Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~1 & 2
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Reserve: 14th August, 2026
Date of Pronouncement: 19th August, 2026
Date of Uploading:19th August, 2026
+
W.P.(C) No. 7305 of 2013, CM APL.72169/2025 & W.P.(C) No.
2937 of 2020, CM APPL.10195/2020. CM APPL.72342/2025
1. NEHRU PLACE HOTELS & REAL
ESTATES PVT LTD ANR
A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER
THE COMPANIES ACT, 1956
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT
8TH FLOOR EROS CORPORATE TOWER
NEHRU PLACE,
NEW DELHI - 110019
……PETITIONER NO. 1
2. RAMAN KUMAR SOOD
S/O SHRI J.R. SOOD,
R/O 19, GOLF LINKS,
NEW DELHI - 110003.
Through:
.....PETITIONER NO. 2
Mr. Vikas Mishra and Mr. Sanchit
Gawri, Advocates
versus
1. SOUTH DELHI MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,
SERVICE TO BE EFFECTED THROUGH ITS
COMMISSIONER,9TH FLOOR,
DR S.P. MUKHEIJEE CIVIC CENTRE,
JAWAHAR LAL MARG
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page1 of 24
DELHI – 110002
…RESPONDENT NO.1
2. Government of NCT of Delhi
THROUGH ITS CHIEF SECRETARY,
DELHI SECRETARIAT, IP ESTATE,
NEW DELHI
…RESPONDENT NO.2
3. Union of India, through
THE SECRETARY,
MINISTRY OF PARLIAMENTARY AFFAIRS
PARLIAMENT HOUSE,
NEW DELHI-110001
…RESPONDENT NO.3
Through:
Ms. Sunieta Ojha, Ms. Vasudha
Priyansh and Ms. Pragti Bhatia,
Advocates for MCD.
Dr. Monika Arora, CGSC with
Mr. Subrodeep Saha, Mr. Prabhat
Kumar, Mr. Abhinav Verma and
Ms. Anamika Thakur, Advocates
for UOI.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY DIGPAUL
JUDGMENT
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE, J.
1.
Since the parties to the present petitions and the reliefs sought are
similar, both these writ petitions have been heard together and are being
disposed of by this common judgment.
2.
These writ petitions assail the assessment of property tax by the
respondents in purported exercise of powers conferred by Section 123D
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page2 of 24
of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 [‘DMC Act’]
3.
For convenience, the facts in the W.P.(C) 7305/2013 are reflected
hereinbelow, but the years of assessment for property tax in both of the
writ petitions pertain to different financial years.
4.
The parties are referred to as per their nomenclature reflected in
the writ petition which is identical to that of in the applications.
5.
The petitioner No. 1 is a company duly incorporated under the
Companies Act, 1956 and the petition is filed through its Director,
petitioner no. 2, who is competent to initiate the proceedings.
6.
Respondent No. 1 is a body incorporated under the DMC Act,
whereas respondent No. 2 is the Government of NCT of Delhi and
respondent No. 3 is the Union of India.
7.
In both of the writ petitions, the prayer of petitioner is for issuance
of a writ or directions, thereby declaring Delhi Municipal Corporation
(Property Tax) Bye laws, 2004 as unconstitutional, illegal, void ab initio
or in the alternative, it is prayed that the Bye-law No. 14 of the Delhi
Municipal Corporation (Property Tax) Bye laws, 2004 be declared as
unconstitutional, illegal, void ab initio.
8.
The petitioner has also prayed for quashing of the aforesaid Bye
Law No. 14 so far as it includes stilt meant for parking under covered
space. The petitioner has also sought quashing of the assessment order
dated 17th January, 2020, whereby the stilt parking area was included
under the definition of covered space for the purpose of assessment of
property tax.
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page3 of 24
9.
In these petitions, an injunction is sought against the respondent
Corporation from initiating proceedings vide the impugned show-cause
notice dated 11th March, 2020, praying that no coercive action be taken
against it by the respondent or its employees.
10.
The factual matrix leading to the institution of the present writ
petitions is given below:11.
In response to the tender issued by the Delhi Development
Authority (‘DDA’) for construction of multistoreyed parking-cumcommercial complex, the predecessor-in-interest of petitioner no. 1 had
given the highest bid, and in response thereto, the tender was allotted
vide letter dated 23rd October, 2000, to the predecessor-in-interest of
petitioner no.1, being the successful bidder.
12.
After payment of the amount of consideration under the bid, the
partial possession of the plot/site was handed over on 23rd February, 2001
and thereafter, the complete possession of the plot was allotted in favour
of the predecessor-in-interest of petitioner no. 1, vide lease deed dated
30th September, 2003, in respect of which the plan for construction was
sanctioned on 26th August, 2002.
13.
The construction of the building was completed and the
completion certificate was issued on 14th February, 2006.
14.
According to the petitioner, the method of taxation of properties in
Delhi underwent change. It is claimed that Section 116(E) of the DMC
Act is the relevant provision for the “Determination of annual value of
covered space of building and of vacant land", which is also followed
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page4 of 24
with a Property Tax Guide, issued by the Municipal Corporation.
15.
The said property tax guide, according to the petitioner, underwent
change through addendum issued subsequently on 03rd June, 2004.
16.
The petitioner claims that the first property tax return on self-
assessment basis for the year 2006-07 was submitted by the predecessorin-interest of the petitioner, after getting the completion certificate.
17.
The return was filed in regard to the portion owned by the
petitioner company as some portions were transferred to various persons.
According to petitioner, instead of filing returns for the entire building,
the predecessor-in-interest of the petitioner submitted such return for
different floors including the parking areas.
18.
The lease hold rights thereafter got converted into free hold and
such conversion was allowed through conveyance deed dated 23rd
October, 2006 executed in favour of the predecessor-in-interest of the
petitioner no. 1, who became the absolute owner of the property.
19.
Pursuant to the order dated 25th May, 2009 passed by this Court
permitting the de-merger of the property-in-question by vesting it in the
petitioner, petitioner No. 1 became the owner of the property in question
w.e.f. 01st April, 2008 and as such, he started filing property tax returns
from 2009-10 onwards, as the earlier returns were filed by the
predecessor-in-interest of the petitioner no. 1.
20.
DMC sought certain information from the petitioner no. 1 vide
communication dated 06th September, 2010.
21.
It is the case of the petitioner that Section 123B (10) of the Act
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page5 of 24
estopped the respondent/DMC from questioning/challenging the returns
which were filed by the petitioner before the expiry of twelve months
from the issuance of notice dated 11th January, 2011, and since the
returns were submitted well in advance, there was no occasion for the
said returns being reopened or questioned by the respondent-DMC.
22.
After receipt of notice dated 11th January, 2011 from the
respondent-DMC, wherein it was alleged that the self-assessed tax return
for the year 2004-05 to 2009-10 were suffering from discrepancies as the
tax for parking area was not paid, the petitioner entered into a chain of
communications with the respondent-DMC.
23.
Eventually, an additional demand was issued by the respondent no.
1 against the petitioner vide assessment order dated 15th October, 2013.
Vide the said order, respondent no.1 held that the petitioner had willfully
filed the wrong return under self-assessment scheme.
24.
The petitioner, thereafter, preferred a writ petition being W.P. (C)
7305/2013 questioning the order dated 15th October, 2013.
25.
In the aforesaid W.P.(C) 7305/2013 on 22nd November, 2013
following order came to be passed:
“CM No. 15726/2013
Exemption is allowed subject to all just exceptions.
W.P.(C) 7305/2013
Issue notice. Notice is accepted by respondent no.1.
Notice is also accepted by respondent no.3. Notice shall also go to
the respondents who are not present.
Renotify on 24.02.2014.
The counter affidavit be filed within four weeks and the rejoinder
affidavit, if necessary, be filed within four weeks thereafter. In the
meanwhile, without prejudice to its rights and contentions, the
petitioner shall deposit a sum of Rs. 5 crores with the South Delhi
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page6 of 24
Municipal Corporation, within four weeks. On such deposit being
[made no coercive steps be taken in respect of the subject matter of
the writ petition till further orders.”
26.
A similar proceeding was taken out against the petitioner in
relation to the subsequent years, i.e., 2014-15, 2015-16 and 2016-17, on
identical grounds and consequentially, assessment order dated 17th
January, 2020 was passed by respondent no. 1 against the petitioner,
which was forwarded vide communication dated 28th January, 2020,
wherein tax of Rs.10,75,96,636/- including interest of Rs.3,94,97,499/-,
was claimed.
27.
The said demand is being questioned in the writ petition bearing
W.P.(C) 2937/2020.
28.
In the said writ petition, this Hon’ble Court has passed the
following interim order dated 20th March, 2020:
CM No. 10196/2020 (Exemption)
Exemption allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
The application stands disposed of.
W. P. (C) 2937/2020 & CM No. 10195/2020 (for interim orders)
Issue notice.
Ms. Biji Rajesh, learned counsel accepts notice on behalf of the
SDMC/respondent No. 1 and prays for time to file reply.
Let the reply be filed within a period of three weeks from today with
an advance copy to learned counsel for the petitioners, who may
file rejoinder thereto, if any, before the next date of hearing.
Let notice now issue to respondent Nos. 2 & 3, by all permissible
modes, including dasti, on the petitioners taking necessary steps
within a period of one week, returnable on 24th April, 2020.
In the meanwhile, without prejudice to its rights and contentions,
the petitioners shall deposit an aggregate sum of Rs.3 crores, with
the South Delhi Municipal Corporation (SDMC), out of which, a
sum of Rs.1.5 crores shall be deposited by the petitioners by 31st
March, 2020 and the remaining balance amount of Rs.1.5 crores
shall be deposited on or before 15th April, 2020.
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page7 of 24
On such deposit being made, no coercive steps be taken in respect
of the subject matter of the writ petition, till further orders.
List the petition before the Roster Bench on 24th April, 2020, along
with the connected matter being W.P. (C) No. 7305/2013.
29.
In both these petitions, the respondents have resisted the challenge
by filing their counter affidavit and written submissions.
30.
In the meanwhile, the MCD launched a one-time property tax
assessment scheme known as ‘Sumpattikar Niptaan Yojana’, “One Plus
Five” Scheme dated 2nd June, 2025 (hereinafter referred to as the
‘SUNIYO’ scheme). The salient features of which are as under:
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page8 of 24
31.
The scheme was valid upto 31st December, 2025.
32.
For putting quietus to all kinds of property tax disputes, the
petitioner had taken a decision to avail the benefit of the aforesaid
SUNIYO Scheme, and submitted their online self-assessment property
tax returns for the FY 2020-21 to FY 2025-26 along with the proof of
payment of Property Tax during the said period, accompanied with other
relevant documents such as completion plan, occupancy certificate, etc.
33.
The petitioner additionally gave an undertaking to withdraw the
court cases, to avail the benefit of the aforesaid scheme, which includes
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page9 of 24
the present writ petitions.
34.
The petitioner also submitted a request vide letter dated 19th
September, 2025 for assessment of their property known as “Multi-level
Car Parking cum Commercial Complex also known as Eros Corporate
Tower”.
35.
The request moved by the petitioner taking recourse of the
SUNIYO Scheme on 19th September, 2025 reads thus:
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page10 of 24
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page11 of 24
36.
Similarly, the petitioner filed an affidavit giving description of the
aforesaid writ petitions.
37.
A specific undertaking is given by the petitioner to the respondent-
MCD enclosed in the aforesaid affidavit, to withdraw both the writ
petitions from the Court upon grant of the benefits of this scheme.
38.
The said affidavit reads thus:
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page12 of 24
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page13 of 24
39.
In response to the above, the respondent no. 1 vide communication
dated 29th September, 2025 issued an assessment order dated 29th
September, 2025 in respect of the property, “Eros Corporate Tower
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page14 of 24
(Commercial Tower cum Multi-level parking), Nehru Place, New Delhi”.
40.
Vide the said assessment order, the difference of property tax
against the petitioner was worked out to Rs. 11,22,20,837/- for the FY
2020-21 to FY 2025-26 under the SUNIYO Scheme.
41.
The petitioner was requested to pay the said amount by filing self-
assessment property tax return under the SUNIYO Scheme, 2025-26 and
was further requested to make the payment through the online portal.
42.
The petitioner, accordingly, paid the property tax through online
mode under the aforesaid SUNIYO Scheme.
43.
It is the case of the petitioner that all kinds of prior dues of the
petitioner as per the SUNIYO Scheme, in the form of property tax,
interest thereon and/or penalty up till FY 2019-20 in respect of the
premises “Eros Corporate Tower (Commercial Tower cum Multi-level
parking), Nehru Place, New Delhi” stand waived.
44.
As such, the petitioner approached this Court through two
independent applications in the writ petitions with the following prayers:
Prayer in CM APPL. 72169/2025 in W.P.(C) 7305/2013
“PRAYER:
In view of the foregoing, it is most respectfully prayed that this
Hon'ble Court may be pleased to:
a) Allow the present application and permit the Petitioners to
withdraw the present writ petition in light of the SUNIYO Scheme
availed by the Petitioner No. 1 Company; and
Direct the Respondent/SDMC to refund/release the sum of
5,00,00,000/- (Rupees Five Crores only) deposited by the
Petitioners pursuant to order dated 22.11.2013 passed by this
Hon'ble Court in a time bound manner;”
Prayer in CM APPL. 72342/2025 in W.P.(C) 2937/2020
“PRAYER:
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page15 of 24
In view of the foregoing, it is most respectfully prayed that this
Hon'ble Court may be pleased to:
a) Allow the present application and permit the Petitioners to
withdraw the present writ petition in light of the SUNIYO Scheme
availed by the Petitioner No. 1 Company;
and
Direct the Respondent/SDMC to refund/release the sum of.
3,00,00,000/-(Rupees Three Crores only) deposited by the
Petitioners pursuant to order dated 20.03.2020 passed by this
Hon'ble Court in a time bound manner;”
45.
These applications are duly resisted by the respondent through
their replies.
46.
According to the respondent, the petitioner had undertaken to
withdraw the writ petitions unconditionally as could be inferred from the
affidavit reproduced above. The SUNIYO Scheme, under which the
petitioner has taken the benefit, is in the form of policy, and the
discretion vests with the respondent to reject the claim of the petitioner
for grant of waiver under the scheme.
47.
It is submitted that the ground taken in the petitions that the stilt
parking is not liable for the assessment of property tax as the same would
not be included in “covered space”, the challenge to that effect already
stood waived.
48.
The interim relief has been enjoyed by the petitioner for all these
years whereas in absence of there being any interim relief in the matter,
the tax would have stood recovered by this time but for the interim order
of this Court.
49.
In rebuttal, the counsel for the petitioner/applicant relied on the
judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in W.P. (C) 15001/2023,
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page16 of 24
titled as “Vikram Malhotra & Anr. vs. Municipal Corporation of Delhi
& Ors.” decided on 28th August, 2025, wherein this Court had granted
permission to the petitioner therein to withdraw the petition with
direction to grant adjustment for the entire amount of Rs.4,59,154/deposited pursuant to the interim orders of this court and directed to
adjust the amount out of the principal amount to be deposited for the
assessment year under the Scheme.
50.
Through another application, the petitioner has brought on record,
the order of the Apex Court dated 29th May, 2026 passed in SLP (C) No.
19956/2026, titled as “Municipal Corporation of Delhi & Ors. vs.
Vikram Malhotra & Anr.” with the copy of the judgment dated 28th
August, 2025 passed by the Division Bench of this Court in W.P.(C)
15001/2023.
51.
According to him, the judgment in the matter of Vikram
Malhotra(Supra) was questioned by the respondent corporation before
the Apex Court in SLP (C) No. 19956/2026 which came to be dismissed
and thereby, the order dated 28th August, 2025 in the writ petition
no.15001/2023 has attained finality.
52.
According to the counsel for the petitioner the amounts were
deposited under the interim orders, as without prejudice to the rights and
contentions and such deposits were only for the purpose of protecting the
interest of the petitioner.
53.
It is the contention of the petitioner that in the given set of
circumstances, the petitioner is entitled for such interim deposit, as the
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page17 of 24
money belongs to the petitioner.
54.
In view of the fact that the arguments were not canvassed on the
merits of the matter and the prayer is for withdrawal, we have only heard
the matter to the limited extent as regards to the permission to withdraw
the petitions alongwith the directions to the respondents for returning the
amount.
55.
On perusal of the pleadings in the writ petitions and the
applications, referred above, this Court finds that the case of the
petitioner pertains to filing of property tax returns for the FY 2005-2006
to FY 2013-14 and 2014-2015 to FY 2016-17, in regards to a multi-level
car parking cum commercial complex (Eros Corporate Tower).
56.
The challenge is clearly based on the constitutional validity of Bye
Law 14 of the Municipal Corporation (Property Tax) Bye Laws, 2004 in
relation to the levy of property tax being illegal/void and the reliefs
claimed in the petitions were that of injuncting the respondents from
initiating the proceedings for recovery which could be in the form of
attachment of the property and sale of the same.
57.
The pleadings in the petitions clearly depict that the petitioner is in
purely commercial business and is operating multi-level car parking. The
levy of property tax by the respondent-SDMC is an issue which is sought
to be canvassed in the petitions.
58.
In both these writ petitions, there operate interim orders, whereby
it is directed that no coercive steps be taken qua recovery of tax upon
deposit of the amounts so directed.
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page18 of 24
59.
For the years 2005-06 to 2013-14, the demand raised was
Rs.18,61,37,201.60/- (Rupees Eighteen Crores Sixty One Lacs Thirty
Seven Thousands Two Hundred and One and Sixty paisa only) whereas
for the years 2014-15 to 2016-17, the total tax demand was of
Rs.10,75,96,636/- (Rupees Ten Crore Seventy Five Lakhs Ninety Six
Thousands Six Hundred Thirty Six).
60.
The petitioner/applicant has not paid a single penny against the
aforesaid assessed demands which include the interest component, and
has now approached this Court seeking refund of the deposits submitted
under the interim orders of this Court.
61.
The fact remains that from 2004 till 2017, except the amounts
deposited under the ad-interim orders of this court, the petitioner has not
paid any property tax qua the property referred to in the writ petitions.
62.
The petitioner opted for the benefit of the SUNIYO Scheme and
accordingly completed all the formalities.
63.
The petitioner through an application dated 19th September, 2025
has requested the respondents to pass a fresh assessment order for the
years 2020-2026. The petitioner in the said application has undertaken to
furnish a fresh affidavit regarding the withdrawal of the cases, however,
in the said application, the petitioner did not indicate that it will be
seeking withdrawal of the amount which was deposited under the adinterim directions of this Court.
64.
The petitioner thereafter sworn an affidavit on 23rd September,
2025 thereby undertaking to unconditionally withdraw the writ petitions
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page19 of 24
from the High Court. The prayer in these applications, to the extent of
seeking directions for refund of the amount, was not at all brought to the
notice of the respondents.
65.
As a sequel of the above, the petitioner had undertaken before the
respondent thereby giving an impression that the petitioner would
simpliciter withdraw the writ petitions and would not be seek refund of
the amounts deposited pursuant to the interim orders in both these writ
petitions.
66.
The petitioner thereafter had drawn the benefit under the Scheme,
as the respondents issued the assessment order for the year 2020-2026
and raised tax to the tune of Rs.11,22,20,837/- (Eleven Crores Twenty
Two Lakhs Twenty Thousands Eight Hundred Thirty Seven) which was
duly paid by the petitioner to the respondent.
67.
As a sequitur, the petitioner has accepted his liability qua the
payment of property tax under the SUNIYO Scheme for the years 20202026, and has also further accepted that the property in regard to which
he is lodging resistance through these writ petitions, is amenable to the
assessment for levying the property tax.
68.
The consequence of above is that the petitioner, by paying the
taxes for the period from 2020-2026 under the assessment order, has
accepted that provision, which is being questioned in these petitions, is
valid and constitutional.
69.
In the aforesaid background, if we appreciate the very conduct of
the petitioner in both of these writ petitions, the first writ petition was
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page20 of 24
initiated in 2013 which contains the challenge for levy of property taxes
from 2005 whereas another writ petition was initiated in 2020 wherein
the challenge is for levy of property taxes from 2014.
70.
From the aforesaid conduct, what can be construed about the
conduct of the petitioner is that by depositing about 1/4th of the amount
i.e., Rupees Eight Crores against the total liability, the petitioner enjoyed
interim relief in the first petition for 13 years, and about 06 years in the
second petition.
71.
The writ petitions are now sought to be withdrawn by the
petitioner with a condition that the directions be issued to the respondents
to refund the amount deposited by him under the interim orders of the
court.
72.
The petitioner has claimed that the deposit was without prejudice
to his rights in the petition. To that extent the petitioner is right in
contending that the deposit was without prejudice to his rights in the
petitions. However, in case, the petitions would have been decided on
merits and the same would have been allowed, the petitioner would have
been entitled for the refund but not on the withdrawal of the petition.
73.
The petitioner, as such, is trying to take the advantage of keeping
the writ petitions pending for years altogether and is seeking an
unreasonable order of issuance of directions to the respondents to refund
the amount deposited by him under the ad interim orders of this Court. If
so granted, not only the same will be against the public interest but also
the same will amount to the petitioner enjoying the privileges which
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page21 of 24
otherwise are not entitled in law.
74.
There is one more facet to the matter viz., the petitioner claims that
the issue sought to be canvassed by him qua the refund of the amount is
covered by the judgment in the matter of Vikram Malhotra & Anr.
(Supra) which was affirmed by the Apex Court.
75.
In our opinion, the case in the matter of Vikram Malhotra & Anr.
(Supra) is distinguishable on certain important issues:
a) In the case of Vikram Malhotra & Anr. (Supra), though the issue
of property tax assessment was involved, the petitioner therein
sought adjustment of the interim amounts deposited, before the
SUNIYO scheme was extended in his favour.
76.
In the case in hand, the petitioner has already deposited the amount
in its entirety under the SUNIYO scheme and is now seeking the benefit
to the extent of directions for refund of the amount, through the
applications preferred.
77.
Once the petitioner has drawn the benefits under the scheme, in
our opinion, this scheme does not postulate the refund of the amount
which is already deposited with the respondents, may it be under the
orders of the court towards the tax liability.
78.
The pendency of the writ petitions, for quite a long time, at the
behest of the petitioner is sought to be utilized by the petitioner
unreasonably to his benefit after taking the benefits under the SUNIYO
Scheme and after accepting his liability to pay the property tax under the
scheme.
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page22 of 24
79.
It is not the case of the petitioner herein that he is asking for
adjustment of the interim deposits, rather the petitioner is seeking the
refund of the same.
80.
In case, if the prayer of the petitioner for refund is granted, the
same will result into modifying the clauses of the scheme in the favour of
the petitioner, which in our opinion is not permissible in law.
81.
Otherwise also, it is not open for the petitioner to seek an order
contrary to the scheme by seeking refund of the amount once having
accepted the benefits of the Scheme and after depositing the amount qua
the assessment order for the period from 2020-2026.
82.
Even otherwise, whenever an amnesty scheme is launched, the
same is in realm of policy.
83.
Such relief as prayed by the petitioner, if granted, will go contrary
to the Amnesty Scheme, under which the petitioner has drawn the benefit
of waiver of past tax liabilities. The amnesty scheme floated by the
respondents is in the form of policy. If the respondents are directed to
refund the amount, deposited by the petitioner towards the interim
discharge of his liability to pay the property tax, the same would be in
violation of the policy of the Amnesty Scheme, which is not permissible
in law.
84.
For the aforesaid reasons, we are of the view that the amounts
which were deposited under the interim orders dated 22nd November,
2023 and 28th March, 2020 in both the writ petitions, to the extent of
Rupees Five Crores and Rupees Three Crores, respectively, cannot be
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page23 of 24
directed to be refunded to the petitioner.
85.
As such, we reject the said prayer of the petitioner.
86.
However, the petitioner having drawn the benefits of the SUNIYO
scheme has undertaken to withdraw the present writ petitions, we dismiss
both these writ petitions as withdrawn.
87.
Pending applications, if any, also stands disposed of.
88.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
(JUDGE)
AJAY DIGPAUL
(JUDGE)
AUGUST 19, 2026/dm/sky/gs
Signed By:SURYAKANT
YADAV
19:17:45
W.P (C) 7305/2013 & W.P (C) 2937/2020
Page24 of 24
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review