Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
+
I N T H E H I G H CO U RT O F DE L H I AT NE W DE L H I
Reserved on: May 07, 2026
Pronounced on: May 25, 2026
BAIL APPLN. 3340/2025
NAZIM
Through:
.....Applicant
Mr. N. Hariharan, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Amaan Shreyas, Mr. Aman
Akhtar, Mr. Akshay Kumar, Mr.
Vasundhara Raj Tyagi, Mr. Arjan
Singh Mandla and Mr. Manish Kumar,
Advocates.
Versus
STATE NCT OF DELHI
Through:
.....Respondent
Ms. Meenakshi Dahiya, APP for the
State with Ms. Vanshika Singh and
Ms. Apoorva Khosla, Advs.
Insp. B, Dutt Vishnoi and Insp. Rajiv
Kumar, PS.: Ghazipur.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SAURABH BANERJEE
JUDGMENT
1.
By virtue of the present bail application under Section 483 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 20231, the applicant seeks grant of
regular bail in proceedings arising out of FIR No.121/2025 dated 10.03.2025
registered at PS.: Ghazipur, Delhi under Sections 103(1)/3(5) of the
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 20232.
Hereinafter “BNSS”
Hereinafter “BNS”
BAIL APPLN. 3340/2025
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:03:17
2.
As per FIR, on 10.03.2025 at about 01:00 AM, the complainant
received a telephonic call from Rohit3 (since deceased), who requested him
to bring his scooter to help collect diesel. After collecting diesel in a 40-litre
oil can, while the complainant and deceased were returning on the wrong side
of the road near Phool Mandi cut on NH-24, a blue car carrying 3 to 4
persons approached them from behind. The complainant identified Yamin as
the driver of the said vehicle, along with Taleem and Talib, and stated that he
can identify another occupant upon seeing him. The said car overtook them,
and when Rohit stopped the scooter, Yamin fired a gunshot at the deceased,
which struck him on his left shoulder. Another occupant of the car fired a
second gunshot at the oil can being carried, resulting in diesel spilling on the
road. Whereafter, the attackers fled towards Uttar Pradesh. Despite sustaining
injuries, the deceased remained conscious and named Nazim, Yamin, Kapil,
Talib and the present applicant as persons involved in the incident. The
complainant, with the assistance of a passer-by, took the deceased to LBS
Hospital, where he succumbed to his injuries during treatment.
3.
As per the post-mortem, the cause of death was opined as
“Haemorrhagic shock consequent upon gunshot injuries to lungs and heart
produce by riffled firearm projectile and sufficient to cause death in ordinary
course of nature. All the injuries are fresh in duration and ante-mortem in
nature”. During the course of investigation, the Police inspected the place of
occurrence and seized relevant exhibits, including blood samples, soil
Hereinafter “deceased”
BAIL APPLN. 3340/2025
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:03:17
samples and empty cartridges. Based thereon, the present FIR came to be
registered and the accused persons were taken into judicial custody.
4.
Of the many grounds raised in the present application, Mr. N.
Hariharan, learned senior counsel for the applicant primarily submitted that
the applicant has been falsely implicated in the present FIR. Even otherwise,
it is not the case of the prosecution that the applicant was physically present
at the scene of the alleged offence and the role attributable to him is limited
to that of a supposed conspirator, however, there is no material on record to
show that the applicant ever met the co-accused persons, Yamin, Talib, or
Naved prior to the incident. In fact, neither has the investigation yielded any
intercepted communication, CCTV footage, and recovery linking the
applicant to any preparatory act, nor has any incriminating material/ evidence
such as fingerprints, DNA, weapon, vehicle used in the commission of the
alleged offence, blood-stained clothes, etc., have been recovered at the
instance of the applicant herein.
5.
The learned senior counsel submitted that the alleged oral dying
declaration is wholly unreliable as it was neither recorded by a Magistrate nor
supported by any medical certification as to the deceased’s fitness to speak.
On the contrary, the prosecution’s own medical evidence shows gunshot
injuries to the lungs and heart, making it highly improbable for the deceased
to have made any coherent or prolonged statement. Significantly, the alleged
declaration is attributed solely to the complainant, an interested witness, and
finds no independent corroboration whatsoever.
6.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that though the
BAIL APPLN. 3340/2025
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:03:17
prosecution seeks to rely upon Call Detail Records4 to allege association
between the applicant and co-accused persons, however, the CDR does not
reveal any communication suggestive of participation in the alleged
conspiracy. In fact, the CDR spanning over three months reflects only three
(3) calls with Yamin, thirteen (13) with Naved, and one hundred sixteen (116)
routine familial conversations with Tariq (his cousin), and significantly, there
were no calls with any of the co-accused on the date of the incident and none
whatsoever with Kapil Gurjar, the alleged principal conspirator.
7.
The learned senior counsel then submitted that reliance placed by the
prosecution on the disclosure statement of Samina (wife of co-accused Yamin)
given on 11.03.2025, which, though records that certain co-accused had
gathered at her house, however, she did not name or implicate the applicant
having attended the said gathering. In fact, she referred to a dispute between
her husband and the deceased regarding diesel/ scrap business, yet made no
allegation of the applicant’s involvement in the said rivalry. Moreover,
custodial statements being inadmissible, have no evidentiary value in the
eyes of law.
8.
Lastly, since the CCTV footage unequivocally shows that the applicant
was picked up from his residence prior to the registration of the FIR,
however, the arrest memo was deliberately prepared with a later time stamp
to suggest a post-FIR arrest, the learned senior counsel submitted that the
same shows that the applicant’s arrest indicate a predetermined effort to
Hereinafter “CDR”
BAIL APPLN. 3340/2025
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:03:17
frame him. Moreover, since the applicant has been languishing in jail since
10.03.2025 i.e. for more than one year two months as on date, and since the
chargesheet has been filed way back on 05.06.2025, his continued
incarceration would not serve any fruitful purpose.
9.
Thus, learned senior counsel for the applicant sought bail of the
applicant under the aforesaid facts and circumstances.
10.
Per contra, Ms. Meenakshi Dahiya, learned APP for the State opposed
the present application to submit that according to the testimony of the
complainant, who also happens to be the eye-witness, even after sustaining
the gunshots, and shortly before his death, the deceased remained conscious
and named Yamin, Kapil, Talib, and the present applicant as the persons
involved in the firing and the conspiracy, thus, the said statement constitutes
a valid ‘dying declaration’ under Section 26 of the Bharatiya Sakshya
Adhiniyam, 20235.
11.
The learned APP submitted that the role attributable to the applicant
herein is that of a key conspirator, his presence at the scene of crime has thus
no relevance. The learned APP further submitted that the CRD analysis
reflects three (3) calls with Yamin, thirteen (13) with Naved, and one
hundred sixteen (116) calls with Tariq, thereby corroborating the nexus and
‘conspiracy’ between the applicant and the co-accused as also the absence of
telephonic conversations on the day of the incident is not enough to disregard
the element of ‘conspiracy’.
Hereinafter “BSA”
BAIL APPLN. 3340/2025
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:03:17
12.
The learned APP also submitted that the brother of the deceased, in his
disclosure statement has categorically stated that prior to his death, his
brother had informed him of threats being extended to his life by Tariq,
Kapil, Yameen and the present applicant since he was instrumental in
stopping of the theft of diesel/ scrap. Furthermore, even the wife of coaccused Yamin in her disclosure statement has stated that the co-accused
persons had gathered at her house as also there was a dispute with the
deceased qua the diesel/ scrap business.
13.
Lastly, the learned APP submitted that the investigation in the matter is
complete, the chargesheet has been filed way back on 05.06.2025, the
charges have been framed, and the trial is at the stage of prosecution
evidence, hence, there is no delay in trial. Moreover, as per the Nominal Roll,
the conduct of the applicant is ‘Unsatisfactory’ and he has been involved in
as many as seven (7) criminal antecedents, thereby demonstrating his
propensity to be involved in repeated criminal activities. As such, learned
APP sought rejection of the present regular bail application.
14.
Additionally, learned counsel for the complainant has supported the
case set up by the prosecution hereinabove. Relying upon Laxman vs. State
of Maharashtra6 and Naeem vs. State of Uttar Pradesh7, the learned counsel
submitted that (i) dying declaration can be the sole basis for conviction, and
(ii) there is no requirement of law that a dying declaration must necessarily
be made to a Magistrate. Moreover, where the eyewitness states that the
2022 (1) Suppl. SCR 697
2024 INSC 169
BAIL APPLN. 3340/2025
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:03:17
deceased was in a fit and conscious state to make the declaration, the medical
opinion will not prevail, nor can it be said that since there is no certification
of the Doctor as to the fitness of the mind of the declarant, the dying
declaration cannot be accepted. What is essentially required is that the person
who records a dying declaration must be satisfied that the deceased was in a
fit state of mind.
15.
This Court has heard the learned senior counsel for the applicant,
learned APP for the State and the learned counsel for the complainant as also
perused the materials on record and the judgments cited by them at Bar.
16.
Since it is no longer res integra that at the stage of consideration of an
application for bail, the Court is to only consider if a prima facie is made out
or is/ are there is any reasonable ground(s) to believe that the accused/
applicant had committed the alleged offence and not assume the role of a trial
Court and venture into the veracity of the evidence. This Court has to be
cognizant of the fact that this is not a mini-trial which needs any streak of
evidence to be taken into consideration.
17.
In view of the aforesaid, and what has been sought to be submitted by
the learned senior counsel for the applicant be it qua discrepancies regarding
time of arrest as per the CCTV footage and/ or absence of telephonic
conversations of the applicant on the day of the incident, primarily, since
those are all matters of trial which need to be established after leading
evidence, as also considering the overall facts and circumstances involved
herein, the nature and gravity of the accusations levelled against the
applicant, the severity of punishment prescribed in the event of conviction
BAIL APPLN. 3340/2025
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:03:17
and more particularly since the applicant having been explicitly named in the
dying declaration given by the deceased, this Court is not inclined to grant
regular bail to the applicant, at this stage.
18.
Regarding the nature of the dying declaration, it need not be gone into
at this stage as the probative value thereof and the weight of evidence thereon
will be considerations for trial. Even otherwise, as held in Laxman (supra) a
dying declaration need not always be recorded by a Magistrate and/ or
supported by any medical certification as to the deceased’s fitness to speak as
asserted by the learned senior counsel for the applicant. Also, there is no
denial about the deceased being mentally fit till before. As of now, there is no
prima facie material to dislodge the dying declaration.
19.
Though the applicant was arrested on the basis of a disclosure
statement of the brother of the deceased and wife of co-accused, however, the
same is to be seen coupled with the fact that the applicant has been explicitly
named in the dying declaration, and there are CDR connectivity inter se him
and the co-accused persons. The same raise a doubt in the mind of this Court
qua non-involvement of the applicant in the present FIR and is actually
sufficient for this Court to draw an adverse inference against him.
20.
Lastly, as per the Nominal Roll received, the conduct of the applicant
inside Jail has been ‘Unsatisfactory’ and outside Jail, he has as many as
seven (7) criminal antecedents. There may thus be a reasonable apprehension
for the applicant influencing the witnesses, tampering with evidence to
hamper the trial thereby frustrating the administration of justice and/ or
indulge in similar offences, if released on bail.
BAIL APPLN. 3340/2025
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:03:17
21.
Accordingly, the present application is dismissed.
22.
Needless to say, the expression of opinion(s), if any, are for the
purposes of adjudicating the present application only, and they shall have no
bearing on the trial.
SAURABH BANERJEE, J.
MAY 25, 2026/Ab/DA
BAIL APPLN. 3340/2025
Digitally Signed
By:BABLOO SHAH
17:03:17
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review