Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:18647-DB
ALOK SHARMA
Date: 2026.05.05
10:44:52 +0530
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 2149 of 2024
1 - Naval Dubey S/o Late Ramgopal Dubey Aged About 19 Years R/o
Katipyapara, Juna Bilaspur, Behind Santoshi Mandir, Distt. Bilaspur
Chhattisgarh
... Appellant(s)
versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through The Distt. Magistrate - Bilaspur
Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Raj Kumar Gupta, Advocate.
For Respondent/State : Mr. N. K. Jaiswal, Dy. Govt. Advocate.
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice.
23/04/2026
1.
Though the matter is listed for hearing on I.A. No. 01, which is an
application for suspension of sentence and grant of bail to the
appellant, however, considering the fact that the appellant is in jail
since 18.07.2020 and with the consent of learned counsel for the
parties, the appeal is heard finally. Accordingly, I.A. No. 01,
stands disposed of.
2.
The present appeal has been filed under Section 415(2) of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short, “BNSS”),
against the impugned judgment of conviction and order of
sentence dated 28.10.2024 passed by the learned Second
Additional Sessions Judge, Bilaspur, District Bilaspur (C.G.), in
Sessions Case No. 28/2021, whereby the appellant has been
convicted for the offence under Section 302 of the Indian Penal
Code and sentenced to life imprisonment along with a fine of Rs.
1,000/-, and in default of payment of fine, to undergo additional
rigorous imprisonment for a period of one year.
3.
Brief facts of the case are that the deceased, Pradip Verma, was
the brother of the complainant, Sumati Verma (PW-1). On
17.07.2020, at about 23:45 to 23:50 hours, the appellant, Naval
Dubey, assaulted the deceased with a sharp-edged weapon
(folding knife) near Diamond Kirana Store, Bhaipara, following a
prior dispute. On 18.07.2020 at about 04:00 a.m., the deceased
succumbed to his injuries during treatment at Care & Cure
Hospital. On 18.07.2020 at 08:00 a.m., the complainant, Sumati
Verma (PW-1), lodged the FIR (Ex. P/1) at Police Station City
Kotwali, Bilaspur. Based on the oral report, the police registered
an offence under Section 302 of the IPC against the appellant.
The merg intimation (Ex. P/2) was recorded, and the inquest (Ex.
P/5) over the dead body was prepared in the presence of
witnesses. The dead body was thereafter sent for post-mortem to
CIMS, Bilaspur, where PW-15, Dr. R.K. Markam, conducted the
autopsy and submitted his report (Ex. P/6).
4.
During the post-mortem examination, the doctor found the
following injuries on the body of the deceased:
5.
•
A stab wound measuring 2 × 0.5 × 8 cm on the
upper part of the body, slightly towards the left side,
with dried blood trailing over the chest, abdomen,
and back.
•
An incised wound measuring 4 × 2 × 0.5 cm on the
posterior aspect of the left arm.
•
An incised wound measuring 2 × 0.5 × 0.5 cm on
the right forearm.
On internal examination, the doctor found a cut injury measuring 1
cm on the small intestine and another cut injury measuring 1 cm
on the large intestine. Approximately 2 liters of blood had
accumulated in the abdominal cavity due to the internal injuries.
6.
After conducting the post-mortem, the doctor opined that the
death was caused by a stab injury to the abdomen and the
resulting hemorrhage. The duration of death was opined to be
since the time of treatment/admission on the intervening night of
17th and 18th July, 2020, and the nature of death was homicidal.
7.
The spot map (Ex. P/3) was prepared by the Patwari, and the
police also prepared a spot map (Ex. P/5). Blood-stained and
plain soil, as well as a sharp-edged folding knife, were seized vide
seizure memos (Ex. P/12 and Ex. P/14), respectively. The clothes
of the deceased and blood-stained bandages received from the
hospital were seized vide seizure memo (Ex. P/13).
8.
The seized knife was sent for query to the doctor who conducted
the post-mortem, and the doctor submitted his query report (Ex.
P/16), wherein he opined that the death may be possible by the
present knife.
9.
The blood-stained and plain soil, the folding knife seized from the
accused, and the clothes of both the deceased and the accused
were sent for chemical examination to the Forensic Science
Laboratory. The FSL report (Ex. P/29) was received, according to
which human blood was detected on the blood-stained soil, the
steel knife, the yellow T-shirt and jeans of the appellant, as well as
on the clothes of the deceased. The blood group found on the
seized knife and on the clothes of the appellant was reported to
be consistent with that of the deceased.
10.
The appellant was arrested on 18.07.2020, and his memorandum
statement (Ex. P/11) was recorded. The statements of witnesses
under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. were also recorded. Upon
completion of the usual investigation, a charge-sheet was filed
before the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Bilaspur, for the
offence under Section 302 of the IPC. The case was thereafter
committed to the Court of the learned Sessions Judge, Bilaspur,
for trial.
11.
The learned trial Court framed a charge against the appellant
under Section 302 of the IPC. The appellant denied the charge
and claimed trial.
12.
In order to prove the charge, the prosecution examined as many
as 26 witnesses. The statement of the appellant under Section
313 of the Cr.P.C. was recorded, wherein he denied all the
incriminating circumstances appearing against him, pleaded
innocence, and stated that he had been falsely implicated. He did
not lead any evidence in his defence.
13.
Upon appreciation of the oral as well as documentary evidence
adduced by the prosecution, the learned trial Court convicted the
appellant and sentenced him as stated in the earlier part of this
judgment. Hence, the present appeal.
14.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the prosecution
has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. It is argued
that there are material omissions and contradictions in the
evidence of the prosecution witnesses, which render it unsafe to
base a conviction thereon. Although the prosecution projected
PW-4 Rahul Goswami, PW-5 Kanha, PW-6 Manoj Sarthi, and
PW-7 Ukesh Sahu as eyewitnesses, all of them have turned
hostile during cross-examination and have specifically stated that
they did not witness the appellant assaulting the deceased.
15.
It is further submitted that these witnesses have admitted that
their statements were obtained under police pressure and
physical duress. It is contended that the independent witnesses to
the memorandum and seizure, namely PW-12 Jana Verma and
PW-14 Chandrakant Verma, have also not fully supported the
prosecution case, with PW-14 admitting that his signatures were
obtained at the police station.
16.
It is also argued that there is no evidence of any culpable intention
or motive on the part of the appellant to commit murder, and the
defence has put forth a plausible theory regarding the presence of
two other unknown persons at the spot. The alleged delay in
lodging the FIR, coupled with the failure of the Investigating
Officer to seize relevant medical records from CIMS Hospital or to
record the statements of independent neighbours and hospital
staff,
creates
serious
doubts
about
the
fairness
of the
investigation.
17.
According to learned counsel, the evidence on record is
insufficient to sustain the conviction of the appellant; therefore, he
is entitled to be acquitted of the charges.
18.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the State opposes the
appeal and submits that the prosecution has proved its case
beyond reasonable doubt. It is contended that the evidence
adduced by the prosecution, particularly the medical and forensic
evidence, unerringly points to the guilt of the appellant in
committing the murder of the deceased. The nature of the injuries
found on the body of the deceased, especially the deep stab
wound to the abdomen causing rupture of the intestines and
resulting in significant internal bleeding of approximately two litres,
clearly indicates that the assault was intentional and sufficient in
the ordinary course of nature to cause death. The medical
evidence of PW-15 Dr. R. K. Markam establishes that the injuries
were homicidal in nature and were caused by a sharp-edged
weapon.
19.
It is further submitted that the initial testimony of the eyewitnesses
(PW-4 to PW-7), though they later turned hostile during crossexamination, provides a consistent account regarding the
presence and involvement of the appellant at the scene of
occurrence. Their presence near Diamond Kirana Store is natural,
and the prompt lodging of the FIR within a short span after the
death minimizes the possibility of fabrication. Moreover, the FSL
report (Ex. P/29) lends scientific corroboration, as it confirms the
presence of human blood on the seized folding knife and on the
appellant’s clothes, which is consistent with the blood group of the
deceased.
20.
Therefore, it is submitted that there is sufficient, cogent, and
clinching evidence against the appellant to sustain his conviction,
and the appeal is liable to be dismissed.
21.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record of the case.
22.
The first question for consideration is whether the trial Court was
justified in holding that the death of the deceased, Pradip Verma,
was homicidal in nature?
23.
The trial Court, relying upon the testimony of Dr. R. K. Markam
(PW-15), who conducted the post-mortem examination on the
body of the deceased, Pradip Verma, recorded that during the
post-mortem he found the following injuries: (i) a stab wound
measuring 2 × 0.5 × 8 cm on the upper part of the body, slightly
towards the left side; (ii) an incised injury measuring 4 × 2 × 0.5
cm on the posterior aspect of the left arm; (iii) an incised injury
measuring 2 × 0.5 × 0.5 cm on the right forearm; (iv) on internal
examination, a 1 cm cut injury on the small intestine and a 1 cm
cut injury on the large intestine; and (v) approximately 2 litres of
blood accumulated in the abdominal cavity.
24.
In his report (Ex. P/6), the doctor opined that the cause of death
was due to stab injury in the abdomen & excessive bleeding from
the injuries, and that the death was homicidal in nature. The said
finding recorded by the trial Court is a finding of fact based on the
evidence available on record, which is neither perverse nor
contrary to the record. Even otherwise, the same has not been
seriously disputed by learned counsel for the appellant. We,
therefore, affirm the said finding.
25.
Now, the question for consideration is whether the death of the
deceased, Pradip Verma, occurred as a result of the injuries
caused by the accused by stabbing him in the abdomen with a
folding knife, and whether the accused, with the intention of
causing his death, inflicted the injuries as detailed in the postmortem report and the testimony of the medical expert.
26.
Kaushal Dewangan (PW-3) stated that on the date of the incident,
at about 11:00–11:30 p.m., he was present near Diamond Kirana
Store along with his friends. He deposed that the accused, Naval
Dubey, was standing at some distance and talking on the phone.
In the meantime, the deceased, Pradip Verma, arrived there on a
bicycle and a conversation took place between them. Thereafter,
two other persons also came to the spot. According to this
witness, the accused left the place, and upon hearing a sound, he
went towards the spot and found the deceased lying on the
ground in an injured condition. He immediately informed the family
members of the deceased, and the injured was taken to the
hospital. The witness was declared hostile and did not support the
prosecution case regarding the actual assault; however, he has
admitted his presence at the place of occurrence and the fact that
the deceased was found injured. His testimony, to that extent,
corroborates the occurrence of the incident and is found to be
reliable.
27.
Sumati Verma (PW-1) stated that the incident occurred on the
intervening night of 17/18.07.2020. Upon receiving information, he
reached the spot near Diamond Kirana Store and found his
brother, Pradip Verma, lying in an injured condition. The injured
was immediately taken to CIMS Hospital, Bilaspur, and thereafter
to Care & Cure Hospital, where he succumbed to his injuries. He
lodged the First Information Report (Ex. P/1). He further stated
that prior to the incident, there had been a dispute between the
accused and the deceased. Despite lengthy cross-examination,
his testimony regarding the circumstances of the incident and the
identity of the accused remains consistent and is duly
corroborated by the medical evidence. Therefore, his testimony is
found to be reliable.
28.
Rahul Goswami (PW-4) stated that he was present near Diamond
Kirana Store along with his friends at the time of the incident. He
deposed that the accused and the deceased were present there
and that an altercation took place between them. In his
examination-in-chief, he stated that the accused assaulted the
deceased with a knife and thereafter fled from the spot. Although,
in his cross-examination, he stated that he did not witness the
actual assault, but he has not denied his presence at the spot or
the presence of the accused at the relevant time. His testimony, to
the extent it supports the presence of the accused and the
occurrence of the incident, is consistent with the other evidence
on record and is found to be reliable.
29.
Kanha (PW-5) and Manoj Sarthi (PW-6) stated that they were
present near Diamond Kirana Store along with other persons at
the time of the incident. They deposed that the accused and the
deceased were present there and that a quarrel took place
between them and the appellant gave a knife blow upon the
deceased. Although they did not fully support the prosecution
case during cross-examination and declared hostile, and stated
that they did not see the actual assault, but they have admitted
their presence at the spot and the fact that the deceased was
found injured immediately thereafter. Their testimony establishes
the presence of the accused at the scene and the circumstances
in which the deceased sustained injuries.
30.
Nimmit Kushwaha (PW-10) stated that he was present near the
place of occurrence and, upon hearing commotion, he saw the
deceased lying in an injured condition. He also stated that the
accused was present at the spot and thereafter fled. Although he
did not witness the actual assault, his testimony regarding the
presence of the accused and the condition of the deceased
immediately after the incident provides an important corroborative
link in the chain of circumstances.
31.
Jana Verma (PW-12) and Chandrakant Verma (PW-14) are
witnesses to the memorandum statement (Ex. P/11) and seizure
(Ex. P/14). They stated that the accused, while in custody, made a
disclosure statement leading to the recovery of a folding knife and
clothes. Although PW-14 stated that his signatures were obtained
at the police station, the recovery at the instance of the accused
stands proved through the testimony of PW-12 and the
Investigating Officer. The said recovery is admissible under
Section 27 of the Evidence Act and connects the accused with the
weapon used in the commission of the offence.
32.
Dr. R. K. Markam (PW-15), who conducted the post-mortem,
deposed that the deceased had sustained a deep stab injury to
the abdomen measuring 2 × 0.5 × 8 cm, along with other incised
injuries. On internal examination, injuries to the small and large
intestines were found, and approximately two litres of blood had
accumulated in the abdominal cavity. He opined that the cause of
death due to stab injury in abdomen & excessive bleeding from
the injuries, and that the injuries were homicidal in nature. This
medical evidence clearly establishes that the injuries were
sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. The FSL
report (Ex. P/29) further corroborates the prosecution case, as
human blood was found on the seized knife and on the clothes of
the accused, which was consistent with the blood group of the
deceased. This scientific evidence lends strong support to the
prosecution version.
33.
Recently, in the case of “State of Kerala vs. K. A. Abdul
Rasheed, 2026 SCC Online SC 592, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
has held that the deposition of a hostile witness can be
acceptable to the extent which find creditworthy. In para 13, it has
been held that:
“13. We pause here to notice that the Constitution
Bench in Neeraj Dutta had specifically dealt with
the efficacy of the deposition of hostile witnesses. It
referred with approval to Sat Paul v. Delhi
Administration wherein it was held:
“52. From the above conspectus, it emerges
clear that even in a criminal prosecution
when a witness is cross-examined and
contradicted with the leave of the court, by
the party calling him, his evidence cannot, as
a matter of law, be treated as washed off the
record altogether. It is for the Judge of fact to
consider in each case whether as a result of
such cross-examination and contradiction, the
witness stands thoroughly discredited or can
still be believed in regard to a part of his
testimony. If the Judge finds that in the
34.
process, the credit of the witness has not
been completely shaken, he may, after
reading and considering the evidence of the
witness, as a whole, with due caution and
care, accept, in the light of the other evidence
on the record, that part of his testimony which
he finds to be creditworthy and act upon it. If
in a given case, the whole of the testimony of
the witness is impugned, and in the process,
the witness stands squarely and totally
discredited, the Judge should as a matter of
prudence, discard his evidence in toto.”
In the present case, the evidence of the prosecution witnesses,
particularly regarding the presence of the accused at the place of
occurrence, assault made by the appellant, the recovery of the
weapon at his instance, and the medical and forensic evidence,
forms a complete chain of circumstances pointing towards the
guilt of the accused. The nature of the injuries inflicted on a vital
part of the body, i.e., the abdomen, clearly indicates the intention
and knowledge to cause death. The conduct of the accused in
fleeing from the spot and the recovery of the weapon at his
instance further strengthen the prosecution case.
35.
Accordingly, it is established that the accused caused the death of
the deceased by inflicting stab injuries with a sharp-edged
weapon, and the offence squarely falls within the ambit of Section
302 of the IPC. The conviction recorded by the trial Court is based
on proper appreciation of evidence and does not warrant
interference. Consequently, the appeal being devoid of merit is
liable to be dismissed.
36.
Inspector Mohd. Kaleem Khan (PW-26) recorded the statements
of various witnesses, including Sumit Verma, Rahul Goswami,
Kaushal Dewangan, Kanha, and Manoj Sarthi, in connection with
the incident. He took the accused into custody and conducted
interrogation. During his memorandum statement (Ex.P/11), the
accused disclosed that he had concealed the folding knife used in
the commission of the offence near Multipurpose School, Gandhi
Chowk. Pursuant to the said disclosure, a folding knife along with
the clothes worn by the accused at the time of the incident were
recovered and seized in the presence of witnesses vide seizure
memo (Ex.P/14). The arrest of the accused was effected on
18.07.2020.
37.
Although witnesses Jana Verma (PW-12) and Chandrakant Verma
(PW-14) did not fully support the prosecution case during crossexamination, they admitted their signatures on the memorandum
and seizure documents. The recovery of the weapon of offence
and the blood-stained clothes at the instance of the accused
remains duly proved. There is no material on record to suggest
any personal enmity between the appellant and the Investigating
Officer so as to infer false implication or planting of evidence. The
FSL Report (Ex.P/29) confirms the presence of human blood on
the seized articles, including the clothes of the deceased, the
folding knife, and the clothes recovered from the accused. This
scientific evidence provides a strong corroborative link to the
prosecution case and supports the version that the seized knife
was used in the commission of the offence. The medical evidence
establishes that the deceased sustained a fatal stab injury to the
abdomen, resulting in massive internal hemorrhage, and he
subsequently succumbed to the injuries during treatment. The
recovery of the weapon of offence at the instance of the accused,
coupled with the medical and forensic evidence, clearly
establishes that the death of Pradip Verma was homicidal in
nature and was caused by the act of the accused.
38.
From the aforesaid analysis, it is evident that the death of the
deceased Pradip Verma occurred as a result of the injury inflicted
by the appellant by stabbing him with a folding knife. The
prosecution has successfully proved its case beyond reasonable
doubt, and the learned trial Court has not committed any legal or
factual error in recording the finding of guilt against the appellant.
Accordingly, the appeal, being devoid of merit, is liable to be
dismissed.
39.
In the result the appeal filed by the appellant fails and hereby
dismissed. The appellant is reported to be in jail since
18.07.2020, he shall undergo the entire sentence as awarded by
the learned trial Court.
40.
Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the
concerned Superintendent of Jail where the appellant is
undergoing his jail sentence to serve the same on the appellant
informing him that he is at liberty to assail the present judgment
passed by this Court by preferring an appeal before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court with the assistance of High Court Legal Services
Committee or the Supreme Court Legal Services Committee.
41. Let a copy of this judgment and the original records be transmitted
to the trial Court concerned forthwith for necessary information
and compliance.
Alok
Sd/-
Sd/-
(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review