Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 05.02.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 16.02.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 16.02.2026
+
W.P.(C) 17518/2025 & CM APPL. 72332/2025
DINESH & ANR.
.....Petitioners
versus
COUNCIL OF SCIENTIFIC AND INDUSTRIAL RESEARCH
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR
GENERAL & ANR.
.....Respondents
+
W.P.(C) 18506/2025 & CM APPL. 76747/2025
NISHA
.....Petitioner
versus
COUNCIL OF SCIENTIFIC AND INDUSTRIAL RESEARCH
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR
GENERAL & ANR.
.....Respondents
+
W.P.(C) 17604/2025 & CM APPL. 72719/2025
RAJENDER SINGH
.....Petitioner
versus
COUNCIL OF SCIENTIFIC AND
INDUSTRIAL RESEARCH
.....Respondent
+
W.P.(C) 17645/2025 & CM APPL. 72885/2025
NISHANT & ORS.
.....Petitioners
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Respondents
+
W.P.(C) 17648/2025 & CM APPL. 72902/2025
KARTAVYA & ANR.
.....Petitioners
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Respondents
+
W.P.(C) 17605/2025 & CM APPL. 72721/2025
NAVEEN DESWAL
.....Petitioner
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR.
.....Respondents
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 17518/2025 & connected matters
15:37:50
+
W.P.(C) 17623/2025 & CM APPL. 72774/2025
AMIT DAHIYA & ANR.
.....Petitioner
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Respondents
+
W.P.(C) 17629/2025 & CM APPL. 72790/2025
PARMESH & ORS.
.....Petitioners
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Respondents
+
W.P.(C) 17668/2025 & CM APPL. 72990/2025
ROHITASH MEENA
.....Petitioner
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Respondents
+
W.P.(C) 17675/2025, CM APPL. 73009/2025 & CM APPL.
7843/2026
SACHIN DAHIYA
.....Petitioner
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Respondents
+
W.P.(C) 17844/2025 & CM APPL. 73685/2025
SOHAN LAL KURI & ORS.
.....Petitioners
versus
COUNCIL OF SCIENTIFIC AND INDUSTRIAL
RESEARCH (CSIR & ORS.
.....Respondents
+
W.P.(C) 18349/2025, CM APPL. 75964/2025 & CM APPL.
1045/2026
SHIVCHARAN MEENA & ANR.
.....Petitioners
versus
COUNCIL OF SCIENTIFIC AND
INDUSTRIAL RESEARCH THROUGH
ITS DIRECTOR & ANR.
.....Respondents
+
W.P.(C) 19205/2025 & CM APPL. 80018/2025
ASHISH MEENA
.....Petitioner
versus
COUNCIL OF SCIENTIFIC AND INDUSTRIAL
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 17518/2025 & connected matters
15:37:50
RESEARCH
.....Respondent
Present:
For Petitioners
Ms. Puja Jakhar, Mr. Harshit Prakash, Ms. Ekta Bharati, Mr.
Satyam Dwivedi, Mr. Shrey, Mr. Gagandeep RM, Mr. Gurveer
Lally, Mr. Indranil Chakravorty, Advs. in Item Nos. 63 to 71
Mr Shanker Raju and Mr Nilansh Gaur, Advocates in Item No.
For Respondents
Mr. Sanjoy Ghose, Sr. Advocate along with Mr. Arun Sanwal,
Mr. Aditya Mani Sharma & Mr. Rohan Mandal, Advocates for
CSIR in Item No. 61
Mr. Sanjoy Ghose, Sr. Adv. with Mr. Arun Sanwal & Mr.
Aditya Mani Sharma, Advocates for CSIR in Item No. 62
Mr. Arun Sanwal & Mr. Aditya Mani Sharma, Advocates for
CSIR in item No. 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70,72
Mr. Sanjoy Ghose, Senior Advocate with Mr. Arun Sanwal and
Mr. Rohan Mandal, Advs. for CSIR in Item No. 73
Mr. Sahaj Garg, SPC with Mr. Sanjay Pal, GP in Item No. 61
Mr.Rakh Pal Singh, SPC Mr.Sambhav Sharma,G.P for R2 in
Item No. 62
Ms. Shubhi Bhardwaj, SPC with Mr. Sanjay Pal, GP for UoI in
Item No. 64
Dr. Vijendra Singh Mahndiyan CGSC for R1 in Item No. 65
Mr. Atul Tanwar, Adv. for R1 in Item No. 66
Ms. Neha Rastogi(Sr. Panel Counsel), Mr. Animesh Rastogi,
Mr. Rajat Dubey, Mr. Shashank Pandey, Ms. Kanchan Semwal
(G.P.), Advocates in Item No. 67
Dr. Ishaan Swarana Sharma, SPC with Ms. Shambhavi Sharma,
GP, Mr. Shubham Shukla, Mr. Ayush, Mr. Mukund Ranjan,
Ms. Avantika Pandey, Ms. Vanshika Arora, Advocates in Item
No. 68
Mr. Ripudaman Bhardwaj, CGSC with Ms. Laavanya Kaushik
(GP) with Mr. Amit Kumar, Ms Pragati Trivedi, Mr Kushagra
Kumar & Ms. Khyaati Bansal, Advs. for
R1 in Item No. 69
Ms. Urvashi Basak, Advocate (Government Pleader) for R1 in
Item No. 70
Mr. Sanjoy Ghose, Senior Advocate along with Mr. Jasbir
Bidhuri and Mr. Aditya Mani Sharma, Advs. for R1 in Item No.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 17518/2025 & connected matters
15:37:50
Mr. Vinay Kaushik, Government Pleader in Item No. 72
Mr. Ashish K Dixit, CGSC with Mr. Umar Hashmi, Ms. Iqra
Shiekh, Ms. Deepika Kalra, Ms. Venni Kakkar & Ms. Urmila
Sharma, Advs. in Item No. 72
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
Through the present batch of Writ Petitions filed under Articles
226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, the Petitioners assail the
correctness of the common Order dated 08.09.2025 [hereinafter
referred to as „Impugned Order‟] passed by the learned Central
Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi [hereinafter
referred to as „the Tribunal‟], whereby the Original Applications
instituted by the Petitioners challenging the prescription of minimum
threshold marks in Paper-III by the Council of Scientific & Industrial
Research [hereinafter referred to as „CSIR‟] in Combined
Administrative Services Examination-2023 [hereinafter referred to as
„CASE-2023‟] were dismissed.
2.
In essence, the Petitioners contend that the Respondent-CSIR
acted arbitrarily and contrary to the terms of the Recruitmentadvertisement by prescribing minimum qualifying marks for Paper-III
after the commencement of the recruitment process, thereby altering
the rules of the game mid-way. It is urged that such a prescription
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 17518/2025 & connected matters
15:37:50
resulted in the exclusion of the Petitioners from consideration for the
post of Section Officer („SO‟).
3.
Hence, the issue that falls for consideration before this Court is
whether
the
Respondent-CSIR
was
empowered
under
the
Recruitment-advertisement to prescribe minimum threshold marks for
Stage-II (Paper-III) of CASE-2023, and whether the prescription of
such threshold marks vitiates the recruitment process as being
arbitrary or contrary to settled principles governing public
employment.
4.
Since the issues raised in all the Petitions arise out of the same
recruitment process, involve identical questions of law and fact, and
challenge the same order of the Tribunal, they are being disposed of
by this common judgment.
FACTUAL MATRIX:
5.
In order to appreciate the controversy, it is necessary to briefly
advert to the relevant facts.
6.
The Respondent-CSIR, on 08.12.2023, issued Advertisement
No.E-1/RC/2023/1
[hereinafter
referred
to
as
„Recruitment-
advertisement‟], inviting applications for the CASE-2023 for filling
444 posts, comprising 76 posts of SO and 368 posts of Assistant
Section Officer („ASO‟). As per the Recruitment-advertisement, the
online application process commenced on 08.12.2023, and the last
date for submission of applications was 12.01.2024.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 17518/2025 & connected matters
15:37:50
7.
Significantly,
the
aforesaid
Recruitment-advertisement
expressly stipulated that “Minimum threshold marks, wherever
prescribed/required, would be decided by the Competent Authority”.
It further stipulated that “The above process is suggestive only.”
8.
The exercise consists of Stage-I and Stage-II. Paper-I and
Paper-II in Stage-I and Paper-III in Stage-II were prescribed as
common and compulsory papers, with further stages of interview for
the post of SO and a Computer Proficiency Test for ASO.
9.
The Stage-I (Paper-I and Paper-II) examination was conducted
between 05.02.2024 and 20.02.2024. Thereafter, vide Notice dated
03.06.2024, the Respondent-CSIR declared the Stage-I results along
with cut-off marks. The applicants were shortlisted for Stage-II
(Paper-III), which was scheduled to be conducted on 07.07.2024.
10.
Prior to the conduct of Paper-III of Stage-II, the Respondent-
CSIR issued a Notice dated 28.06.2024 prescribing minimum
qualifying marks for Paper-III, keeping in view the functional
requirements of the post.
11.
Thereafter, the Petitioners appeared in Stage-II (Paper-III) of
the CASE-2023. Subsequently, on 02.10.2024, the Respondent-CSIR
issued the list of candidates shortlisted for interview for the post of
SO. The Petitioners were not shortlisted, having failed to secure the
minimum qualifying marks in Paper-III.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 17518/2025 & connected matters
15:37:50
12.
The final result of CASE-2023 was declared on 02.01.2025,
followed by the issuance of appointment letters and joining of selected
candidates.
13.
It is only thereafter that the Petitioners approached the Tribunal
by filing Original Applications challenging the prescription of
minimum threshold marks in Paper-III.
14.
The Tribunal, upon a detailed consideration, dismissed the
Original Applications vide the Impugned Order, on the following
grounds:
i.
The discretion to prescribe threshold marks was expressly
reserved in favour of the Respondent-CSIR in the Recruitmentadvertisement itself.
ii.
The threshold marks were notified prior to the relevant stage of
examination.
iii.
The candidates who participate in such an exercise without
protest are estopped from challenging the same at a later stage.
15.
Aggrieved by the same, the present batch of Writ Petitions has
been preferred by the respective Petitioners.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES:
16.
Heard learned Counsel for the parties at length and, with their
able assistance, perused the paperbook.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 17518/2025 & connected matters
15:37:50
17.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioners has submitted that the
prescription of minimum threshold marks amounted to changing the
rules of the game after commencement of the recruitment process.
Reliance has been placed upon the judgments rendered in Tej Prakash
Pathak & Ors. v. Rajasthan High Court & Ors.1; and Salam
Samarjeet Singh v. High Court of Manipur at Imphal and Anr.2
18.
Per contra, learned Senior Counsel for the Respondent-CSIR
has submitted that:
i.
The Recruitment-advertisement, under Clause 5-A titled
“Scheme of Examination”, expressly stipulates that “minimum
threshold marks, wherever prescribed/required, shall be decided by
the Competent Authority”. The Recruitment-advertisement, therefore,
unequivocally reserves discretion in favour of the Respondent-CSIR
to prescribe minimum qualifying marks at the relevant stage of the
selection process.
ii.
The minimum threshold for Stage-II (Paper-III) was duly
notified to the candidates prior to the commencement of Paper-III, and
hence, no element of surprise or arbitrariness can be attributed to the
said decision.
iii.
Learned Senior Counsel also raised a preliminary objection
regarding non-joinder of necessary parties, contending that the
candidates who have already been selected pursuant to the recruitment
process are required to be impleaded, as their rights would be directly
2024 INSC 847
(2024) 14 SCC 179
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 17518/2025 & connected matters
15:37:50
affected. It is pointed out that while in W.P.(C) No.17844/2025,
certain ASO candidates have been arrayed as parties, even therein
their particulars have not been disclosed, and candidates selected for
the post of SO have not been impleaded in any of the Writ Petitions.
19.
No other submissions have been made by the learned Counsel
representing the parties.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
20.
It is trite that a recruitment advertisement constitutes the charter
governing the selection process. The rights of candidates and the
discretion of the recruiting authority must, therefore, be examined
primarily with reference to the express stipulations contained therein.
In the present case, Clause 5-A of the Recruitment-advertisement,
under the heading “Scheme of Examination”, categorically provides
that “Minimum threshold marks, wherever prescribed/required, shall
be decided by the Competent Authority”. Additionally, the
advertisement clarifies that the outlined process is “suggestive only”.
These stipulations unmistakably reserve discretion in favour of the
Respondent-CSIR to prescribe qualifying benchmarks at appropriate
stages of the examination.
21.
Once such discretion is expressly reserved in the Recruitment-
advertisement, the contention that the prescription of minimum
qualifying marks amounts to altering the rules of the game mid-way is
rendered untenable. The candidates entered the selection process with
clear notice that the competent authority retained the power to
prescribe threshold marks wherever required. The exercise of such
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 17518/2025 & connected matters
15:37:50
power, therefore, cannot be characterised as an ex post facto
introduction of a new criterion.
22.
The legal position in this regard stands authoritatively settled by
the decision of Five Judge Bench of the Supreme Court in Tej
Prakash Pathak (supra). The Supreme Court, while delineating the
contours of permissible discretion in recruitment processes, has held
that in the absence of statutory rules to the contrary, a recruiting
authority is entitled to evolve an appropriate selection methodology,
including the prescription of minimum benchmarks, provided such
benchmarks are notified before the commencement of the relevant
stage and do not take candidates by surprise. The Court clarified that
what is impermissible is a post-evaluation change in criteria, and not
the prescription of qualifying standards prior to the conduct of the
concerned stage.
23.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present
case, it is evident that the minimum qualifying marks for Paper-III
were notified on 28.06.2024, whereas Stage-II (Paper-III) was
conducted on 07.07.2024. The prescription of threshold marks thus
preceded the relevant stage of examination. Neither the evaluation
process nor the outcome of the examination influenced the fixation of
the benchmark. Consequently, the decision falls squarely within the
permissible domain recognised by Tej Prakash Pathak (supra).
24.
The reliance placed by the Petitioners on Salam Samarjeet
Singh (supra) is misplaced. The said decision turned on a situation
where the selection criteria for the viva voce test were altered on the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 17518/2025 & connected matters
15:37:50
eve of the viva voce, that too after the conclusion of the written
examination. In contradistinction, the present case is one where the
power to prescribe minimum threshold marks was expressly
contemplated by the Recruitment-advertisement itself and was
exercised prior to the conduct of the concerned paper. The Petitioners
have also failed to allege and prove prejudice because prescription of
minimum marks was a process of short listing the candidates for next
stage and was applicable uniformly across the board.
25.
It is also relevant to note that the prescription of minimum
qualifying marks was justified by the Respondent-CSIR on the basis
of the functional requirements of the posts in question. No material
has been placed on record to demonstrate that the threshold so
prescribed
was
manifestly
arbitrary,
irrational,
or
wholly
disproportionate. In the absence of such material, this Court would be
slow to interfere with an administrative decision taken by an expert
body in matters of recruitment, particularly when the decision is
traceable to an express enabling clause.
26.
Furthermore, once participated in the examination without
raising any objection and taken their chance, the Petitioners cannot be
allowed to challenge the examination after not qualifying.
Undisputedly, criterion was same for everyone.
27.
A preliminary objection regarding non-joinder of selected
candidates was raised on behalf of the Respondent-CSIR. While the
submission merits consideration, this Court does not deem it
necessary to examine the same in detail, as the challenge to the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 17518/2025 & connected matters
15:37:50
recruitment process fails on merits. Once it is held that the
prescription of minimum threshold marks was within the competence
of the Respondent-CSIR and in conformity with law, adjudication on
the issue of non-joinder would be purely academic.
CONCLUSION:
28.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds no
infirmity in the reasoning adopted by the Tribunal. The Tribunal has
correctly appreciated the terms of the Recruitment-advertisement and
applied the law laid down by the Supreme Court. The Impugned
Order does not suffer from any illegality, arbitrariness, or perversity
warranting interference under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution
of India. Accordingly, the Impugned Order dated 08.09.2025 is
upheld.
29.
The present Petitions are accordingly dismissed. All pending
applications also stand closed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
FEBRUARY 16, 2026
jai/sh
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
W.P.(C) 17518/2025 & connected matters
15:37:50
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review