Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 19thFebruary 2026
+
MAC.APP. 624/2015
NEERU DEVI & ORS
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. Pankaj Gupta & Mr. Vikas
Kumar, Advs.
versus
NARENDER YADAV & ORS (NATIONAL INSURANCE CO
LTD)
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Archana Gaur, Adv. for
Insurance Co.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed seeking enhancement of the impugned
award dated 9th April 2015 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Karkadooma Courts, East District, Delhi [“Tribunal”] in MACP No.
249/2012, whereby compensation of Rs.14,18,100/- was awarded along with
the interest of 9% per annum to the representative of the deceased, Ms. Payal
Srivastava [appellant nos. 1 to 3 herein]
Incident
2.
Accident occurred on 19th September 2012, at about 10 p.m. near red
light signal of Ashok Niketan, Anand Vihar, when Ms. Payal Srivastava and
Mr. Dushyant Kumar [deceased] were travelling on a scooter. An HGV
container, make Ashok Leyland, bearing registration no. HR- 38J-6095
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 624/2015
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:12:11
[offending vehicle] driven by respondent no.1 [driver] at a high speed in a
zigzag manner, hit the scooter. Both sustained injuries and were taken to Dr.
Hedgewar Hospital, where they were declared “brought dead”. FIR No.
259/2012 was registered under Sections 279/304A of the Indian Penal Code
1806, at Police Station Anand Vihar. A claim petition was filed, and the
Tribunal found that the accident had occurred due to rash and negligent
driving of respondent no.1 of vehicle which was owned by respondent no.2
and insured by respondent no. 3.
Impugned Award
3.
The Tribunal, while adjudicating the claim petitions, returned a
finding of negligence against respondent no.1/driver of the offending
vehicle on the basis of the eye-witness testimony, criminal case record
including FIR and chargesheet, site plan, and mechanical inspection report.
4.
The Tribunal held that these materials sufficiently established rash
and negligent driving on the touchstone of preponderance of probabilities.
Consequently, the respondent no.1/driver, respondent no.2/owner and
respondent no.3/insurer of the offending vehicle were held jointly and
severally liable to satisfy the award.
5.
For the purpose of computing compensation in the claim concerning
the deceased Ms. Payal Srivastava, the Tribunal relied upon documentary
evidence proved through the employer’s witness, including the appointment
letter, salary record and attendance register, to assess her income. The
Tribunal considered the gross salary but, after deductions, treated the
monthly income as Rs. 16,450/-. Since the deceased was unmarried, 50% of
the income was deducted towards personal and living expenses. The
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 624/2015
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:12:11
multiplier was applied with reference to the age of the mother, treating her
as the dependent, and no addition towards future prospects was granted,
following the precedents considered applicable at the time.
Compensation Granted
6.
On the basis of above assessment, the Tribunal computed loss of
dependency and awarded compensation under conventional heads. A total
sum of Rs. 14,18,100/- was awarded, comprising Rs. 12,83,100/- towards
loss of dependency, Rs. 1,00,000/- towards loss of love and affection, Rs.
25,000/- towards funeral expenses, and Rs. 10,000/- towards loss of estate,
together with interest @ 9% per annum from the date of filing of the claim
petition till realization. The compensation awarded by the Tribunal is
summarised as under:
S.NO.
HEADS
AMOUNT AWARDED
1.
Loss of dependency
Rs.12,83,100/-
2.
Loss of love and affection
Rs. 1,00,000/-
3.
Funeral Expenses
Rs.25,000/-
4.
Loss of Estate
Rs.10,000/-
TOTAL
Rs.14,18,100/-
INTEREST
9%
Analysis
7.
Mr. Pankaj Gutpa, counsel for appellants, seeks enhancement on the
following grounds:
i)
Firstly, the benchmark income/salary of the deceased was not
considered correctly, inasmuch as while the salary slip showed that she
working as a “Customer Relationship Manager” with M/s Shiv Auto
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 624/2015
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:12:11
Cars Pvt. Ltd. and was earning Rs 18,500/- per month, the Tribunal
deducted the allowances and took the salary as Rs.16,450/- per month.
The discussion in this regard is contained in paragraph 23 of the
impugned order, which extracted as under:
“23.The PW3/ Sh. Harit Sandal, HR Executive,
from Shiva Auto Car (India) Pvt. Ltd., has proved
the Appointment Letter, Salary Breakup, Salary
Record, Wages Register, and Attendance Sheet of
deceased as Ex. PW3/B, which shows the deceased
was getting salary of Rs. 18,500/- p.m. In view of the
judgments in Manasvi Jain V/s. DTC II (2014) ACC
420 (SC) and another judgement of Hon'ble Apex
Court in Shyamwati Sharma Ors. V/s. Karam Singh
&Ors. F(2010) SLT 328, after necessary deductions
it comes to Rs. 16,450/- p.m. As per the Appointment
Letter Ex PWl/1, Deceased was working as a
Customer Relationship Manager, having appointed
on 06.03.2012 in Shiva Auto Car Ltd. She was still
in her probation period.”
ii)
Sh. Harit Sandal [PW-3], HR (Executive), proved the
appointment letter, appraisal data, salary breakup, salary record, wages
register and attendance sheet. The salary breakup shows that the gross
salary was Rs 18,500/- per month, which included the basic pay of
Rs.11,100/-, HRA of Rs.5,350/- and conveyance allowance of Rs.800/.
The Tribunal deducted Rs. 2,000/- from the gross salary on an
unexplained basis and considered the benchmark income has Rs.
16,450/- per month.
iii)
Mr. Pankaj Gupta, counsel for appellant on this aspect has
relied upon the following Supreme Court judgments:
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 624/2015
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:12:11
a.
Kavita Devi & Ors. v. Sunil Kumar & Anr. 2025 INSC 938,
the Supreme Court enhanced compensation by re-examining the
income of the deceased and drawing guidance from National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Indira Srivastava (2008) 2 SCC 763 on the
meaning of “just compensation” and “income”. The Supreme Court
emphasized that income is not limited to the pay packet carried home
by an employee but may include allowances forming part of the salary
structure. The Court held that allowances regularly received and used
for the benefit of the family must be considered while determining
dependency, subject to proof and the facts of each case. Relevant
paragraph is extracted as under:
“17. This Court has consistently held in case of the
allowances which are included in the component of
salary of the deceased, Tribunal has to take into
consideration these allowances as they were used
for supporting the family. The claimants have to
show that these allowances were regularly received
and used for the family’s benefit. Further, while
determining whether the allowances form a part of
the salary or not, the Tribunal by looking into the
facts of each case and by considering the extent of
dependency of the claimants on the salary of the
deceased including the allowances, have to
determine whether these allowances should be
excluded from determination of the income of the
deceased. If the answer of the Tribunal is in
affirmative, then the allowances may be excluded
for determination of loss of dependency. If the
Tribunal answers the above point in negative, then
the Tribunal has to include the allowances for
computation of income of the deceased, thus
determining the loss of dependency.”
(emphasis added)
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 624/2015
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:12:11
b.
Manorma Sinha & Anr. v. The Divisional Manager, Oriental
Insurance Company Ltd & Anr 2025 INSC 1237, wherein the
Supreme Court held income includes monetary and non-monetary
benefits beneficial to the family, irrespective of their taxable status, and
that exclusion of allowances would be erroneous. Relevant paragraph
is extracted as under:
“12. Now, the next question is whether allowances
are to be added to the salary for determining the
multiplicand. In National Insurance Co. Ltd. v.
Indira Srivastava & Ors. (2008) 2 SCC 763, it was
held that “the term income has different
connotations for different purposes. A court of law,
having regard to the change in societal conditions
consider the question not only having regard to pay
packet the employee carries home at the end of the
month but also other perks which are beneficial to
the members of the entire family”. In Vijay Kumar
Rastogi v. Uttar Pradesh State Roadways
Transport Corporation [2018 SCC OnLine SC 193
paragraph 11] a three-Judge Bench of this court
noticing earlier decisions on the point observed that
“the income should include those benefits, either in
terms of money or otherwise, which are taken into
consideration for the purpose of payment of income
tax or professional tax, although some elements
thereof may not be taxable due to exemption
conferred thereupon under the statute.” Following
the decision in Vijay Kumar Rastogi (supra) in
National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Nalini & Ors.
[2024 SCC OnLine SC 2252], it was held by this
Court that the emoluments and the benefits accruing
to the deceased under various heads for the
purposes of computation of loss of income, ought to
be included irrespective of whether they are taxable
or not. Thus, in our view, the High Court erred in
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 624/2015
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:12:11
excluding the allowances from the computation to
arrive at the multiplicand. Hence, the total monthly
income was rightly computed by the Tribunal at
Rs.53,367.”
(emphasis added)
iv)
In light of the above and in view of the decisions of the
Supreme Court, there can be no dispute that the salary has to be taken
as Rs.18,500/-, including allowances.
v)
Secondly, as regards future prospects, it is pointed out that the
deceased was 28 years of age at the time of accident, and, therefore,
40% future prospects ought to have been added, in alignment with the
principles enunciated in National Insurance Company Limited v.
Pranay Sethi & Ors. (2017) 16 SCC 680.
vi)
Thirdly, the multiplier of ‘13’ was applied by the Tribunal
based on the age of the mother, which practice now stands disapproved
by the Supreme Court as per paragraph 59.7 of National Insurance
Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi & Ors. (supra), and the multiplier
has to be considered as per the age of deceased, which would be ‘17’.
Relevant paragraph is extracted as under:
“59. In view of the aforesaid analysis, we proceed
to record our conclusion.
………
59.7. The age of the deceased should be the basis
for applying the multiplier.”
vii)
Fourthly, no amount towards loss of consortium was granted,
which ought to be Rs.80,000/- on account of two parents. [Rs 40,000/X 2], loss of estate should be Rs.15,000/-; funeral expenses should be
Rs.15,000/- as per principles stated in National Insurance Company
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 624/2015
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:12:11
Limited v. Pranay Sethi & Ors. (supra)
8.
Ms. Archana Gaur, counsel for insurance company/respondent no.3
has argued on the issue the salary and the allowances. However, considering
the recent decision of Supreme Court, this Court is not in a position to accept
the plea.
9.
Accordingly, the appeal is allowed.
10.
As per above assessment, following is the revised computation of
compensation:
S.
Heads
No.
Income of deceased (A)
Awarded by
Awarded by this
the Tribunal
Court
Rs.16,450 /-
Rs. 18,500/-
(less Income Tax)
Add Future Prospects (B)
Nil
40%
Less Personal expenses of
50%
50%
Rs. 8,225/-
Rs. 12,950/-
Rs.98,700 /-
Rs.1,55,400 /-
the deceased (C)
Monthly loss of dependency
[(A +B)-C = D]
Annual loss of dependency
(D x12)
Multiplier (E)
Total loss of dependency
Rs. 12,83,100/-
Rs.27,97,200 /-
(D x E = F)
Medical expenses (G)
Nil
Nil
Compensation for loss of
Nil
Rs. 80,000/-
Rs.1,00,000 /-
Nil
Rs.10,000 /-
Rs.15,000 /-
consortium (H) (40,000 x 2 )
Compensation for loss of
love and affection (I)
Compensation for loss of
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 624/2015
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:12:11
estate (J)
Compensation towards
Rs. 25,000/-
Rs.15,000 /-
Rs. 14,18,100/-
Rs.29,07,200 /-
9%
9%
funeral expenses (K)
TOTAL COMPENSATION
(F+G+H+I+J+K = L)
RATE OF INTEREST AWARDED
Conclusion
11.
For the aforesaid reasons, the impugned award is modified. The
compensation is enhanced by a sum of Rs. 14,89,100/-, as computed
hereinabove.
12.
Enhanced amount of compensation along with interest at the rate of
9% from the date of filing of petition shall be deposited by respondent
no.3/Insurance Company before the Tribunal within 4 weeks.
13.
Enhanced compensation shall be kept in Fixed Deposit Receipts
(FDRs) of Rs. 25,000/- each for periods of 1 month, 2 months, 3 months and
so on, in succession as may be calculated. Interest accrued on the FDRs shall
be credited to the designated Savings Bank Accounts of the LRs. Upon
maturity of the FDRs, the principal amount shall also be transferred to their
respective Savings Bank Accounts.
14.
Copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned Tribunal.
15.
Appeal stands allowed and disposed of.
16.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
17.
Statutory deposit (if any) shall be refunded to appellant.
18.
Judgement be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL, J
FEBRUARY 19, 2026/sm/tk
Signature Not Verified MAC.APP. 624/2015
Digitally Signed
By:MANISH KUMAR
18:12:11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review