Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
ALOK
SHARMA
2026:CGHC:24310-DB
NAFR
Digitally signed
by ALOK
SHARMA
Date:
2026.06.23
10:51:58
+0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 88 of 2026
1 - Nirmal Manjhi S/o Mahesh Ram Aged About 23 Years R/o
Khokhroama, P.S. Gharghoda, Distt. Raigarh
2 - Niranjan Manjhi S/o Mahesh Ram Aged About 20 Years R/o
Khokhroama, P.S. Gharghoda, Distt. Raigarh
... Appellant(s)
versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through Police Station - Gharghoda, Distt.
Raigarh Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Anuroop Panda, Advocate.
For State
: Mr. Shailendra Sharma, Panel Lawyer.
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Order on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice.
17/06/2026
1.
Today, though the matter is listed for hearing on I.A. No. 01 of
2025, which is an application for suspension of sentence and
grant of bail, however, considering the fact that the appellants are
in jail since 29.12.2019, therefore, with the consent of learned
counsel for the parties, the appeal is heard finally.
2.
This criminal appeal has been filed under Section 415(2) of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short, “the BNSS”)
against the impugned judgment of conviction and order of
sentence dated 10.11.2025 passed by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Gharghoda, District Raigarh (C.G.) in Sessions
Trial No. 17/2022, arising out of Crime No. 244/2019, Police
Station Gharghoda, District Raigarh, whereby the appellants have
been convicted and sentenced in the following manner:Conviction
Sentence
Under Section 302 read with Life imprisonment and fine of Rs.
Section 34 of Indian Penal 1000/- with a default stipulation to
Code
3.
undergo R.I. for 01 months.
The case of the prosecution in brief is that on 22.12.2019 at about
10:30 PM, in village Khokhroama, Pakhnakot, Police Station
Gharghoda, District Raigarh (C.G.), the accused persons namely
Nirmal Manjhi and Niranjan Manjhi, under the influence of liquor,
were creating nuisance and hurling abuses in the locality. When
the deceased Mahetter Manjhi objected and asked them not to
create disturbance, both the accused persons picked up a quarrel
with him. It is alleged that accused Nirmal Manjhi assaulted the
deceased with an iron rod on his head and accused Niranjan
Manjhi assaulted him by fists and blows. As a result of the assault,
the deceased sustained serious injuries, became unconscious
and fell on the ground. He was initially taken to Community Health
Centre, Gharghoda and thereafter referred to K.G.H. Hospital,
Raigarh for better treatment. During treatment, he succumbed to
his injuries on 28.12.2019 at about 10:30 AM. On the basis of the
report lodged by Bahartin Manjhi (PW-1), wife of the deceased,
FIR Ex.P-1 was registered against the accused persons under
Sections 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code. During merg inquiry,
inquest proceedings were conducted and the dead body was sent
for post-mortem examination.
4.
Dr. Rajesh B. Goswami (PW-12) conducted the post-mortem
examination on the dead body of the deceased and found as
many as 18 ante-mortem injuries on different parts of the body,
including contusions and abrasions over the face, forehead, upper
limbs and buttocks, along with serious internal injuries on the
head. On internal examination, extensive contusions were found
over the occipital, parietal, frontal and temporal regions of the
scalp, along with subdural and subarachnoid haemorrhage
involving both sides of the brain and accumulation of about 100 ml
of blood within the cranial cavity.
5.
After conducting the post-mortem examination, the doctor opined
that all the injuries were ante-mortem in nature and that the cause
of death was head injuries resulting in shock and haemorrhage,
and that the death had occurred within about eight hours prior to
the post-mortem examination. The post-mortem report is Ex.P-21.
6.
Statements of witnesses under Section 161 Cr.P.C. were recorded
during investigation and, after completion of investigation, chargesheet was filed before the Court of Judicial Magistrate First Class,
Gharghoda, from where the case was committed to the Court of
Sessions for trial of the accused persons under Sections 302/34
IPC.
7.
The case was committed to the Court of Sessions by the Court of
Judicial Magistrate First Class, Gharghoda, District Raigarh
(C.G.), as the offence under Section 302 IPC is exclusively triable
by the Court of Sessions. The learned Trial Court framed charge
against accused persons Nirmal Manjhi and Niranjan Manjhi for
the offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 of
the Indian Penal Code. The accused persons denied the charge,
pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. In order to establish the
charge, the prosecution examined as many as 13 witnesses and
exhibited several documents including the FIR, merg intimation,
inquest
report,
memorandum
statements,
seizure
memos,
medical examination report, query report and post-mortem report.
The statements of both the accused persons were recorded under
Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, wherein they
denied all the incriminating circumstances appearing against
them, pleaded innocence and stated that they had been falsely
implicated in the case. However, no witness was examined in
defence.
8.
After considering and appreciating the evidence available on
record, the learned Trial Court has convicted the appellants and
sentenced them as mentioned in para 1 of this judgment. Hence,
this appeal.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellants would submit that the
impugned judgment of conviction and sentence is contrary to law
and the evidence available on record. It is argued that the
prosecution has failed to establish beyond reasonable doubt that
the death of deceased Mahetter Manjhi was homicidal in nature.
Dr. Rajesh B. Goswami (PW-12), who conducted the post-mortem
examination, did not specifically opine in Ex.P-21 that the death
was homicidal. The prosecution also failed to examine any doctor
who treated the deceased during his hospitalization, thereby
leaving a serious gap in proving the cause of death. It is further
submitted that the bed-head ticket was not proved in accordance
with law and, therefore, could not have been relied upon by the
learned Trial Court. The alleged weapon of offence, namely the
iron rod, was neither properly connected with the injuries nor
exhibited as a material object during trial, and the seizure
witnesses having turned hostile, the alleged recovery itself
becomes doubtful.
10.
Learned counsel would further submit that there was considerable
and unexplained delay in lodging the FIR, despite the prosecution
case that the police had received information regarding the
incident much earlier. It is argued that the evidence on record
does not establish any prior meeting of minds or common
intention between the appellants so as to attract Section 34 IPC.
On the contrary, the evidence suggests that the incident arose
suddenly during a quarrel when the parties, who were close
relatives and had no previous enmity, were under the influence of
alcohol. In such circumstances, the findings recorded by the
learned Trial Court are based on conjectures and surmises rather
than reliable and legally admissible evidence. Therefore, the
appellants are entitled to the benefit of doubt and the impugned
judgment of conviction and sentence deserves to be set aside.
11.
On the other hand, learned State counsel supported the impugned
judgment and submitted that the prosecution has successfully
proved its case beyond reasonable doubt. It is contended that the
involvement of the appellants in the crime has been established
by the cogent and reliable testimony of eyewitnesses Bahartin
Manjhi (PW-1) and Jethuram Manjhi (PW-2), who consistently
deposed that accused Nirmal Manjhi assaulted the deceased with
an iron rod and accused Niranjan Manjhi assaulted him by fists
and blows. Their evidence is duly corroborated by the medical
evidence of Dr. Rajesh B. Goswami (PW-12), who found as many
as 18 ante-mortem injuries on the body of the deceased and
opined that the death was caused by head injuries resulting in
shock and haemorrhage. It is further submitted that merely
because the seizure witnesses did not support the prosecution
case in its entirety, the otherwise reliable ocular evidence cannot
be discarded. The evidence on record clearly establishes that the
deceased sustained fatal injuries during the assault made by the
appellants and succumbed to those injuries during treatment. The
conduct of the appellants, the nature of the weapon used, the part
of the body targeted, and the severity of the injuries caused
clearly demonstrate their intention and knowledge sufficient to
attract the offence punishable under Section 302 read with
Section 34 IPC. Therefore, the learned Trial Court has rightly
convicted and sentenced the appellants and the impugned
judgment warrants no interference by this Court.
12.
We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused
the record carefully.
13.
With respect to the nature of death of the deceased, Bahartin
Manjhi (PW-1), the wife of the deceased, has deposed that on the
date of the incident accused Nirmal Manjhi assaulted the
deceased with an iron rod on his head, while accused Niranjan
Manjhi assaulted him by fists and blows, as a result of which the
deceased sustained injuries, became unconscious and fell on the
ground. Jethuram Manjhi (PW-2), an eyewitness to the incident,
has also supported the prosecution case and stated that accused
Nirmal Manjhi struck the deceased with an iron rod on his head
and accused Niranjan Manjhi assaulted him by fists and blows.
The witnesses to the inquest proceedings also noticed visible
injuries on the face and head of the deceased. Thus, the ocular
and medical evidence collectively establish that the deceased
died as a consequence of the injuries sustained in the incident.
14.
P.W. 12, Dr. Rajesh B. Goswami, has stated in his deposition that
on 28.12.2019 he conducted the post-mortem examination of the
dead body of deceased Mahetter Manjhi and found as many as
18 ante-mortem injuries on different parts of the body, including
contusions and abrasions over the face, forehead, upper limbs
and buttocks. On internal examination, he found extensive
contusions over the occipital, parietal, frontal and temporal
regions of the scalp, subdural and subarachnoid haemorrhage
involving the brain, and accumulation of blood within the cranial
cavity. He opined that all the injuries were ante-mortem in nature
and that the death was caused due to head injuries resulting in
shock and haemorrhage. He further stated that the injuries found
on the body of the deceased could not have been caused merely
by a fall in a drunken condition. In his cross-examination, no
material contradiction or circumstance could be elicited by the
defence to discredit his medical opinion regarding the cause of
death. Thus, the medical evidence adduced by the prosecution
clearly establishes that the deceased died on account of the head
injuries sustained by him.
15.
So far as the involvement of the accused persons in the crime in
question is concerned, P.W.-1 Bahartin Manjhi and P.W.-2
Jethuram Manjhi are the eyewitnesses to the incident. P.W.-1
Bahartin Manjhi, who is the wife of the deceased, has stated in
her deposition that on the date of the incident both the accused
persons were under the influence of liquor and were creating
nuisance near her house. When her husband Mahetter Manjhi
objected to their conduct, accused Nirmal Manjhi assaulted him
with an iron rod on his head and accused Niranjan Manjhi
assaulted him by fists and blows, as a result of which he fell down
and became unconscious. P.W.-2 Jethuram Manjhi has also
supported the prosecution case and deposed that he witnessed
the quarrel and saw accused Nirmal Manjhi assaulting the
deceased with an iron rod while accused Niranjan Manjhi
participated in the assault by fists and blows. Both the witnesses
have consistently stated that the deceased sustained injuries in
the assault made by the accused persons and was thereafter
taken for medical treatment. In their cross-examination, though
certain omissions and contradictions were elicited, nothing
substantial could be brought on record to discredit their presence
at the spot or their version regarding the assault. Their evidence
remains consistent on the material particulars of the occurrence
and finds corroboration from the medical evidence regarding the
injuries sustained by the deceased.
16.
P.W. 2, Jethuram Manjhi, is another eyewitness to the occurrence.
He has stated that on hearing the commotion, he reached the
spot and witnessed accused Nirmal Manjhi assaulting the
deceased with an iron rod, while accused Niranjan Manjhi was
assaulting him by fists and blows. He has further deposed that
after the assault the deceased fell on the ground and became
unconscious. In his cross-examination, he denied the suggestion
that he had not witnessed the incident or that the deceased
sustained injuries by accidentally falling on the road. His
testimony substantially corroborates the version of P.W. 1.
17.
P.W. 3, Ram Kumar, has stated that on receiving information
about the incident, he reached the spot and found the deceased
lying in an injured condition. Thereafter, he assisted in taking the
deceased home and subsequently to the hospital for treatment.
Though he is not an eyewitness to the assault, his evidence
supports the fact that the deceased had sustained injuries in the
incident and was immediately taken for medical treatment. He
was cross-examined by the defence, but nothing substantial could
be elicited to discredit his testimony.
18.
P.W. 4, Chamar Manjhi, is a witness to the memorandum and
seizure proceedings. However, during trial he did not support the
prosecution case in material particulars and was declared hostile.
Though he admitted his signatures on the relevant documents, he
did not support the prosecution version regarding the recovery of
the iron rod at the instance of the accused.
19.
P.W. 6, Dr. Vikas Kumar Sharma, medically examined the
deceased on 23.12.2019 and found multiple injuries on his body.
He prepared the medical examination report Ex.P-10. He has
further stated that upon a query made by the Investigating Officer
regarding the seized iron rod, he furnished his report Ex.P-11 and
opined that the injuries sustained by the deceased could be
caused by the said iron rod and could also be caused by fists and
blows followed by a fall on a rough surface. The defence crossexamined him at length, but his evidence regarding the injuries
sustained by the deceased remained substantially unshaken.
20.
P.W. 9 Dr. Arun Kumar Patel, who conducted the medical
examination of the injured Bahartin Bai, after her medical
examination noticed pain in the left shoulder and restricted
movement. After her examination, he gave his report Ex. P/18. In
cross-examination, he admitted that the injuries noticed on the
body of the injured Bahartin Bai could have also been caused by
falling on the floor.
21.
The evidence of P.W. 1 and P.W. 2 regarding the assault made by
the accused persons finds substantial corroboration from the
medical evidence of P.W. 12. Thus, the prosecution has
successfully established that the deceased sustained fatal injuries
in the assault attributed to the accused persons.
22.
The next question for consideration is, whether the case of the
appellants are covered within Exception-4 to Section 300 IPC visa-vis culpable homicide not amounting to murder and their
conviction can be converted to Section 304 Part-I or Part-II of the
IPC, as submitted by the learned counsel for the appellants ?
23. The Supreme Court in the matter of Sukhbir Singh v. State of
Haryana, reported in 2002 (3) SCC 327 observed as under:“21. Keeping in view the facts and circumstances of
the case, we are of the opinion that in the absence of
the existence of common object Sukhbir Singh is
proved to have committed the offence of culpable
homicide without premeditation in a sudden fight in the
heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel and did not act
in a cruel or unusual manner and his case is covered
by Exception 4 of Section 300 IPC which is punishable
under Section 304 (Part I) IPC. The finding of the
courts below holding the aforesaid appellant guilty of
offence of murder punishable under Section 302 IPC
is set aside and he is held guilty for the commission of
offence of culpable homicide not amounting to murder
punishable under Section 304 (Part I) IPC and
sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 10
years and to pay a fine of Rs.5000. In default of
payment of fine, he shall undergo further rigorous
imprisonment for one year.”
24. The Supreme Court in the matter of Gurmukh Singh v. State of
Haryana, 2009 (15) SCC 635, laid down certain factors which are
to be taken into consideration before awarding appropriate
sentence to the accused with reference to Section 302 or Section
304 Part II of the IPC, which state as under :“23. These are some factors which are required to be
taken into consideration before awarding appropriate
sentence to the accused. These factors are only
illustrative in character and not exhaustive. Each case
has to be seen for its special perspective. The relevant
factors are as under :
(a) Motive or previous enmity;
(b) Whether the incident had taken place on the
spur of the moment;
(c) The intention/knowledge of the accused while
inflicting the blow or injury;
(d) Whether the death ensued instantaneously
or the victim died after several days;
(e) The gravity, dimension and nature of injury;
(f) The age and general health condition of the
accused;
(g) Whether the injury was caused without
premeditation in a sudden fight;
(h) The nature and size of weapon used for
inflicting the injury and the force with which the
blow was inflicted;
(i) The criminal background and adverse history
of the accused;
(j) Whether the injury inflicted was not sufficient
in the ordinary course of nature to cause death
but the death was because of shock;
(k) Number of other criminal cases pending
against the accused;
(l) Incident occurred within the family members
or close relations;
(m) The conduct and behaviour of the accused
after the incident.
Whether the accused had taken the injured/the
deceased to the hospital immediately to ensure
that he/she gets proper medical treatment ?
These are some of the factors which can be
taken into consideration while granting an
appropriate sentence to the accused.
24. The list of circumstances enumerated above is
only illustrative and not exhaustive. In our considered
view, proper and appropriate sentence to the accused
is the bounded obligation and duty of the court. The
endeavour of the court must be to ensure that the
accused receives appropriate sentence, in other
words, sentence should be according to the gravity of
the offence. These are some of the relevant factors
which are required to be kept in view while convicting
and sentencing the accused.”
25. Likewise, in the matter of State Vs. Sanjeev Nanda, 2012 (8)
SCC 450, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that once
knowledge that it is likely to cause death is established but without
any intention to cause death, then jail sentence may be for a term
which may extend to 10 years or with fine or with both. It has
further been held that to make out an offence punishable under
Section 304 Part II of the IPC, the prosecution has to prove the
death of the person in question and such death was caused by
the act of the accused and that he knew that such act of his is
likely to cause death.
26. Further, the Supreme Court in the matter of Arjun Vs. State of
Chhattisgarh, 2017 (3) SCC 247, has elaborately dealt with the
issue and observed in paragraphs 20 and 21, which reads as
under :“20. To invoke this Exception 4, the requirements that
are to be fulfilled have been laid down by this Court in
Surinder Kumar v. UT, Chandigarh [(1989) 2 SCC
217 : 1989 SCC (Cri) 348], it has been explained as
under :(SCC p. 220, para 7)
“7. To invoke this exception four requirements
must be satisfied, namely, (I) it was a sudden
fight; (ii) there was no premeditation; (iii) the act
was done in a heat of passion; and (iv) the
assailant had not taken any undue advantage or
acted in a cruel manner. The cause of the
quarrel is not relevant nor its I relevant who
offered the provocation or started the assault.
The number of wounds caused during the
occurrence is not a decisive factor but what is
important is that the occurrence must have been
sudden and unpremeditated and the offender
must have acted in a fit of anger. Of course, the
offender must not have taken any undue
advantage or acted in a cruel manner. Where,
on a sudden quarrel, a person in the heat of the
moment picks up a weapon which is handy and
causes injuries, one of which proves fatal, he
would be entitled to the benefit of this exception
provided he has not acted cruelly.”
21. Further in Arumugam v. State [(2008) 15 SCC
590 : (2009) 3 SCC (Cri) 1130], in support of the
proposition of law that under what circumstances
Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC can be invoked if
death is caused, it has been explained as under :
“9. .... '18. The help of exception 4 can be
invoked if death is caused (a) without
premeditation; (b) in a sudden fight; (c) without
the offender's having taken undue advantage or
acted in a cruel or unusual manner; and (d) the
fight must have been with the person killed. To
bring a case within Exception 4 all the
ingredients mentioned in it must be found. It is to
be noted that the “fight” occurring in Exception 4
to Section 300 IPC is not defined in the Penal
Code, 1860. It takes two to make a fight. Heat of
passion requires that there must be no time for
the passions to cool down and in this case, the
parties had worked themselves into a fury on
account of the verbal altercation in the
beginning. A fight is a combat between two or
more persons whether with or without weapons.
It is not possible to enunciate any general rule
as to what shall be deemed to be a sudden
quarrel. It is a question of fact and whether a
quarrel is sudden or not must necessarily
depend upon the proved facts of each case. For
the application of Exception 4, it is not sufficient
to show that there was a sudden quarrel and
there was no premeditation. It must further be
shown that the offender has not taken undue
advantage or acted in cruel or unusual manner.
The expression “undue advantage” as used in
the provisions means “unfair advantage”.
27. In the matter of Arjun (supra), the Supreme Court has held that if
there is intent and knowledge, the same would be case of Section
304 Part-I of the IPC and if it is only a case of knowledge and not
the intention to cause murder and bodily injury, then same would
be a case of Section 304 Part-II of the IPC.
28. Further, the Supreme Court in the matter of Rambir Vs. State
(NCT of Delhi), 2019 (6) SCC 122,
has laid down four
ingredients to bring a case within the purview of Exception 4 to
Section 300 of IPC, which reads as under:
“16. A plain reading of Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC
shows that the following four ingredients are required:
29.
(i) There must be a sudden fight;
(ii) There was no premeditation;
(iii) he act was committed in a heat of passion;
and
(iv) The offender had not taken any undue
advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual
manner.”
Reverting to the facts of the present case, it is quite vivid that on
the date of incident i.e. 22.12.2019 at about 22:30 hours, there
was an altercation between the accused persons and the
deceased Mahhettar Manjhi when he objected to their creating
nuisance in a drunken state. In the said occurrence, the accused
persons got infuriated and in furtherance of their common
intention, accused Nirmal Manjhi gave a blow by means of an iron
rod on the head of the deceased, whereas co-accused Niranjan
Manjhi assaulted him by fists and blows, as a result of which the
deceased sustained multiple injuries and became unconscious.
As per the evidence of P.W. 1 and P.W. 2, there was a consistent
account that the accused persons on a sudden heat of passion
and without premeditation, in furtherance of their common
intention assaulted the deceased, and the defence plea that the
deceased accidentally fell on a construction site was not found
trustworthy
in
view
of
the
medical
evidence.
In
these
circumstances, it is evident that the act of the accused was
neither
accidental
nor
without
knowledge
of
the
likely
consequences, and the nature of injuries inflicted, clearly shows
that they had the knowledge without intention that such assault
was likely to cause death, the offence of the appellants does not
travel beyond Section 304 of I.P.C.
30.
Considering the facts and circumstances of the present case, the
consistent ocular testimony of PW-1 (wife of the deceased) and
PW-2, coupled with the medical evidence of PW-12 Dr. Rajesh B.
Goswami and the postmortem report (Ex. P-21), it stands proved
that the deceased Mahhettar Manjhi sustained injuries at the
hands of the accused persons in furtherance of their common
intention. However, taking into account that the incident arose out
of a sudden altercation when the deceased objected to the
drunken nuisance caused by the accused persons, and there
being no clear evidence of prior premeditation to commit murder,
though the act was committed with knowledge that such assault
was likely to cause death, ends of justice would meet if the
conviction of the appellants under Section 302/34 IPC is
altered/converted to one under Section 304 Part-I/34 of the IPC.
31.
Accordingly, the appeal is partly allowed to the extent that the
conviction of the appellants under Section 302 read with Section
34 of the IPC is set aside, however, they are convicted under
Section 304 Part I read with Section 34 of the IPC and sentenced
to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 10 years each along with
fine of Rs. 1,000/- each, and in default of payment of fine, to
further undergo rigorous imprisonment for one month each.
32.
As the appellants are in jail, they shall serve the remaining
sentence as modified by this Court.
33.
Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the
concerned Superintendent of Jail where the appellants are
undergoing their jail sentence to serve the same on the appellants
informing them that they are at liberty to assail the present
judgment passed by this Court by preferring an appeal before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court with the assistance of High Court Legal
Services Committee or the Supreme Court Legal Services
Committee.
34. The trial Court record along with a copy of this judgment be sent
back immediately to the trial Court concerned for compliance and
necessary action.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Alok
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review