Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~41 to 43 & 53
*
+
~42
+
~43
+
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 28th January, 2026
Uploaded on: 2nd February, 2026
W.P.(C) 10532/2021&CM APPL. 18595/2022, CM APPL.
32535/2022, CM APPL. 36129/2024, CM APPL. 64839/2024, CM
APPL. 64862/2024, CM APPL. 69047/2025
THE NAVAL TECHNICAL OFFICERS CGHS LTD.....Petitioner
Through:
versus
THE REGISTRAR OF COOPERATIVE SOCIETIES
.....Respondent
Through:
W.P.(C) 10652/2022&CM APPL. 30896/2022
MADAN GOPAL AGARWAL
.....Petitioner
Through:
versus
REGISTRAR OF CO-OPEARTIVE SOCIETIES & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through:
W.P.(C) 19260/2025&CM APPL. 5701/2026
NAVAL TECHNICAL OFFICERS CO-OPERATIVE GROUP
HOUSING SOCIETY LIMITED
.....Petitioner
Through:
versus
REGISTRAR CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
.....Respondent
Through:
AND
W.P.(C) 1147/2026&CM APPL. 5597/2026
NAND KISHOR
.....Petitioner
Through:
versus
THE REGISTRAR OF COOPERATIVE SOCIETY & ANR.
.....Respondents
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
Through:
Appearances:
For Petitioners:
Mr. Vivek Kumar Tandon, Ms. Ritu Rajput, Ms. Laxmi Gupta, Advs. in
Item.41
Mr Rahul Shukla Mr Ramandeep Singh Ms Bachita Baruah, Advs. in item 53.
For Respondents:
Mr. Vivek Kumar Tandon, Ms. Ritu Rajput, Ms. Laxmi Gupta, Advs. in item
nos. 42, 43 & 53
Mr Rahul Shukla Mr Ramandeep Singh Ms Bachita Baruah, Advs. for
Applicant.
Ms Urvi Mohan, Adv. in item nos. 41, 43 & 53.
Mr. Anubhav Gupta, Advocate, Panel Counsel ( Civil ) / GNCTD , Mr. Kartik
Sharma, Advs. for RCS in item nos. 41 & 53
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
Prathiba M. Singh, J.(Oral)
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
These are four writ petitions which relate to one Society i.e., Naval
Technical Officers Co-Operative Group Housing Society Limited (hereinafter
“the Society”), and various issues arising in respect of its membership.
3.
The litigation has a very long and chequered history. There are two
factions of Petitioners before the Court laying claim to the Society’s
membership and by extension on the Society itself. One faction consists of
officers who claim to have been working as ‘Technical Officers’ in the Naval
Department of the Central Government and are stated to have been the
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
original members. Whereas, on the other hand, there are the present members
of the Society. Accordingly, separate writs have been filed by the two factions
on behalf of the Society – both portraying as the REAL Society.
4.
The brief facts necessary for adjudication are that the Society itself was
registered way back in December, 1983, with an address at Sena Bhawan,
New Delhi. The actual total number of members who were there in the Society
is in dispute. The Society itself, originally, claimed to have 277 members
between 1983-97. It is stated that on 31st March, 1994, the Society was called
upon by the Registrar of Cooperative Societies (hereinafter “RCS”) for
verification of the final list of members. The relevant records were submitted
by the Society and a letter was sent on 17th October, 1997 by the RCS
attaching the list of 277 members for being transmitted to the Delhi
Development Authority (hereinafter “DDA”). The said letter of the RCS to
the DDA resulted in allotment of the subject land located at Plot No.3A,
Sector-23, Dwarka Phase-I, to the Society on 3rd June, 1998.
5.
In respect of the said allotment, a sum of approx. Rs. 2.56 crores was
deposited by the Society. In support of the same, a challan from the Central
Bank of India dated 15th July, 1998 has been placed on record. In the said
challan the address of the Society is mentioned as 212 D, Sena Bhawan, New
Delhi-110011. After this amount was deposited, the DDA vide its
communication dated 8th November, 2002, reduced the membership strength
of the Society from 277 to 238. This reduction has been alleged by the original
members to have been done fraudulently and to their detriment.
6.
It is stated that the original members having discovered the said alleged
manipulation filed a writ petition being W.P.(C) 21912/2005 titled Naval
Technical Officer G/H So Vs. Registrar Of Society & Anr. The prayer in the
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
said writ petition was as under:
“a) Issue appropriate writ directions, orders
directing the respondent No. 1 to decide the expulsion
issue of the members of the petitioner society.
b) Direct the respondent to determined the rights of
the members of the petitioner society and draw the
allotment of the flats amongst the genuine members
who are the subscribers to the memorandum.
c) Pass such other further orders as may deem fit and
proper in the facts and circumstances of the case and
in the interest of justice.”
7.
During the relevant period, certain irregularities were also unearthed in
the functioning of the RCS as also various other Housing Societies which led
to the filing of W.P.(C) 10066/2004 titled Yogi Raj Krishna Co-operative
Housing Society Vs. DDA & Ors. 2008:DHC:2139-DB.
8.
The writ petition filed by the original members of the Society was
tagged with the said Yogi Raj (supra) writ petition. Further to the directions
passed in the said petitions, a case was registered by the CBI being FIR No.
RC/DLI/2006/A/0064 on 29th December, 2006. Chargesheet was also filed
on 27th June, 2008 against certain individuals and concerned officials of the
RCS.
9.
In the members’ writ petition, the final order dated 27 th August, 2008
was passed in the following terms:
“Vide orders passed in WP(C)No. 10066/2004 titled
Yogi Raj Krishna Cooperative Group Housing Society
Vs. DDA and Anr. we have given certain directions with
regard to refund of the amount of Rs. 60,000/- out of the
sum of Rs. 75,000/- deposited in the High Court by the
petitioners in this case. Rs. 15,000/- were to be retained
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
for meeting the expenses of the Committee. Let a copy of
the said judgment be placed on the record of this case.
Mr. Anil Amrit, learned counsel on behalf of the
Intervenors, submits that the Intervenors are in control
of the records of the Society and they are the real
members. The issue of members eligible for the draw of
lots and their validity is to be gone into in terms of the
directions passed in the case of Yogi Raj Krishna CGHS.
This is common ground between the Intervenors as also
the petitioners. The only question surviving is with
regard to the deposit of Rs. 15,000/- to be made.
The amount of Rs. 60,000/- may be refunded to the
petitioner and the sum of Rs.15,000/- deposited by them
would be without prejudice to the rights and contentions
of either party.
The writ petition stands disposed of accordingly.”
10.
The above order, in effect, followed the directions passed in Yogi Raj
Krishna Co-operative Housing Society (supra) in respect of the Naval
Society as well. In the judgment in Yogi Raj Krishna Co-operative Housing
Society (supra), the Court had constituted a committee for verification of the
members. The operative portion of the said judgment dated 25th August, 2008
is extracted below:
“11. Having heard learned counsel representing
different viewpoints and considered the matter and the
progress made so far, we are of the view that this
gigantic task of verification needs to be performed by
those, who are conversant with the requirements and
Rules and can expeditiously deliver. We are conscious
of the fact that it was on account of complicity of former
staff and officers of Registrar of Cooperative Societies
that the defunct and bogus societies were revived and
passed on into the hands of builder mafia. Nevertheless,
the same cannot be a ground not to utilize the available
talent and expertise with the office of Registrar of
Cooperative Societies and its staff for the verification
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
especially when the same is also part of their statutory
responsibilities. We are of the view that the
apprehensions and misgivings, if any, on this account,
can be redressed by creation of a mechanism where the
verification carried out by the Registrar of Cooperative
Societies and the Rule Committee is reviewed and
approved by an independent Committee.
We are, therefore, of the view that rather than
entrusting the task of verification itself to the Committee
constituted by us, it would be appropriate if the task is
performed by the office of the Registrar, Cooperative
Societies and the Rule 90 Committee and is reviewed by
the Committee constituted by us. However, in view of the
developments noted earlier, the Committee also
requires to be re-constituted.
12. We accordingly re-constitute the Committee as
under:
1. Justice R.C. Chopra (retired) - Chairman
2. Mr.A.K. Malhotra, DIG, CBI - Member
3. Mr.G.S. Meena, Addl. Secretary, Land and Building
Deptt. - Member
The Committee is hereinafter referred to as Justice
Chopra’s Committee.
13. The verification of membership of the 58 Societies
excluding Ashadeep CGHS, i.e. 57 Societies, listed in
Annexure I, shall be carried out by the office of the
Registrar of Cooperative Societies and approved by the
Rule 90 Committee within time frame as agreed to
during the hearing. The broad modalities and procedure
to be followed is outlined as under:
(i) All the concerned Cooperative Societies shall furnish
all the information/documents along with the lists
of members in compliance of Schedule VII under
the DCS Rules, 2007 to the office of Registrar
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
within 15 days.
(ii) The concerned Cooperative Societies shall publish
a public notice in two leading daily newspapers of
NCT of Delhi, one each in English and Hindi
inviting objections on the proposal regarding
clearance of membership for allotment of
flats/plots by draw of lots as approved by
Registrar of Cooperative Societies.
(iii) Cooperative societies thereafter shall submit the
revised proposal, if any, within 30 days of
publication of public notice along with objections
received and comments
thereon to the
Registrar’s office. The Registrar shall dispose the
objections after hearing the parties/objectors, as
necessary, within 30 days.
(iv) The scrutiny of the documents furnished shall
thereafter be done by the Office of the Registrar of
Cooperative Societies and deficiency memo, if
any, will be issued to the society for removal of
deficiencies within a period of 15 days.
(v) After receipt of complete documents from the
societies, the documents will be scrutinized by the
Office of the Registrar within 15 days.
(vi) At the time of verification, a duly authorized person
of the concerned society shall be present along
with requisite documents in original as per clause
23 of Schedule VII.
(vii) After examining the office records of the proposal
submitted by the Cooperative Society and
documents, the matter shall be referred by the
Office of Registrar to the committee constituted
under Rule 90 of DCS Rules along with its
recommendations also taking into account inputs
by CBI for approval.
(viii) On receipt of recommendations, the Rule 90
Committee
shall
examine
and
review
recommendations made by Registrar of
Cooperative Societies and take a decision thereon
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
preferably within 15 days of receipt.
(ix) Report of the Registrar of Cooperative Societies
together with the Rule 90 Committee’s approval,
shall be placed before the Justice Chopra’s
Committee constituted by the Court comprising
Justice R.C. Chopra (retired), Mr.A.K. Malhotra,
DIG, CBI and Mr.G.S. Meena, Addl. Secretary,
Land and Building Deptt. for consideration,
review and approval. Justice Chopra’s Committee
shall consider the reports and recommendations
made and in its discretion, may approve, modify,
reject or remit the reports or any part thereof or
any recommendation as made. It would also be
open for the Justice Chopra’s Committee to hear
in its discretion any of the objectors or aggrieved
persons
and
seek
any
further
information/document or clarification that it may
require and take a decision thereon with regard to
the grievance of such a person, his entitlement,
eligibility or otherwise.
14. Justice Chopra’s Committee shall submit its report
regarding the approval, rejection, modification,
remission, rejection of the report of the Registrar and
the Rules Committee within two months of having
received the report and recommendations from the
Registrar and Rules Committee. The Court upon receipt
of the report of the Justice Chopra’s Committee together
with the recommendations from the Registrar of
Cooperative Societies and the report of Rule 90
Committee shall pass suitable orders and direct the
Registrar of Cooperative Societies to forward the list, as
approved, to DDA for draw of lots. ”
11.
As can be seen from a conjoint reading of the judgement passed in Yogi
Raj Krishna Co-operative Housing Society (supra) and the order dated 27th
August, 2008 passed in W.P.(C) 21912/2005, the Justice Chopra Committee
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
was to submit a report after which orders were to be passed for forwarding
the list to the DDA for draw of lots in the relevant Societies.
12.
From the events which have transpired, thereafter the Court is informed
that Justice Chopra had recused from the committee and thereafter another
committee comprising of Mr. K.K. Mathur and Mr. Y.D. Bankata was
constituted by the Delhi Government. The new Committee’s terms of
reference were as under:
“The terms of reference for the Committee are as
follows
:1. To suggest measures which could be taken
for verification of membership in such Cooperative
Group Housing Societies which have already held self
draw of lots in violation of DCS Act and Rules.
2. To suggest procedure for verification of membership
in such Cooperative Group Housing Societies, original
records of which have been misplaced by
the society/RCS
Office.
3. To suggest measures for verification of membership
in such Cooperative Group Housing Societies in which
charge sheets alleging various illegalities/irregularities
have been filed by the CBI in the competent court of law
and
are
pending
trial.
4. To suggest measures to ensure that matters which led
to
CBI
investigation
do
not
recur.
5. To suggest measures to strengthen the office of RCS
so as to enable it to meet the expectation of the people.
6. To examine the existing infrastructure in the office of
RCS and to suggest measures to improve the same.”
13.
The said Committee had considered the fact that there was a CBI
investigation which was pending and chargesheets were being filed in various
cases. While the said chargesheets were being filed and the CBI investigation
was going on, the Committee considered that the office of the RCS as also the
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
various members of the several Societies were facing complications and
difficulties. The report of the Committee records that delays have taken place
in the allotment of apartments despite land having been allotted. Some parts
of the Committee’s report are relevant and are extracted below:
“In this background, and particularly in the light
of various court proceedings, which are still going on,
the office of the RCS has been facing many
complications and controversies since the year 2005
and is indeed at a loss as to how to take further action
towards forwarding the Iist of members to the DDA in
regard to the societies which have been investigated by
the CBI.
According to the officers of the organization of the RCS,
the verification of the membership of the
CBI investigated societies could not be undertaken in
view of the fact that in the case of Yogiraj
Krishna Cooperative Group Housing Society Ltd. and
others Vs DDA and others, the High Court vide its order
dated 25-08-2008 had directed the office of the
Registrar, Cooperative Societies to keep in view the
findings of the CBI while verifying the membership of
the concemed societies. The chargesheets filed by the
CBI against these societies point to serious and gross
violations of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act, 1972
and Rules, 1973 which, inter alia, . include the
following:i) The societies had been wrongly revived by the
builders on the basis of forged and fake documents.
ii) The land was allotted to an entity, which
was cooperative society only for the namesake. The
funds were organized by the builders and not by the socalled members
of
the
societies.
iii) The societies did not have Managing Committees,
which were duly elected by the members. No election
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
was held and no meeting of Managing Committee was
held.
The
persons
enrolled
through
this
process could not be taken as members in
accordance with the provisions of the Delhi
Cooperative
Societies Act
and
Rules.
iv) The documents, including the membership register,
proceedings register, among others, were forged and
fabricated and the same could not be used for the
purpose of verification of the members as was directed
by the Court. In several societies, the documents had
been destroyed by the Managing Committee to evade
punitive action by the CBI.
In this state of affairs, inordinate delays have taken
place in allotment of apartments to the present members
of the societies. Many of these members had joined such
societies at a later date for meeting their genuine need
of a shelter in the city. For them, the delay has resulted
in great hardship on account of the lack of a residential
accommodation and has also caused great financial
burden as many of them are reported to have taken bank
loans, etc. for meeting financial requirements in this
regard.
APPROACH
The assessment of this Committee is that we have
to identify pragmatic solutions to the problems
indicated above, which, while sorting out the difficulties
of the genuine members of the concerned cooperative
societies are in line with the various orders passed by
the High Court and which can be worked out within
the overall framework of the DCS Act and Rules.”
14.
The Committee then considered various measures that were to be taken
for verification and other aspects. The relevant recommendations of the
Committee are as under:
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
Sr.
Finding
Relevant Recommendations
No.
1.
2.
To
suggest
measures
which
could be taken for
verification
of
membership in such
Cooperative Group
Housing Societies
which have already
held self draw of
lots in violation of
DCS Act and Rules.
While we were deliberating on this issue during the
various meetings of our Committee, we learnt that the
Government of NCT of Delhi has in principle taken a
decision that the RCS should forward the list of even
those societies to the DOA where there have been self
draws of lots.
We would suggest that for further processing of this
matter, the Office of RCS, in particular, and the Govt. of
NCT of Delhi, in general, need to keep the following
factors in view:(i) While the membership in even CBI investigated
societies is regularized by the DOA, the individual , I
members and other office bearers of the societies who
have been named by the CBI in the chargsheets should
not get the benefit of such regularization till the criminal
cases pending against them are finally decided.
(ii) Indemnity Bonds may be taken from each member
as has been ordered by the High Court in various cases
before any regularization.
(iii) While members of societies, who ,have resorted to
self draw, could be given the benefit of provisional
regularization to ameliorate their long suffering, it would
be prudent to impose a reasonable charge in money
terms on them before any regularization , so that it acts
as a deterrent in such cases for the future. [...]
(iv) In regard to the CBI investigated societies, the
special order under Section 127 of the DCS Act, 2003
needs to also lay down that till such time as the particular
society gets a clean chit from the courts, neither the
Society as a whole nor- its individual members would be
allowed to sell/transfer the apartments to any new
person/member.
To
suggest [...]Our committee has been informed that in many
procedure
for Cooperative Group Housing Societies in question all the
verification
of relevant records are not available. Although, there is no
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
membership in such
Cooperative Group
Housing Societies,
original records of
which
have
been
misplaced by the
society/RCS
3.
To
suggest
measures
for
verification of
membership in such
cooperative GHS in
which charge sheets
alleging
various
irregularities/illegal
ities have been filed
by the CBI in the
doubt that for the office of the Registrar, Cooperative
Societies to take further action in such cases smoothly
the availability and reliability of the relevant records
would have been a great help, nevertheless, in the
present situation of absence of the relevant record some
pragmatic solution to this problem has to be thought out.
We feel that in all such cases at least three types of
records could be obtained. Firstly, the member in
question needs to produce some proof of his residence as
required by law for enrolment in such societies. For this,
many different types of evidence can be taken into
account, such as Ration Card, Election ID card,
electricity bill, bank account, passport, etc. Secondly, the
audit reports tiled by societies with the RCS also indicate
the list of members and the payments made by them. If
such audit reports are conducted timely, they can be
taken as satisfactory evidence for the entitlement of
members in question and the payments made by them.
Thirdly, the bank record of the payments made by the
members of the society are a good corroborative
evidence. The bank account record of individual
members, of course, needs to match with the banking
record of the concerned society.
Indeed, as suggested above, the Office of the RCS could
proceed further in such cases of non availability of the
required records with the societies if some proof of
residence and actual payment to the society through the
banks is available for the relevant period.
3. To suggest measures for verification of membership
in such cooperative GHS in which charge sheets alleging
various irregularities/illegalities haye been filed by the
CBI in the competent court of law and are pending trial
We presume that under this term of reference, we have
to consider cases where the societies have the relevant
records which need be maintained under the Act and
Rules, but on which it is not possible to rely on account
of the fact that these societies have been investigated by
the CBI and there are many allegations of forgery and
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
competent court of manipulation, We, as a Committee, have consciously
law and are pending decided not to make any specific suggestions in this
trial
regard because we find that this matter has been agitated
before the High Court in two cases, viz. Rajvihar
Cooperative Group Housing Society Ltd. Vs. RCS and
Jayabhawani Cooperative Group Housing Society Ltd.
Vs. RCS. In the case of Rajvihar CGHS, the High Court
has directed that the allotment shall be subject to thee
following conditions:
(a) It would be provisional in nature at present.
(b) All the members would file an affidavit of indemnity
within two weeks by giving undertaking to the Registrar
of Cooperative Societies to the effect that if promoter
members come forward and stake claim for the allotment
for these flats and obtain favourable order from the
competent court of law, these members shall abide by
those orders.
15.
This report was then placed before the Competent Authority i.e., the
then Hon’ble Lieutenant Governor (hereinafter “Hon’ble LG”) who vide a
file noting dated 20th September, 2011 passed the following direction:
“I have perused the file.
The notification to regularize the draw of lots of 26
societies and proposal for withdrawal of proceedings
for supersession u/s 37 of the DCS Act are approved.
The permission to invite other societies which might
have conducted self draw before 2010 to give them
opportunity for regularization is also given.
I do not favour debarment of office bearers u/s 77(2) of
DCS Act since the draws were held with the consent of
all members and the outcomes were accepted
unanimously. Evidently, no irregularity other than
procedural, was involved.
Regarding the imposition of charges in money terms on
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
the members, the recommendation of the Mathur
Committee on this issue, as already approved, should be
followed.”
16.
Pursuant to the above order of the Competent Authority, the order dated
17th October, 2011 was issued in the following terms:
“ORDER
No. F. 47/86/RCS/Policy/2009/PF/- In exercise of
the powers conferred by section 127 of Delhi
Cooperative Societies Act, 2003 (Delhi Act No.3,
of
2004),
the
Lt.
Governor of the National Capital Territory of
Delhi is pleased to regularize the self-draw
conducted by the following 26 Cooperative
Housing Societies from the operation of sub
section (1) of section 77 of the said Act by giving
one-time exemption, namely:1. Air India CGHS Ltd.
2. Appu Enclave CGHS Ltd.
3. Baroda House NRI CGHS Ltd.
4. Batukji CGHS Ltd.
5. Bharat Jagriti CGHS Ltd.
6. Chitrakootdham CGHS Ltd,
7. Crown CGHS Ltd.
8. Delhi Apartment CGHS Ltd.
9. IDC CGHS Ltd. (Subject to outcome of SLP
NO.4802-03/2011)
10. Karuna Vihar CGHS Ltd.
11.Khattar CGHS Ltd.
12.Mahajan Shree CGHS Ltd.
13.Maharani Aventibar CGHS
14.Mahavir CGHS Ltd.
15.Manisha CGHS Ltd.
16. Naval Technical Officers CGHS Ltd.
17.Pragti Sheel Bharva CGHS Ltd.
18.S.B. Youth CGHS Ltd
19.Sanchar Vihar CGHS Ltd.
20.Sant Sunder Dassji CGHS Ltd.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
21.Sapna Ghar CGHS Ltd.
22.Saptaparni CGHS Lid.
23.Sarve Satyam CGHS Ltd.
24. Satyam CGHS Ltd.
25.Shree New Anamika CGHS Ltd
26.Shri Radha Krishna CGHS Ltd.
(1) However, the members and other office
bearers of the CBI investigated societies who have
been charge sheeted by CBI shall not get the
benefit of such regularization and their names
shall not be sent to DDA till the criminal cases
pending against them are finally decided as in the
case of other CBI investigated societies.
(2) The allotment would be provisional in nature
and indemnity bond on non-judicial stamp paper
of Rs. 100/- has to be submitted by members as
well as President/ Secretary of the society.
Separate affidavit has to be filed by the members
& Secretary of the society to the effect that they
had no objection to the manner of conduct &
outcome
of
the
self
draw.
(3) The regularization of self draw shall be
subject to payment of penalty by each member
who have carried out self draw without the
approval
of
RCS
as follows: 1. Owners of 02 bedrooms houses - Rs.15000/2. Owners of 03 bedrooms houses - Rs.20000/3. Owners of 04 bedrooms houses - Rs.25000/-
17.
(4) - One time exemption in r/o self draw society
is restricted only up to the provision of section
77(1) of DCS Act, 2003. ”
Thus, the initial reduction of members from 277 to 238 and the
irregularities, etc. are now the subject matter of the CBI investigation where
a chargesheet has been filed.
18.
In the meantime, however, pursuant to the order dated 17 th October,
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
2011 passed by the GNCTD, the then present Managing Committee of the
Society had collected the membership amounts, the respective apartments
have been built and possession has also been handed over to the concerned
members.
19.
In the meantime, the elections for the Managing Committee of the
Society were also conducted and an Administrator was appointed. The said
Administrator made various allegations against some of the individuals who
had come in control of the Society. A writ petition was also filed being
W.P.(C) 6433/2011 titled The Naval Technical Officers Co-operative Group
Housing Society (CGHS) vs. The Registrar of Cooperative Societies (RCS)
New Delhi & Anr. The allegations in this writ petition were against one Mr.
Anil Motwani and certain other members. The relevant portions of the writ
are captured herein below:
“That the petitioner-herein had filed an application
dated 28.07.2011 to the R-1 thereby bringing to the
notice of the RCS Office various illegal actions by a
section / group of members. The said section / group of
members is headed by Sh. M.G. Motwani who keeps on
instigating the other members against the CGHS. The
names of the members against whom action was sought
are:
1.
Sh.
Anil
Motwani
(M-527)
2.
Sh.
M.G.
Agarwal
(M-578)
3.
Sh.
Sanjay
Gandhi
(M-658)
4.
Sh.
I.S.S.H.
Prashad
(M-606)
5.
Sh.
Jasmeet
Singh
(M-565)
6.
Smt.
Anita
Vaishnev
(M-564)
7. Maj. V.S. Sankhla & Brig. (retd.) V.S Sankhla (M600)
8. Smt. Monika Nigan & Sh. Manoj Nigam (M-666)
9. Smt. Rajinder Kaur & Sh. Avtar Singh (M-613)
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
10. Smt. Suman Godar & Sh. Gautam Godara (M546).
11. Sh. Vikram Singh Negi & Smt. Kavita Negi (M670)
12.
Sh.
R.K.
Mehta
(M-562)
19. Sh. Ashok Kumar Gupta (M-545)
13.
That the above-enumerated members have
been indulging in the activities which are detrimental to
the interest of the CGHS. On 10.01.2010 a group of
persons under the Chairmanship of Sh. Anil Kumar
Motwani conducted illegal draw of lots. Sh.
M.G.Motwani was the coordinator. The Ex-Managing
Committee had expelled the said persons u/s 86(1)(c) of
the DCS Act, 2008 r/w Rule 99 of the DCS Rules 2007
but the same was not approved due to the procedural
lapses.
14.
That the section / group headed by Sh. M.G.
Motwani had also been associated illegal activities
when forcible possessions were taken of the flats without
any draw of lots. On 20.02.2011 in the morning at about
9:30 A.M. some 60-70 people entered the society
premises and forcibly snatched the flat keys from
Guddu, the store-keeper. They broke open the locks of
some of the flat and put their own locks. They also
deployed their own security. A bogus allotment was
signed by Sh. I.S.S.H, Prashad (M-606), Sh. Jasmeet
Singh (M566), Smt. Anita Vaishnav (M-564). A copy of
the "bogus" allotment letter is annexed herewith and
marked as Annexure:P-2”
20.
In this writ petition filed by the Administrator, vide order dated 2nd
September, 2011, the Court directed as under:
“xxx
xxx
xxx
It is agreed that the petition can be disposed of with the
direction that no member of the petitioner Society shall
be permitted to take possession of the flats in
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
pursuance of any self-draw and in case such
possession has been taken as identified by the
Administrator they shall be sealed. The possession
shall be handed over only after a draw of lots is carried
out by the DDA after the names are forwarded through
the Registrar, Cooperative Societies in accordance with
law. No meetings as are alleged to be taking place shall
be permitted in the premises of the Society. Respondent
No.Z/SHO of the local police station to give all
assistance for due compliance of the order.
Learned counsel for respondent No.1 further assures
that a decision will be taken on the application filed by
the Administrator under Sections: 118 (7) and 77(2) of
the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act, 2003 on 20.7:201.1
within a period of one (1) month from today.
The writ petition and the application accordingly stand
disposed of.”
21.
As per the above order, the possession of the flats in the Society was
not to be given to any of the members upon conducting self-draw of lots. The
DDA was to carry out a fresh draw of lots, and no meetings were to be held
in the Society. Unfortunately, however, the said order never came to be given
effect to, as subsequent to this order, the order of the Competent Authority
dated 17th October, 2011 extracted above came to be passed, whereby one
time regularisation was directed of the self-draw conducted by various
societies including the subject Society. Thus, the order dated 2 nd September,
2011 has just remained unimplemented.
22.
The stand of Mr. Tandon, ld. Counsel appearing for the Society now is
that the Society has a total of 238 flats and all have been occupied. The stand
of Mr. Agnihotri, ld. Counsel for the original members is that in the entire
process the wrongdoers have benefited and the original members have not
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
been able to enjoy the membership of the Society, who have been left
completely high and dry without any flats.
23.
The stand of the RCS is that the order dated 2nd September, 2011 passed
in W.P.(C) 6433/2011 has merged with the final order given by the GNCTD
dated 17th October, 2011 in which the self-draw was regularized following the
KK Mathur report.
24.
Having heard the ld. Counsels for the parties and having perused the
record, the ultimate situation that now emerges is that the verification of
individual members has not been carried out till date.
25.
At this stage, it is submitted by Mr. Tandon, ld. Counsel, that the RCS
has carried out the verification in terms of the order dated 5 th May, 2015 in
W.P.(C) 519/2012 titled Manohar Lal & Anr. V. The Registrar, Co-op.
Group Housing Society and Ors. In the said writ petition, the following order
had been passed:
“45. We consequently find substance in the
submission of learned counsel for the respondents that
in issuance of the notification dated 17" October, 2011,
the Government has taken a careful view after
application of mind to the facts which emerged by
deciding to exempt the 26 societies from the
applicability of Section 77 of the Act and regularising
the centre of place. We see that the respondents have
issued the notification carefully inasmuch as the
notification has excluded members and other office
bearers of the CBI investigating societies who have
been charge-sheeted by theCBI shall not get the benefit
of such regularisation and their names shall not be sent
to the DDA till criminal cases pending against them are
finally decided. The regularisation is subject to payment
of penalties for the self draw which have been
prescribed. The exemption is only one time and
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
restricted to the application of the provisions of Section
77(i) of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act, 2003.
46. It is also explicit that the one time exemption is
restricted only to the provisions of Section 77(i) of the
Delhi Cooperative Societies Act, 2003. Inherent therein
is the statutory requirement that all other provisions of
the statute which had to be satisfied. The Registrar of
Cooperative Societies is therefore required to conduct
the necessary verification for eligibility in accordance
with Schedule (vii) of the Delhi Cooperative Societies
Rules, 2007. Apart from this requirement, the indemnity
bonds have to be submitted by the members as well as
the president/secretary of the society. An affidavit has to
be filed by the members as well as the secretary of the
respondent no. 4 to the effect that they have no objection
to the manner of conduct and outcome of the self-draw.”
26.
Pursuant to this order, the verification is alleged to have been carried
out by the RCS. The issue relating to membership had got quite complicated
as the share certificates which have been issued qua the Society are to the tune
of 672 against the strength of 238 members. The peculiarities of this Society
have also been recorded therein which are as under:
“9. The complexity/ peculiarity of this society are:
(i) that the count of total membership as per serial
number of the share certificates has gone upto 672
against a freeze strength of 238 members.
(ii) Though the self draw was stated to be conducted on
10.01.2010 and the same was regularized by
notification dated 17 10.2011 in respect of 26 societies,
the result sheet of the draw is not traceable on record or
with the society. However, no controversy among the
members has come to notice regaining the occupancy of
the flats.
(iii) The original records of the society for the purpose
of verification as per Schedule Vil are not available with
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
the society which in turn has relied on information
available in the record of RCS..”
27.
In the verification process, the allegation is that the original members
were never called for a hearing. The list of joint members, etc. have all been
set out in the noting which has been placed on record through the RCS and
ultimately, the finding of the RCS is that 211 members have been cleared for
membership and regularization of self-draw to the DDA. This exercise which
has been conducted by the RCS on 26th October, 2018 and thereafter approved
in 2019 is not under challenge by any of the parties. The original members
claim that they were not aware of this exercise being conducted by the RCS
and in fact one writ petition i.e., W.P.(C) 10532/2021 has been filed seeking
approval for the remaining members as well.
28.
In view of the above, the ultimate conclusion is that:
i)
In respect of the irregularities with the Societies, the CBI has
already filed its chargesheet and the trial has to now proceed therein;
ii)
Insofar as verification of members is concerned, the RCS has
conducted its verification vide a detailed noting and report and has
forwarded the names of 211 members for allotment to the DDA.
iii)
Both the Society and the original members are aggrieved by this
noting. The grievance of the Society that the remaining members ought
to be regularised. The grievance of the original members is that they
were not given a hearing and they have been deprived of membership
– despite being the original members.
29.
In terms of the Section 112 of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act,
2003, all the aggrieved persons are free to file an appeal against this
recommendation of the RCS dated 26th October, 2018. However, at this stage,
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
the prayer for verification of membership in these writ petitions would
therefore no longer sustain. All the aggrieved parties would have to avail of
their remedies as per law in respect of the recommendation by the RCS. The
said appellate remedy can be availed of, both by the original members and by
the excluded members.
30.
Accordingly, the parties are free to avail of their appellate remedy
challenging the verification process which has been undertaken by the RCS
in terms of the noting as annexed as Annexure P-6 in W.P.(C) 10532/2021
during the period 2018-19. If such an appeal is filed by 30th April, 2026 before
the Delhi Cooperative Tribunal (hereinafter ‘DCT’), the said appeal shall be
adjudicated in accordance with law. The Society as also the original members
are permitted to file such appeals.
31.
In the counter affidavit of the RCS, insofar as 211 members are
concerned, there are stated to be certain discrepancies. The said discrepancies
may be pointed out to the DCT in the appeal which may be filed.
32.
The DCT shall now take a comprehensive decision in respect of the
entire membership of this Society in accordance with law and decide the same
by 31st December, 2026. Anything observed herein, shall not bind the final
decision of the RCS, who is free to examine all the relevant documents and
then finalise the membership of the Society.
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
33.
All these writ petitions are disposed of in the above terms. All pending
applications, if any, are also disposed of.
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
MADHU JAIN
JUDGE
JANUARY 28, 2026
Rahul/msh
Digitally Signed
By:RAHUL
17:34:21
W.P.(C) 10532/2021 & connected matters
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review