Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~1 (02.03.2026)
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 10765/2018, CM APPL. 42471/2019
NIRMALA @ BHARPAI
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Pardeep Kumar, Advocate.
Versus
GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & ANR
Through:
.....Respondents
Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC for
GNCTD Services with Mr. N.K.
Singh, Ms. Aliza Alam and Mr.
Mohnish Sehrawat, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
28.03.2026
%
[As per to Notification No. 64/G-4/Gen1.-I/DHC dated 27th February, 2026,
matters listed on 2nd March, 2026 (on account of “Holi”), are to be taken
up on 28th March, 2026.”]
1.
This writ petition arises out of a claim for grant of family pension in
respect of late Shri Guru Dutt Sharma and constitutes a second round of
litigation between the parties. The dispute essentially relates to the question
as to who was the legally wedded spouse of the deceased employee, basis
which the Petitioner (Nirmala @ Bharpai) seeks entitlement to the family
mention. The matter, therefore, turns on the determination of her marital
status, which is sought to be established on the basis of documents on
record.
2.
Few foundational facts are not in dispute. Shri Guru Dutt Sharma
W.P.(C) 10765/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 11:06:46
served as a Trained Graduate Teacher in Respondent No. 2 school. He
retired from service on 30th November, 1989 and died on 10th November,
2014. Kanta Devi, whose name stands reflected in the pension records as his
wife, had predeceased him on 24th February, 2003. Nirmala has since passed
away. The present petition is now being pursued by Mr. Ashok Kumar
Sharma, stated to be the son of late Shri Guru Dutt Sharma through Kanta
Devi, who seeks to continue the proceedings as a legal representative of
Nirmala on the basis of a Will stated to have been executed in his favour.
3.
Nirmala’s case was that she was the first and only legally wedded
wife of late Shri Guru Dutt Sharma, having married him on 12 th December,
1946 according to Hindu rites. According to her, no child was born from that
marriage and, for that reason, Shri Guru Dutt Sharma later entered into a
second marriage with Kanta Devi without obtaining any decree of divorce.
On that footing, it was asserted that the marriage with Kanta Devi was void
in law and that Nirmala alone was entitled to family pension.
4.
This Court, in the earlier round, in W.P.(C) No. 3411/2016, did not
finally determine that claim. It permitted the Petitioner (Nirmala @ Bharpai)
to place additional documents before the authorities and directed
reconsideration. Pursuant thereto, the Deputy Director of Education passed
the order dated 31st August, 2018, which is under challenge in the present
proceedings.
5.
The impugned order proceeds on the basis that, at the time of
retirement, late Shri Guru Dutt Sharma had furnished his family particulars
showing Kanta Devi as his legally wedded wife, which was also reflected in
the Pension Payment Order. It further notes that the official service records
did not record the name of Nirmala as the wife of late Shri Guru Dutt
W.P.(C) 10765/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 11:06:46
Sharma. The authority also relied on the absence of any claim during the
lifetime of the employee, the lack of any material evidencing divorce, and
the inconsistency in the Petitioner’s case regarding the date of marriage. It
concludes that the claim is not supported by the official record and is,
therefore, not maintainable.
6.
Mr. Ashok Kumar Sharma, however, places reliance on a different set
of documents. These include a certificate said to have been issued by the
Gram Panchayat, Village Purkhas Rathi, District Sonepat, stating that Guru
Dutt Sharma had first married Nirmala and had later, without divorce,
contracted a second marriage with Kanta Devi.
7.
Reliance is also placed on certain communications of 1966 and 1967,
including a letter said to have been addressed by the school management to
the Education Officer seeking permission for a second marriage during the
subsistence of the first, the reply thereto, and the school’s subsequent
communication forwarding the required documents for granting the
permission. On the strength of these purported communications, it is
contended that the school and the authorities were aware of Nirmala’s status
and Kanta Devi was being treated as the second wife.
8.
Mr. Ashok Kumar further relies on a record in which the name of
Kanta Devi is said to have been struck off and the name of Nirmala entered
instead, to show that the service or pension record had, at some stage,
reflected Nirmala as the spouse. The relevant entry reads as follows:
W.P.(C) 10765/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 11:06:46
9.
The Respondents, consistent with the reasoning in the impugned
order, rely on the official service and pension records to contend that, at the
time of retirement, late Shri Guru Dutt Sharma had declared Kanta Devi as
his legally wedded wife, which stood reflected in the Pension Payment
Order as well as the family and nomination records. Nirmala’s name does
not find mention in the official record, that no documentary proof of
marriage has been produced, and that the material relied upon by the
petitioner does not displace the recorded particulars.
10.
The Court has considered the aforenoted submissions. Family pension
does not depend merely on nomination, nor can an entry in the service
record or Pension Payment Order, by itself, conclude the issue of who the
W.P.(C) 10765/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 11:06:46
legally wedded spouse was. A nomination may be relevant for limited
service purposes, but it does not override legal status under the pension
rules.1 Equally, where the employee was governed by Hindu law, a second
marriage during the subsistence of the first marriage would ordinarily be
void, and a second wife would not acquire entitlement to family pension
merely because her name stood entered in official records. To that extent,
the impugned order states the matter too broadly when it suggests that no
other claim could be considered once Kanta Devi had been shown in the
pension papers.
11.
But that is only one side of the matter. While nomination or pension
records are not conclusive, the burden still remains on Mr. Ashok Kumar to
establish, on reliable material, that Nirmala was indeed the first legally
wedded wife and that the later marriage with Kanta Devi was void. It is here
that the record becomes grossly uncertain.
12.
First, the dates themselves are not free from confusion. The
Petitioner’s case is that her marriage with late Shri Guru Dutt Sharma took
place in December 1946. The impugned order, however, records her date of
marriage on 13th March, 1968, which appears to be the date otherwise
associated with the alleged second marriage. Whether this is merely an error
in the order or reflects inconsistency in the underlying material is itself
unclear. Second, the authenticity and legal weight of the old letters of 1966
and 1967 are disputed by the Respondents. Third, even if those documents
are taken at face value, they do not, by themselves, prove every element
required to grant the relief sought. They may indicate that the school
management and the Education Officer were told that a second marriage was
G.L. Bhatia v. UOI & Anr. (1999) 5 SCC 237.
W.P.(C) 10765/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 11:06:46
proposed because the first wife had no issue. But they do not, without more,
conclusively identify the spouse or establish the date of the first marriage,
the actual solemnisation of the second marriage, the subsistence of the first
marriage on that date, the absence of divorce in fact or in law, or the legal
consequences that are now sought to be drawn from them.
13.
It must also be remembered that no state authority could have
conferred legal validity upon a second marriage that was otherwise void in
law. Therefore, even if the correspondence is genuine, any such tacit or
purported “permission” could have no legal sanctity. At the highest, those
documents are pieces of surrounding evidence. They may support the
Petitioner’s narrative to some extent. They do not conclude it.
14.
The service record, including the family declaration and pension
papers in which Kanta Devi was shown as wife, also cannot be treated
insignificant. They are official records emanating from the deceased
employee’s own service record. The Petitioner has pointed to an entry in the
service record indicating that the name of ‘Smt. Nirmala Devi’ was struck
off and substituted with that of ‘Smt. Kanta Devi’. This circumstance does
raise a question as to whether the record underwent alteration at some stage
and what was the basis thereof. However, the nature, timing, and authority
for such alteration are themselves matters of dispute and there are no
underlying supporting documents.
15.
There is another difficulty. No contemporaneous proceedings appear
to have been taken during the lifetime of late Shri Guru Dutt Sharma for
correction of service records, declaration of marital status, or challenge to
the continued reflection of Kanta Devi’s name in the pension papers. That
circumstance is not conclusive against Nirmala, especially having regard to
W.P.(C) 10765/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 11:06:46
her age and stated illiteracy. But it does add to the uncertainty of the record
and reinforces the need for a forum that can test the competing versions
through evidence.
16.
It is true that the mere existence of disputed facts does not, by itself,
bar writ jurisdiction. The writ court may, in an appropriate case, decide
disputed questions of fact. But that principle does not mean that every
dispute of this kind should be tried on affidavits. Where the lis turns on old
and contested documents, family history, marital status, and the need to test
the authenticity and probative value of rival records, the writ court would be
appropriate to undertake a final adjudication. Such issues ordinarily require
oral evidence, production of original records or secondary evidence, and
such further proof as the parties may be able to lead.
17.
In the present case, that is precisely the problem. Nirmala’s
documents are not so clear and unimpeachable that the Court can, in writ
jurisdiction, declare her to have been the first legally wedded wife and, on
that basis alone, direct release of family pension. Nor are the Respondents
justified in treating the service records and nomination as foreclosing the
enquiry altogether. The controversy lies in a narrow but difficult space
between those two positions. It is a controversy that calls for adjudication in
a properly constituted civil proceeding, not for resolution on affidavit
evidence in a writ petition.
18.
For that reason, this Court is not inclined to determine the marital
status of Nirmala or Kanta Devi, or of the consequent entitlement to family
pension. The impugned order may stand as an administrative rejection for
the present, but it cannot be treated as a conclusive adjudication of status
binding on a competent civil court. If Mr. Ashok Sharma establishes, in
W.P.(C) 10765/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 11:06:46
appropriate proceedings, that Nirmala was the legally wedded wife of late
Shri Guru Dutt Sharma and that the rival claim founded on Kanta Devi had
no legal basis, the pensionary consequences would necessarily have to be
reconsidered in accordance with law.
19.
Accordingly, while declining to grant relief in the present writ
petition, this Court leaves it open to Mr. Ashok Kumar to seek appropriate
remedies in accordance with law for establishing the rights, if any, claimed
through Nirmala. In the event any such rights are established in appropriate
proceedings, it shall be open to Mr. Ashok Kumar to place the same before
the Respondents for consideration of consequential benefits, if any, in
accordance with law, without treating the impugned order as foreclosing the
matter.
20.
Before parting, the Court considers it necessary to note one further
aspect. Family pension is a personal statutory benefit payable to the eligible
family member in her own right. It does not ordinarily form part of the estate
of the deceased employee and is not heritable in the ordinary sense. The
Supreme Court has explained that family pension is a welfare entitlement
governed by the relevant rules, and not property of the deceased capable of
devolving as part of their estate.2 Therefore, if Nirmala had died before her
status as the legally entitled widow stood recognised, Mr. Ashok Kumar
could not step in and claim continuing family pension in her place merely by
describing himself as her legal representative. Such a claim would ordinarily
not survive in that form.
21.
However, a distinction must be drawn between a claim for continuing
family pension and a claim for arrears, if any, that may have accrued to
W.P.(C) 10765/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 11:06:46
Nirmala during her lifetime, assuming she were ultimately held to be the
legally entitled widow. While a claim for continuing family pension would
not survive in favour of Mr. Ashok Kumar, the question of arrears stands on
a different footing. Even so, he does not automatically become entitled to
claim such arrears as the legal representative of Nirmala. Though he asserts
such status on the basis of a Will stated to have been executed in his favour,
he would be required to establish, in accordance with law, his entitlement to
represent the estate. He would have to establish before the competent forum
not only that Nirmala was the legally wedded wife entitled to family
pension, but also that he is competent in law to represent or succeed to her
estate.
22.
All rights and contentions of the parties regarding the question of
succession to the estate of Nirmala, as well as the merits of the marital-status
dispute, are left open.
23.
The writ petition is disposed of in the above terms. Pending
applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
MARCH 28, 2026/nk
Jodh Singh v. UOI & Anr. (1980) 4 SCC 306.
W.P.(C) 10765/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 06/04/2026 at 11:06:46
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review