Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:42285
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.13692 of 2024
Reserved on: 28.09.2026
Decided on: 30.09.2026
Uploaded on: 30.09.2026
Naveen Chander Bhadwal
… Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh and another
… Respondents
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Yogesh Jaswal, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1Yes
____________________________________________________
_
For the petitioner:
Mr. Puneet Gupta, Advocate (through V.C.)
and Karan Veer Singh, Advocate.
For the respondents:
Mr. Rajat Chauhan, Assistant Advocate
General.
Ajay Mohan Goel, Judge
By way of this petition, the petitioner has, inter alia,
prayed for the following reliefs:“(i) Issue an appropriate writ, direction or order especially
in the nature of Certiorari quashing the impugned order
dated 21.10.2024(Annexure P-8) and the tailor-made Rule
8 of the Himachal Pradesh Printing and Stationery
Department Overseer Offset, Group-B (Non-Gazetted)
Non-Ministerial Services, Recruitment and Promotion
Rules, 2024 to the extent the "Educational Qualification"
of Diploma in Offset Printing Technology mandatory for
promotion to the post of Overseer Offset has been deleted
only in order to favour the ineligible persons available in
Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:42285
the feeder cadres and to oust the petitioner from the zone
of consideration for promotion to the post of Overseer
Offset despite the fact the petitioner is the sole eligible
and available employee since 06.02.2024 in the feeder
cadre who is having the educational qualification of
Diploma in Offset Printing Technology as detailed in the
petition
and
the
entire
action
of
the
respondent
Department is absolutely illegal, arbitrary, discriminatory,
unjust, illegal, tailor-made, violative of the principles of
the natural justice and Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India and also the well settled law laid
down by this Hon'ble Court and the Hon'ble Supreme
Court of India as detailed in the writ petition;
(ii) Issue an appropriate writ, direction or order especially
in
the
nature
of
Mandamus
directing
the
official
respondents to consider and promote the petitioner as
Overseer Offset being the sole eligible employee in the
feeder cadre.
iii) grant any other appropriate writ, order or direction as
may be deemed just and appropriate in the peculiar facts
and circumstances of the instant case;
(iv) exempt the petitioner from filing the certified and
typed copies of the annexures and permit the filing of
photostat copies thereof;
(v) exempt the petitioner from service of the advance
notices upon the respondents.
It is, therefore, respectfully prayed that during the
pendency of the captioned petition, the effect and
operation of the impugned Himachal Pradesh Printing
and Stationery Department Overseer Offset, Group-B
2026:HHC:42285
(Non-Gazetted) Non-Ministerial C Services, Recruitment
and Promotion Rules, 2024 may kindly be stayed or in
the alternative, the respondents be restrained from
promoting any ineligible employee from the feeder cadres
as Overseer Offset who is not having the education
qualification of Diploma in Offset Printing Technology, in
the interests of justice, equity, good conscience and fair
play”
2.
Brief facts necessary for adjudication of this petition are
that the petitioner is serving as a Camera Operator in the
respondent- Department. According to the petitioner, the post of
Camera Operator is the feeder post for promotion to the post of
Overseer Offset and in terms of Notification dated 27.07.2010
(Annexure P-4), the post of Overseer Offset has to be filled in 100%
by way of promotion, failing which, by direct recruitment on regular
basis or on contract. He further submitted that promotion to the
post of Overseer Offset is to be made from the feeder categories of
Offset Operators/ Camera Operators/Litho Artists having 5 years
regular service or regular combined with continuous ad hoc service
in any grade. As per the petitioner, in Clause-7 of the said
Recruitment & Promotion Rules, 2010 (hereinafter referred to as “the
2010 Rules”), minimum educational and other qualifications for
direct recruitment were mentioned and further as per Clause-8
thereof, these educational qualifications are also essential for
2026:HHC:42285
promotion.
3.
The grievance of the petitioner is that in terms of the
impugned
Notification
dated
24.06.2024
(Annexure
P-5),
the
respondents have repealed the 2010 Rules and brought into force
the Himachal Pradesh Printing and Stationery Department Overseer
Offset Group-C (Non-Gazetted Non-Ministerial Service) Recruitment
& Promotion Rules, 2024 (“the 2024 Rules”), in terms whereof, the
minimum educational qualifications, which are required in the case
of direct recruitment, have been done away with for promotion.
4.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner argued that the
petitioner was fulfilling the educational qualifications which were
prescribed in terms of the 2010 Rules and was also fulfilling the
other eligibility criteria to be promoted to the post of Overseer Offset,
which post was lying vacant. He argued that as a result of the
impugned Notification, the ineligible candidates in the feeder
category were made eligible without any rhyme or reason and this
act of the respondent-Department is bad in law. Learned counsel
argued that there was no rationale in doing away with the
educational qualifications, which existed in the 2010 Rules for the
purpose of promotion. He submitted that the impugned Notification
was tailor-made to promote certain ineligible incumbents, who
otherwise would not have been promoted to the post of Overseer
Offset for not possessing the requisite educational qualifications in
2026:HHC:42285
term of the 2010 Rules. Further, by referring to the reply that has
been filed to the petition by the Department, learned Counsel
submitted that the reply was completely unsatisfactory and there
was no cogent explanation as to why the 2010 Rules were repealed
and the 2024 Rules were brought into force.
5.
On the other hand, learned Assistant Advocate General
submitted
that
the
present
writ
petition
was
completely
misconceived. He argued that the 2010 Rules were repealed by the
Department and the 2024 Rules were brought into force, so as to
give a chance to those incumbents who were serving in the feeder
categories for promotion to the post of Overseer Offset, but were not
possessing the requisite educational qualifications which were
prescribed in the 2010 Rules. However, these incumbents had
gained enough experience by virtue of their service in the feeder
categories so as to render them eligible for promotion to the post of
Overseer Offset. He argued that the petitioner has no fundamental
right of promotion, there is no arbitrariness or illegality in the 2024
Rules and the same have not been tailor-made for anyone. He
submitted that in the reply of the Department, this was specifically
and categorically mentioned. He argued that though allegations were
made by the petitioner that the Rules were tailor-made to suit
certain incumbents, but then none from the feeder categories were
impleaded as a party respondent, which rendered the petition as bad
2026:HHC:42285
for non-joinder of necessary parties also.
6.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and having
perused the pleadings as well as the impugned Notification, we are of
the considered view that there is no merit in this writ petition.
7.
It is a matter of record that in terms of the 2010 Rules,
the essential qualifications prescribed for direct recruitment to the
post of Offset Overseer were essential even for the purpose of
promotion, however, in terms of the impugned Notification, the 2010
Rules were repealed and the 2024 Rules were brought into force. In
terms of the 2024 Rules, though there is a requirement of essential
educational qualifications as is mentioned for the purpose of direct
recruitment, however, the condition of possession of essential
qualifications has been done away with for the purpose of promotion
and certain new feeder categories have also been added.
8.
A perusal of the
reply filed by the respondent-
Department demonstrates that this condition was removed, inter
alia, in light of the fact that the officials, who were there in the feeder
categories acquired good experience, knowledge and expertise in
their work over a long period of service in the feeder category with
the respondents. In light of the fact that there were representations
received
by
the
Department
concerned,
Notification
dated
24.06.2024 was issued, in terms whereof, the requirement of
educational qualification was done away with for the purpose of
2026:HHC:42285
promotion and certain categories which were earlier not included as
feeder categories like Photo Type Setter Operators, who did not had
any promotional avenues, were also included in the zone of
consideration. It is also evident from the reply filed by the
Department, as submitted by the learned Assistant Advocate
General that the post in question in fact was not vacant and was
occupied till July, 2025.
9.
It is also a matter of record that the persons, who are
likely to be affected in case any relief, as is prayed for by the
petitioner, is granted to him, have not been impleaded as party
respondents. It cannot be the case of the petitioner that he is not
aware as to who all are there eligible now for promotion to the post in
issue and thus, there is merit in the contention of the learned
Assistant Advocate General that the petition indeed is bad for nonjoinder of necessary parties.
10.
Be that as it may, the justification which has been given
by the State in the reply as to why the 2024 Rules were brought into
force is a cogent and valid explanation. The petitioner has failed to
substantiate that the impugned Notification was brought into force,
as tailor-made to suit some ineligible incumbents, as was alleged
before this Court. In fact, no material has been placed before this
Court from which such as inference can be drawn.
11.
Even otherwise, it is settled law that questions relating
2026:HHC:42285
to constitution, pattern, nomenclature, cadres, categories, creation,
abolition, prescription of qualification and other conditions of service
including avenues of promotion and criteria to be fulfilled for such
promotion pertain to the field of Policy and is within the exclusive
discretion and jurisdiction of the State, subject of course to the
limitation or restrictions envisaged in the Constitution of India. It is
not for statutory Tribunals etc. to direct the Government to have a
particular method of recruitment or eligibility criteria or avenues of
promotion or impose itself by substituting its view for that of the
State. This has been clearly laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
of India in P.U. Joshi and Others vs. Accountant General, Ahmedabad
and Others along with connected matter, (2003) 2 Supreme Court
Cases 632.
12.
In the present case, otherwise also, it is not as if on
account of the impugned Notification, the right of the petitioner of
promotion has been taken away. The petitioner still has the right of
promotion and this, of course, will be subject to his overall seniority
and fulfillment of the conditions of promotion as and when the post
becomes available and the Department of Promotion Committee is
constituted.
13.
It is settled law that an employee does not have any
fundamental right of promotion and the only fundamental right is to
be considered for such promotion. Herein, it is not the case of the
2026:HHC:42285
petitioner that this fundamental right of his has been breached by
ignoring him for promotionto the post in issue, as his only grievance
is that by doing away with the qualification criteria for the purpose
of promotion, those who were earlier ineligible, have been made
eligible for promotion to the post in issue. As observed herein above
also, as the same is a Policy decision which was taken by the
Department concerned and as it could not be demonstrated before
this Court that issuance of impugned Notification dated 27.07.2010
(Annexure P-4) was either an arbitrary act or an act of colorable
exercise of power or on account of some malafide, this writ petition
being devoid of any merit is dismissed, so also ending miscellaneous
application(s), if any.
(Ajay Mohan Goel)
Judge
(Yogesh Jaswal)
Judge
September 30, 2026
(Rishi)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review