Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
(2026:JHHC:16728)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
C.M.P. No.1088 of 2025
-----Neha Kumari, aged about 32 years, wife of Vijay Anand and
daughter of Vijay Kumar, resident of Muhalla Upper Rajbari Road,
M/s. Madhu Traders, Jharia, P.O. and P.S. Jharia, District Dhanbad,
Jharkhand
…
Petitioner
Versus
Vijay Anand son of Arjun Modi, resident of Addi Bunglow Road,
Jhumri Telaiya, P.O. and P.S. Telaiya, District Koderma, Jharkhand.
…
For the Petitioner
For the Opp. Party
Opposite Party
-----: Md. Zaid Ahmed, Advocate
: Mr. Abhay Prakash, Advocate
-----PRESENT
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR CHOUDHARY
By the Court:2.
Heard the parties.
This Civil Miscellaneous Petition has been filed invoking the
jurisdiction of this Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
with the prayer to quash the order dated 18.08.2025 passed by learned
Principal Judge, Family Court, Dhanbad in O.S. Case No.249 of 2023 by
which learned Principal Judge has allowed the petition dated 02.08.2025
filed by the plaintiff of the said case; who is the opposite party herein
for accepting his evidence, after settlement of issues, as additional
evidence and prayer for consequential reliefs has also been made in this
civil miscellaneous petition.
C.M.P. No.1088 of 2025
(2026:JHHC:16728)
3.
The brief fact of the case is that the defendant of the said O.S.
Case No.249 of 2023 who is the petitioner herein, was set ex parte in the
said case consequent upon failure of her to file the written-statement.
When the case was fixed for ex parte evidence, the plaintiff filed the
examination-in-chief
in
shape
of
affidavit
of
two
witnesses.
Subsequently, the said ex parte order was recalled. The defendantpetitioner filed her written-statement and issues were settled. After
settlement of the issues, the plaintiff filed a fresh affidavit to be treated
as his examination-in-chief and the plaintiff filed a petition to expunge
his previous examination-in-chief which was made during the ex parte
hearing of the case. The Family Court vide order dated 20.01.2025
expunged the said examination-in-chief on affidavit, which was made
during the ex parte hearing of the case. The defendant/petitioner filed
C.M.P. No.319 of 2025 in this Court and vide order dated 16.07.2025, a
co-ordinate Bench of this Court set aside the said order dated 20.01.2025
passed by learned Additional Principal Judge, Additional Family Court
No-II, Dhanbad in the said case and remitted the matter back to learned
court for further proceeding in accordance with law and restored the
examination-in-chief which was filed in shape of affidavit during the ex
parte hearing of the matter.
4.
The
learned
Family
Court
considered
that
the
earlier
examination-in-chief filed in shape of affidavit dated 17.12.2022
consisted of six (6) pages but the subsequent affidavit in shape of
C.M.P. No.1088 of 2025
(2026:JHHC:16728)
examination-in-chief dated 03.08.2024 consisted ten (10) pages. In the
said affidavit dated 03.08.2024, there was repetition of the previous
evidence which was mentioned in the said affidavit dated 17.12.2022. So
in order to avoid the repetition of the evidence in the earlier affidavit in
the subsequent affidavit, learned Principal Judge, Family Court,
Dhanbad ordered in the interest of justice and for the just decision of
the case that only paragraphs-10 and 11, second part of paragraph-20,
paragraphs-23 to 28 and paragraphs-30 to 33 will be treated as
additional evidence/supplementary affidavit of evidence and the rest
paragraphs of examination-in-chief filed in shape of affidavit dated
03.08.2024 was expunged because of repetition of the facts which was
already existing in the examination-in-chief in shape of affidavit dated
17.12.2022 and directed the plaintiff to renumber paragraphs-10 and 11,
second part of paragraph-20, paragraphs-23 to 28 and paragraphs-30 to
33 of the examination-in-chief filed in shape of affidavit dated
03.08.2024 to be in continuation from paragraph-1 of the earlier
affidavit.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the opposite party
has already filed his examination-in-chief in shape of affidavit on
17.12.2022, his subsequent filing of further examination-in-chief in
shape of affidavit cannot be permitted more so when the examinationin-chief filed in shape of affidavit dated 03.08.2024, fresh evidence is not
permissible in law. Hence, the impugned order dated 18.08.2025 is
C.M.P. No.1088 of 2025
(2026:JHHC:16728)
unjustified and untenable in law as a witness cannot be permitted to get
himself examined in examination-in-chief twice in a case and two
evidences of the same person in the same case are not permissible in
law. It is further submitted that the defendant-petitioner cannot be
directed by the Family Court to cross-examine his witnesses in respect
of the subsequent evidence of the plaintiff filed in shape of
examination-in-chief by way of affidavit. Hence, it is submitted that the
prayer, as prayed for in the instant C.M.P., be allowed.
6.
Learned counsel for the opposite party on the other hand
vehemently opposes the prayer of the petitioner made in the instant
C.M.P. and submits that the Family Court Act is a self-contained code.
Section 10 (3) of the Family Court Act empowers a Family Court for
laying down its own procedure with a view to arrive at a settlement in
respect of the subject-matter of the suit or proceedings or at the truth of
the facts alleged by the one party and denied by the other. It is next
submitted that Section 14 of the Family Courts Act, empowers a Family
Court to receive as evidence any report, statement, documents,
information or matter that may, in its opinion, assist it to deal
effectually with a dispute, whether or not the same would be otherwise
relevant or admissible under the Indian Evidence Act which goes to
show that the provisions of Indian Evidence Act is not strictly
applicable to the proceedings before the Family Court. In support of his
contention, learned counsel for the opposite party relies upon the
C.M.P. No.1088 of 2025
(2026:JHHC:16728)
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Vibhor
Garg vs. Neha reported in 2025 INSC 829 paragraph-10.2 of which
reads as under:“10.2. Section 14 of the FC Act gives a wide discretion to the
Family Courts in deciding matrimonial disputes since they can go
beyond the strict rules of evidence in terms of relevance and
admissibility while admitting any evidence which they think is
relevant for the adjudication of the dispute at hand. However, we
do not think that adverting to Section 14 of the FC Act is required
in the present facts when the Evidence Act itself permits such a
communication to be admitted in evidence by way of an exception.
The powers under Section 14 of the FC Act would normally be
resorted to in a scenario where the Evidence Act creates some
prohibition with respect to the relevance or admissibility of any
evidence. But if the Family Court is of the opinion that it is
expedient to go beyond the procedural technicalities of the
Evidence Act for adjudicating the dispute, in such a case, the
Family Court is allowed to take that evidence on record,
notwithstanding what is stated in the Evidence Act. But the
exercise of this extraordinary power under Section 14 of the FC
Act is not warranted in this case.”
7.
It is next submitted that the undisputed fact remains that initially
the defendant/petitioner herein was set ex parte. There was no writtenstatement filed on behalf of the defendant when the plaintiff filed his
examination-in-chief in shape of affidavit on 17.12.2022. After filing of
the written-statement by the defendant and settlement of the issues,
obviously new facts were introduced and to meet the same it was
incumbent upon the plaintiff to put forth some additional evidence.
Under such circumstances, the plaintiff ought to have been given an
opportunity to adduce additional evidence and rightly so, the plaintiff
has been given such an opportunity. The only anomaly is that instead of
the plaintiff mentioning his additional evidence in continuation to the
C.M.P. No.1088 of 2025
(2026:JHHC:16728)
paragraphs of the evidence which was already on record, the plaintiff
filed the examination-in-chief in shape of affidavit dated 03.08.2024 also
incorporating the earlier evidence which was already on record under
the impression that the earlier one can be expunged and the subsequent
affidavit will be the sole affidavit but the same did not find favour with
this Court and the co-ordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated
16.07.2025 passed in C.M.P. No.319 of 2025 ordered that the earlier
examination-in-chief filed in shape of affidavit will remain intact. Under
such circumstances, the only option left for the Family Court was to
expunge the paragraphs which were repeated in the subsequent
affidavit filed in shape of examination-in-chief dated 03.08.2024 which
was already mentioned in the earlier examination in chief filed in shape
of affidavit dated 17.12.2022. It is next submitted that it is a settled
principle of law that a Court is having inherent power in respect of the
case records of a court concerned and Family Court has been vested
with the additional power of laying down its own procedure as well,
under Section 10 (3) of the Family Courts Act. Under such
circumstances, no illegality has been committed by learned Principal
Judge, Family Court in passing the impugned order. Therefore, it is
submitted that this C.M.P., being without any merit, be dismissed.
8.
Having heard the rival submissions made at the Bar and after
carefully going through the materials available in the record, it is
pertinent to mention here that the undisputed fact remains that the
C.M.P. No.1088 of 2025
(2026:JHHC:16728)
defendant was first set ex parte when the case was pending in the court
of Family Court, Koderma. The defendants filed a transfer petition in
this Court and subsequently, the case which was originally numbered
as O.S. No.82 of 2022, was transferred to the Family Court, Dhanbad
and was renumbered as O.S. No.249 of 2023. Thereafter, the ex parte
order was recalled. The defendant was given opportunity to file the
written-statement. She filed her written-statement. Subsequently, the
issues were settled. So, under such circumstances, a right was also
accrued to the plaintiff to adduce additional evidence in order to meet
the averments made by the defendant in her written-statement. Hence,
consequent upon the opportunity being given to the defendant to file
her written-statement, the plaintiff was entitled to adduce further
evidence by way of further examination-in-chief of the plaintiff as well
as his witnesses who were already examined, when the proceeding was
going on ex parte and there was no written-statement in record filed on
behalf of the defendant, on recall. The evidence in a Civil Court because
of the amendment in the procedural law can be recorded by accepting
inter alia examination-in-chief in shape of affidavit. When earlier the
examination-in-chiefs were recorded in the Court by the presiding
officer of the courts concerned, the procedure was when any ex parte
order was recalled and the defendant is given an opportunity to file the
written-statement then the plaintiffs were also permitted to adduce
further evidence in shape of further examination-in-chief by recalling
C.M.P. No.1088 of 2025
(2026:JHHC:16728)
the witnesses. Now, in the present set up since the examination-in-chief
is being permitted to be filed in shape of affidavits, the appropriate
procedure for recalling a witness for his further cross-examination is by
filing a subsequent affidavit which is to be treated as further
examination-in-chief on recall of the witness and that has exactly been
done but the anomaly is that in the subsequent examination-in-chief,
instead of numbering the paragraphs in continuation of the earlier
examination-in-chief which was filed in shape of affidavit when the
case was running ex parte, a new number has been assigned to the
paragraphs of the affidavit starting from Number-1 in the subsequent
affidavit and some repetition has also been made which were already
there in the earlier affidavit which was filed in examination-in-chief
dated 17.12.2022. The same has been set at right by learned Principal
Judge, Family Court by expunging the paragraphs which were repeated
and which were earlier existing in the said affidavit dated 17.12.2022
and also numbering the paragraphs in continuation. This in the
considered opinion of this Court cannot be termed as recording of
evidence of the plaintiff or his witness twice as contended by the
petitioner.
9.
It is needless to mention that the plaintiff some of whose
paragraphs in the said affidavit dated 03.08.2024 has been expunged,
has no grievance. There is no rhyme or reason why the defendant can
have any grievance against expunging of some of the paragraphs of an
C.M.P. No.1088 of 2025
(2026:JHHC:16728)
affidavit filed in shape of examination-in-chief by the plaintiff which is
of course, a further examination in chief of the plaintiff on recall as a
witness.
10.
Therefore, this Court do not find any illegality in the impugned
order dated 18.08.2025 passed by learned Principal Judge, Family Court,
Dhanbad in O.S. Case No.249 of 2023 warranting interference of this
Court in exercise of its power under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India.
11.
Accordingly, this Civil Miscellaneous Petition, being without any
merit, is dismissed.
12.
In view of disposal of the instant Civil Miscellaneous Petition, the
interim order dated 15.01.2026, is vacated.
13.
Registry is directed to intimate the Court concerned forthwith.
14.
Let a copy of this judgment along with the Lower Court Records
be sent back to the Court concerned by the Registry.
(Anil Kumar Choudhary, J.)
High Court of Jharkhand, Ranchi
Dated the 10th of June, 2026
AFR/ Animesh
Uploaded on- 12/06/2026
C.M.P. No.1088 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review