Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
reportable
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC (El Pet) No.22 of 2023 with
El Pet No.13 of 2022 with
El.Recr P No.7 of 2022 with
Rl.Recr Pet No.8 of 2022
Shri Ningthoujam Mangi, aged about 71 years,
s/o late N.Ibomcha, resident of Kumbi Ward
No.9 PO Moirang, PS Kumbi, District
Bishnupur, Manipur 795133.
… Applicant
-Versus1.
Mr.Ahanthem Shanjoy Sigh aged about
46 years s/o Ahanthem Surchandra Singh,
Permanent resident of Wangoo Sabal,
Wagoo Ahallup, PO Moirang & PS Kumbi,
Bishnupur District, Manipur 795133.
2.
Mr.Sanasam Premchandra Singh, aged about
46 years, s/o (late) Jabamjao @ Sanasam Jaramajao
Singh, Kumbi Salangkonjin Part-2, Near
Public Community Hall, PO Moirang & PS
Kumbi, Dist Bishnupur, Manipur 795133.
3.
Dr.Khangembam Romesh Singh aged about
45 years, s/o Shri Khangembam Amrita Singh,
Kumbi Khuga Wangma, PO Moirang & PS
Kumbi, Dist Bishnupur, Moirang 795133.
4.
Mrs.Naorem Sorojini Devi, aged about 43 years
w/o Shougrakpam Chandrakumar Singh,
Saiton Maning Leikai, PO Moirang & PS Kumbi
Dist, Bishnupur, Manipur 795133.
… Respondents
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A.GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the applicant
::
Mr.Ajoy Pebamm, Advocate.
For the respondents ::
Mr.N.Mahendra, Advocate &
Mr.B.R.Sharma, Advocate.
Date of hearing
::
23.05.2025.
Date of order
::
19.09.2025
O R D E R (CAV)
[1]
By the present application, under Order 6 Rule 17 of the
CPC, 1908, read with Section 87(1) of the Representation of the People
Act, 1951, applicant is praying for allowing amendment of the Written
Statement dated 04.07.2022 filed by the respondent No.1 in the main
Election Petition No.13 of 2022.
[2]
Heard Mr.Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel for the applicant,
Mr.N.Mahendra, learned counsel and Mr.B.R.Sharma, learned counsel
for the respondents.
[3]
It is the case of the applicant that while the applicant filed
his Written Statement dated 04.07.2022 in the main Election Petition
No.13 of 2022, due to bonafide mistake, certain facts and statements
have not been specifically stated and as such amendment of the same
is required for determining the real dispute in between the parties and
it shall not cause any prejudice to any of the respondents and shall not
change the character or nature of the case as well.
[4]
It is stated that the facts and statements sought to be
incorporated in the Written Statement by way of amendment are
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
already on record before the Court as the same are there in the
pleadings of the Election Recrimination Petition No.8 of 2022 [Ref:
Election Petition No.13 of 2022].
[5]
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel for the applicant/
respondent No.2 in the election petition submits that the proposed
amendments in the written statement of the respondent No.2 are
already on record and has been pleaded in the recrimination petition
being El. Recr. Pet. No. 8 of 2022 and these are not new pleas to be
introduced by means of amendment. The application for amendment is
filed for the sake of formality and in order to introduce the pleading
already taken in the recrimination petition filed by the applicant. It is
further submitted that no prejudice shall be caused to any of the parties
and due to Bonafide mistake, the same could not be incorporated in
the written statement of the applicant/respondent No.2 in the election
petition. He refers to the following case laws in support of his
submission regarding permissibility of amendment in terms of Order 6
Rule 17 CPC:
(i)
B K Narayan Pilai v. Parameswaran Pilai: (2001) 1
SCC 712- The power to allow the amendment is wide and can
be exercised at any stage of the proceedings in the interest of
justice. All amendments of pleading should be allowed which
are necessary for determination of the real controversies.
(ii)
Baldev Singh v. Manohar Singh: (2006) 6 SCC 498-
Power of amendment under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC be construed
liberally and may be allowed to determining the real
controversy if the application is filed before the commencement
of the trial.
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
(iii) Usha Balasaheb Swami v. Kiran Appaso Swami:
(2007) 5 SCC 602- Order 6 Rule 17 CPC stipulates that
amendment of pleadings can be allowed at any stage for
determining the real controversy between the parties. The
proviso however restricts such application if the trial has
commenced.
(iv) Abdul Rehman v. Mohd. Ruldu: (2021) 11 SCC 341Court should allow amendments that may be necessary for
determination of the real question in controversy between the
parties.
(v)
Gurbaksh Singh v. Buta Singh: AIR 2018 SC 2635-
The object of Order 6 Rule 17 CPC is that courts should
adjudicate the merits of the case that comes before them and
should consequently allow all amendments that may be
necessary for determining the real controversy between the
parties, provided it does not cause injustice or prejudice the
other side.
(vi) Varun Pahwa v. Renu Chaudhary: AIR 2019 SC
1186- Inadvertent mistake in memo of parties can be
corrected.
(vii) Rupadhar Pujari v. Gangadhar Bhatra: (2004) 7
SCC 654- Law relating to election petition cannot be allowed
to be interpreted with much rigidity and by indulging in hairsplitting. Procedural law must be construed to really serve as
handmaid of justice, make them workable and advance the
ends of justice.
[6]
Learned counsel for the applicant submits that in view of
the decisions cited above, the application for amendment of written
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
statement of the respondent No.2 be allowed, as the same will not
introduce new pleas and will not prejudice any of the parties.
[7]
Mr. B R Sharma, learned counsel for respondent No.1/
election petitioner, submits that even if the power of amendment of
pleadings as stipulated under the provisions of Order 6 Rule 17 CPC is
wide enough and the same can be resorted to at any stage, its
applicability in election petition has to be circumscribed by the
provisions of the Representation of People Act, 1951. He draws the
attention of this Court the provisions of Sections 81, 83, 86 and 87 RP
Act which mandates filing of election petition with 45 days, disclosure
of all material facts in an election petition, expeditious disposal of the
election petition within a period of 6 months and applicability of CPC to
be within the framework of RP Act. It is pointed out that new pleas with
respect to material facts cannot be introduced by way of amendment
that too after expiry of 45 days of limitation. He further submits that
the plea to be taken in recrimination petition cannot be introduced in
the written statement. Mr. B R Sharma, learned counsel for election
petitioner submits that the application of amendment may be dismissed
with exemplary cost being devoid of any merit. He relies on the
following decisions:
(i)
Harnam Singh v. Tirath Singh: ILR Vol. XVII Punjab
Series 798- The provision of Order 6 Rule 17 CPC would be attracted
to the election petition, provided it is not inconsistent with any provision
of the Act or Rules.
(ii)
Thangjam Mohendro Singh v. Thokchom Lokeshwar
Singh: 2024 SCC OnLine Mani 506- This Court held in para 8 as
“8. It is the settled principle of law that new plea to change the
nature of the case cannot be introduced by way of amendment
or in form of subsequent plea. The salutary provisions of Order
8 Rule 9 and Order 6 Rule 17 are aimed to facilitate in arriving
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
a correct decision based on relevant facts. However, such
provisions cannot introduce altogether new facts to change the
nature of dispute. In election petition, any introduction of new
material facts is to be made within 45 days' time limit fixed by
Section 81 of RP Act, if the same is permissible.”
[8]
Mr. N. Mahendra, learned counsel for the respondent
No.2/returned candidate adopts the submissions of Mr. B R Sharma and
further adds that the present application is misconceived and the
proposed amendment is not required to be incorporated in the written
statement of the applicant herein/respondent No.2 in the election
petition. In the election petition filed by the respondent No.1 herein
against the respondent No.2 herein, the pleadings and materials facts
are relating to the respondent No.2. However, in the proposed
amendment of the applicant, the material facts intended to be
introduced are related to the defects in the nomination and other
aspects of the respondent No.1 herein/election petitioner. It is urged
that the proposed amendment in the written statement of the applicant
will not be a subject matter of the election petition, rather these are
the pleading in the recrimination petition filed by the applicant against
the respondent No.1 herein. It is prayed that the application for
amendment of written statement be dismissed with cost.
[9]
On perusal of the pleading of the parties and submissions
at bar, this Court frames the following core points for determination:
Whether the material facts for recrimination petition
under Section 97 RP Act, 1951 be incorporated in the
written statement in election petition by way of
amendment of written statement?
[10]
Before proceeding further, it will be proper to reproduce
some of the relevant provisions of statute.
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
Order 6 Rule 17 - Amendment of pleadings
The Court may at any stage of the proceedings allow either party to
alter or amend his pleadings in such manner and on such terms as may
be just, and all such amendments shall be made as may be necessary
for the purpose of determining the real questions in controversy
between the parties:
Provided that no application for amendment shall be allowed
after the trial has commenced, unless the Court comes to the
conclusion that is spite of due diligence, the party could not have raised
the matter before the commencement of trial.
Order 8 Rule 1 - Written statement
The defendant shall, within thirty days from the date of service of
summons on him, present a written statement of his defence:
Provided that where the defendant fails to file the written
statement within the said period of thirty days, he shall be allowed to
file the same on such other day, as may be specified by the Court, for
reasons to be recorded in writing, but which shall not be later than
ninety days from the date of service of summons.
REPRESENTATION OF THE PEOPLE ACT, 1951
Section 81 - Presentation of petitions
(1) An election petition calling in question any election may be
presented on one or more of the grounds specified in sub-section (1)
of section 100 and section 101 to the High Court by any candidate at
such election or any elector within forty-five days from, but not earlier
than the date of election of the returned candidate or if there are more
than one returned candidate at the election and dates of their election
are different, the later of those two dates.
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
Explanation.-In this sub-section, "elector" means a person who was
entitled to vote at the election to which the election petition relates,
whether he has voted at such election or not.
……………
(3) Every election petition shall be accompanied by as many copies
thereof as there are respondents mentioned in the petition and every
such copy shall be attested by the petitioner under his own signature
to be a true copy of the petition.
Section 83. Contents of petition
(1) An election petition(a) shall contain a concise statement of the material facts on which the
petitioner relies;
(b) shall set forth full particulars of any corrupt practice that the
petitioner alleged including as full a statement as possible of the names
of the parties alleged to have committed such corrupt practice and the
date and place of the commission of each such practice; and
(c) shall be signed by the petitioner and verified in the manner laid
down in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908) for the
verification of pleadings:
Provided that where the petitioner alleges any corrupt practice,
the petition shall also be accompanied by an affidavit in the prescribed
form in support of the allegation of such corrupt practice and the
particulars thereof.
(2) Any schedule or annexure to the petition shall also be signed by the
petitioner and verified in the same manner as the petition.
Section 86. Trial of election petitions
(1) The High Court shall dismiss an election petition which does not
comply with the provisions of section 81 or section 82 or section 117.
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
Explanation. - An order of the High Court dismissing an election petition
under this sub-section shall be deemed to be an order made under
clause (a) of section 98.
(2) As soon as may be after an election petition has been presented to
the High Court, it shall be referred to the Judge or one of the Judges
who has or have been assigned by the Chief Justice for the trial of
election petitions under sub-section (2) of section 80A.
(3) Where more election petitions than one are presented to the High
Court in respect of the same election, all of them shall be referred for
trial to the same Judge who may, in his discretion, try them separately
or in one or more groups.
(4) Any candidate not already a respondent shall, upon application
made by him to the High Court within fourteen days from the date of
commencement of the trial and subject to any order as to security for
costs which may be made by the High Court, be entitled to be joined
as a respondent.
Explanation. - For the purposes of this sub-section and of section 97,
the trial of a petition shall be deemed to commence on the date fixed
for the respondents to appear before the High Court and answer the
claim or claims made in the petition.
(5) The High Court may, upon such terms as to costs and otherwise as
it may deem fit, allow the particulars of any corrupt practice alleged in
the petition to be amended or amplified in such manner as may in its
opinion be necessary for ensuring a fair and effective trial of the
petition, but shall not allow any amendment of the petition which will
have the effect of introducing particulars of a corrupt practice not
previously alleged in the petition.
(6) The trial of an election petition shall, so far as is practicable
consistently with the interests of justice in respect of the trial, be
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
continued from day to day until its conclusion, unless the High Court
finds the adjournment of the trial beyond the following day to be
necessary for reasons to be recorded.
(7) Every election petition shall be tried as expeditiously as possible and
endeavour shall be made to conclude the trial within six months from
the date on which the election petition is presented to the High Court
for trial.
Section 87 - Procedure before the High Court
(1) Subject to the provisions of this Act and of any rules made
thereunder, every election petition shall be tried by the High Court, as
nearly as may be, in accordance with the procedure applicable under
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908) to the trial of suits:
Provided that the High Court shall have the discretion to refuse,
for reasons to be recorded in writing, to examine any witness or
witnesses if it is of the opinion that the evidence of such witness or
witnesses is not material for the decision of petition or that the party
tendering such witness or witnesses is doing so on frivolous grounds or
with a view to delay the proceedings,
(2) The provisions of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of 1872), shall
subject to the provisions of this Act, be deemed to apply in all respects
to the trial of an election petition.
[11]
Section 87 of RP Act, 1951 provides that in an election
petition, the provisions of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 shall be
applicable as nearly as may be applicable. However, in case of
inconsistency between the provisions of CPC and RPA, the special
provisions of RPA will prevail over CPC to the extent of such
inconsistency. Accordingly, the provisions of Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC for
amendment of pleadings will be applicable in a proceeding of election
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
petition initiated under RP Act subject to the limitation of Section 81 of
RP Act which prescribes limitation period for filing election petition as
45 days. In other word, any amendment introducing new material facts
within the meaning of Section 83 of the Act will be impermissible after
45 days as prescribed under Section 81. Even though the power of
court to allow amendment under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC is wide enough
in a suit, the restriction of Section 81 will control such power in view of
the express provision of Section 87 of the Act. Likewise, the period of
limitation for filing written statement is not provided in the RP Act and
as per the provision of Section 87 of the Act, Order 8 Rule 1 CPC for
filing of written statement will be applicable in an election petition.
[12]
It will be fruitful to refer to some case law in this regard
for amendment of written statement in an election petition. In the case
of Salem Advocate Bar Association v. Union of India: (2005) 6
SCC 344, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the 30/90 days period in
Order 8 Rule 1 CPC for filing of written statement is not mandatory, but
is directory and in appropriate the court may extend time to file written
statement. However, the outer limit of 90 days has to be respected as
far as practicable and extension is to be resorted in exceptional cases
for doing complete justice. Relevant para are reproduced below.
“20. The use of the word “shall” in Order 8 Rule 1 by itself is
not conclusive to determine whether the provision is mandatory
or directory. We have to ascertain the object which is required
to be served by this provision and its design and context in
which it is enacted. The use of the word “shall” is ordinarily
indicative of mandatory nature of the provision but having
regard to the context in which it is used or having regard to the
intention of the legislation, the same can be construed as
directory. The rule in question has to advance the cause of
justice and not to defeat it. The rules of procedure are made
to advance the cause of justice and not to defeat it.
Construction of the rule or procedure which promotes justice
and prevents miscarriage has to be preferred. The rules of
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
procedure are the handmaid of justice and not its mistress. In
the present context, the strict interpretation would defeat
justice.
21. In construing this provision, support can also be had from
Order 8 Rule 10 which provides that where any party from
whom a written statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9,
fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed by
the court, the court shall pronounce judgment against him, or
make such other order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit. On
failure to file written statement under this provision, the court
has been given the discretion either to pronounce judgment
against the defendant or make such other order in relation to
the suit as it thinks fit. In the context of the provision, despite
use of the word “shall”, the court has been given the discretion
to pronounce or not to pronounce the judgment against the
defendant even if the written statement is not filed and instead
pass such order as it may think fit in relation to the suit. In
construing the provision of Order 8 Rule 1 and Rule 10, the
doctrine of harmonious construction is required to be applied.
The effect would be that under Rule 10 Order 8, the court in
its discretion would have the power to allow the defendant to
file written statement even after expiry of the period of 90 days
provided in Order 8 Rule 1. There is no restriction in Order 8
Rule 10 that after expiry of ninety days, further time cannot be
granted. The court has wide power to “make such order in
relation to the suit as it thinks fit”. Clearly, therefore, the
provision of Order 8 Rule 1 providing for the upper limit of 90
days to file written statement is directory. Having said so, we
wish to make it clear that the order extending time to file
written statement cannot be made in routine. The time can be
extended only in exceptionally hard cases. While extending
time, it has to be borne in mind that the legislature has fixed
the upper time-limit of 90 days. The discretion of the court to
extend the time shall not be so frequently and routinely
exercised so as to nullify the period fixed by Order 8 Rule 1.”
[13]
In the case of Ram Dayal vs. Brijraj Singh and Ors. :
MANU/SC/0269/1969: AIR 1969 SC 110: 1969 INSC 136,
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that amendment in election petition
introducing new material facts will be barred after expiry of 45 days as
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
stipulated under Section 81 of the Representation of the People Act,
1951. Relevant par 2 is reproduced below:
“2. An election petition has, under Section 81(1) of the
Representation of the People Act, 1951, to be filed within 45
days of the date of the publication of the result of the election.
An application for setting aside the election, that Dataram was
below the age of 25 and on that account the election was liable
to be set aside under Section 100(1)(d)(i) of the Act made on
August 15, 1967, would plainly have been barred, and by
amendment the ground could not be permitted to be added.
This Court in Harish Chandra Bajpai v. Triloki
Singh MANU/SC/0057/1956 : [1957]1SCR370 held that the
Election Tribunal has power to allow an amendment in respect
of particulars of illegal and corrupt practices, or to permit new
instances to be included, provided the grounds or charges are
specifically stated in the petition, but its power to permit
amendment of a petition under Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC
will not be exercised so as to allow new grounds or charges to
be raised or the character of the petition to be so altered as to
make it in substance a new petition, if a fresh petition on those
allegations would on the date of the proposed amendment be
barred. By the amendment a new ground for setting aside the
election was sought to be introduced, and the High Court was
right in rejecting the application for amendment.”
[14]
In the case of Muniraju Gowda P.M. vs. Munirathna
and Ors.: MANU/SC/0756/2020: AIR 2021 SC 432: 2020 INSC
594, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that amendment proposing to
incorporate new plea after the period of limitation cannot be allowed in
an election petition. Relevant para are reproduced below for ready
reference:
“16. It is only after two months of the first Respondent filing
I.A. No. 4 of 2019 that the Petitioner herein moved an
application in I.A. No. 1 of 2020 for amendment of the
pleadings by incorporating one paragraph, after the existing
para 30 of the election petition. To be precise I.A. No. 1 of 2020
was filed on 11.02.2020 seeking to incorporate one paragraph
as para 30(a) in the original election petition. This proposed
additional paragraph comprised of two parts, one relating the
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
alleged corrupt practices and the other relating to the
requirements of Section 101(b) of the Act. By the order
impugned herein, the High Court allowed the amendment to
the extent of first part of para 30(a), but rejected the
amendment as regards the second part which relates to the
ingredients of Section 101 (b). As rightly pointed out by the
High Court, the election Petitioner cannot be allowed to
suddenly wake up to the reality of lack of pleading of
material facts, relating to his rights in terms of Section
101 after more than 18 months of the filing of the
election petition. The same is also barred by limitation.
Therefore, the High Court did the right thing in
disallowing the second part of the proposed para 30 (a)
and in striking off prayer (c).
17. In any case, the second part of paragraph 30 (a) sought to
be incorporated by way of amendment, does not satisfy the
requirement of pleading of material facts, necessary for the
High Court to form an opinion in terms of Clause (a) or (b) of
Section 101.”
[15]
In the case of V.S. Achuthanandan v. P.J. Francis
and Ors.: MANU/SC/0197/1999: 1999 INSC 123, Hon’ble
Supreme Court held in para 14 that introduction of material facts in
election petition cannot be introduced by way of amendment after the
expiry of the time limit.
“14. It would, thus appear, that the election petition was
rejected mainly on the ground that it did not disclose the cause
of action as according to the learned trial Judge the allegations
regarding corrupt practice were vague and did not disclose
"material facts and full particulars" of the corrupt practice
alleged. It is evident that the learned trial Judge did not
distinguish between the 'material facts' and 'material
particulars' of allegations regarding corrupt practices as defined
under Section 123 of the Act. The Law on the point is wellsettled which appears to have not been taken note of by the
learned trial Judge. After referring to various pronouncements
of this Court including cases in Balwan Singh v. Lakshmi Narain
and Ors. MANU/SC/0192/1960 : [1960]3SCR91, Samant N.
Balakrishna and Anr. v. George Fernandez and
Ors. MANU/SC/0270/1969 : [1969]3SCR603 . Virendra Kumar
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
Saklecha v. Jajiwan and Ors. [1973] 1 SCC 826, Shri Udhav
Singh v. Madhav Rao Scindia
MANU/SC/0302/1975 :
[1976]2SCR246 , F.A. Sapa and Ors. v. Singera and Ors. and
Gajanan Krishnaji Bapat and Anr. v. Dattaji Raghobaji Meghe
and Ors. MANU/SC/0455/1995 : AIR1995SC2284 and host of
other authorities, this Court in L.R. Shivaramagowda etc. v.
T.M.
Chandrashekar
etc.
MANU/SC/0756/1998
:
AIR1999SC252 held that while failure to plead 'material
facts' is fatal to the election petition and no amendment
of the pleading is permissible to introduce such
material facts after the time limit prescribed for filing
the election petition, the absence of 'material
particulars' can be cured at a later stage by an
appropriate amendment. An election petition was not liable
to be dismissed is limine merely because full particulars of
corrupt practice alleged were not set out. It is, therefore,
evident that material facts are such primary facts which must
be proved at the trial by a party to establish existence of a
cause of action. Whether in an election petition a particular fact
is material fact or not, and as such, required to be pleaded is a
question which depends on the nature of the charge leveled,
the ground relied upon, and in the light of the special
circumstances of the case.”
[16]
In Moirangthem Hemanta Singh v. Paonam Brojen
Singh & Anr.:2024 SCC OnLine Mani 507, this Court discussed the
scope of amendment of election petition as embodied under Order 6
Rule 17 of CPC read with the mandatory provisions of Sections 87 & 81
of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 and held as below:
“[21]
The principle of amendment as embodied in Order
6 Rule 17 CPC provides for amendment of the pleadings of the
parties generally prior to the commencement of trial for
determining the true dispute between the parties. However, no
new case can be introduced by such amendment. Section 87
of RP Act permits the application of the rules of CPC in an
election petition as far as practicable and in case of
inconsistency, the provisions of RP Act shall prevail. Reading
together the provisions of Order 6 Rule 17 CPC with Section 81
of RP Act, any amendment to election petition has to be made
within the stipulated 45 days.
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
[22]
In the present case, the election petitioner prays
for introducing a missing page of the affidavit Form-26 of the
returned candidate. The issue is whether such an endeavour
amounts to amendment of the election petition. If the answer
is YES, such an amendment after 58 days will be barred by
Section 81 of RP Act. As already observed above, the missing
document, ie, Annexure R-1 is only a material document and
inserting the same as page 95A will not amount to amendment
of election petition, as the necessary material facts have
already been averred in para 10, 11 and 12 of the election
petition. Accordingly, third point is also decided in favour of
the applicant.”
[17]
In the present case, the applicant is respondent No.2 in
the election petition being El. Pet. No. 13 of 2022 filed by the
respondent No.1 herein against the respondent No.2 herein/returned
candidate. The main pleadings in the election petition are against the
respondent No.2 herein with respect to the defects in the nomination
paper specially FORM-26 and plea of corrupt practices and concealment
of materials facts. The applicant herein/respondent No.2 in election
petition has already filed written statement to the election petition on
04.07.2022 and also recrimination petition being El. Rec. Pet. No. 8 of
2022 on 30.05.2022 against the respondent No.1 herein/election
petitioner. However, the present application for amendment of written
statement under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC was filed on 20.02.2023 with a
prayer to include para 9 to 22 to the written statement already filed on
04.07.2022 on the plea that the same could not be incorporated in the
written statement by bonafide mistake. It is clarified that the proposed
amendment is not new plea and its contents are already incorporated
in the recrimination petition filed the applicant against the election
petitioner.
[18]
This Court has minutely gone through the contents of the
proposed amendment as conatained in para 7 of the application
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
proposing to add para 9-22 in the written statement after para 8. On
perusal of the contents of proposed para 9-22, it is seen that the facts
narrated in these para are against the election petitioner and none of
them relates to the returned candidate. It may be noted that the written
statement
in
an
election
petition
is
the
reply
of
the
defendants/respondents to the averments in the election petition. In
the election petition, all the allegations are against the returned
candidate and other unsuccessful candidates are impleaded as party,
because the election petitioner prays for a relief for declaring him as
elected after setting aside the election of the returned candidate. If no
prayer is made for declaring the election petitioner as elected and the
prayer is simply for setting aside the election of returned candidate,
other candidates are not necessary party. Generally, no allegation is
made against other defeated candidates in an election petition.
[19]
In the present case, the contents of proposed para 9-22
to be incorporated in the written statement, are actually pleadings
against the election petitioner which have already been included in the
recrimination petition filed by the applicant against the election
petitioner and the same have nothing to do with the election petition
filed by the election petitioner against the returned candidate. In other
words, the contents of the proposed amendment as para 9-22 are not
required for determining the controversy in the election petition,
because nothing has been alleged against the returned candidate and
all the averments are directed against the election petitioner. In fact, e
para 9-22 are the pleading to be taken in the recrimination petition. It
is settled proposition of law that plea of recrimination cannot be
introduced in the written statement by way of amendment. Besides,
the proposed amendment does not have any bearing on the election
petition.
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
[20]
While upholding the permissibility of invoking the
provisions of Order 6 Rule 17 CPC for amendment of pleading specially
the written statement in an election petition, this Court is of the
considered view that the pleadings of recrimination petition against the
election petitioner cannot be incorporated in the written statement filed
in the election petition initiated against the returned candidate by the
election petitioner. Accordingly, the
present application being
MC[El.Pet.] No. 22 of 2023 is dismissed with a cost of Rs.10,000/[rupees ten thousand] to be deposited in favour of High Court Bar
Association of Manipur for relief purpose. The cost is to be deposited
within 30 days and proof of the same be filed with the registry.
[21]
List the main matter, i.e., El. Pet. No. 13 of 2022 along
with connected matters on 06.10.2025 for further proceedings.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Priyojit
signed
RAJKUMA Digitally
by RAJKUMAR
R PRIYOJIT PRIYOJIT SINGH
Date: 2025.09.19
SINGH
13:51:05 +05'30'
MC[EL.PET.] NO. 22 OF 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review