Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 07.02.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 27.02.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 27.02.2026
+
W.P.(C) 10453/2025 and CM APPL. 43406/2025
NAVLENDRA KUMAR SINGH
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Amit Rawal, Sr. Adv.
along with Ms. Rishika, Adv.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Premtosh K Mishra, CGSC
along with Mr. Shrey Sharma
and Mr. Anubhav Upadhyay,
Advs.
Mr. Sanjay Pal, GP.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
Through the present Petition, the Petitioner assails the
correctness of the judgment dated 08.07.2021 [hereinafter referred to
as „Impugned Judgment‟] passed by the Central Administrative
Tribunal [hereinafter referred to as „CAT‟], whereby O.A.
No.322/2020 filed by the Petitioner was dismissed, while refusing to
interfere with the order passed by the Disciplinary Authority ordering
reduction of present time scale of pay to the lower time scale for a
period of three years, which was to operate as a bar to his promotion
during that period to the post for which he is reduced, with further
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:35:53
direction that on the expiry of the said period, the future increments of
his pay shall stand postponed and that he shall not regain his original
seniority in the higher times scales of post on restoration of his
original post, which in Appeal was affirmed by the Appellate
Authority.
2.
At the outset, it may be noted that the present Petition has been
filed after a period of four years from the date of the Impugned
Judgment of the CAT. The issue of delay, therefore, arises for
consideration apart from the merits of the challenge raised herein.
3.
In order to comprehend the issues involved in the present
Petition, the relevant facts, in brief, are required to be noticed.
4.
The Petitioner is a Selection Grade DANICS Officer. At the
relevant time in 2016, the Petitioner was posted as Land Acquisition
Collector [hereinafter referred to as „LAC‟]. For the acquisition of
land for the Slum and JJ Department, a notification under Section 4 of
the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 [hereinafter referred to as „LA Act‟]
was issued on 15.09.2000, which included land comprised in Khasra
Nos. 426, 435, 401, 576, 577, 587 and 589, admeasuring 27 bighas
and 16 biswas, in village Bhalaswa, Jahangirpur, belonging to late
Shri Khushi Ram.[hereinafter referred to as „Khushi Ram‟]. A Writ
Petition being W.P.(C) 6461/2000 was filed by Khushi Ram
challenging the aforesaid acquisition. During the pendency of the Writ
Petition, the LAC passed an award on 12.04.2002 and compensation
of Rs.1,19,52,394.75/- was paid to the sons of Khushi Ram in 2002.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:35:53
5.
Khushi Ram had filed application bearing No. CM 2833/2002
in his Writ Petition, W.P.(C) 6461/2000, supported by an Affidavit,
seeking permission to withdraw the said Writ Petition. However, his
counsel did not bring the fact to the notice of the Court and the said
Writ Petition, along with a batch of Writ Petitions pertaining to the
land acquisition Notification No. F.11(24)/98/L&B/LA/8895 were
clubbed together, and allowed by a common judgment on 12.12.2002,
resulting in quashing of the said land acquisition notification.
6.
On 04.03.2003, a fresh Notification under Section 4 of the LA
Act was issued, which included the land of Khushi Ram. Immediately
thereafter, the Slum and JJ Department informed the Competent
Authority that compensation to Khushi Ram for acquisition of his land
had already been paid in 2002, and he had filed an application for
withdrawal of his Writ Petition; hence, fresh Notification for including
his land was not required to be issued. On being brought to the notice
of the Hon‟ble Lieutenant Governor, a note was prepared by the Joint
Secretary on 27.08.2003, which resulted in a recommendation to
exclude the land of Khushi Ram from acquisition. Consequently,
while issuing the declaration under Section 6 of the LA Act, the land
of Khushi Ram was not included in the acquisition.
7.
Khushi Ram is stated to have died on 18.10.2009. On
24.09.2015, one Sh. Vimal Jain, claiming to have an Agreement to
Sell („ATS‟), General Power of Attorney („GPA‟), Will and Receipt
dated 10.05.2004, and claiming to be a representative of Khushi Ram
filed an application for permission to refund the compensation
amount.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:35:53
8.
On the basis of the aforesaid application, the Petitioner initiated
the proceedings as LAC, and pursuant thereto, the following order was
passed on 24.05.2016:
“Sh. Sandeep Srivastava, Advocate for Shri Vimal Jain in person, Shri
R.C.Meena Tehsildar, Shri Umed Singh, Manung & Sh. BM Sharma,
JE, (DUSIB). Heard both the parties. A written submission be
submitted on or before the NDOH, i.e. 10.06.2016 at 3 PM.
Meanwhile, land status with photographs be called from Halka
Patwari.”
9.
The aforesaid order was signed by the Petitioner and all the
parties. However, subsequently, another paragraph was added which
bore only the signature of the petitioner, and read as follows:
“At this stage, advocate for the applicant requests for change of date
of hearing. Accordingly, the date is changed as 01.06.2016 instead of
10.06.2016. Parties have noted down the change date. Put up on
01.06.2016 at 3 PM.”
10.
On 01.06.2016, the following Order was passed:
“The Halka Patwari has placed on record 2 No. of status report along
with photographs and copy of Jamabandi which is taken on record.
Present Shri Sandeep Srivastava advocate along with Sh. Vimal Jain,
applicant. None is present on behalf of DUSIB.”
11.
It is pertinent to note that the Petitioner was transferred vide
Order dated 30.05.2016 to another district. As noticed above, the next
date of hearing in the matter was advanced from 10.06.2016 to
01.06.2016 and thereafter, the Petitioner proceeded to pass a final
order (running into 25 pages) on 03.06.2016, accepting the refund and
permitting Sh. Vimal Jain to deposit Rs.3,26,30,694/- with the LAC
on the ground that the acquisition of that land has come to an end. The
said amount was deposited on 28.06.2016 with his successor in office.
12.
The Petitioner was placed under suspension on 23.08.2016
while disciplinary proceedings against him were contemplated.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:35:53
Aggrieved thereby, the Petitioner preferred an OA No.4047/2016
before the CAT to challenge the suspension order, which was allowed
on 16.12.2016, setting aside the suspension order and reinstating the
Petitioner.
13.
Thereafter on 10.03.2017, the Petitioner was issued Articles of
Charges , which read as under:
“ARTICLE-I
That Shri Navlendra Kumar Singh, Selection Grade Officer of
DANICS, while working as Addl. District Magistrate/Land Acquisition
Collector, District North, Govt. of NCT of Delhi during the year 2016,
committed gross misconduct in as much as he abused his official
position by passing an illegal order dated 3rd June, 2016 on the
representation of Shri Vimal Jain, R/o Loni Road, without any lawful
authority and jurisdiction, with mala fide intention and ulterior motive
to favour a private person, adversely affecting the Government
interest in respect of a valuable piece of land.
ARTICLE-II
That Shri Navlendra Kumar Singh, Selection Grade Officer of
DANICS, while functioning in the aforesaid post during the aforesaid
period, committed gross misconduct in as much as he abused his
official position by conducting the proceedings hastly, without
following the due procedure, in deciding the aforesaid case, with
malafide intention and ulterior motive to favour a private person,
adversely affecting the Government interest in respect of a valuable
piece of land.
By the above acts of omission & commission, Shri Navlendra Kumar
Singh, Selection Grade Officer of DANICS exhibited lack of absolute
integrity and devotion to duty, which is unbecoming of a Govt.
servant, thereby violating the provisions of Rule 3 of CCS (Conduct)
Rules, 1964.”
14.
Once again, the Petitioner filed O.A. No.911/2018 before CAT,
challenging the Article of Charges which was disposed of while
directing the conclusion of disciplinary proceedings within four
months.
15.
It is also relevant to note that the Delhi Urban Shelter
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:35:53
Improvement Board („DUSIB‟) had filed an application for the recall
of the order of this Court dated 12.12.2002, whereby the land
acquisition notification No. F.11(24)/98/L&B/LA/8895 had been
quashed. Sh. Vimal Jain filed an independent Writ Petition bearing
Case No. WP(C) No.7964/2016. A Division Bench of this Court,
vide detailed judgment, held that Khushi Ram, his counsel and
Sh. Vimal Jain had practised fraud. Hence, the Review Application
was allowed, and the Writ Petition filed by Khushi Ram after
restoration, along with the Writ Petition of Sh. Vimal Jain was
dismissed by Order dated 26.11.2018.
16.
In the statement of imputation, the allegations against the
Petitioner were elaborated. The Inquiry Officer was appointed, who
reported that Article-I was not proved, whereas the imputation against
the Petitioner under Article-II stands proved. Disciplinary Authority,
vide Disagreement Note with respect to Article-I dated 28.03.2019,
informed the Petitioner, while granting him the opportunity to submit
his response-cum-representation, which was filed on 18.04.2019. An
advice was received from the UPSC on 13.09.2019 and the Petitioner
submitted a representation in a response to the advice of the UPSC.
Thereafter, by Order dated 31.12.2019, penalty was imposed on the
Petitioner by the Disciplinary Authority. The Appeal filed by the
Petitioner against the Order of the Disciplinary Authority imposing
penalty was rejected by the Appellate Authority, leading to the filing
of the OA No.322/2020 before CAT, which was disposed of while
upholding the Disciplinary Inquiry, the order passed by the
Disciplinary Authority. However, liberty was granted to the Petitioner
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:35:53
to make a representation with regard to reduction of penalty, and the
Petitioner pursued the same on 13.08.2021 by submitting his
representation to the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India.
In the meantime, on completion of three years of the period of penalty,
the Petitioner was restored to the Selection Grade of DANICS (Pay
Level-11) w.e.f. 31.12.2022.
17.
In
the
meantime,
on
05.01.2024,
another
Order
(No. 14016/22/2023-UTS.II) was passed against the Petitioner by the
Ministry of Home Affairs [Hereinafter referred to as “MHA”],
Government of India. Paragraph No.6 of the Order reads as under:
“6. And now, therefore, in accordance with the advice of the DoPT, the
Competent Authority has decided that the date of commencement of
approved service of Shri Navlendra Kumar Singh, DANICS, shall be
01.07.2006. However, for the purpose of granting the future promotions,
03 years will be deducted from the length of his approved service, so as to
comply with the conditions stipulated in the penalty order dated
31.12.2019 imposed on the officer. The representation dated 19.09.2023
stands disposed of accordingly.”
18.
Aggrieved thereby, the Petitioner filed OA No. 802/2024 before
the CAT to quash and set aside the aforesaid Order dated 05.01.2024
to the extent of deduction of 3 years approved service of the Petitioner
for all promotions and to direct the Respondents therein to count the
entire approved service of the Petitioner, the said OA of the Petitioner
was allowed on 15.07.2024, and the CAT directed the deletion of
paragraph no.6 of the aforesaid order dated 05.01.2024.
19.
The Petitioner did not challenge the correctness of the order
passed by the MHA on 25.07.2024, rejecting the representation of the
Petitioner, by filing a fresh Original Application before the CAT, but
opted to file the present Writ Petition on 19.07.2025, challenging the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:35:53
order passed by the CAT on 08.07.2021.
20.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and, with their able
assistance, perused the paperbook along with the documents produced.
21.
Learned senior counsel for the Petitioner, while explaining the
delay in filing the present Petition, submits that the order passed,
while rejecting the Petitioner‟s representation, resulted in the merger
of the Impugned Judgment passed by CAT, thereby giving the
Petitioner a fresh cause to file the Petition. Learned senior counsel
further submits that the successor in office of the Petitioner, namely
Sh. K.C. Surender, who had implemented the order passed by the
Petitioner, was granted relief by the CAT on 26.09.2018, resulting in
hostile discrimination against the Petitioner.
22.
It is submitted by the learned senior counsel that the Petitioner
had acted after taking legal opinion and the Petitioner had passed the
order dated 03.06.2016 as a quasi-judicial authority, which cannot be
the subject matter of disciplinary proceedings.
23.
Per contra, learned counsel for the Respondent has supported
the Impugned Judgment, while referring to the judgment passed by the
Division Bench of this Court on 26.11.2018, while reviewing the
order dated 12.12.2002.
24.
This Court has considered the submissions advanced by the
learned counsel for the parties.
25.
The doctrine of merger finds no application in the present case.
By the Impugned Judgment dated 08.07.2021, the CAT declined to
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:35:53
interfere with the findings on the Articles of Charge, thereby affirming
the conclusions arrived at by the Disciplinary Authority. While the
Tribunal observed that the punishment imposed was serious and
granted the Petitioner liberty to submit a representation for revisiting
the quantum of penalty, such liberty for administrative consideration
did not re-open the adjudication of the charges or detract from the
finality of the dismissal of the original application. The liberty so
granted was confined to reconsideration of the penalty and did not
amount to a remand of the matter or revival of the original cause of
action.
26.
Consequently, the subsequent rejection of the Petitioner‟s
representation does not result in the merger of the Tribunal‟s
adjudicatory order into a later administrative decision, nor does it
revive the cause to challenge the Impugned Judgment, so as to
overcome the bar of delay and laches. Any contrary view would
render the finality of judicial determinations illusory by permitting
them to be deferred through the pursuit of collateral administrative
remedies. The plea of merger is thus misconceived by the Petitioner
and cannot extend the period for assailing the Impugned Judgment.
27.
The Petitioner did not challenge the correctness of the
Impugned Judgment for nearly four years. No explanation has been
furnished for the delay in instituting the present Writ Petition. The
Petitioner, being a Selection Grade DANICS Officer discharging
quasi-judicial functions, was represented before the Tribunal and was
fully aware of the dismissal of his Original Application. Despite this,
the Petitioner did not challenge the same. Once the CAT declined to
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:35:53
interfere with the order of punishment, it was incumbent upon the
Petitioner to assail the same. The present Petition, having been filed in
July 2025, is liable to be dismissed on the ground of unexplained
delay and laches alone.
28.
Even otherwise, examining the present Petition on merits
notwithstanding the delay, it is evident that the Petitioner was
transferred vide order dated 30.05.2016. The submission of the learned
senior counsel that the Petitioner took a decision on the basis of legal
opinion does not merit acceptance in the aforesaid factual backdrop.
Despite the issuance of the said transfer order, the Petitioner
proceeded to advance the date of hearing from 10.06.2016 to
01.06.2016 and thereafter passed the final order on 03.06.2016, before
relieving his office.
29.
Under the scheme of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, the
acquisition process is initiated by the appropriate Government through
a notification under Section 4(1), followed by a declaration under
Section 6 that the land is required for a public purpose. Upon passing
of the award and taking of possession, Section 16 provides that the
land shall vest absolutely in the Government free from all
encumbrances. No provision of law has been shown by the Petitioner
to this Court which empowers the Land Acquisition Collector to
restore land once vested, to determine lapse of acquisition dehors the
statutory scheme, to accept refund of compensation for reversal of
acquisition, or to entertain and decide claims contrary to the statutory
scheme.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:35:53
30.
Absent any statutory provision countenancing such a course of
action, the view taken in the disciplinary proceedings cannot be said to
suffer from perversity or legal infirmity.
31.
Moreover, the Petitioner cannot claim ignorance of the fact that
on 31.03.2003, the Slum and JJ Department had intimated that Khushi
Ram had accepted the compensation and filed an application for
withdrawal of his Writ Petition, W.P.(C) 6461/2000. The imputations
forming the basis of the Articles of charge were duly examined and
stood established in the departmental proceedings. In these
circumstances, the view taken by the Disciplinary Authority, as
affirmed by the CAT, cannot be said to suffer from any patent
illegality.
32.
The Petitioner also cannot claim that he was unaware of the fact
that Khushi Ram had filed application for withdrawal of the Writ
Petition, particularly when declaration under Section 6 of the LA Act
was issued in the year 2004-05, excluding the land of Khushi Ram on
the basis of intimation given by the Slum and JJ Department. The
Petitioner, being the statutory authority entrusted with land acquisition
proceedings in the district, cannot disassociate himself from official
records and governmental decisions forming part of the acquisition
file. Constructive knowledge of such material is attributable to him in
the discharge of his official duties. The issuance of such declaration
necessarily involved consultation with the office of the LAC. In these
circumstances, the plea of lack of awareness is unsustainable.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:35:53
33.
The Petitioner has also failed to establish any case of hostile
discrimination. Sh. K.C. Surender merely implemented the order
passed by his predecessor and was not similarly situated. A material
distinction thus existed between the Petitioner and his successor in
office.
34.
This Court does not sit in appeal over findings recorded in a
duly conducted departmental inquiry. The scope of interference under
Article 226 of the Constitution in such matters is confined to
examining procedural irregularity, violation of principles of natural
justice, or perversity in findings. No such infirmity has been
demonstrated in the decision of the Disciplinary Authority.
35.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the present Petition is
dismissed both on the grounds of unexplained delay and laches and on
merits.
36.
All pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
FEBRUARY 27, 2026
jai/ad
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
16:35:53
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review