Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
!"#" $%
'
& &
(
&&& ))*"! $ +#,
-
.
-
- /+
( (
,
(
&&&
0%
1 2 0 &
(
(
#) $ $ +#,
(
!
""""
(
(
#
/ & + 3 *,
$
%
%
!
##&'(
#))' &
#,#
.!
*
-
%
!
/
%
!
!%-
%1
%
-
-
!
%
! %
-
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
2 !
!%
!
-
+(
$
#4 56 /5/#
%
! !
5) 57 /5/# 2
!%-
!
%
%
!
!-
!%-
%
#4
%
%
!
!%!
-
%
- 2
!
!
%
-
!%-
#/&,(
!
-
%
!
!
! .! -
%
%
%
- 1%
!
%1
!
!%-
%
!
8!
/
57 5' /5/, %1
%
# 2
!
-
%1 2 +%
%
8!
%
%
%1
!
1-
- 1%
%
%1
!
%!
-
%
-
%
!
!%-
!
!-
%
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
#4
!%-
%
%
!
!
!
/,
%!
!-
!%-
#,)
%
%
%!
!
!
!
%
-
-;
/,& (
!
%
%1
< /5
-;
%
!
%
!
%
%
=
%
-
!-
%1
!
!
!%-
!
!-
-
%1
%
-
-
/'/
%
!
!-
-
!
$
-
%
!
-
%
-
-
%
!-
!
!
%1
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
%1
!
%
,
- !
-
%
%1
-
- !
:
%
!
.!
!%%
-
$
%
!
%
!
-
!
%!
!
:
8 !
$ %!
< /5
-!
%
/,
-
-
-
!
>
!
!-
'
$
%
!
%1
!
!-
!%-
%
!
#4
!
!
“18. Disputes if any, arising during the period of this
agreement between CHB and the agency shall be referred to
the sole arbitration of the Chairman CHB or a person
nominated by him (The fact that the person so nominated is
also an employee of CHB shall not be a bar on his acting as
an Arbitrator nor shall any of the parties have any objection
to his nomination for the said reason). The decision of the
Sole Arbitrator so appointed shall be final and binding on
both the parties. The venue of Arbitration shall be at
Chandigarh. All disputes are subject to Chandigarh
Jurisdiction only.”
?
$
%
!
%1
-
!
!
/,
#,)
-
!
If the contractor considers any work demanded
of him to be outside the requirements of the contract, or
disputes any drawings, record or decision given in writing
by the Engineer,in,Charge or if the Engineer in Charge
considers any act or decision of the contractor on any
matter in connection with or arising out of the contract or
carrying out of the work to be unacceptable and is disputed,
such party shall promptly within 15 days of the arising of the
disputes request the Chief Engineer/CPM, or where there is
no Chief Engineer/CPM, request the Additional Director
General/Special Director General, who shall refer the
disputes to Dispute Redressal Committee (DRC) within 15
days along with a list of disputes with amounts claimed, if
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
any in respect of each such dispute. The Dispute Redressal
Committee (DRC) give its decision within a period of 60
days extendable by 30 days by consent of both the parties
from the receipt of reference from CE/CPM/ADG/SDG. The
constitution of Dispute Redressal Committee (DRC) shall be
as indicated in Schedule ‘F’. Provided that no party shall be
represented before the Dispute Redressal Committee by an
advocate/legal counsel etc.
The DRC will submit its decision to the concerned
ADG/SDG for acceptance. ADG/SDG in a time limit of 30
days from receipt of DRC decision will convey acceptance or
other wise on the said decision. If the Dispute Redressal
Committee (DRC) fails to give its decision within the
aforesaid period or the ADG/SDG fails to give his decision
in the aforesaid time limit or any party is dissatisfied with
the
decision
of
Dispute
Redressal
Committee
(DRC)/ADG/SDG the neither party may within a period of
30 days from the receipt of the decision of Dispute Redressal
Committee (DRC)/ADG/SDG or on expiry of aforesaid the
time limits available to DRC/ADG/SDG may give notice to
the Chief Engineer/CPM, CPWD, in charge of the work or if
there be no Chief Engineer/CPM, the Additional Director
General/Special Director General concerned or if there be
no Additional Director General/Special Director General,
the Director General, CPWD for appointment of arbitrator
on prescribed proforma as per Appendix XVII under
intimation to the other party.
It is a term of contract that each party invoking arbitration
must exhaust the aforesaid mechanism of settlement of
claims/disputes prior to invoking arbitration.
The CE/ADG/SDG shall in such case appoint the sole
arbitrator or one of the three arbitrators as the case may be
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
within 30 days of receipt of such a request and refer such
disputes to arbitration. Wherever the Arbitral Tribunal
consists of three Arbitrators, the contractor shall appoint
one arbitrator within 30 days of making request for
arbitration or of receipt of request by Engineer,in,charge to
CE/ADG/SDG/DG for appointment of arbitrator, as the case
may be, and two appointed arbitrators shall appoint the
third arbitrator who shall act as the Presiding Arbitrator. In
the event of
(a) A party fails to appoint the second Arbitrator, or
(b) The two appointed Arbitrators fail to appoint the
Presiding Arbitrator, then the Director General,
CPWD shall appoint the second or Presiding
Arbitrator as the case may be.
Dispute or difference shall be referred for
adjudication through arbitration by a Tribunal having sole
arbitrator where claimed amount is Rs. 20 Crore or less.
Where claimed Value is more than Rs. 20 Crore, Tribunal
shall consist of three Arbitrators as above. The requirements
of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996)
and any further statutory modification or re,enactment
thereof and the rules made there under and for the time
being in force shall be applicable.
It is a term of this contract that the party invoking
arbitration shall give a list of disputes with amounts
claimed, if any, in respect of each such dispute along with
the notice for appointment of arbitrator and giving reference
to the decision of the ADG/SDG on the finding
recommendation of DRC.
It is also a term of this contract that member(s) of the
Arbitration Tribunal, shall be a Graduate Engineer with
experience in handling public works engineering contracts,
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
and further he shall have earlier worked at a level not lower
than Chief Engineer/equivalent (i.e. Joint Secretary level of
Government or India). This shall be treated as a mandatory
qualification to be appointed as arbitrator.
Parties, before or at the time of appointment of Arbitral
Tribunal may agree in writing for fast track arbitration as
per the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996)
as amended in 2015.
Subject to provision in the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 (26 of 1996) as amended in 2015 whereby the counter
claims if any can be directly filed before the arbitrator
without any requirement of reference by the appointing
authority. The arbitrator shall adjudicate on only such
disputes as are referred to him by the appointing authority
and give separate award against each dispute and claim
referred to him and in all cases where the total amount of
the claims
by any
party
exceeds
Rs.1,00,000/,,
the
arbitrator shall give reasons for the award.
It is also a term of the contract that fees payable to arbitral
tribunal shall be as approved by DG, CPWD, OM issued
vide no.2/2006/SE(TLC)/CSO/137 dated 19,11,2019 (or its
latest amendment as approved by DG, CPWD.). This fee
shall be shared equally by parties.
The place of arbitration shall be as mentioned in Schedule F.
In case there is no mention of place of arbitration, the
arbitral tribunal shall determine the place of arbitration.
The venue of the arbitration shall be such place as may be
fixed by the Arbitral Tribunal in consultation with both the
parties. Failing any such agreement, then the Arbitral
Tribunal shall decide the venue.”
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
$
!
%
-
!
/'/
!
“2.
That the contractor shall abide by the fulfill all
the terms & conditions of this agreement including those
Schedule,I (Page 1 to 116) original bid documents
consisting notice inviting tender, documents relating to
eligibility criteria special conditions, other financial bid
related
documents
and
general/Special
condition,
specification, schedule quantity, Schedule,II (Page 117 to
142 comprising of Original Bid Document of the Contractor,
its undertaking & acceptance by competent authority i.e. of
CM, CHB & approval), Schedule,III (Page 143 to 349
comprising of acceptance of tender, award of work &
agreement), annexed hereto and in default thereof, he
(contractor) as laid down in this Agreement comprising of
'Bid Document and Financial Bid' annexed hereto.”
)
!
%
!
%
!%-
!%
-
%
!
%
!
%
!
-
>
%
!
%
#5
!-
%
/
%
%
!
!
$
%.
%1
!
%
;
$
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
8!
!-
%1
-;
!
!
%
:
%
@
%
!
%
%
%
#4
-
-
##
!
#4
!
%
-
-
%
2 !
%
%
/
%
!-
%
$
!-
-
-
!
!
-
%1
!
%
%
!-
%
/,
!
-
-
%1
-
%
!-
!
%
-
-
!
!
!
!
%!
%
!
-
%
-
-
%1
#/
##
%
-
%1 2 A%
!
-
%
% -
.! -
!
!
% &
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
'( ')
*
+
"
# $
# $
, (
- $
8 -
2 +%
!
##&'
%
-
* 8 -
(
?
(
!
#'
-
-
prima facie
%
%!
%
%
#6
%
$
.! -
-
-
!
-
!
%
* ! +!
#' $
!
"
# $
##
B! 1
prima facie
!
%
2 +%
!
-
!
%
!
!
!
!
%1
!
!
%
!
!
-
C!
facie 8
$
B! 1 !
$ %!
!
!
(
##&'
*! + !
%
-
%
+!
##&'
!
prima
<
!
“120. In view of the above discussion, we formulate
our conclusions on this aspect. First, the separability
presumption contained in Section 16 is applicable not only
for the purpose of determining the jurisdiction of the
Arbitral Tribunal. It encapsulates the general rule on the
substantive independence of an arbitration agreement.
Second, parties to an arbitration agreement mutually intend
to confer jurisdiction on the arbitral tribunal to determine
questions as to jurisdiction as well as substantive
contractual disputes between them. The separability
presumption gives effect to this by ensuring the validity of an
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
arbitration agreement contained in an underlying contract,
notwithstanding the invalidity, illegality, or termination of
such contract. Third, when the parties append their
signatures
to
a
contract
containing an
arbitration
agreement, they are regarded in effect as independently
appending their signatures to the arbitration agreement. The
reason is that the parties intend to treat an arbitration
agreement contained in an underlying contract as distinct
from the other terms of the contract; and Fourth, the validity
of an arbitration agreement, in the face of the invalidity of
the underlying contract, allows the Arbitral Tribunal to
assume jurisdiction and decide on its own jurisdiction by
determining the existence and validity of the arbitration
agreement. In the process, the separability presumption
gives effect to the doctrine of competence,competence.
xxx,xxx,xxx,xxx
165. The legislature confined the scope of reference under
Section 11(6,A) to the examination of the existence of an
arbitration agreement. The use of the term "examination" in
itself connotes that the scope of the power is limited to a
prima facie determination. Since the Arbitration Act is a
self,contained code, the requirement of "existence" of an
arbitration agreement draws effect from section 7 of the
Arbitration Act. In Duro Felguera (supra), this Court held
that the referral courts only need to consider one aspect to
determine the existence of an arbitration agreement,whether
the underlying contract contains an arbitration agreement
which provides for arbitration pertaining to the disputes
which have arisen between the parties to the agreement.
Therefore, the scope of examination under Section 11(6,A)
should be confined to the existence of an arbitration
agreement on the basis of Section 7. Similarly, the validity
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
of an arbitration agreement, in view of Section 7, should be
restricted to the requirement of formal validity such as the
requirement that the agreement be in writing. This
interpretation also gives true effect to the doctrine of
competence,competence by leaving the issue of substantive
existence and validity of an arbitration agreement to be
decided by arbitral tribunal under Section 16. We
accordingly clarify the position of law laid down in Vidya
Drolia (supra) in the context of Section 8 and section 11 of
the Arbitration Act.
166. The burden of proving the existence of arbitration
agreement generally lies on the party seeking to rely on such
agreement. In jurisdictions such as India, which accept the
doctrine of competence,competence, only prima facie proof
of the existence of an arbitration agreement must be
adduced before the referral court. The referral court is not
the appropriate forum to conduct a minitrial by allowing the
parties to adduce the evidence in regard to the existence or
validity of an arbitration agreement. The determination of
the existence and validity of an arbitration agreement on the
basis of evidence ought to be left to the arbitral tribunal.
This position of law can also be gauged from the plain
language of the statute.”
#7
$
!
.! -
%
!
&
%1 2 +%
(
!
-
.
!
“110. The scope of examination under Section 11(6,A) is
confined to the existence of an arbitration agreement on the
basis of Section 7. The examination of validity of the
arbitration agreement is also limited to the requirement of
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
formal validity such as the requirement that the agreement
should be in writing.
111. The use of the term ‘examination’ under Section 11(6,A)
as distinguished from the use of the term ‘rule’ under Section
16 implies that the scope of enquiry under section 11(6,A) is
limited to a prima facie scrutiny of the existence of the
arbitration agreement, and does not include a contested or
laborious enquiry, which is left for the arbitral tribunal to
‘rule’ under Section 16. The prima facie view on existence of
the arbitration agreement taken by the referral court does
not bind either the arbitral tribunal or the court enforcing
the arbitral award.
112. The aforesaid approach serves a two,fold purpose –
firstly, it allows the referral court to weed out nonexistent
arbitration agreements, and secondly, it protects the
jurisdictional competence of the arbitral tribunal to rule on
the issue of existence of the arbitration agreement in depth.
113. Referring to the Statement of Objects and Reasons of
the Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2015, it
was observed in In Re: Interplay (supra) that the High Court
and the Supreme Court at the stage of appointment of
arbitrator shall examine the existence of a prima facie
arbitration agreement and not any other issues. The relevant
observations are extracted hereinbelow:
“209. The above extract indicates that +
/ +
+
+
0 +
+
+
2' 3+
)
+
+
+
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
+
+ +
+
' Accordingly, the “other issues” also
include examination and impounding of an unstamped
instrument by the referral court at the Section 8 or
Section 11 stage. The process of examination,
impounding,
and
dealing
with
an
unstamped
instrument under the Stamp Act is not a time bound
process, and therefore does not align with the stated
goal of the Arbitration Act to ensure expeditious and
time,bound appointment of arbitrators.[…]
(Emphasis supplied)
114. In view of the observations made by this Court in In Re:
Interplay (supra), it is clear that the scope of enquiry at the
stage of appointment of arbitrator is limited to the scrutiny
of prima facie existence of the arbitration agreement, and
nothing else. For this reason, we find it difficult to hold that
the observations made in Vidya Drolia (supra) and adopted
in NTPC v. SPML (supra) that the jurisdiction of the referral
court when dealing with the issue of “accord and
satisfaction” under Section 11 extends to weeding out ex,
facie non,arbitrable and frivolous disputes would continue
to apply despite the subsequent decision in In Re: Interplay
(supra).
115. The dispute pertaining to the “accord and satisfaction”
of claims is not one which attacks or questions the existence
of the arbitration agreement in any way. As held by us in the
preceding parts of this judgment, the arbitration agreement,
being separate and independent from the underlying
substantive contract in which it is contained, continues to
remain in existence even after the original contract stands
discharged by “accord and satisfaction” .
116. The question of “accord and satisfaction”, being a
mixed question of law and fact, comes within the exclusive
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal, if not otherwise agreed
upon between the parties. Thus, the negative effect of
competence,competence would require that the matter
falling within the exclusive domain of the arbitral tribunal,
should not be looked into by the referral court, even for a
prima facie determination, before the arbitral tribunal first
has had the opportunity of looking into it.”
#,
"
# $
%
-
!
6+ 5+
,
-
( ')
+8
- ::
!
%
%
%
%
-
8 !
%
!
>
%
##
>
%
-
!
-
-
prima facie 8
%1
#4
%
6,
>
!
C!
%1
!
- %
D -
!
%
C!
-
.!
!
-.
//,7
%
!
B!
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
!
!
#?
!
-
#'
-
-
%
?46?57)/57 )4#7##,4/,
-
%
!%.
#/
2 !
-
!
#)
%
-
%
--!
/5
@
@ !
!
/#
%
-
%
//
%
%1
%
%
%
%
B!
!
-
/)
B!
-.
-
%
C!
!
+
(
(
& &
$ 7 893
=
=
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.01.23 17:25
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
;
%
C!
E ;
E ;
,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review