Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/SCR.A/14283/2026
(GJHC240742232026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 08/10/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CRIMINAL APPLICATION (HABEAS CORPUS) NO. 14283 of
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
==========================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
==========================================================
NIRAV PAWAN CHUGH
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MOKSHAY R VYAS(7453) for the Applicant
MR DARSHAN K BHOJAK(10550) for the Applicant
MR LB DABHI APP for the Respondent No. 1
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
Date : 08/10/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA)
1.
The petitioner Nirav Chugh being a father of corpus – daughter aged
about 2 years and 3 months, has invoked the extraordinary
jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, seeking a writ of Habeas Corpus for production and custody
of minor daughter presently, residing with respondent no.6 Mansi
Nirav Chugh, who is the mother of the child.
R/SCR.A/14283/2026
(GJHC240742232026)
2.
JUDGMENT DATED: 08/10/2026
We have heard learned counsel Mr. M. R. Vyas with Mr. D. K.
Bhojak appearing for and on behalf of the petitioner and learned
APP Mr. L. B. Dabhi, on advance copy.
3.
Brief facts giving rise to file present petition are stated to be as
under:
(i)
The petitioner married to Mansi Chugh respondent no.6 on
04.09.2016 and out of the said matrimonial relationship, a minor
daughter Vedika was born on 10.05.2024 at City Surat.
(ii) It is alleged that the minor daughter aged about 2 years and 3 months
is illegally detained by the mother and her parents. In this
background, it is alleged that on 28.05.2026, the respondent wife left
the matrimonial home and the minor daughter remained with the
petitioner till 06.08.2026. That on or about 06.08.2026, the
differences arose between the husband and wife with respect to
property documents and during the discussions at the home i.e. on
07.08.2026, the minor daughter was removed from the home without
the knowledge and consent -expressed or implied by the wife and
the entire episode being recorded in the CCTV cameras. The mother
of the petitioner took visit the house where the corpus expressed her
desire to live with the petitioner and her mother and thereafter, on
10.08.2026, the petitioner father tried to meet and see with the child
on mobile, but he was not permitted to see the child. The child was
confined within a room by the mother illegally.
R/SCR.A/14283/2026
(GJHC240742232026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 08/10/2026
(iii) The petitioner the father of the daughter approached the concerned
police station on 10.08.2026 and lodged a written complaint with
respect to the removal of the minor daughter. The police was nonresponsive.
The petitioner himself took visit the police station
accompanied by an advocate. The petitioner orally informed that no
offence is made out because child is with her mother. In that view of
the matter, the petitioner addressed a written representation on
11.08.2026, complaining of the conduct of the police and thereafter,
on 18.08.2026 to the higher police official of Surat.
(iv) The petitioner husband thereafter served a legal notice upon the wife
and her parents for the illegal detention of the daughter, and act of
extortion, etc. The notice was replied by the wife and her parents
through their advocate on 25.08.2026. In the meanwhile, the
petitioner husband has filed a private complaint on 20.08.2026 being
Enquiry No.162 of 2026 before the learned Judicial Magistrate First
Class, Surat under Section 175(3) of the Bhartiya Nargrik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023 against the wife and her parents, inter alia alleging
that the police failed to register the FIR for the act of kidnapping,
extortion, attempt to murder, theft, criminal conspiracy, and
wrongful confinement, allegedly committed by the wife and her
parents, with a further prayer to issue warrant for immediate
production of minor daughter before the Court and handover the
custody of the daughter to him. Upon receiving the complaint, the
Magistrate Court issued notice to the opponent for their reply and
hearing. While issuing notice, the Magistrate Court has observed
R/SCR.A/14283/2026
(GJHC240742232026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 08/10/2026
that “having regard to the facts and circumstances of the present
matter, it would not be an appropriate to pass an order for securing
the custody of the child as the question of custody of the child is
governed by the procedure prescribed under the applicable law and
the applicant is at liberty to avail such appropriate remedy before the
Competent Forum”. The said complaint is pending for its
adjudication before the Court of Judicial Magistrate at Surat.
4.
In such circumstances, the petitioner father of the minor daughter,
by way of the present petition, prays for issuance of writ of Habeas
Corpus directing the respondents to produce the minor daughter
before the Court as the respondent mother as well as her parents
have no right to keep the custody of the minor corpus and he being a
natural guardian of the minor, and having regard to the welfare of
the child, he may be handed over the custody of her daughter.
5.
Mr. Vyas, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, submitted
that the custody of the child was with the petitioner, when the
mother had left the matrimonial home and thereafter, without any
consent or knowledge of the husband, the corpus being taken away
illegally and presently, she is with the wife – mother and grandmaternal parents; thus, since 07.08.2026, the corpus forcibly being
taken and detained illegally by the respondents and also refused to
access to the child; the complaint filed in the Court at Surat for
directing the mother to produce the child before the Court and
therefore, the petitioner is constrained to approach before this Court;
that the petitioner having all the means to take care of the minor
R/SCR.A/14283/2026
(GJHC240742232026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 08/10/2026
daughter; he is the practicing chartered accountant, against which,
the respondents are not capable of taking proper care of the minor
daughter; that the denial of access of daughter to the father
prejudices the paternal relationship and the child’s welfare and
therefore, having regard to the welfare of the child, prima-facie case
is made out for issuance of the notice and necessary direction for
production of the corpus before this Court.
6.
We have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner and carefully perused the material on
record.
7.
The petitioner seeks issuance of writ of Habeas Corpus for
production of his minor daughter aged about 2 years and 3 months
and also seeks her custody. Thus, in our opinion, dispute is a custody
battle between the parents. It is relevant to note that, the petitioner
husband before initiation of the proceedings served a legal notice
through Advocate upon the respondent wife and her parents. The
legal notice was responded by detailed reply. The petitioner has
produced the reply of the notice at Page-99 of this petition. So as to
understand the dispute between the husband and wife, the gist of the
reply is set out hereunder:
(1)
The wife had denied each and every allegation,
averments and contentions made in notice and further alleged
that, the same has been false, frivolous, misleading and legally
untenable and having been alleged with an ulterior motive to
R/SCR.A/14283/2026
(GJHC240742232026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 08/10/2026
pressurize and harass.
(2)
Without prejudice to the allegation, the contents of para-
9 of the notice have been denied and further contended that, the
minor daughter has remained with the wife for the purpose of
her care, safety and welfare and considering the circumstances
prevailing between the parties, the child remained in a safe and
proper environment.
(3)
That, after the marriage the in-laws caused a mental
distress and humiliation to the wife and thereafter, in the year
2021, the wife had started experiencing anxiety related issues
and treatment thereof was being taken at the different
counseling centers as well as psychiatric doctors of the Surat
and thereafter, during January, 2025, the petitioner husband
developed a habit of extensively using ChatGPT even for minor
and routine manner and would repeatedly engaged with the said
platform and gradually husband started forming and fabricating
various narratives, which further affected his behaviour and
inter-personal relationship with the wife and contributed to the
increasing matrimonial discord between the parties. It is
specifically alleged that in April, 2025 during the dental
treatment with Dr. Pooja Clinic at Surat, the husband developed
one sided emotional and romantic attachment towards the
doctor and started writing and sending romantic letters to her. In
May, 2025, the wife expressed her concern to the husband and
his family and requested to refrain from excessive use of
ChatGPT. However, behaviour of the husband was not changed
and thereafter despite of extensive counseling and medication,
the doctor informed that the husband is suffering from Bipolar
R/SCR.A/14283/2026
(GJHC240742232026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 08/10/2026
Disorder, Mania and Depression. That on 26.05.2026, the
husband was found by the wife viewing pornographic and
sexually explicit videos on his mobile, while minor daughter
was sleeping beside the wife. Thus, watching such obscene
content in the presence of the minor child could have a serious
and adverse impact upon her impressionable mind and overall
development and while objecting the same, the petitioner
husband used abusive language, behaved aggressively and
threw household articles at the wife and that too in the presence
of the child. This was the reason, compelling the wife to left the
house and thereafter, for the sake of daughter and to save the
marriage life, she returned to the matrimonial home. The words
used by the husband like “mother manipulator” “daughter
thief”, “mama extortionist”, and “father spineless” shows that,
this is nothing but the husband’s excessive dependence upon
ChatGPT.
8.
Reverting to the case of the present case, as observed earlier, the
dispute as raised here is a custody battle between the parents. It is
not in dispute that the minor daughter aged about 2 years and 3
months is presently residing with the respondent No. 6 – mother /
wife. However, due to her residence with her parent respondent nos.
4 and 5, it appears that, the petitioner husband has wrongly pleaded
that, the custody of the daughter is with grand-maternal parents i.e.
respondent nos. 4 and 5.
9.
We are conscious about the settled principle of law that in a matter
of custody of minor child, the welfare of the child is the paramount
consideration and it will override the legal right of either party /
R/SCR.A/14283/2026
(GJHC240742232026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 08/10/2026
parent.
10. In the facts of the present case, we may profitably refer to and rely
the case of Sarita Sharma Vs. Sushil Sharma, (2000) 3 SCC 14,
wherein, considering the all the aspect relating to the welfare of the
children, the Supreme Court while dismissing the writ petition,
observed as under:
“when the minor child is in custody of the mother,
such custody cannot be considered unlawful merely
because the father seeks custody, and it was not proper
for the High Court to have allowed the Habeas Corpus
writ application and directed the appellant to handover
custody of the children to the respondent and permit
him to take them away to USA. What would be in the
interest of children requires a full and thorough
enquiry and therefore, the High Court should have
directed the respondents to initiate appropriate
proceedings in which such an enquiry can be held. “
11.
Similarly, in the landmark judgment of Tejaswini Goud Vs.
Shekhar Jagdishprasad Tiwari, (2019) 7 SCC 42, the Supreme Court
reiterated that writ of habeas corpus in child custody matter is
maintainable only where the custody is unlawful or without authority of
law. Even in such cases, the Court must be guided by the paramount
consideration of welfare of the child rather than the legal rights of the
parties. The Supreme Court further held that, in child custody matters, the
ordinary remedy lies only under the Hindu Minority and Guardianship
Act, 1956 or the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890. If the court believes
R/SCR.A/14283/2026
(GJHC240742232026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 08/10/2026
that the matter require a thorough examination of facts, it may choose not
to use its extra ordinary jurisdiction and instead instruct the parties to
seek relief before competent Civil Court. The relevant paras, 19 and 20
reads as under:
"19. Habeas corpus proceedings is not to justify or examine the
legality of the custody. Habeas corpus proceedings is a medium
through which the custody of the child is addressed to the
discretion of the court. Habeas corpus is a prerogative writ
which is an extraordinary remedy and the writ is issued where in
the circumstances of the particular case, ordinary remedy
provided by the law is either not available or is ineffective;
otherwise a writ will not be issued. In child custody matters, the
power of the High Court in granting the writ is qualified only in
cases where the detention of a minor by a person who is not
entitled to his legal custody. In view of the pronouncement on
the issue in question by the Supreme Court and the High Courts,
in our view, in child custody matters, the writ of habeas corpus
is maintainable where it is proved that the detention of a minor
child by a parent or others was illegal and without any authority
of law.
20. In child custody matters, the ordinary remedy lies only
under the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act or the
Guardians and Wards Act as the case may be. In cases arising
out of the proceedings under the Guardians and Wards Act, the
jurisdiction of the court is determined by whether the minor
ordinarily resides within the area on which the court exercises
such jurisdiction. There are significant differences between the
enquiry under the Guardians and Wards Act and the exercise of
R/SCR.A/14283/2026
(GJHC240742232026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 08/10/2026
powers by a writ court which is of summary in nature. What is
important is the welfare of the child. In the writ court, rights are
determined only on the basis of affidavits. Where the court is of
the view that a detailed enquiry is required, the court may
decline to exercise the extraordinary jurisdiction and direct the
parties to approach the civil court. It is only in exceptional
cases, the rights of the parties to the custody of the minor will
be determined in exercise of extraordinary jurisdiction on a
petition for habeas corpus."
12. Again, in Kanika Goel Vs. State of Delhi, (2018) 9 SCC 578, the
Supreme Court held that in petition seeking the writ of Habeas Corpus, the
High Court must examine at the threshold whether the minor is in lawful
custody of another person (private respondent). Whether the custody is with the
mother, the Court may not make any further enquiry or resort to a summary or
elaborate enquiry to determine the welfare of the child.
13. Applying the aforesaid principles to the present case, the custody of
the minor daughter aged about 2 years and 3 months with the mother
– respondent no. 6 cannot termed to be an illegal custody and having
regard to the allegations made by the wife, as referred in para-7 of
the judgment, we are of the considered opinion that, no case is made
out to change the custody of minor daughter and having regard to
the nature of dispute between the parties, the issue of custody
required thorough enquiry by the competent court as dispute
involves detailed disputed facts requiring extensive evidence to be
recorded and determined by the competent court.
R/SCR.A/14283/2026
(GJHC240742232026)
JUDGMENT DATED: 08/10/2026
14. For the aforementioned reasons, in the facts of the present case, we
deem it fit not to exercise our extra ordinary jurisdiction. It is open
to the parties to avail alternative remedies in accordance with law. In
that case, the Court concerned shall decide the application in
accordance with law without being influence by the observations
made in this order. We further make it clear that, we have not
examined or expressed any opinion on the rival claims of the parties
regarding permanent or interim custody of the minor child.
15. Accordingly, this application stands dismissed at the admission
stage.
(ILESH J. VORA,J)
(R. T. VACHHANI, J)
P.S. JOSHI/DOD/12.10.2026
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review