Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3168 ]
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY THREE
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRIJUSTICE K. LAKSHMAN
WRIT PETITIO N NOS: 43521.40827 AND
oF 2022
wP NO.4352 1OF 2022t
Between:
Babu Benhur.R, S/o John Bilmoria.R aged about 48 years Occ .Temp pM
employment Fl/o Plot No.135, S.C.B. 5-20-241 , Road No.4, Ravi colony, Mahindra
Hills'
secunderabad
...pETrrroNER
AND
1. THE STATE OF TELANGANA, Rep by its Principal Secretary Higher Education
Department Secretariat Hyderabad Telangana State
2. THETELANGANA STATE COUNCIL OF HIGHER EDUCATION, Represented by
its Commissioner Masab Tank Hyderabad
3. THE CONVENOR, TS LAWCET and PGLCET 2022 Admissions Online
counselling center PGRRCDE Osmania University Hyderabad Telangana state
500007
4. THE OSMANIA UNIVERSITY, Tarnaka Hyderabad Rep by its Reglqtlql5. The TELANGANA ADMISSION AND FEE, REGULATORY COMMITTEE,
Represented bv its Chairman,
O. Or.'A.R.nhOedk'ar college of ldw, Repreented by its corrospondenUPrincipal No.1-81
.Bhaglingampally,Chikadpallay
...REspoNDENrs
Petition under Article 226 ol the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to
ISSUE AN ORDER OR A DIRECTION OR A WRIT ONE IN THE NATURE OF WRIT
OF MANDAMUS DECLARING THE action of the respondents in not alloting
admission/seat to the petitioner (Hall ticket no. No.12222101219/RANK-9049 into 3
year LLB Course under TS-Lawcet 2022 lN THE 6TH RESPONDENT INSTITUTION
under 15% unreseryed open quota as illegal, contrary to law judicial precedents
fundamental rights and consequently
1. Direct the respondents 1 to 5 to admit the petitioner herein to the 6th
respondent institution the 157o unreserved quota in TSLAWCET- and consequently
direct
2. To set aside the 1st phase Counselling of TSLAWCET-2022 as it is not
followed the ratio of 15% unreserved open quota.
3. To direct the respondent No.5 to take necessary action/steps to monitor the
admissions to maintain 157o unreserved open seats by taking necessary steps for
locals and non locals on Merit basis ( with No reservations)
lA NO: 1
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased direct the
respondents herein in allot the seat to the petitioner in Convener Quota OF 15% OF
U NRESERVED OPE N S EATS in TS-LAWCET-( Hall ticket no. No.1 2222101 21 9/RANK-
9049 in the 6th respondent institution/college pending disposal of the above writ
petition
20F
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay all further
ongoing phase No.1 admissions of TS-LAWCET-?922 Pending disposal of the above
writ petition
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI J. C. FRANCIS
Counsel for Respondent No. 1: GP FOR HIGHER EDUCATION
Counsel for Respondent Nos' 2 & 3: SMT. C. VANI REDDY
Counsel for Respondent No. 4: SRI CH. JAGANNATHA RAO
Counsel for ResPondent Nos. 5 & 6: --
NavaSheelaA,W/oJ.C.Francis,aged4S.years'Occ'Household'R/o'3-3-389/8'
Cnipp"iilir.,Kachiguda, Hyderabad- Telangana'
...pE,,oNER
D
Education
Higher
STATE OF TELANGANA, Rep by its Princiq?l Secretary
1.
" THE
S1ate'
D;"",tmeitt Sicretariat, Hvderabad, Telangana
,. fEE'i-'Eili!6;,'i{;i. sihiE cduNdrL roR HroHEn EDUcArloN, Rep by its
-' CommGGioner, Masab Tank, Hyderabad'
3. THE CONVENOR TS LANCET and PGLCET 2022, Admissions Online
Counselling Center PGRRCDE, Osmania University, Hyderabad Telangana State
500007.
4. rHE osMANlA uNlvERSlTY, Tarnaka, Hyderabad, Rep by its *"9jlJlT;ororrr"
Petition under Article 226 of lhe Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to
issue an order or a direction or a writ one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring
the proceedings of the respondents dated 05.11.2022 declaring the petitioner (Hall
ticket no. 12212101621) as not eligible for exercising the web options ibr admission
into 3 year LLB Course under TS-Lawcet 2022 as illegal, contrary to law judicial
precedents and fundamental rights including right to education and consequently direct
respondents herein to grant the following reliefs. A. direct the respondents to permit the
petitioner to exercise web options in TS Lawcet B. direct the respondents to consider
the case as per Clause D(9) of the notification issued by the respondents for the TS
Lawcet admissions 2022 by proper mode of communication in transprancy with
reference to admissions under the notifications therein
7M
Petition under Section 1 51 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased direct the
respondents to include name of the petitioner (Hall ticket no 122121O'1621) in the
registered list of candidates to be published on 17.11.2022 so as to enable the
pctitoncr to exercise her web options in phase-1 in TS Lawcet 2022 counseling
Pending disposal of the above writ petition and pas$
Counset for the Petitioner: SRI DHARMESH D.K.JAISWAL
Counsel for Respondent No. 1: GP FOR HIGHER EDUCATION
Gounse! for Respondent Nos.2 & 3: SMT. C. VANI REDDY
Counsel for Respondent No.4: SR! CH. JAGANNATHA RAO
Between:
NAVA SHEELA A, Wo J.C. Francis, aged 48 years, Occ. Household, R/o. 3-3389/8, Chappal Bazar, Kachiguda, Hyderabad- Telangana.
EIIIj]
1' THE STATE OF TELANGANA, Rep LV ttt Principal Secretaryr Higher
r" Education
P.qg4fnent Secretariat, Hyderabad, Telangana State.
^ THE TELANGANA srATE couNCiL rodHtcH-rri
2EoucnrroN, Rep by its
CommissioJ'lgr, lVasab Tank, Hyderabad
3. THE CONVENOR - TS LAWC_EI and PGLCET 2\22,Admissions Online
C^o^unselling Center PGRRCDE, osmanii unrversiiv,-AydJ;-bfi
i"iangun, State
500007.
4- THE osMANtA uNrvERsrry.Jqgk?.,.Hlderapad,
lep by its Registrar.
5. Dr. B. R. AMB E DKAR coLLEG F .oF. r-4w,. nep. ov lf didi#oe-n'uFiincipar,
No.1-8-1, Bhaglingampally, Chikkadpally,'Hy<ierabad.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in
the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased
to
issue an order or a direction or a writ one in the nature of writ of mandamus
declaring
the action of the Respondents in not allotting admission/seat to the petitioner (Hall
ticket no. 12212101621lrank no.2324) into 3 year LLB Course under TS-Lawcel2022
in the sth Respondent tnstitution as illegal, contrary to law judicial precedents,
fundamental rights and consequently direct the Respondent No.1
to 4 to admit the
Petitioner herein in the Sth Respondent lnstitution
lA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition underSection 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
to direct the
Respondents herein to allot the seat to the Petitioner in convenor
Quota in TSLAWCET (Hall ticket No.122121o162tRank No.2324) in the sth
Respondent
lnstitution/college pending disposal of the above writ petition
IANO:2 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
stated in the
to stay all further
ongoing phase no.1 admissions of TS-LAWCET-2}22 pending disposal of the
writ petition
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI DHARMESH D.K.JA|SWAL
counsel for Respondent No. 1: Gp FoR HTGHER EDUCATION
Gounsel for Respondent Nos. 2 & 3: SMT. C. VANI REDDY
counsel for Respondent No. 4: sRt cH. JAGANNATHA RAo
Counsel for Respondent No. 5: --The Court made the following: ORDER
above
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.LAKSHMAN
WRIT PETITION N
1.40827 AND 43048 0 F 2022
COMMON ORDER:
The /ls involved in all the present writ petitions is the same.
Therefore, the same were heard together and are being decided by way
of common order.
2. Heard Mr. .1.C. Francis, learned counsel for the petitioner in
W.P. No. 4352 | of 2022, Mr. Dharmesh D.K. Jaiswal, learned counsel
f,or the petitioners in W.P. No.40827 of 2022 and W.P. No. 43048 of
z)2z,learned Government Pleader for Higher Education appearing on
behalf of respondent No.1 and Mrs. C. Vani Reddy, learned Standing
Counsel for Telan gana State Council for Higher Education (TSCFIE)
appearing on behalf of respondent No.2'in all the writ petitions and
Mr. Ch. Jagannatha Rao, learned standing counsel for Osmania
University, appearing on behalf of respondent No.4 in all the writ
petitions.
)
Kt...l
W.P. Nos.4i52l. .10827 & 4i048 o12022
3. Facts of the case
i) The petitioners herein appeared fbr rhe T.S. I_,{wc[17
Examination (hereinafter referred to as 'examination') Ibr admission
into three (3) year undergraduate law course. The peritioner in w.p.
Nos. 40827 of 2022 and 43048 of 2022 was allotted F{all ricket No.
1221210162l and secured a rank of ,2324, .
ii) As per rhe procedure of admission, the candidates qualifying
the examination will be permitted to exercise web-options to select
colleges of their preference. vide remarks on the website dealing
adrnissions of LAwcET, the petirioner in w.p. Nos . 40g27
the
with
of 2022
and 43048 of 2022was denied the option of rnarking her preferred
colleges by the convener, T.s. LAwcET (hereinafter referred
to as
'convener') on the ground that she studied antl gave her tenth (
l0,n)
standard examination, intermediate exarhination and three-year
undergraduate degree examinations outside the state of
Telangana/Andhra Pradesh. 'fherefore, she was not entitled for a
Convener Seat.
-)
KL.J
W.P. Nos.43-521.40827 & 43048 of 2022
iii) The said action of denying the option of selecting the
colleges of her preference was challenged by the petitioner in W.P.
No.40827 of 2022. This Court vide interim order dated I l.l I .2022 in
I.A. No.l of 2022 directed the Convener to permit the petitioner
therein to exercise her web-options to select the colleges of her
preference and permit her to participate in the admission counselling
process, subject to the result of the writ petition.
iv) The petitioner in W.P. No.40827 of 2022 exercised her
web-options and selected Dr. B.R. Ambedkar College of Law,
Hyderabad as her 1" preference, K.V. Ranga Reddy College,
Hyderabad as her 2nd preference, Andhra Mahila Sabha, Hyderabad as
her 3'd preference and Marwadi College, Hyderabad as her 4'h
preference. However, after selecting her preferred colleges, the
petitioner in W.P. No.40827 of 2022 wab not allotted any college in
the Phase-l provisional allotment of seats in Dr. B.R. Ambedkar
College of Law, Hyderabad, which was her l't preference.
Challenging the non-allotment of a seat in Dr. B.R. Ambedkar College
of Law, Hyderabad, the petitioner in w.P. No.40827 of 2022 filed
another writ petition bearing W.P. No.43048 of 2022.
K1...,
W.P. Nos.4i-521.40827 & 4i018 ol'1012
v) The petitioner in W.P. No.43521 of 2022 was allotted Hall
Ticket No.l2222l0l2l9 and secured a rank of '9049'. He exercised
his web-options to select his preferred colleges for admission. [{e
marked Dr. B.R. Ambedkar College of Law, Hyderabad as his l"
preference, Mahatma Gandhi Law College, tlyderabad as his 2nd
preference, Panugoti Madhava Rao College, t{yderabad as his 3'd
preference and Pendekanti Law College, Hyderabad as his 4'h
preference. However, no seat was allotted to him in the Phase I
provisional allotment of seats. Therefore, he filed W.P. No.43521 of
2022 challenging the non-allotment of seat in Dr. B.R. Ambedkar
College of Law, Hyderabad as illegal and arbitrary. Further, a
direction was sought to direct Dr. B.R. Ambedkar College of, Law,
I{yderabad to grant him admission under the I5Yo seats of Convener
quota. The petitioner also sought to set-aside the Phase I counselling
and allotment of seats.as the Same w'as in violation of relevant seat
allotment rules.
vi) In w.P. No.43048 of 2022, this courl vide interim order
dated 29.11.2022 in I.A. No.1 of 2022 directed the Convener to keep
l
KI,.J
W.P. Nos.4i521,40827 & 43048 of 2022
one seat vacant in Dr. B.R. Ambedkar Law College, Hyderabad
(Respondent No.5 therein).
vii) tn W.P. No.4352 | of 2022. this Court vide order dated
02.12.2022 in I.A. No.1 of 2022 directed the Convener to keep
one
seat vacant in Dr. B.R. Ambedkar Law College, Hyderabad
(Respondent No.6 therein).
w.P
& 43048 of2022:
'
i) The petitioner is a local candidate and is entitled for
admission under 85% seats reserved for local candidates
Andhra Pradesh Law Courses (Regulation of Admissions
and 5 year LLB lB.L. courses through common Entrance
under
into 3 year
Test) Rules,
2006 (hereinafter referred to as 'Rules, 2006)'
ii) Though the petitioner studied her tenth (10'n) standard
examination, intermediate examination and three-year
degree outside the state of Telangana/Andhra
undergraduate
Pradesh, she is still a
local candidate as her parents were perrnanent residents
of TelangtrLa'
Further, her husband is from Hyderabad and she has been
Telangana for more than twenty three years. [n support
residing in
of the same,
KL,.J
W.P. Nos.43.-i21. 10827 & 4i048 ot t02l
she filed her rnorher's Mulki certificate datecl 2g.09.1970 and her
Residence Certificate dated OZ.O4.2O0S.
iii) The petitioner shall be considered as a local as she is a
pe,nanent resident of Hyderabad and non-consideration of her
candidature as a local is against Article 37tD of the Constitution
of
India and Presidential Order, 1g74.
ir) The petitioner, in argnendo, contends that in the event she
is not treated as a local candidate for admission under glyo, she
entitled for admission as a non-local for the l5oh unreserved seats.
is
She
relied on Rule 7 ol'the Rules, 2006.
v) Further, relying on the provisional allotment of list of Dr.
B.R. Ambedkar Law college, Hyderabad it was contended
seats in the l5o/o unreserved category are illegally
that the
allotted without
following the Rules , 2006. she contends that there is no transparency
in allotment of seats in |5o/o unreserved quota.
vi) Additionally, the petitioner contends that r5yo unreserved
seats are filled as seats reserved for local candidates and the
illegal.
same is
KI,,J
W.P. Nos.43521.40827 & 4i048 o(2022
ner in W.P. N
i) Though the petitioner is a local candidate, he is also entitled
to claim a seat under the l\Yo unreseryed category.
ii) The petitioner reiterated the contentions of the petitioner in
W.P. Nos.40827 of 2022 and 43048 of 2022 that the seats were
allotted contrary to the Rules, 2006 and the l5oh seats unreserved
seats are not filled. Therefore, he is entitled for a seat under the l5Yo
category
tions of
i) The residential status of the parents alone is not enough for
the petitioner to claim status of a local candidate.
ii) The l5olo unreserved seat category is open for both local and
non-local candidates. The petitioners cannot contend that such l5% is
restricted only for non-local candidates.
iii)
Relying on NTR University of Health Sciences,
Vijayawada v. Dr. Babu Rajendra Prasadr (hereinafter referred to
'. lzooo; 2 ALT 716 (FB)
KL.J
W.P. Nos.43-52t.40827 & 4i048 of 2022
as 'NTR Uni'ersity decided by the Full Bench of HC'), it was
contended that reservation is calculated on the number seats available
and such seats are proportionally dividerl between the g5% Iocal
category and l5oZ unreserved category.
iu) The petitioners in all the writ petitions are entitled to claim
seat under the 150% unreserved seats. However, due to their
ranks, they
were not allotted seats in their preferred colleges.
7. Findings of the Court:
i) It is ..t in dispute that both the petitioners have secured
qualifying marks in the examination. The only question before
this
court is whether the petitioners are entitred for a seat as local
candidates or non-local candidates and whether the allotment
of seats
by the convener was in accordance with the applicable law.
ii) Before deciding the issues at hand, it is apposite to discuss
the background behind having admissions to educational institutions
in the name of local and non-local candidates.
iii) The erstwhile combined State of Andhra Pradesh consisted
of three regions i.e., the Andhra region, the Telan gana region and the
\
KL.J
W.P. Nos.43521.40827 & 43048 o12022
Rayalaseema Region. To ensure equal opportunities and
representation to all the people from the three regions in matters of
education and public employment, the Central Government vide the
Thirty Second (32'o) Constitutional Amendment, 1973 added Article
37lD to the Constitution of India. Article 37lD empowers the
President of India to pass orders in respect of the State of Andhra
Pradesh to meet the requirements of the State for equal opportunities
in the fields of education and employment.
iv) It is relevant to note that in exercise of the powers conferred
under Article 37lD of the Constitution of India, the President issued
Presidential order: Andhra Pradesh Educational Institutions
(Regulations and Admissions) Order, 1974 (hereinafter 'Presidential
Order, 1974). The said Presidential Order, 1974 defined the concept of
local candidates, the concept of unreseryed seats and the division of
the available seats between 85% and l5%.
l0
KL,J
W. P. Nos.43 52t . 40827 & 4304t of 2O2Z
v) 'fhc Suprerne cou't in Sandeep v. union of India2
extracted the relevant provisions of the presidential
order, 1974,
which are further extracted below:
"15. At this stage we think it appropriate to refer
to the
relevant clauses of the presidential order. The pertinent
clauses, \ .e are inclined to think, are:
"1.(2) It extends to the whole of the State of Andhra
Pradesh.
(3) It shall come into force on the rst day of Jury, rg74.
2-Interpretation.-(l) In this order, unless the context
otherwise requires(a) 'available seats' in relation to any course of study,
means the number of seats provided in that course
for
admission at any time after excluding those reserved
for
candidates from outside the State;
(D) 'local area,, in respect of any university
or other
educational institution, means the local area specified
in para
3 of this order for the purposes of admission to such
university or other educational institution;
(c) 'local candidate', in reration to any local area,
candidate who quarifies under para 4 of this
means a
order as a rocar
candidate in relation to such local area;
@ 'state Government' means the Government of
Andhra Pradesh;
\
tj
2. p0rc12 scc
I
t
:
:
ll
KL,J
43048 o12022
W.P. Nos.43521,40827 &
means an
(e) 'State-wide educational institution' educational
an
institution or a department of
educational
of this Order;
institution specified in the Schedule
means the Andhra Pradesh
university'
$'State-wide
under the Andhra Pradesh
Agricultural University constituted
24 of
1963 (Andhra Pradesh Act
Agricultural Universiry Act'
Technological University
1963), or the Jawaharlal Nehru
Nehru Technological
constituted under the Jawaharlal
16 of 1972)'
Act,1972(Andhra Pradesh Act
University
(2) Any reference to any district
in this Order shall be
the area comprised in that
construed as a reference to
on the lst daY of JulY' 1974'
district
(10 of 1897) applies
(3) The General Clauses Act' 1897
Order as it applies for the
this
of
interpretation
the
for
interPretation of a Central Act'
part of the State comprising the
3. Local area'-(l) The
west Godavari, East
districts of Srikakulam, visakhapatnam,
as
and Prakasam shall be regarded
Godavari, Krishna, Guntur
of admission to the Andhra
the local area for the purpose
and to any other
University, the Nagarjuna University
educationalinstitution(otherthanaState-wideuniversityor
which is subject to the
State-wide educational institution)
controloftheStateGovernmentandissituatedinthatpart'
the districts of
(2) The part of the State comprising
Khammam'
Adilabad. Hyderabad' Karimnagar'
Nizamabad and
Nalgonda'
Mahaboobnagar' Medak'
Warangalshaltberegardedasthelocalareaforthepurposes
ofadmissiontotheosmaniaUniversity(theKakatiya
(other
educational institution
University) and to any other
or State-wide educational
than a State-wide university
l
KL.J
W.P. Nos..li52t.4Og27 & 43048
institution) rvhich is sub.iect to
Governlnent and is situated in that
of 2022
the contror o[ the State
part.
(3) I'he part o' rhc State comprising the
districts of
chittoor and Nerore sha, be
regarded as the rocar area for the
purposes of admission to Sri
venkateswara tJniversity and to
any other educational
institution (other than a State-wide
university or State-wide
Anantapur, cuddapah. Kurnoor,
educatio'ar institution) rvhich is subject
State Government and is situated
to the contror of the
in that part.
4.Locar canditrates.-(r) A candidate
any course of, study shall be regarded
relation to a local area__
for admission to
as a local candidate in
(a) if he has studied in an educationar
educational institutions in such
institution or
rocar area for a period of not
Iess than rour consecutive academic
years
academic year in which he appeared
"naing
with the
or, as th" .ur" may be,
first appeared in the relevant qualifying
examination; or
(b) where during the whole or any
consecutive acadr
wh i ch
part of the four
n.,oo",;I::,:ffi ::lff J# J:: ;:lH::I""flr;
the rerevant quarifying examination,
educationar institution, if he
he has not studied in any
has resided in that rocar area
for
a
period of not ress than four years
immediatety p....uing the
date of commencement of the
relevant quarifying examination
in which he appeared or, as the
case may
be, first appeared.
(2) A candidate for admission
to any course of study who
is not regarded as a rocar candidate
relation to any local area shall_
(a) it he has studied in educarionar
for a period of not ress than seven
ending with the academic year
uno.,
;il;;;(r)
in
institutions in the state
consecutive academic years
in which he appeared or,
as the
!
li
KL.J
W.P. Nos.43521.40827 & 43048 o|2022
case may be, first appeared for the relevant qualifying
examination. be regarded as a local candidate in relation to-
(i) such local area where he has studied lor the maximum
period out of the said period of seven years; or
(ii) where the periods of his study in two or more local
areas are equal, such local area where he has studied last in
such equal periods; or
(b) if,, during the whole or any part of the seven
consecutive acadernic years ending with the academic year in
which he appeared or, as the case may be, first appeared for
the relevant qualif,ying examination, he has not studied in the
educational institutions in any local area, but has resided in
the State during the whole of the said period of seven years,
be regarded as a local candidate in relation to-
(i) such local area where he has resided for the maximum
period out of the said period of seven years: or
(ii) where the periods of his residence in two or more local
areas are equal, such local area where he has resided last in
such equal periods.
Explanatiorz.-For the purposes of this paragraph-
(i) 'educational institution' means a university or any
educational institution recognised by the State Government, a
university or other competent authority;
(r0 'relevant qualifying examination' in relation to
admission to any course of study, means the examination, a
pass in which is the minimum educational qualification for
admission to such course of study;
(iii) in reckoning the consecutive academic years during
which a candidate has studied-
l.i
KL.J
W.P. Nos.213521.40827 & 4i048 ot2022
(a) any period of intcrruption of his study by reason of his
failure to pass any exaniination; and
(b) any period o{'his stud1, in a State-wide university or a
State-wide educational institution, shall be disregarded.
(lv) the question whether any candidate for admission to
any course of study has resided in any local area shall be
determined with reference to the places where the candidate
actually resided and not with reference to the residence of his
parent or other guardian.
5. Reservotion
in non-State-wide universities and
educationol institutions.-(l) Adrnissions to eighty-five per
cent of the available seats in errery course of study provided
by the Andhra University. the Nagarjuna University, the
Osmania [Jniversity, the Kakatiya University or Sri
venkateswara University or by any other educational
institution (other than a State-rvide university or a State-wide
educational institution) which is subject to the control of the
state Government shall be reserved in favour of the local
candidates in relation to the local area in respect of such
university or other educational institution.
(2) While determining under sub-para (l) the number of
seats to be reserved in favour of local candidates any fraction
ofa seat shall be counted as one:
Provided that there shall be at least one unreserved seat.
6.Reservation in state-wide universities and stote-wide
educational institutions.-(l) Admissions to eighty-five per
cent of the available seats in every course of study provided
by a State-wide university or a State-wide educational
institution shall be reserved in favour of and allocated among
the local candidates in relation, to the local areas specified in
l_i
KL,J
W.P. Nos.4i52l, 40827 & 43048 of 2022
sub-para ( I ), sub-para (2) and sub-para (3) of Para 3, in the
ratio of 42:36:22 respectively:
Provided that this sub-para shall not apply in relation to
any course of study in which the total number of available
seats does not exceed three.
(2) While determining under sub-para (l) the number of
seats to be reserved in favour of the local candidates, any
fraction of a seat shall be counted as one:
Provided that there shall be at least one unreserved seat.
(3) While allocating under sub-para (l) the reserved seats
among the local candidates in relation to different local areas,
fractions of a seat shall be adjusted by counting the greatest
fractions as one and, if necessary, also the greater of the
remaining fractions as another; and, where the fraction to be
so counted cannot be selected by reason of the fractions being
equal, the selection shall be by lot:
Provided that there shall be at least one seat allocated for
the local candidates in respect of each local area.
T.Filling of reserved vacant seats.-If a local candidate in
respect of local area is not available to fill any seats reserved
or allocated in f,avour of local candidate in respect of that
local area, such seat shall be filled as if it has not been
reserved.
8. Power
to outhorise issue of directiozs.{l) The
President may, by order, require the State Government to
issue such directions as may be necessary or expedient for the
purpose of giving effect to this Order to any university or to
any other educational institution subject to the control of the
State Government; and the university or other educational
institution shall comply with such directions.
r6
Ki-.J
W.l). Nos..l352 l. 40827 & 43048 o12022
(2) 'fhe State Governlllent rnay, fbr the purpose of issuing
any directions under sub-para (l) or f,or satisfying itself that
any directions issued under that sub-para have been complied
with, require, by order in rvriting, any university or any other
educational institution sub.iect to the control of the State
Government to furnish them such information, report or
particulars as may be specified in the ordcr; and the university
or other educational institution shall comply with such order."
16. The State Government issued the Circular in 1979. The
relevant paragraphs of the Circular deserve to be reproduced.
They read as follows:
"2. The Andhra Pradesh Educational Institutions
(Regulation of Admissions) Order, 1974 provides for
reservation of seats in favour of local candidates in courses of
study provided by the universities and othcr educational
institutions subject to the control of the State Government.
Para 9 of the Order lays dorvn that the provisions of that
Order shall have effect notwithstanding anything contained in
any statute, ordinance, rule, regulation or other order (whether
made before or after the commencement of the Order) in
respect of admissions to any university or any other
educational institutions subject to the control of the State
Government. Para 10 of the said Order, however, declares
that nothing in the Order shall affect -the operation of any
provisions made by the State Government or other competent
authority (whether before or after the commencement of the
Order) in respect of reservations in the matter of admission to
any university or other educational institution in favour of
women, socially and educationally backward classes of
citizens, the scheduled castes and the Scheduled Tribes
insofar as such provisions are not inconsistent with the Order.
t7
KL,J
W.P. Nos.43521.40827 & 43048 of 2022
3. After the coming into force of the above Presidential
Order, rvith eft-ect from l-7-1974. admissions to the
educational institutions in the entire State are to be made in
the light of the provisions of the said Order. According to
Para 4 of the Order a candidate for admission to any course of
study shall be regarded as a local candidate in relation to the
local area-
(a) if he has studied in an educational institution or
educational institutions in such local area for a period of not
less than four consecutive academic years ending with the
academic year in which he appeared or, as the case may be,
first appeared in relevant qualifying examination; or
(b) where during the whole or any part of the four
consecutive academic years ending with the academic year in
which he appeared or, as the case may be, first appeared for
the relevant qualifiring examination, he has not studied in any
educational institution, if he has resided in that local area for a
period of not less than four years immediately preceding the
date of commencement of the relevant qualifying examination
in which he appeared, or, as the case may be, first appeared.
4.lt must be noted that Para 4(a) as extracted above
covers the cases of those candidates who studied in an
educational institution or educational-institutions for a period
of not less than four consecutive academic years ending with
the academic year in which he appeared or, as the case may
be, first appeared in the relevant qualiffing examination,
while Para 4(b) applies to the case of other candidates. For
purposes of Para 4(a) educational institution has been defined
as a university or any educational institution recognised by
the State Government, a university or other competent
authority. The eligibility of a candidate who has studied
during any part of the four-year period in an unrecognised
l8
K1-.J
W.t'. Nos.4-1521. 40827 & 43048 of 2022
institution rvill have to be clcalt with under Para 4(b). While
considering the eligibility of a candidate to be regarded as a
local candidate, under Para 4(a) of the Order by virtue of lour
consecutive years of study in a local area, it should be noted
that in reckoning the consecutive academic years of study,
any interruption in the period of his study, by reason of his
failure to pass any examination shall be disregarded. For
instance, a candidate who has studied in the IXth and Xth
classes and the junior and senior intermediate classes in
institutions of the same local area with a break of one year
after the X Class on account of failure to pass the Xth class
examination at the first atternpt, shall be regarded as a local
candidate in relation to that local area for adrnission to a
degree course in any institution in that area.
5. The above definition of the local candidate (as it stood
until it was amended with effect from 25-l l-1976) had given
rise to certain situations wherein some of the candidates
belonging to the State of Andhra Pradesh who have studied or
resided throughout within the State came to be regarded as
non-local candidates in all the local areas within the State. [n
order to avoid such a situation, the Government of India have
since issued the Andhra Pradesh Educational Institutions
(Regulation of Admissions) Second Amendment Order, 1976
ampliffing the said definition in para 4 of the Order.
6.
The Andhra Pradesh Educational Institutions
(Regulation of Admissions) Second Amendment Order, 1976
inserts a new sub-paragraph in the said 1974 Order viz. subpara (2) to Para 4 thereby making provision for considering
the claims of persons, who under the old definition would
have become non-local in relation to all local areas in the
State. According
to sub-para (2)(a) of Para 4, after
amendment, if such a candidate has studied in educational
t9
KL.J
W.P. Nos.4352l, 40827 & 43048 of 2022
institutions in the State /br a period o/'not less than seven
consecutive academic years ending with the acodemic year in
which he appeared on, as the case may be, first appeared for
the relevant qualifying examiruttion, he shall be regarded as a
local candtdate in relation to that local area where he had
studied for the longest period out of the said period of seven
years. In the event of the periods of study in two or more
local areas being equal he shall be regarded as local candidate
in relation to that local area where he studied during the last
of the said equal periods. Clause (D) to sub-para (2) applies to
a candidate who. during the whole or any part of the seven
consecutive academic years ending with the academic year in
which he appeared or as the case may be, first appeared for
the relevant qualifying examination has not studied in
educational institutions in any local area, but has resided in
the" State during the whole of the said seven years, the
candidate shall be regarded as a local candidate in relation to
that local area where he has resided for the longest period out
of the said seven-yeff period. This residence test will be
applied to candidates in whose cases there is a gap in study,
occasioned otherwise than by reason of failure to pass in an
examination, in the prescribed full term of seven years
imrnediately preceding the relevant qualiS,ing examination. It
has also been provided that where the periods of residence in
two or more local areas are equal, such a candidate shall be
regarded as a local candidate in relation to the local area
where he resided last in such equal periods. The application of
the liberalised definitions made through the Second
Amendment Order are illustrated by the examples given in
Annexure I.
***
KL,J
W.P. Nos.43521,40827 & 4i0,18 of 2022
9. ... thc Government have directed that for the purpose of
adrrrission into educational institutions, those who clairn to be
local candiciates with refereuce to Para 4( I )(a) or Para 4(2)(a)
of the Andhra Pradesh Educational Institutions (Regulation of
Admissions) Order, 1974 should produce evidence in the
form of study certificates issued by the heads of the
educational institutions concerned indicating the details of the
year or years in which the candidate has studied in an
educational institution or institutions in such local area for a
period of not less than four or seven consecutive academic
years ending with academic year in which he appeared or, as
the case may be, first appeared in the relevant qualifying
examination. Those who do not qualify as local candidates
under Para 4(l)(a) or 4(2)(a) but claim to qualify by virtue of
residence under Para 4(l)(b) or Para 4(2)(b) of the said
Order should produce a certificate issued by an fficer of the
Revenue Department not below the rank of Tahsildar in the
-for* annexed vide Annexure II.
* *:k
11. As clarifications were being sought on the question as
to who should be considered eligible to apply as candidates
belonging to the State of Andhra Pradesh for the purpose of
admission to courses of studies offered by educational
institutions, subject to the control of the State Government
against the 15% of the available seats kept unreserved in
terms of the Andhra Pradesh Educational [nstitutions
(Regulation of Admissions) Order, 1974 the Government
after careful consideration have directed that the following
categories of candidates may be treoted as eligtble to apply
for admissions to educational institutions in the State, subiect
to the control of the State Government, as candidates
belonging to the State of Andhra Pradesh against the l5% of
2t
KL.J
W.P. Nos.43-521.40827 & 4i048 ol2022
the available seats left unreserved in terms of the Presidential
Order:
(r) All local candidates defined in the Presidential Order.
(ir) Candidates who have resided in the State for a total
period of ten years excluding periods of study outside the
State; or either of whose parents have resided in the State for
a total period of ten years excluding periods of employment
outside the State;
(iii) Candidates who are children of parents who are in the
employment of this State or Central Government, public
sector corporation. local bodies, universities and other similar
quasi-public institutions within the State; and
(rv) Candidates who are spouses of those in the
employment of this State or Central Government, public
sector corporations, local bodies, universities and educational
institutions recognised by the Government, a university or
other competent authority and similar other quasi-government
institutions within the State.
12. It has been decided that persons in the employment of
this State or Central Govemment, public sector corporations,
local bodies, universities and other similar quasi-public
institutions, within the State may be treated as eligible to
apply for admission to the part-time course of study offered
by the educational institutions in the State subject to the
control of the State Government as candidates belonging to
the State of Andhra Pradesh.
13. The Government considers that in the large majority of
cases falling under the above categories, 'nativity' may not be
in doubt. The heads of educational institutions or other
admission authorities may call for appropriate certificates of
)2
Kl"i
W.P. Nos.43-52t,40827 & 4i048 o{'l0ll
study/residence or employtnent in cases of doubt." (emphasis
supplied)
vi) The Presidential Order, 1974 states that educational
institutions in the State of Andhra Pradesh shall allot 85o of the
available seats to local candidates belonging to the local areas as
defined. The remaining l|oh of the seats shall be allotted to candidates
as unreserved seats
vii) The Presidential Order, 1974 defines local area in the forrn
of university regions i.e., the Osmania University region, Andhra
University region and Sri Venkateshwara University Region. It is
students belonging to these regions who can claim benefit as local
candidates
viii) Local candidates are defined as students who have studied
in an educational institution for at least four consecutive years in the
local area which includes the last academic year in which he/she
appeared or first appeared in the relevant qualifuing examination; or
has not studied in an educational institution for whole or any part of
four consecutive years but has resided in such local area for four
KI-.J
W.P. Nos.4i521,40827 & 4i048 of 2022
consecutive years immediately preceding the date of commencement
of the relevant qualifying examination or the date when he/she first
appeared for such examination. The candidates will also be termed
local candidates if he/she has studied in an educational institution for
seven consecutive years or has not studied in an educational institution
but has resided in the local area of seven consecutive years. The seven
consecutive years shall be said to have been completed with the
ending academic year in which he/she appears for the exam or the
year when he first appeared for the exam. Such area will be treated as
a local area in which the candidate has spent the maximum period out
of the said seven years and when the period of residence is divided
between two local areas and the period of stay is equal, the local area
in which the candidate last resided will be considered. Therefore, the
students who satisfu the definition of local candidates will be eligible
to claim a seat in an educational institution under 85o/o category.
i*) The Presidential Order, 1974was clarified in the year 1979
in respect of the candidates who can claim seats under the 15%
unreserved category. It was stated that all local candidates are entitled
l4
Kt,.J
W.P. Nos.43521. 40821 & 43048 ol l0l2
for a seat under the i5%o ur-rreserved category along with candidates
who have resided in the State of Andhra Pradesh or whose parents
who have resided in the State of Andhra Pradesh for a period of ten
years. The ten years are calculated, in case of candidates, by excluding
the period of study outside the State of Andhra Pradesh and in case of
their parents, the period of employment outside the State of Andhra
Pradesh. Further, candidates whose parents are in employment of the
State Government or Central Government or whose SpouSeS are in
such employment are also entitled for seats under the l1Yo unreserved
category.
x) It is relevant to note that Rules, 2006 regulating the
admission process of the LAWCET examinations were issued in line
with the Presidential Order, 1974. The definitions of local area, local
candidates, the breakup of seats between 85Yo to local candidates and
l5o/o as unreserved seats under Rules, 2006 are parimateria to the
definitions of the Presidential Order, 1974.
xi) For a better understanding of the admission process under
the Rules ,2006, the relevant provisions are extracted below:
\
\
KI-.J
W.P. Nos.43521,40827 & 43048 of 2022
"Allotment of Seats:
( I ) University colleges
All the sanctioned intake of seats in 3-YEAR/5-YEAR
LLB./B.L. courses in University colleges shall be filled by the
Convener, LAWCET Admissions. Such seats shall be allotted
to eligible candidates on the basis of and Rules of Reservation
as laid down in Rule 7 hereunder.
(a) Unaided Non-Minority and Minority Professional
Institutions
(a) "the seats allotted to each Un-aided Non-Minority and
Minority Professional Institution for admission of Candidates
shall be classified as:
( I ) Category A seats (2) Category B seats
(b) The Category A seats shall be 80% of sanctioned intake of
seats in 3-YEAR/5-YEAR LL.BIB.L. courses in Un-Aided
Non-Minority and Minority Professional Institutions, which
shall be filled with eligible candidates on the basis of Rank
obtained at LAWCET/LAWCET-AC, as the case may be,
following the procedure laid down in Rule 6 (ii) and Rules of
Reservation laid down in Rule 7. (C) The Category B Seats
shall be 20Yo of the total intake of seats in each course in
respect of Un-Aided Non-Minority and Minority Professional
lnstitutions, which shall be open for admission the eligible to
KL,J
W.P. Nos.43-521.40821 & 43048 of 2A22
candidates including candidates belonging to other States and
Union Territories of'lndia and NRls on rnerit basis, following
the provisions of Rule 6 (iii).
Within Category B, seats not exceeding l5Yo of the total
intake of seats rnaybe filled, at the discretion of the
Institution, rvith NRIs.
(d) In respect of Minority Professional Institutions, the seats
filled up with eligible minority candidates of the concerned
minority, as a percentage of total seats, should satis$r the
minimum percentage norm as prescribed by the Government
while according the rninoritl,' status.
Rules of Reservation for admission
All the seats in the University colleges and Category A seats
in Unaided Non- Minority and Minority lnstitutions offering
3-YEAIUS-YEAR shall be reserved, to the following
categories in Admissions:
Region-wise reservation of seats Admission to 85% of the
seats in each course shall be reserved for the local candidates
and the remaining l|Yo of the seats shall'be un-reserved seats
as specified in the Andhra Pradesh Educational Institutions
(Regulations and Admissions) Order, 1974 is subsequently
amended.
EXPLANATION: For purpose of these rules.
(a)Local Areas means:
KL.J
W.P. Nos.4i521,40827 & 43048 of ?022
( I )I'he part of tlre State comprising the districts of Adilabad,
Ilydcrabad (including Twin Cities) Ranga Reddy,
Karimnagar, Khammam, Medak, Mahaboobnagar, Nalgonda,
Nizamabad and Warangal shall be regarded as the Local Area
for the purpose of admission to the Osmania University, the
Kakatil'a University and the Telangana University and to any
other educational institutions (other than State wide
University or State wide educational institution) which is
subject to the control of the State Government and is situated
in that part
(2)The part of the State Comprising the districts of
Srikakulam, Yizianagaram, Visakhapatnam, East Godavari,
West Godavari, Krishna. Guntur and Prakasam shall be
regarded as the Local Area for the purpose of admission to the
Andhra University, the Acharya Nagarjuna University and
Adikavi Nannaya University and to any other educational
institutions (other than State wide University or State wide
educational institution) which is subject to the control of the
State Government and is situated in that part...
(3) The part of the State Comprising the districts of
Anantapur, Kumool, Chittoor, Cuddapah and Nellore shall be
regarded as the Local Area for the purpose of admission to the
Sri Venkateswara University, the Sri Krishnadevaraya
University and the Yogi Vemana University and to any other
educational institutions (other than State wide University or
l8
KL.J
W.P. Nos.43521.40827 &43048 of 2022
State wide educational institution)
"vhich
is subject to the
control of the State Governrncnt and is situated in that part...
(b) "The Local Candidate" ineans:
(1) A candidate for admission shall be regarded as a local
candidate in relation to a local area.
(AXf he/she has studied in Educational Institution or
Educational Institutions in such local area for a period of not
less than four consecutive academic years ending with the
academic year in which he/she appeared or as the case may
be. first appeared in the relevant quali$'ing examination, or
(B) Where. during the rvhole or any part of the four
consecutive academic years ending with the academic year in
which he/she appeared or as the case may be Frrst appeared
for the relevant qualiffing examination he/she has not studied
in any Educational [nstitutions, if he/she has resided in that
local area for a period of not less than four years immediately
preceding the date of commencement of the relevant
qualiffing examination which he/she appeared or as the case
may be first appeared.
(2)A candidate for admission to the Course who is not
regarded as local candidate under clause (l) above relation to
any local area shall,
(A) If he/she has studied in Educational Institutions in the
State for a period of not less than seven consecutive academic
years ending with the academic year in which he/she appeared
KL,J
W.P. Nos.43521.40827 & 43048 of 2022
or as Lhe case may be lirst appeared for the relevant qualilying
examination be regarded as a local candidate in relation to,
(l) Such local area rvhere he/she has studied for the maximum
period out of said period of seven years, or
(ll) Where the period of his/her study in two or more local
areas are equal, such local area, where he/she has studied last
in such equal period, or
(B) If, during the whole or any part of seven consecutive
academic years ending with the academic year in which
he/she appeared or as case may be first appeared for the
relevant qualiffing examination he/she has not studied in the
Educational Institutions in any local area but has resided in
the State during thc r.vhole of the said period of seven years,
be regarded as a local candidate in relation to
(l) Such local area where he/she has resided for the maximum
period out of the said period of seven years, or
(II) Where the periods of his/trer residence in two or more
local areas are equal such local area where he/she has resided
last in such equal periods.
(3) The following categories of candidates are eligible to
apply for admission to the remaining l5%o of un-reserved
seats:
(A) All the candidates eligible to be declared as local
candidates.
-.i0
Kt...i
\V.P. Nos.4-j521.40827 & 4i048 of 2022
(B) Candidates who have resided in the State lor a toral period
of l0 years excluding periods of study outside the State or
either of u'hose, parent have resided in the State fbr a total
period of ten years excluding period of employment outside
the State.
(C) Candidates who are children of parents who are in the
employment of this State or Central Government, public
Sector Corporations, Local Bodies, Universities and other
similar quasi-public Institutions, within the State
(D) Candidates who are spouses of those in the employment
of the State or Central Government Public Sector
Corporations, Local Bodies, Universities and Educational
lnstitutions recognized by the Government or University OR
Other competent authority and similar quasi Government
Institutions within the State.
(4) If a local candidate in respect of a local area is not
available to fill any seat reserved or allocated in favour of a
local candidate in respect of that local area, such seat shall be
filled if it had not been reserved."
xii) Rule 3 of the Rules, 2006 deals with allotment of seats in
university colleges, unaided Non - Minority and Minority
Professional Institutions. In the present case, we are dealing with
il
KL,J
W.P. Nos.43521,40827 & 43048 of 2022
Unaided Non-Minority Institutions (hereinafter referred to as
'colleges'), therefore, the discussion shall be restricted to the same.
xiii) Rule 3(ii) of the Rules, 2006 states that seats in colleges
are divided into Category 'A' and Category 'B'. Category'A' deals
with 80% of the sanctioned seats which are to be filled based on the
rank obtained in the examination by the Convener. Category 'B' deals
with remaining 20Yo of the sanctioned seats which are to be filled
based on the discretion of the colleges.
xiv) Rules 5 &. 6 of the Rules, 2006 provide for the method of
admission and procedure of admission, respectively. The said Rules
provide the procedure to be followed by the Convener to allot
colleges. Rule 7 of the Rules, 2006 deals with the rules of reservation
for admissions. Rule 7(i) provides region-wise reservation and states
that 85Yo seats which are available for allotment by the Convener are
reserved for local candidates. In other words, 85% of the Category 'A'
seats shall be reserved for local candidates (85% of the 800/o seats to
be allotted by the Convener). The remaining 15oZ seats of Category
'A' seats shall be unreserved seats.
)z
Kt-.J
W.P. Nos.4i-521 . 40827 & 41048 o12022
xv) The definition of local candidates in Rules, 2006 is
parimateria to definition of local candidates as discussed above in
relation to the Presidential Order, 1974. To avoid repetition, the same
is not discussed again.
xvi) Now coming to the facts of the case, the petitioner in W.P.
Nos.4082 7 of 2022and 43048 of 2022cannot be considered as a local
candidate as she fails to satis$r the requirements of the definition of a
local candidate. The petitioner admittedly completed her tenth ( l0'")
standard examination, intermediate examination and three-year
undergraduate degree outside the state of Telangana/Andhra Pradesh.
Therefore, it cannot be said that she studied for four consecutive years
in the local area neither has she resided in the local area immediately
preceding the date of commencement of the relevant qualifuing
examination or the date when he/she
'first appeared for such
examrnatton.
xvii) Further, the contention of the petitioner that she should be
considered as a local candidate based on her mother's Mulki
Certificate and her Residence Certificate cannot be accepted for the
)-)
KL.J
W.P. Nos.43521.40827 & 43048 of 2022
simple reason that Rules, 2006 do not provide that parents' residence
is a criterion to be considered to treat a candidate as a local candidate.
Rules, 2006 only contemplate period of study in local area or period
of residence in such area to be calculated for four consecutive years or
seven consecutive years, as the case may be. The definition of a local
candidate under the Presidential Order, 1974 and Rules, 2006 is clear.
In the absence of challenge to such definition, the contention of the
petitioner that she is a local candidate on account of her period of
residence and place of birth cannot be considered. Therefore,
according to this Court, the petitioner in w.P. Nos.4oB27 of 2022 and
43048 of 2022 cannot be considered as a local candidate and she is not
entitled for a seat under 8502 reserved for local candidates.
xviii) Now coming to the question whether the petitioner in
w.P. Nos.40827 of 2022 and 43048 of 2022 is eligible to claim a seat
under 15% unreserved seats. The answer to the said question is
affirmative. It is clear based on the certificates produced by the
petitioner that she has been residing in the State of Telangana for over
ten years and also her parents have resided in the State of Telangana
for over ten years. Further, the respondents in their Counter-Affidavit
Kt-.j
W.P. Nos.43521.40827 & 4i048 ol.2012
filed in W.P. No.43048 of 2022 admit that the petitioner is entitled to
claim a seat under l5o/o unreserved category. Therefore, the petitioner
is entitled an eligible for a seat under l5oz unreserved category.
xix) The petitioner in w.p. No.43521 of 2022 contends thar he
is entitled for a seat under l5oz unreserved category. According to this
court, the petitioner being a local candidate is eligible to claim a seat
under both 85% as a local candidate and under 15oZ unreserved seats.
xx) The petitioners in all the writ petitions herein contend that
the allotment in relation to l5o/o unreserved seats happened contrary to
the Rules, 2006 as candidates entitled for seats as local candidates
under 85% quota were allotted seats in 15% unreserved quota, thereby
denying the petitioners their right to compete for seats in the said l5%
quota.
xxi) The petitioner in w.p. Nos.40g27 of 2022 and 4304g of
2022 contends that Dr. B.R. Ambedkar Law college has a total of l g0
seats. out of 180 seats, 144 seats (g0% of lg0) fall within the
Category 'A' seats which are to be filled by the Convener. Further, out
of the said 144 seats, 122 seats (85% of 144) are to be filled with local
.35
KL.J
W.P. Nos.4-1521. 10827 & 4-1048 o12022
candidates and the remaining2? seats (15% ol 144) shall be treated as
seats to be filled as unreserved seats as per Rules, 2006. However, the
petitioner contends that among the said 22 seats most of them were
allotted to local candidates who are otherwise eligible for a seat under
85% quota as a local candidate. [n other words, the petitioner contends
that a student who will get a seat under 85oZ quota as a local candidate
was given a seat under 15% quota of the unreserved seats. According
to the petitioners, the said allotment is illegal.
xxii) On the other hand, the respondents in their CounterAffidavit in W.P. No.43521 of 2022 contend that the allotment of
seats was done by proportionally dividing the reservation between
85Yo and 15% quota. Therefore, the allotment of seats was valid and
the petitioners were not allotted any college under the l5Yo quota due
to their higher rank.
xxiii) Therefore, the question now is whether the allotments of
22 seats (15% unreserved seats) in B.R. Ambedkar Law College is
illegal. Before answering the said question, it is important to discuss
the nature of l5oh unreserved seats.
KL,J
W.P. Nos.4i52l , 40827 & 4i048 of t0t2
xxiv) It is clear thar the ls% category is open to local
candidates as well as the candidates who satisfy other criteria as to
period of residence and whose parents/spouses are in the employment
of State or central Governrnent. The 15oz unreserved category is not
for non-local candidates but for candidates who satisfi the criteria
mentioned in the Presidential Order, 1974.
xxv) Further, the l|Yo unreserved seats are to be considered as
seats that are to be filled based on merit and competition among
the
candidates who fall within the eligible categories mentioned therein.
In other words, in the l5oz unreserved seats, there is no preference
given to any candidate belonging to local area over other candidates
who claim seats under the residence criteria. For the purposes of
l5o4
unreserved seats, all the eligible candidates are considered equals
and
a candidate having a better rank will get a'seat over other
candidate.
xxvi) The above view is fortified by the decision of the
Supreme court in NTR university of Health sciences v.
G. Babu
Rajendra Prasad3 which overruled the decision of NTR university
'. lzoo:;5 scc 3so
tl
KL.J
W.P. Nos.43521.40827 & 43048 of 2022
decided by HC (supra) relied upon by the respondents. The Supreme
Court in NTR University (supra) held that l50Z unreserved seats are
open to all the eligible candidates and social reservations applicable to
85% quota of local candidates are not applicable to l5Yo unreserved
seats. The relevant paragraphs are extracted below:
"12. Article 371-D of the Constitution of India contains a special
provision applicable to the State of Andhra Pradesh only. 54% of
seats are required to be filled up from open categories and 467o
of seats are to be filled up from the reserved category candidates
in each of the three regions from the medical colleges and
engineering colleges. Having regard to the reservations made
region wise, indisputably 85% of seats are to be filled up frorn
amongst local candidates whereas only l5% of seats are to be
filted up from amongst outside candidates.
14.
It is not in dispute that limited seats are available for
admission in the superspeciality courses. [t may be true that
norrnally the reservation has to be made for the entire State but in
terms of Article 37l-D of the Constitution of India reservation
has to be made region wise. The seats have been reserved
indisputably on total available seats in each discipline and those
who come within the zone of consideration are considered for
adrnission from amongst the reserved category candidates. Once
it is found that reservation has been made for the reservedcategory candidates on the total number of seats available in each
i8
KL.J
W.P. Nos.4i521.40827 &4i048
course, the l{igh Court rnust be herd
manifest crror in issuing the impugned
15. Having regar<I to trre ract that
of 2022
to have committed a
direction.
reservation has been provided
to the extent of 46% of a, the seats, the
question of any further
reservatio, i.e. fior the remaining l 50/o
of the seats wourd not
arise."
Therefore, this court cannot accept the
contention of the respondents
that the allotments to coileges were made
reservations between g5% seats of
by dividing sociar
local candidates and 15%
unreserved seats. The said allotment
of providing caste_based
reservation in the l5oz unreserved seat
quota is illegal and contrary to
law laid down by rhe Supreme court in
NTR university (supra).
xxvii) Now coming to the question of ailotment
petitioner in w.p. Nos.40g2 7 of 2022
before this court rist of the provisionar
and Phase II. This court has perused
and 4304g of 2022 placed
alrotment of seats for phase I
the said allotment rist and has
found that the allotments happened contrary
mandate of Presidential Order, 1974.
of seats, the
to Rures, 2oo6and the
KL.J
W.P. Nos.43521.40827
& 43048 o12022
xxviii) As stated above, local candidates are eligible for a seat
both under 85% category and 15% unreserved seat category
However, a candidate who has a better rank and who is eligible to
obtain a seat as a local candidate under the 85% quota in his4rer
preferred college, cannot be allotted a seat under 15% unreserved seat
quota in the same preferred college. Doing so will reduce the chances
of other candidates who are ineligible to claim a seat as a local
candidate.
xxix) The object behind the l5o/o unreserved seats is to fill
them based on competition between local candidates, candidates who
have resided in the State of Andhra Pradesh or whose parents who
have resided in the State of Andhra Pradesh for a period of ten years
and candidates whose parents/spouses are in employment of the State
Government or Central Govemment. If a iandidate, who is otherwise
getting a seat under the 85% quota as a local candidate, is given a seat
under 15% unreserved quota, the competition gets significantly
impaired. The effect of allotting seats to local candidates having a
better rank in the l5Yo unreserved quota, will make it practically
-10
KL,J
W.P. Nos.43521,40827 &43048 of 2022
impossible for other candidates who are not local to secure a seat
under the l5Yo unreserved quota.
xxx) In the present case, the Phase-I list of provisionally
selected candidates of Dr. B.R. Ambedkar Law College shows that a
candidate having a rank of '286' and belonging to the OU region
(local candidate) was allotted a seat under the unreserved category of
l5o . However, a candidate having a rank of '296' belonging to OU
region (local candidate) was allotted a seat under the local category of
85%. This clearly shows that a candidate having a better rank than
another and who belonged and was entitled to a seat as a local
candidate was allotted a seat under 15o/o unreserved quota. Similarly,
a candidate having a rank of '396' and belonging to OU region (local
candidate) was allotted a seat under the local category of 85%
xxxi) Likewise, the Phase I list of provisionally selected
candidates of Dr. B.R. Ambedkar Law College shows that a candidate
having a rank of '82' belonging to the OU region (local candidate)
was allotted a seat under the unreserved category of l5yo. Therefore,
4t
KL,J
W.P. Nos.43521,40827 & 43048 o12022
it is clear that the Convener allotted colleges to the candidates
illegally.
xxxii) According to this Court, the Convener should first allot
colleges fillirrg up the 85% quota of local candidates which includes
the reserved seats. After filling up these 85% seats reserved for local
candidates, the Convener shall then fill up the remaining 15% by
considering merit among the local candidates and other candidates. In
the present case, the allotment of seats was contrary to the Rules,
2006. A perusal of the Phase I and Phase II allotment listof Dr. B.R.
Ambedkar Law College alone shows that out of 22 unreserved seats
l9 were filled by tocal candidates. It is clear that the petitioner in W.P.
Nos.40827 of 2022 and 43048 of 2022 would be entitled to a seat if
the allotment of l57o unreserved seats was not done in favour of local
candidates. The same is evident from the fact that a local candidate
who secured a rank of '2652' was allotted a seat under the l5oh
unreserved quota and candidates who secured a rank of '4032' and
'4096' belonging to the OU region were allotted seats under the l1oh
unreserved quota. Therefore, petitioner having a better rank of '2324'
l
Kt..j
\['.P. ,r"os.4]-521. -10817 & 4i04ti ot'1012
was entitted for a seat ullder l57o unreserved quota and has been
illegally denied the sanre.
xxxiii) According to this Couft, the petitioner in W.P.
No.4352
| of 2022 was also illegally denied a seat as the candidate
securing a rank of '9077' was allotted a seat under the 15%
unreserved quota, whereas the petitioner having a rank of '9049' was
not allotted a seat under 15% unreserved quota'
xxxiv) The action of the Convener and the method adopted in
allotment of seats is illegal and has an effect of depriving eligible
students from getting seats uncler the l5%o unreserved quota' This
Court would have interfered to set aside the entire allotment process.
However, as the counselling is completed and classes have begun, this
Court has to balance competing equities of students who were already
allotted seats and the students who have been deprived a seat'
Admissions are completed and the clock cannot be set back.
xxxv) It is apt to reler to the decision of the Supreme Court in
Punjab Engg. College v. Sanjay Gulatia wherein the Court noted
o.
lrsa:;3 scc 517
4i
KL,J
W.P. Nos.4352t, 40827 & 43049 of 2022
that the admission of students happened ilregaily
procedure. The court refused to interfere with
students. However, issued a stern warning
and in vioration of
the admissions of the
to erring authorities in not
following the admission process. The rerer.ant paragraphs
extracted below:
"4. cases like these in which admissions granted
educationar institutions are quashed raise
to students in
a sensitive human
issue' It is unquest.ionabry true that the authorities
charged with the duty of admitting students
institutions must act fairly and objectively.
who are
to educational
If admissions to these
institutions are made on extraneous considerations
and the
authorities viorate the norms set down by
the rures and
regulations, a sense of resentment and frustration
is bound to be
generated in the minds of those unfortunate
young students who
are wrongly or purposefully left out. Indiscipline
in educational
institutions is not whoily unconnected with
a lack of sense of
moral values on the part of the administrators
and teachers alike.
But, the problem which the courts are faced with
is, that it is not untir a period of six months
in these cases
or a year erapses after
the admissions are made that the intervention
of the court comes
into play. writ petitions invorving a chailenge
to such admissions
are generally taken up by the High Courts as promptly
possible but even then, students who are wrongly
one or two semesters of the course by the time
as
admitted finish
the decision of the
are
!l
.t.t
KL''I
W.I'). Nos.l.i-52 l. 40827 & 43048 ot'2022
I'ligh Coun is pronounccd. A further appeal to this court
consumes still more timc. rl'[riclr .creates furthcr dill'iculties in
adjusting equities between students who are wrongl,v admitted
and those who are unjustly excluded. lnevitably, the court has to
rest content rvith an acadeuric pronouncement of the true legal
position. Students rvho are wrongly admitted do not suffer the
consequences of the rnanipulations, if any, made on their behalf,
by interested persons. This has virtually come to mean that one
must get into an educational institution by means, fair or foul:
Once you are in, no one r,vill put you out. Law's delays work their
wonders in srrch diverse fashions.
5. We find that this situation has emboldened the erring
authorities of educational institutions of various States to irrclulge
in violating the norms of adrnission with impunity. They seem to
feel that the courts will leavc the admissions intact. even if the
admissions are granted contrary to the rules and regulations. This
is a most unsatisfactory smte of affairs. Laws are meant to be
obeyed, not flouted. Some day, not distant, if admissions are
quashed for the reason that they were made wrongly, it will have
to be directed that the names of studdnts who are wrongly
admitted should be removed from the rolls of the institution. we
might have been justified in adopting this course in this case
itself, but we thought that we may utter a clear warning before
taking that precipitate step. We have decicled, regretfully, to
allow the aforesaid 16 students to continue their studies, despite
the careful and weighty finding of the High courr that at least
eight of them, namely, the seven wards of employees and Ashok
4_5
KL.J
W.P. Nos.43521,40827 & 4i048 of 2022
Kumar Kaushik, were admitted to the l]pgineering course ln
violation of the relevant rules and regulations'"
8. Conclusion:
i) in light of the competing equities of students, this coun
deems it fit not to interfere with the admission of students who have
already been allotted seats. However, the petitioners are entitled for a
retief owing to the illegal allotment process adopted by the Convener respondent.
ii) In light of the aforesaid discussion, this Court holds as
follows:
a)
\
\
w.P. No.43048 of 2022 and w.P. No.43521 of 2022 are
allowed;
b)
t
The petitioner in w.P. No.43048 of 2.022 shall be allotted the
seat which was directed by this Court to be kept vacant in
respondent No.5 college therein vide ordet dated 29.11.2022
in
I.A. No.l of 2022;
c)
The petitioner in w.P. No.4352 | of 2022 shall be allotted the
seat which was directed by this Court to be kept vacant
in
t
KI...r
W.P. Nos.4l.jl l. .t0817 ._pt 4i0ll{ ot.l()ll
respondent No.6 collcge tltcrein virle order dated
02.12.2022 in
I.A. No. I of 2022;
d)
w.P. No.40827 of 2022 becomes infrucruous as rhe perlrioner
therein was permitted tcl exercise web-options and
selectecj her
prefe*ed colleges vide the interim orcler datecl r l. r
I .2.022 in
I.A. No.I of 2022 and, therefore, the same is dismissed as
infructuous.
iii) In the circumstances of the case, there shall be no ortler.as
to costs.
As a sequel thereto, misceilaneo,s petitio,s, if any, pe,di.g
i.
all the writ petitions shall also stand closed.
//TRUE COPY//
To,
SD/. T. TIRUMALA DEVI
ASSISTANT REGIgMAR
SECTIOTTOFFICER
1. The Principal Secretarytligher Education Department, State of Tdlangana,
Secretariat Hyderabad Telangana State
2. The Commissioner, Telangana State Council Of Higher Education, Masab Tank
Hyderabad
3. The Conve!9r.IS LAWCET and PGLCET 2022 Admissions Online Counselling
Center PGRRCDE Osmania University Hyderabad Telangana State 500002
The
Registrar, Osmania University, Tarnaka Hyderabad Rep by its Registrar
I5. The chairman,
Telangana Admission And Fee, Regulatory committeel
6. One CC to Sri J C Francis Advocate [OPUC]
7. Two CCs to GP For Higher Education, High Court for the State of Telangana.
lourl
8. One CC to Smt. C. Vani Reddy, Advocate(OpuC)
9. One CC to Qr! Ch. Jagannathd Rao, Advocate(OpUC)
10.One CC to Sri Dharmesh D. K. Jaiswal, Advocbte(Opuc)
11.Two CD Copies
MBC
GJP
HIGH COUI-T
DATED: 09/0312023
1 vtE
tt
)
o()
S T A r4
1 B \t\[R
t[8
I
i
.,
t Dssp pi,('
COMMON ORDER
WP NOS:43521,40827 AND 43048 OF 2022
WRIT PETITION No's 43048 and 43521 of 2022 are
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WRIT PETITION 40B2Tof 20Zz
DISMISSING AS INFRUCTUOUS WITHOUT COSTS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review