Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
SPECIAL APPEAL No. - 1223 of 2026
Neeraj Kumar
.....Appellant(s)
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s)
Counsel for Respondent(s)
: Prabhakar Awasthi (Sr. Advocate),
Deepankar Nath Tripathi, Nitin Sharma
: C.S.C., R.K. Ojha (Sr. Advocate),
Shyam Sunder
Chief Justice's Court
HON'BLE ARUN BHANSALI, CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE KSHITIJ SHAILENDRA, J.
1. Heard Shri Prabhakar Awasthi, learned Senior Counsel, assisted by
Shri Nitin Sharma and Shri Deepankar Nath Tripathi for the appellant,
learned Standing Counsel for respondents no. 1, 2 and 3 and Shri R.K.
Ojha, learned Senior Counsel, assisted by Shri Shyam Sunder for
respondents no. 4 and 5.
2. This intra court appeal is directed against order dated 21.09.2026,
whereby learned Single Judge has disposed of Writ-C No. 36339 of 2026
filed by respondents no. 4 and 5 (‘the respondents’), setting aside the
order dated 12.08.2026 passed by the Regional Level Committee (‘RLC’)
and remanding the matter to it with liberty to the parties to file documents
in support of their stand so as to facilitate a fresh consideration by the
RLC on all the issues raised.
3. Brief facts of the case are that the elections of the Committee of
Management of Shyam Singh Inter College, Bilsuri, District Bulandshahr
were held on 26.03.2019 in which the appellant was elected as President
and one Urmila Devi as Manager. The term of the Committee being
admittedly of five years, the same came to an end in June, 2024. The
Manager-Urmila Devi sent a list of members of General body to the Joint
Director of Education, Meerut Division, Meerut on 12.04.2024 in terms of
Clause 9(3) of the Scheme of Administration indicating that the term of
the Committee was going to expire on 22.06.2024.
SPLA No. 1223 of 2026
4. Thereafter, an agenda was issued on 29.04.2024 under the signatures of
Manager-Urmila Devi and President-Neeraj Kumar (the appellant herein)
indicating six agenda-issues for consideration, in pursuance whereof a
meeting was held on 12.05.2024 wherein decision on all the agendaissues was taken and 15.06.2024 was notified as the date of next
elections. Elections were, accordingly, held on 15.06.2024 in which the
respondent-Committee was elected.
5. The matter was agitated by the appellant before the RLC raising
challenge to the elections on various grounds. The RLC passed the order
dated 12.08.2026 invalidating the elections dated 15.06.2024 with a
direction to the District Inspector of Schools, Bulandshahr (‘DIOS’) to
ensure holding of fresh elections in accordance with the approved Scheme
of Administration.
6. The respondents challenged the order dated 12.08.2026 by filing the
writ petition giving rise to this appeal. The writ petition was heard on
11.09.2026 and judgment was reserved, which was delivered on
21.09.2026. Learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition in terms
already indicated herein-before.
7. Assailing the order passed by the learned Single Judge, learned Senior
Counsel has submitted that the writ petition has been allowed without
inviting counter affidavit from the appellant and, therefore, the appellant
having been deprived of having his say in the matter, the order passed by
the learned Single Judge deserves to be set aside on this ground alone.
8. It is further contended that the order passed by the learned Single Judge
is substantially based upon Clause 9(2) of the Scheme of Administration
in ignorance of sub-clause (3) thereof, which provides that list of
members of General body would be declared two months prior to expiry
of the term of the elected body and five copies of the said list would be
sent to the DIOS and one copy to Regional Joint Director. It is further
contended that once, on 12.04.2024, a list of members of General body
was already sent by the Manager, there was no justification for the
respondents to hold another meeting on 12.05.2024 and take a decision to
enroll new members which were surreptitiously enrolled in the said
meeting and based thereupon, elections were held on 15.06.2024, which,
SPLA No. 1223 of 2026
being contrary to the stipulations contained in the Scheme, are ex facie
illegal.
9. It is further contended that the agenda dated 29.04.2024 not only
contained forged signatures of the appellant, the same were also forged in
the meeting held on 12.05.2024 although neither the appellant had signed
the agenda nor did he participate in the meeting and the entire
proceedings having been surreptitiously held in a clandestine manner, the
consequential elections were liable to be discarded, however, the learned
Single Judge has not given a thoughtful consideration to the submissions
advanced on behalf of the appellant.
10. It is further submitted that one Kusum Devi is also said to have
participated in the elections held on 15.06.2024, however, she also did not
participate therein and submitted her affidavit dated 19.03.2025 before the
DIOS to that effect and all these aspects having been raised before the
RLC and considered by it, the order passed by it was perfectly in
accordance with law and required no interference by the learned Single
Judge.
11. It is further contended that no prejudice would be caused to the
respondents if fresh elections are held in accordance with the stipulations
contained in the Scheme of Administration and, therefore, irrespective of
the fact that the Committee elected pursuant to the elections dated
15.06.2024 has functioned for more than two years, the same would be of
no significance as far as the merits and effect of the order passed by the
RLC are concerned.
12. Learned Standing Counsel has supported the order impugned and
submissions have been made that the parties would have ample
opportunity to have their say before the RLC pursuant to the order passed
by the learned Single Judge and, therefore, no interference is warranted in
the order of the writ court.
13. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the private respondents has
made submissions that out of 301 members of the General body, 199
members had participated in the elections held on 15.06.2024 and even if
42 members enrolled in the meeting held on 12.05.2024 are excluded,
SPLA No. 1223 of 2026
participating members would be 157 and since only 17 votes were cast in
favour of the appellant, the election result would not at all be affected
and, for this reason, no interference is required in the elections or their
result.
14. It is further submitted that the appellant had, in fact, participated in the
elections and after facing defeat therein, he did not agitate any grievance
but came up with his objections after a long period of six months and
though the matter remained pending before RLC for a considerable period
of time, no effort was ever made by the appellant to get the matter
decided and, therefore, it is a case where the objections raised by the
appellant were merely an afterthought having no substance therein.
15. It is further contended that the finding recorded by the RLC to the
effect that the list of members of general body finalized on 12.05.2024
was not approved, was contrary to the stipulations contained in the
Scheme, wherein there is no requirement of according approval to the list
and once it was sent to the authorities in terms of Clause 9(3) of the
Scheme, the same was sufficient for holding elections, which were held in
accordance with law.
16. It is lastly contended that the matter having been remanded by the
learned Single Judge, it is open for the appellant to have his say before the
RLC, which is under obligation to decide the rival contentions by passing
a fresh order in terms of the order passed by the learned Single Judge and,
therefore, no interference is warranted in the order passed by the writ
court.
17. We have considered the submissions made and have perused the
material available on record.
18. A perusal of the order dated 12.08.2026 passed by the RLC indicates
that the contentions raised by the appellant as well as private respondents
and also the report submitted by the DIOS were discussed in the order and
the elections held on 15.06.2024 were nullified/dislodged mainly on the
ground that no approval was accorded to the list of members of the
General body after enrolling 42 new members and, therefore, the said list
was invalid. The RLC also reproduced various clauses of the Scheme of
SPLA No. 1223 of 2026
Administration and after setting aside the elections dated 15.06.2024,
issued directions to the DIOS to get conducted fresh elections.
19. Learned Single Judge has reproduced Clauses 7 and 9 of the Scheme
in his order and, after considering the submissions made by the parties
including the argument advanced by the appellant before us as regards his
forged signatures, the learned Single Judge has arrived at a conclusion
that the specific case of the appellant regarding forgery has not been
considered by the RLC.
20. Learned Single Judge has also given consideration to the induction of
42 new members and, based upon the nature of the order passed by the
RLC and having noticed shortcomings therein, the order dated 12.08.2026
was set aside and the matter was remanded to the RLC granting liberty to
both sides to file documents in support of their stand to facilitate a fresh
consideration by the RLC in accordance with law.
21. Looking at the nature of order passed by the learned Single Judge, if
we proceed to examine the contentions raised by the rival sides, we find
that a clear finding is yet to come on the allegations of forgery and also
sanctity qua the agenda dated 29.04.2024, meeting held on 12.05.2024
and the consequential elections held on 15.06.2024 and any observation
made by this Court at this stage would certainly prejudice fresh
determination to be made by the RLC in pursuance of the order passed by
the learned Single Judge.
22. We are observing so in view of the fact that though plea regarding
non-participation of Kusum Devi was taken by the appellant in his
representation filed before the RLC, nowhere it was indicated as to
whether the appellant did or did not participate in the meeting/elections.
Even in the memo of this Special Appeal or in affidavit, the said plea has
not been taken.
23. As regards the issue as to whether, after sending the list of members
of General body on 12.04.2024, any subsequent list could at all be sent,
the same, prima facie, does not appear to be hit by any clause of the
Scheme, inasmuch as the requirement under Clause 9 (3) of the Scheme is
only to send the list two months prior to expiry of the term of Committee.
SPLA No. 1223 of 2026
Admittedly, the term of the Committee previously elected was going to
expire in June, 2024 and as to whether, subsequent to sending of list on
12.04.2024, any further list based upon the meeting dated 12.05.2024 was
actually sent to the officials and, if sent, as to whether the same would
conform to the requirements contained in Clause 9(3) of the Scheme, all
these aspects require determination by the RLC.
24. We refrain ourselves from recording any finding on any issue raised
by the parties before us as we are satisfied that, in the facts and
circumstances of the case, where the parties are at various contentious
issues, our observations in any direction would prejudice case of either of
the parties during the fresh determination to be made by the RLC.
25. As far as the submission made on behalf of the appellant that the
learned Single Judge did not grant opportunity to the appellant to file
counter affidavit, we find from bare reading of second paragraph of the
order passed by the learned Single Judge that the writ petition was finally
decided with the consent of learned counsel for parties without exchange
of pleadings on the basis of material available on record. As to what had
transpired before the learned Single Judge and what statements were
actually made by the respective parties while addressing the writ Court,
the same cannot be ascertained by this Court in light of the indications
made in second paragraph of the order.
26. In view of the above discussion, we are not inclined to interfere with
the order passed by the learned Single Judge.
27. The special appeal has no substance; the same is, therefore, dismissed.
(Kshitij Shailendra,J.) (Arun Bhansali,CJ.)
November 2, 2026
AKShukla/-
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review