Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
R
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 16TH DAY OF JUNE, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VENKATESH NAIK T
CRIMINAL CONTEMPT PETITION NO.5 OF 2025
BETWEEN:
NEW SPACE RESEARCH AND TECHNOLOGIES PVT. LTD.
A COMPANY INCORPORATED
UNDER THE COMPANIES ACT, 2013
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT:
2ND FLOOR, GV TOWERS
SAHAKAR NAGAR
SANJEEVINI NAGAR
BENGALURU-560 092
KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY ITS AUTHORISED SIGNATORY
JULIUS SOMOJIT AMVIT.
… COMPLAINANT
(BY SRI ANGAD KAMATH, ADVOCATE)
Digitally
signed by
ANJALI M
Location:
High
Court of
Karnataka
AND:
1.
MR. PRABHAT SHARMA
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
S/O. MR. SHISHU PAL SHARMA.
2.
MRS. GARIMA SHARMA
W/O. MR. PRABHAT SHARMA
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS.
RESPONDENT NOS.1 AND 2 ARE
RESIDING AT NO.L-58
SECTOR 11, NOIDA
GAUTHAM BUDDHA NAGAR
UTTAR PRADESH-201 301.
-2-
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
3.
MS. RANU SHARMA, IPS
AGED MAJOR
ADCP TRAFFIC
(JAIPUR SOUTH COMMISSIONERATE)
KING EDWARD MEMORIAL (YADGAR)
AJMERI GATE, M.I. ROAD
JAIPUR-302 001.
4.
MR. TANVIR
S/O. LATE ABDULREHMAN
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF POLICE (ACP)
CEN POLICE STATION, NORTH EAST DIVISION
RESIDING AT NO.B.A-59
PWD QUARTERS
KHB COLONY MAIN ROAD
R.T. NAGAR POST
BENGALURU-560 032.
… ACCUSED
(BY SMT. KAVITHA DAMODARAN, ADVOCATE, FOR A-1 TO A3, &
SRI RAHUL KRISHNA REDDY P., ADVOCATE, FOR A-4)
***
THIS CRIMINAL CONTEMPT PETITION IS FILED UNDER
ARTICLE 215 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA AND SECTION 15 OF
THE CONTEMPT OF COURTS ACT, 1971, READ WITH RULE 3 OF THE
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT (CONTEMPT OF COURT PROCEEDINGS)
RULES, 1981, PRAYING TO TAKE SUO-MOTU COGNIZANCE AND
INITIATE CRIMINAL CONTEMPT PROCEEDINGS AS AGAINST
ACCUSED NOS.1 TO 4 UNDER ARTICLE 215 OF THE CONSTITUTION
OF INDIA AND SECTIONS 2(c), 10, 12, AND 15 OF THE CONTEMPT
OF COURTS ACT, 1971, FOR DELIBERATE AND WILFUL
DISOBEDIENCE OF THE ORDER DATED 6-12-2024 PASSED BY THIS
HON'BLE COURT IN WRIT PETITION NO.32999 OF 2024, AND TO
PUNISH AND CONVICT THE ACCUSED AND SENTENCE THEM TO
IMPRISONMENT AND FINE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS
OF THE CONTEMPT OF COURTS ACT, 1971.
THIS CRIMINAL CONTEMPT PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD
AND RESERVED ON 02.06.2026, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT,
THIS DAY, VENKATESH NAIK T. J., PRONOUNCED THE
FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VENKATESH NAIK T
-3-
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VENKATESH NAIK T)
This criminal contempt petition is filed under Article 215
of the Constitution of India, 1950, read with Sections 2(c), 10,
12 and 15 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, seeking
initiation of contempt proceedings against accused Nos.1 to 4.
2. I.A. No.1 of 2026 is filed under Section 15(1) of the
Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, to recall the order dated
24.02.2026
overruling
the
office
objection
raised
on
maintainability of the petition.
3. In view of the preliminary objection raised to the
maintainability of this petition alleging that the accused had
committed criminal contempt of this Court and praying for
taking suitable action against them, the following question of
law arises for our consideration:
i. Whether the Criminal Contempt of Court case
filed seeking to take action against an alleged
contemnor without the consent of the Advocate
General is maintainable?
4. Sri Dhananjaya Joshi, learned senior counsel for the
accused, has contended that the petition required the prior
-4-
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
consent of the Advocate General of Karnataka. Earlier, the
Registry had raised objection with regard to maintainability of
the petition on the ground that the Advocate General's consent
was not forthcoming and hence, the issue of maintainability of
the petition was kept open. In fact, the Advocate General has
neither granted, nor denied consent, and the complainant is
seeking suo motu cognizance of this petition. On 24.02.2026,
this Court has overruled the office objection on maintainability
of
the
petition
and
directed
issuance
of
notice
to
the
respondents. The learned counsel appearing for the accused
submits that without taking suo motu cognizance of the
petition, this Court could not have overruled the office
objections on maintainability of the petition, in the absence of
the Advocate General's consent. Further, there is no order of
this
Court
on
the
administrative
side
permitting
the
consideration of the petition. There is also no order of the Court
recording at least a prima facie finding that the alleged
actions/conduct of the respondents/accused may tantamount to
criminal contempt. Further, the petition has been filed by a
private party without obtaining the prior consent of the
Advocate General, which is a condition precedent for initiation
of criminal contempt proceedings. The requirement of obtaining
-5-
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
the Advocate General's prior consent is not a mere procedural
formality, but a substantive safeguard intended to prevent
abuse of the contempt jurisdiction. Further, the issue of
compliance with requirements of Section 15 of the Contempt of
Courts Act, 1971, goes to the very root of the petition. In the
absence
of
compliance
with
the
mandatory
statutory
requirements, the petition itself is not maintainable and
therefore, the question of issuing notice to the respondents
would not arise. Therefore, it is contended that this Court could
not have proceeded to overrule the objection on maintainability
without ensuring compliance with the statutory mandate and
the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court. Therefore,
the learned counsel for the accused prays to recall the order
dated 24.02.2026 and to dismiss the contempt petition.
5. In support of his contentions, the learned counsel for
the accused has relied on the following decisions:
i.
P.N. Duda v. P. Shiv Shanker and others reported in
(1988) 3 SCC 167, and
ii.
Bal Thackrey v. Harish Pimpalkhute and others reported
in (2005) 1 SCC 254.
6. On the contrary, Sri Angad Kamath, learned counsel
for the complainant, has filed objections to the interlocutory
-6-
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
application seeking recall of the order dated 24.02.2026 stating
that the application is wholly misconceived, untenable in law
and liable to be rejected In Limine. The accused/applicants
proceed on a fundamentally erroneous assumption that the
contempt proceedings are a private motion within the meaning
of Section 15(1)(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, and
that, in the absence of prior consent of the Advocate General,
the petition itself is non-maintainable. The assumption is wrong
both on the scheme of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, and
on the express language of the High Court of Karnataka
(Contempt of Court Proceedings) Rules, 1981. In fact, the
present petition is not a private motion seeking initiation of
contempt proceedings on the strength of any supposed right
vested in the complainant. The contempt petition merely places
before this Court the material facts, documents and information
disclosing acts, which according to the complainant, call for
consideration by this Court in exercise of its contempt
jurisdiction. The source of jurisdiction invoked is not the
complainant's motion, but the constitutional and inherent
jurisdiction of this Court under Article 215 of the Constitution of
India read with Section 15 of the Contempt of Courts Act,
1971.
-7-
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
7. It is further contended that entire edifice of the
accused case collapses upon a plain reading of Rule 5(v) of the
High Court of Karnataka (Contempt of Court proceedings)
Rules, 1981. Rule 5(v) of the High Court of Karnataka
(Contempt of Court proceedings) Rules, 1981, requires the
complainant, in a case of criminal contempt, to state whether
consent of the Advocate General has been obtained, expressly
preserves the power of the Court to take action suo motu on
the basis of the information disclosed. The Rule is significant for
two reasons. Firstly, it recognises that what may trigger suo
motu action is the information disclosed. Secondly, it does not
limit the mode by which such information may reach the Court.
Therefore, the Rules do not say that information must come
only by way of newspaper report, letter or administrative
reference. Information may reach the Court in any legally
recognised form, including through the medium of a formal
petition, as in the present case.
8. It is contended that the distinction becomes clearer on
a conjoint reading of Rule 5 along with Rule 7 of the High Court
of Karnataka (Contempt of Court proceedings) Rules, 1981.
Rule 7 of the High Court of Karnataka (Contempt of Court
-8-
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
proceedings) Rules, 1981, specifically deals with initiation of
proceedings on information other than a petition or a reference.
It is only such information, namely information disclosed
otherwise than by a petition or reference, that is required in the
first instance to be placed before Hon'ble the Chief Justice on
the administrative side. The necessary consequence is that
where information is already disclosed through the medium of a
petition or reference, the matter does not fall within the
purview of Rule 7(i) of the High Court of Karnataka (Contempt
of Court proceedings) Rules, 1981.
9. It is contended that the consent of the Advocate
General is relevant where the Court is invited to act on a
private motion under Section 15(1)(b) of the High Court of
Karnataka (Contempt of Court proceedings) Rules, 1981. Thus,
it has no application where the Court acts on its own motion
upon information placed before it. The present petition is of the
latter category. The petition is merely the vehicle through
which information reaches this Court and it is not the source of
the Court's power. This position is no longer open to a serious
debate in view of the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the
case of Prashant
Bhushan and another reported in
(2021) 1 SCC 745, wherein information regarding the alleged
-9-
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
contempt reached the Court through a petition filed by a
private person. The objection was specifically advanced stating
that, since the initiation was at the instance of a private party
and no consent of the Advocate General was obtained, suo
motu contempt could not be proceeded with, the Hon'ble Apex
Court rejected the objection and made it clear that a petition by
a private person may constitute the source of information,
while cognizance may yet be taken by the Court suo motu in
exercise of its own constitutional power. The said ratio is
directly applicable to the case on hand. Thus, the accused
cannot reintroduce through the back door, a limitation, which
the Hon'ble Apex Court has already repelled.
10. In support of his contentions, the learned counsel for
the complainant has relied on the following decisions:
i.
Prashant Bhushan and Another v. Alleged Contemnor in
Suo Motu Contempt Petition (Crl.) No.1 of 2020,
ii.
S.N. Nagaraja Rao v. Chikkachennappa and Others in
C.C.C. (Criminal) No.4 of 1978,
iii.
Timex Group India Limited and Another v. Mahesh Kumar
and Others in Cont.Cas.(Crl) 2 of 2017,
- 10 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
iv.
Court on its own motion v. Rajesh Girothiya and Others
in Cont.Cas.(Crl.) 4 of 2024,
v.
GE Motors India Pvt. Ltd. v. Mukesh Kumar reported in
2005 SCC OnLine Del 915, and
vi.
Advocate-General of Andhra Pradesh v. Chennamsetty
Chakrapani and Others in Contempt Case No.741 of
1995.
11.
We
have
heard
the
learned
counsel
for
the
complainant/petitioner and the learned senior counsel for the
accused/respondents. Perused the material available on record
and the decisions cited supra.
12. The complainant has filed a suit against accused
Nos.1 and 2 and other persons in Original Suit No.8367 of 2024
for perpetual injunction, restraining the defendants, their
agents, contractors, their employees, partners or any other
person/entity claiming through or under the defendants from
directly or indirectly copying, sharing or using in any manner
the confidential/proprietary information/material belonging to
the complainant, inter alia, as referred to in the Forensic
Investigation Report.
13. Along with the plaint, I.A. Nos.3 and 4 were filed
under Order XXVI, Rules 1 and 9 read with Section 151 of the
- 11 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
CPC praying to grant an ex parte interim order to appoint the
Court Commissioner.
14. Regarding I.A. Nos.3 and 4, the trial Judge, by order
dated 29.11.2024, refused to pass ex parte order, but issued
emergent notice on I.A. No.3 and in so far as I.A. No.4 is
concerned, failed to pass any speaking order. Being aggrieved
by the order dated 29.11.2024, the complainant filed Writ
Petition No.32999 of 2024 before this Court. On 06.12.2024,
this Court passed an ex parte order appointing the Court
Commissioner to carryout search and seizure of the operation
of the date storage media, files, folders, documents etc. in the
premises
of
the
accused/respondents
and
directed
the
Commissioner to execute the warrant for seven days between
20.12.2024 and 28.12.2024 and to submit a report to this
Court on 06.01.2025. Both accused Nos.1 and 2, declined to
obey the statutory warrant, creating a stand up situation in
which the Court Commissioner and his team were effectively
kept outside the property in contravention of this Court's
explicit directives. Immediately, after these events, the Court
Commissioner documented the incident in detail. In accordance
with this Court's order, the Commissioner prepared a formal
report dated 01.06.2025. In his report, the Commissioner
- 12 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
recounted the sequence of events chronologically, listing the
obstacles encountered at each step. The said Commissioner's
report was placed before this Court in Writ Petition No.32999 of
2024 and this Court without expressing any opinion on the
merits of the Court Commissioner's report, by order dated
29.01.2025, was pleased to dispose of the writ petition
directing the learned trial Judge to pass appropriate orders on
the Court Commissioner's report in accordance with law.
15. In this regard, the complainant filed this contempt
petition to take action.
Soon after initiation of the petition,
notice was ordered and insofar as maintainability of the petition
is concerned, it was overruled on 24.02.2026. Accordingly,
notice was issued to the accused. In this petition, I.A. No.1 of
2026 is filed seeking recall of the order dated 24.02.2026.
Learned counsel for the accused disputed that the contempt
petition is not maintainable in the present form as requirement
of Advocate General's consent has not been obtained. Hence, it
is just and necessary to quote Section 15 of the Contempt of
Courts Act, 1971, which specifies how criminal contempt is to
be taken cognizance of. It will be useful to set out here the
relevant portions of this section:
- 13 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
"15. Cognizance of criminal contempt in other cases(1) In the case of a criminal contempt, other than a
contempt referred to in Section 14, the Supreme Court
or the High Court may take action on its own motion or
on a motion made by(a) the Advocate-General, or
(b) any other person, with the consent in writing of the
Advocate-General, or
(c) in relation to the High Court for the Union Territory
of Delhi, such law officer as the Central Government
may, by notification in the official Gazette, specify in
this behalf, or any other person, with the consent in
writing of such law officer."
According to the above provisions, action for 'criminal
contempt' of the High Court can be initiated - (1) by the High
Court on its own motion; or (2) on a motion made by the
Advocate-General; or (3) on a motion made by any other
person with the consent of the Advocate-General.
16. It is also a fact that the complainant has not secured
consent of the Advocate General for presenting this petition.
When the learned counsel raised a preliminary objection based
on Section 15(1) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, and
submitted that the petition cannot be entertained by this Court
- 14 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
as the complainant has not secured the consent of the
Advocate General, he was directed to file a memorandum
raising the contention and the complainant was permitted to
file a reply. Thereafter, a specific plea or the lines of the
preliminary objection raised has been taken by the accused.
The complainant has filed his reply, in which, he has contended
that as the petition is filed under Article 215 of the Constitution
for taking action against the accused for having committed
criminal contempt of the order of the High Court, in exercise of
its powers under that Article, consent of the Advocate General
was not necessary and in any event, taking consent of the
Advocate General as provided in Section 15(1) of the Contempt
of Courts Act, 1971, is only directory and not mandatory.
17. Further, the jurisdiction and powers of this Court to
punish any one for committing contempt of itself is derived
from the provisions of the Constitution of India vide Article
215 and not from the provisions of the Contempt of Courts Act,
1971. The petition is filed under Article 215 of the Constitution
of India.
For exercising the power under Article 215 of the
Constitution
of
India,
consent
of
the
Advocate
General
prescribed under Section 15 the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971,
- 15 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
is not necessary. In any event, the consent of Advocate
General prescribed is only directory and not mandatory.
18. Having set out the facts of the case and the
contentions urged for the parties, we shall now proceed to
consider the question arising for consideration. Article 215 of
the Constitution of India reads as under:
"215. Every High Court shall be a Court of record and
shall have all the powers of such a court including the
power to punish for contempt of itself".
19. Article 215 of the Constitution of India confers on
every High Court the power to punish for contempt of itself.
This power is wide enough to cover cases of ex facie criminal
contempt as also every act or omission, which amounts to
contempt of the High Court. Therefore, whether contempt of
High Court alleged to have been committed by any one is of the
description referred to in Section 14 or Section 15 of the
Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, it is competent for the High
Court to punish the alleged contemnor in exercise of its power
under that Article. Such an action could be taken by the High
Court under Article 215 of the Constitution of India either on its
own motion on securing information in whatever manner, or on
- 16 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
a motion made by the Advocate General or by any other
person. Consent of the Advocate General is not contemplated
by the Article for a motion made by any other person.
20. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of P.N. Duda v.
P. Shiv Shanker and Others reported in (1988) 3 SCC 167
at paragraph No.54 has held as under:
"54. A conjoint perusal of the Act and rules makes it clear
that, so far as this Court is concerned, action for
contempt may be taken by the court on its own motion or
on the motion of the Attorney-General (or SolicitorGeneral) or of any other person with his consent in
writing. There is no difficulty where the court or the
Attorney-General choose to move in the matter. But when
this is not done and a private person desires that such
action should be taken, one of three courses is open to
him. He may place the information in his possession
before the court and request the court to take action:
(vide C.K. Daphtary v. O.P. Gupta [(1971) 1 SCC 626]
and Sarkar v. Misra [(1981) 1 SCC 436]; he may place
the information before the Attorney-General and request
him to take action; or he may place the information
before the Attorney-General and request him to permit
him to move the court. In the present case, the petitioner
alleges that he has failed in the latter two courses — this
will be considered a little later — and has moved this
“petition” praying that this Court should take suo motu
action. The “petition” at this stage, constitutes nothing
more than a mode of laying the relevant information
- 17 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
before the court for such action as the court may deem fit
and no proceedings can commence until and unless the
court considers the information before it and decides to
initiate proceedings. Rules 3 and 4 of the Supreme Court
(Contempt of Court) Rules also envisage a petition only
where the Attorney-General or any other person, with his
written consent, moves the court. Rule 5 is clear that only
a petition moved under Rule 3(b) and (c) is to be posted
before the court for preliminary hearing. The form of a
criminal miscellaneous petition styling the informant as
the petitioner and certain other persons as respondents is
inappropriate for merely lodging the relevant information
before the court under Rule 3(a). It would seem that the
proper title of such a proceeding should be “In re . . . . .
(the alleged contemnor)” (see: Kar v. Chief Justice
[(1962) 1 SCR 319] though that decision related to an
appeal from an order of conviction for contempt by the
High Court). The form in which this request has to be
sought and considered in such cases has also been
touched upon by the Delhi High Court in Anil Kumar
Gupta v. K. Subba Rao [ILR (1974) 1 Del 1] . This case,
at the outset, pointed out that the information had been
erroneously numbered by the office of the court as
Criminal Original No. 51 of 1978 and concluded with the
following observations:
“The office is to take note that in future if
any information is lodged even in the form of
a petition inviting this Court to take action
under the Contempt of Courts Act or Article
215 of the Constitution, where the informant
is not one of the persons named in Section
- 18 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
15 of the said Act, it should not be styled as
a petition and should not be placed for
admission
on
the
judicial
side.
Such
a
petition should be placed before the Chief
Justice for orders in Chambers and the Chief
Justice may decide either by himself or in
consultation with the other judges of the
Court whether to take any cognizance of the
information. The office is directed to strike
off the information as “Criminal Original No.
51 of 1973” and to file it”."
21. Further, the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Bal
Thackrey v. Harish Pimpalkhute and Others reported in
(2005) 1 SCC 254 at paragraph Nos.16 to 18, and 23 has
held as under:
"16. The whole object of prescribing procedural mode
of taking cognizance in Section 15 is to safeguard the
valuable time of the court from being wasted by
frivolous contempt petitions. In J.R. Parashar case
[(2001) 6 SCC 735] it was observed that the underlying
rationale of clauses (a), (b) and (c) of Section 15(1)
appears to be that when the court is not itself directly
aware of the contumacious conduct, and the actions are
alleged to have taken place outside its precincts, it is
necessary to have the allegations screened by the
prescribed authorities so that the court is not troubled
with frivolous matters. To similar effect is the decision in
S.K. Sarkar case [(1981) 1 SCC 436] .
- 19 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
17. In the light of the aforesaid, the procedure laid and
directions issued in Duda case are required to be
appreciated also keeping in view the additional factor of
the Chief Justice being the master of the roster. In
State of Rajasthan v. Prakash Chand [(1998) 1 SCC 1]
it was held that it is the prerogative of the Chief Justice
of the High Court to distribute business of the High
Court both judicial and administrative. He alone has the
right and power to decide how the Benches of the High
Court are to be constituted; which Judge is to sit alone
and which cases he can and is required to hear as also
which Judges shall constitute a Division Bench and what
work those Benches shall do.
18. The directions in Duda case when seen and
appreciated in the light of what we have noticed
hereinbefore in respect of contempt action and the
powers of the Chief Justice, it would be clear that the
same prescribe the procedure to be followed by High
Courts to ensure smooth working and streamlining of
such contempt actions which are intended to be taken
up by the Court suo motu on its own motion. These
directions have no effect of curtailing or denuding the
power of the High Court. It is also to be borne in mind
that the frequent use of suo motu power on the basis of
information furnished in a contempt petition otherwise
incompetent under Section 15 of the Act may render the
procedural
safeguards
of
the
Advocate
General's
consent nugatory. We are of the view that the directions
given in Duda case are legal and valid.
xxx xxx.
- 20 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
23. In these matters, the question is not about
compliance or non-compliance with the principles of
natural justice by granting adequate opportunity to the
appellant but is about compliance with the mandatory
requirements of Section 15 of the Act. As already
noticed the procedure of Section 15 is required to be
followed even when petition is filed by a party under
Article 215 of the Constitution, though in these matters
petitions filed were under Section 15 of the Act. From
the material on record, it is not possible to accept the
contention of the respondents that the Court had taken
suo motu action. Of course, the Court had the power
and jurisdiction to initiate contempt proceedings suo
motu and for that purpose consent of the Advocate
General was not necessary. At the same time, it is also
to be borne in mind that the courts normally take suo
motu action in rare cases. In the present case, it is
evident that the proceedings before the High Court were
initiated by the respondents by filing contempt petitions
under Section 15. The petitions were vigorously pursued
and strenuously argued as private petitions. The same
were never treated as suo motu petitions. In absence of
compliance with the mandatory requirement of Section
15, the petitions were not maintainable."
22. From perusal of the facts and circumstances of the
case and the decisions cited supra, it appears that action for
contempt is divisible into two categories, namely, that initiated
suo motu by the Court and otherwise instituted on the
Advocate
General's
motion
or
permission.
The
mode
of
- 21 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
initiation in each case would necessarily be different. While in
the case of suo motu proceedings, it is the Court itself which
must initiate by issuing a notice, in other cases, initiation can
only be by a party filing an application.
determination
in
this
contempt
The main issue for
petition
is
'whether
the
contempt proceedings initiated against the accused is in
accordance with law or not?'
23. Learned counsel for the complainant enlightened Rule
5(v) of the High Court of Karnataka (Contempt of Court
proceedings) Rules, 1981, and contended that in a case of
criminal
contempt,
the
consent
of
Advocate
General
is
necessary, or the Court can take action suo motu on the basis
of the information received and the High Court of Karnataka
(Contempt of Court proceedings) Rules, 1981, do not say
information must come only by way of newspaper report,
letter, or administrative reference and information may reach
the Court in any legally recognised form, including in the form
of petition.
24. Hence, it is just and necessary to analyse Rule 3,
5(v), 7 and 8 of the High Court of Karnataka (Contempt of
Court proceedings) Rules, 1981, which read as under:
- 22 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
Rule 3. Form of motion.(i)
Every motion for taking action for contempt of the
High Court shall be in the Form of a petition and shall be
entitled "in the matter of proceeding for contempt of
High Court under Article 215 of the Constitution and the
Contempt of Courts Act, 1971" and
(ii)
Every motion for taking action for contempt of any
Court subordinate to the High Court, shall be in the form
of a petition and shall be entitled "in the matter of
proceeding for contempt under the Contempt of Courts
Act, 1971."
Rule 5. Contents of petition.xxx xxx xxx
5(v). In the case of criminal contempt of the High Court
other than a contempt referred to in Section 14 of the
Act, the complainant shall state whether he has obtained
the consent of Advocate General and if so, produce the
same.
Nothing shall preclude the High Court from taking action
suo motu on the basis of the information disclosed.
Rule 7. Initiation of proceedings on information.(i)
Any information other than a petition or reference
shall, in the first instance be placed before the Chief
Justice in the administrative side.
(ii) If the Chief Justice or such other Judge as may be
designated
by
him
for
the
purpose,
considers
it
expedient or proper to take action under the Act, he shall
- 23 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
direct that the said information be placed for preliminary
hearing.
(iii) On such direction the matter shall be dealt with in
accordance with Rule 8 treating the information as a
petition.
Rule - 8. Preliminary hearing and notice.(i)
Every petition or reference shall be posted for
preliminary hearing before the appropriate Bench.
(ii)
(a) The Court, if satisfied that a prima facie case
has been made out, may direct issue of notice to the
accused; otherwise it shall dismiss the petition or reject
the reference.
(b) The notice shall be in Form 1 and shall be
accompanied by a copy of the petition or reference
or information, and annexures if any thereto."
25. This case, at the outset, points out that the
complainant has filed the complaint under Section of 15 the
Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, and Article 215 of the
Constitution of India read with Rule 3 of the High Court of
Karnataka (Contempt of Court proceedings) Rules, 1981, which
should not be justified as a petition and should not be placed
for admission on the judicial side. Such a petition should be
placed before the Hon'ble Chief Justice for orders and the
Hon'ble Chief Justice may decide either by himself or in
consultation with the other Hon'ble Judges of this Court,
- 24 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
whether
to
take
any
cognizance
of
the
information.
Accordingly, the Office has raised the objections for noncompliance of these legal aspects. Whereas in this case, the
said statutory requirements have not been complied with.
26. The last question that remains to be touched upon is
'whether in a case where the Advocate General is in a position
to consider a request under Section 15(1)(c) of the Contempt
of Courts Act, 1971, it is open to the complainant to seek the
consent of the Advocate General.' Apart from the fact that, in
the present case, the complainant has not approached the
Advocate General on the premise that his advice is not at all
necessary and it is not open to him to seek such consent,
Section 15 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 is quite clear
that the written consent of the Advocate General as have been
specifically authorised by the section, would be taken note of
for entertaining a petition under the said section. But this does
not, in any manner, deprive the complainant of his remedy as
he can come before the Court, as indeed he has done,
requesting the Court to take suo motu action.
However, the
procedure as approved by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of
P.N. Duda (supra) has to be followed as there cannot be a
numbering of the information given before this Court as a
- 25 -
CRL.CCC No. 5 of 2025
Contempt of Court Case (Criminal) and the issuance of notice
to the accused without following such procedure.
27. In view of the discussions made hereinabove, I.A.
No.1
of 2026
is allowed. The
order
dated 24.02.2026,
overruling the office objections raised on maintainability of the
petition, is recalled.
The Registry shall treat this petition as 'information'
under Rule 7 of the High Court of Karnataka (Contempt of
Court proceedings) Rules, 1981, and shall place the same
before Hon'ble the Chief Justice for necessary orders.
28.
In the result, this criminal contempt petition is
closed for statistical purpose.
Sd/(ANU SIVARAMAN)
JUDGE
Sd/(VENKATESH NAIK T)
JUDGE
KVK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review