sri. Lethif B., appearing for
the petitioner would contend that the allegations are the
ones punishable under Sections 143, 147, 148, 448, 323,
324, 427, 395, 149 of the IPC. The said allegation is
necessarily to be common against all the accused and it is
-6NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
infact common against all the accused. The acquittal
order passed by the concerned Court is on the basis of
the complainant himself turning hostile. In the teeth of
the fact that the complainant himself turned hostile, the
Court holds that the prosecution has failed to prove the
guilt beyond all reasonable doubt and therefore, the
petitioner is entitled to be the same order as is passed by
the concerned Court acquitting the aforesaid accused.
6.
Learned HCGP would however refute the
submission to contend that the petitioner would escape
trial, should necessarily face trial and considered for
acquittal by the concerned Court and this Court should
not interfere at this juncture, as a person, who has
escaped trial should not be shown any indulgence under
section 482 of Cr.P.C .
7.
I have given my anxious consideration to the
respective submissions made by the learned counsel and
have perused the material on record.
8.
The afore-narrated facts are not in dispute.
The allegation against the petitioner are the ones
punishable under Sections 143, 147, 148, 448, 323, 324,
427, 395, 149 of the IPC. The allegation was against 22
accused and the offences alleged were common, the
allegations are also common. The concerned Court, by its
order dated 01.12.2021, acquits accused Nos.1, to 11,
14, 16 to 18 and 21 by rendering the following reason:
REASONS
9.
Poin"t No.1 to 5: The P.W.1 has
stated that on 15.09.2013 at about 8.30 p.m.
when P.W.4 was insider the Bar, somebody
picked up quarrel with him and those persons
damaged the Bar and hence, he sustained
injuries. He has also stated that, the P.W.2 also
sustained injuries in the incident and both of
them taken treatment in the Wenlock hospital.
The P.W.2, P.W.4 and Babanna sustained
injuries and therefore, he filed the first
information before the Police. He has deposed
that the police came to the Bar and drawn the
panchanama in Ex.P.2. The P.W.2 has deposed
that when he was in the Bar of P.W.1 many
-7NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
people assembled and one of them thrown
stone towards him and therefore, himself and
P.W.4 sustained injuries and took treatment in
the hospital.
10.
P.W.3 has deposed that on
15.09.2013 at about 8.30 p.m. the P.W.4 was
inside the Bar, about 25 persons came to the
Bar and there was quarrel between P.W.4 and
those 25 persons. He has deposed that such 25
persons damaged the Bar and he took
treatment in Wenlock hospital for the injuries
sustained in the incident. The P.W.1 to 3 have
not stated the name of any of the accused of
this case and even not identified the accused.
The prosecution treated these witnesses hostile
and cross examined. The P.W.1 to 3 have
totally denied the allegation that the accused of
this case have quarrelled with P.W.4, assaulted
P.W.7 to 7, damaged the Bar and committed
dacoity of Rs.2,000/- from the Bar.
11.
The P.W.4 to 7 have totally denied
the incident itself. The P.W.8 and P.W.9 have
deposed that they have not witnesses the
incident. The P.W.4 to 9 have been cross
examined by the prosecution and even in the
cross-examination the P.W.4 to 9 denied the
allegation made by the prosecution. Therefore,
there is no evidence against the accused that
they
have
formed
unlawful
assembly,
committed criminal trespass in the Bar of
P.W.1, voluntarily caused hurt to P.W.1 to 7 and
committed dacoity of Rs.2,000/- from the Bar of
P.W.1. Hence, the accused cannot be convicted
for the offences alleged against them because
of insufficient evidence. Accordingly, I answer
these points in the Negative and proceed to
pass the following:
ORDER
Acting under Section 232 of Code of
Criminal Procedure the accused No.1 to 11, 14,
16 to 18 and 21 are acquitted for the offences
punishable under Section 143, 147, 148, 448,
-8NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
323, 324, 395, 427 r/w 149 of Indian Penal
Code.
Their bal bond stands cancelled.
Office is directed to retain the material
objects as they are required in split up cases."
9.
The reason for acquitting the other accused as
afore-quoted is the fact that the complainant himself had
turned hostile and other witnesses had not supported the
charge sheet. If the complainant had turned hostile and it
resulting in acquittal of the aforesaid accused, it cannot
but be said that the same would be applicable to the
petitioner as well, notwithstanding the fact that he was not
available for trial. It is not the case of sending the
petitioner for trial for the very same offences and result
being the same as is ordered on 01.12.2021 in
S.C.No.103/2018. It would be an exercise in futility to
permit further trial, which would be of no utility and be a
waste of judicial time.
10.
The view of mine, in this regard, is fortified by
the judgment rendered by a Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court in Crl.P.4796/2017, wherein the Co-ordinate Bench
considering identical set of facts has held as follows:
“12.
Having
heard
the
learned
Advocates appearing for parties and on perusal
of
records
it
would
disclose
that
petitioner/accused was never traced and nonbailable warrant issued against him was never
executed. Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION vs
AKHILESH SINGH reported in AIR 2005
SCC 268 has held quashing of charge and
order discharging co-accused can be passed, if
the proceedings initiated against co-accused is
on similar allegations and if said judgment had
reached finality. It is also held that discharge
of a co-accused by the High Court by holding
that no purpose would be served in further
proceeding with the case, is just and proper.
In another ruling in MOHAMMED ILIAS vs.
STATE OF KARNATAKA reported in (2001)
3 Kant LJ 551 this Court has held as under:
-9NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
“The petitioner is the accused in
the case and he is shown to be the
absconding. Therefore, the case
against the petitioner was split up
and charge-sheet was laid against
other available accused Nos.1 and
3 for committing an offence
punishable under Sections 498A
and 307 IPC r/w 34 Indian Penal
Code, 1860. After the trial, the
Sessions
Judge
acquitted
the
accused Nos.1 to 3. The petitioner
was arrested and proceedings were
revived against him in the split
charge sheet.... In the instant case
also, the full pledged trial was held
against accused Nos.1 to 3, in
respect of the same offence. In the
second round of trial against the
petitioner, the evidence to be
produced cannot be different from
the one that was produced by the
prosecution in the earlier case.
Therefore, in that view of the
matter, the proceeding is quashed.”
13.
Yet, in another ruling THE STATE
OF KARNATAKA vs. K.C.NARASEGOWDA
reported in ILR 2005 Kar. 1822 this Court
has held to the following effect:
“As the case before the Sessions
Judge is not a pending case, he
cannot keep the file any longer
pending nor he can close the case
as he has to await appearance of
the accused or the production by
the State, for passing orders
regarding undergoing sentence. As
such, considering these peculiar
facts and circumstances, it is
deemed proper to exercise the
inherent jurisdiction under Section
of
Cr.P.C.
instead
of
jurisdiction under Section 385 of
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
Cr.P.C. in the interest of justice. As
the entire material evidence of the
prosecutions is one and the same,
as against all the accused including
the non-appealing accused No.1,
who is said to be absconding, there
is no second opinion that he is also
entitled for the same benefit of
doubt as he is extended for his coaccused. Accused acquitted by
giving benefit of doubt.”
14. In this background, when the facts
on hand are examined, it would clearly indicate
that not only complainant but also other
witnesses including the inmates of ambulance
in which they were travelling on the date of
incident, had turned hostile in the proceedings
which was continued against co-accused.
Though, P.W.1 – complainant had admitted
that he has lodged a compliant as per Ex.P-1
and had also admitted that he has given a
statement identifying the accused before the
Investigation Officer, he did not identify the
accused persons present before Court. In fact,
statements given by him as per Exs.P-2 to P-4
when confronted, he denied the same and had
also denied the suggestion put by the public
prosecutor that he had furnished the
statements as per Exs.P-2 to P-4 as false.
P.W.2 to P.W.8 had not identified the accused
persons
present before the jurisdictional
Sessions Court. In fact, they have not even
identified the statements made by them before
the
Investigating
Officer
and
nothing
worthwhile has been elicited in their crossexamination to disbelieve
their evidence.
Thus, taking into consideration said evidence
available on record Sessions Court had arrived
at a conclusion that evidence of the witnesses
examined by prosecution would not come to
their assistance. In fact, witnesses to the
seizure
panchnama - Ex.P-40, who were
examined as P.W.16 and P.W.17, have also
turned hostile and they have stated that police
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
had called them a year back to the police
station and when they went to the police
station, they had not seen any accused
persons in police station. However, they admit
police having taken their signatures on the
papers and contents of it were not known to
them.
15. It is in this background, trial Court
on appreciation of entire evidence had
acquitted all the accused persons by holding
that prosecution had failed to prove the
offence alleging accused persons beyond
reasonable doubt attracting the ingredients of
provisions of the offence alleged against them.
In fact, Sessions Court has observed that there
was certain communal disturbance in Dakshina
Kannada district and other places at Bantwal
Taluk and to please on community of people,
the Investigating Officer might have falsely
implicated the accused persons in a false case
or to avoid the blame to be received from the
public or other community people and such
possibilities cannot be ruled out. In this
background, when prayer of petitioner sought
for in the present petition is examined, it can
be noticed that contents of supplementary
charge sheet filed against the petitioner is
similar, identical and in fact, it is replica of
charge made against accused Nos.1 to 23 and
25 to 33, who15 were tried in S.C.No.12/2007,
94/2007 and 26/2008 and had been acquitted.
16. In that view of the matter, this
Court is of the firm view that judgment
rendered by trial Court insofar as it relates to
accused Nos.1 to 23 and 25 to 33 is similar
and identical to the charge made against the
present petitioner. This Court does not find
any independent or separate material having
been placed by the prosecution against
present petitioner to put him on trial once
again and directing the petitioner-accused to
undergo the order of trial, which ultimately
would fetch same result as that of accused
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
Nos.1 to 23 and 25 to 33. When allegation
made against accused Nos.1 to 23 and 25 to
33 is compared with the allegation made
against present petitioner, it has to be
necessarily held that they are identical, similar
and inseparable in nature and no independent
decision can be taken against the present
petitioner. Therefore, no purpose would be
served even if the present petitioner is ordered
to be tried by the trial Court.
17. In view of the afore stated facts and
the law laid down, as discussed hereinabove, it
would emerge that there would be no harm or
injustice that would be caused to prosecution if
benefit of acquittal order is passed in favour of
accused – petitioner, since accused Nos.1 to
23 and 25 to 33 against whom similar
allegation had been made is already acquitted.
Though, it is contended by Sri. Rachaiah,
learned HCGP appearing for the State that
petitioner should not be extended said benefit,
since he is an absconder, by relying upon
judgment of Coordinate Bench this Court is not
inclined to accept said contention for single
reason that said judgment had been rendered
based on the judgment of Apex Court in the
case of DEEPAK RAJAK vs. STATE OF WEST
BENGAL reported in (2007) 15 SCC 305
where under Apex Court after noticing the
facts obtained in the said case, had held that
benefit of acquittal, should be extended to the
appellant, since co-accused had been acquitted
and held that a departure can be made in
cases where accused has not surrendered
“after conviction” in addition to not filing an
appeal against the conviction.
As such,
noticing earlier position of law laid down it was
held by the Apex Court that in case of acquittal
of a accused for same offence on same set of
facts and on similar accusations, if considered,
it would entile for acquittal of co-accused also.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
18. In that view of the matter,
present proceedings initiated against petitioner
is liable to be quashed.
Hence, I proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
(i) Criminal petition is hereby allowed.
(ii) Proceedings in C.C.No.1170/2007 pending
on the file of Addl. Civil Judge & JMFC,
Bantwal, in Cr.No.130/2006 registered by
Bantwal Rural Police Station, is hereby
quashed insofar petitioner is concerned.
In view of criminal petition having been
disposed of on merits, I.A.No.1/2017 for stay
does not survive for consideration and same
stands rejected.”
The Co-ordinate Bench was considering a case
where the co-accused who had escaped trial had not
surrendered or was not arrested by the police.
In the light of there being no evidence against any
of the accused and the split up charge against the
petitioner being tried now before the learned Sessions
Judge would become an exercise in futility. In the teeth of
there being no evidence or a specific charge against this
petitioner, that was not charged against others, I deem it
appropriate to obliterate the proceedings against the
petitioner.”
In the light of the afore-quoted order of this Court,
allegations against the petitioner and other accused, who are
acquitted of the offences being similar, the petitioner is entitled
to succeed in the subject petition for the very same reasons
rendered by this Court.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:5194
CRL.P No. 17281 of 2025
HC-KAR
7. For the aforesaid reasons, the following:
ORDER
(i)
The Criminal Petition is allowed.
(ii)
The
proceedings
in
C.C.No.3069/2013
(original
C.C.No.2533/2006), pending before the Court of
JMFC
(II
Court),
Mangaluru,
D.K.,
qua
petitioner, stand quashed.
Sd/(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE
NVJ
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 40
CT:SS
the
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review