Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 11.02.2026
+
O.M.P. (COMM) 488/2023
NATIONAL RESEARCH DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
& ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Joydeep Sarma, Mr.
Kaushal Kapoor, Mr. Lalit
Verma & Mr. A P Singh, Advs.
versus
MAK CONTROLS AND SYSTEMS PRIVATE
LIMITED
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Satyam Thareja, Mr.
Rakesh Karela & Mr. Shaurya
Katoch, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J. (ORAL)
1.
This petition is filed under Section 34 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (in short „the Act‟) against the Award dated
07.08.2023.
2.
The facts shorn of unnecessary details are that the
petitioners/claimants on 06.03.2002 entered into a „Programme Aimed
at Technological Self Reliance‟ agreement (for short „the agreement‟)
with the respondent. The respondent was given financial assistance to
develop a product „Mak World Traker‟. The agreement was for a
period of twelve years. A royalty agreement of even date was also
executed between the parties. The respondent at end of each financial
year, for five years from start of commercial sale of product had to
pay royalty of Rs.24 Lakhs per annum. The respondent completed the
O.M.P. (COMM) 488/2023
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:44:38
project in the year 2007 but failed to commercialize it. The nil annual
royalty returns were filed due to non-commencement of commercial
production. Notice under Section 21 of the Act dated 24.06.2019 was
issued by the petitioners. The notice was responded to on 02.07.2019
stating that there is no liability to pay royalty. The Arbitrator was
appointed by this court under Section 11 of the Act.
3.
The claim of the petitioners for royalty totaling to
Rs.1,20,00,000/- was rejected in view of clause 4.1(f) of the
agreement.
3.1
The claim for damages for not transferring the technology on
failure to commence commercial production by the respondent was
rejected on the ground of limitation. Hence, the present petition.
4.
The clause 4.1(f) stipulated that the respondent at the end of
each financial year shall pay a lump-sum royalty of Rs.24 Lakhs per
annum, for five years from the start of commercial sale of the product.
Learned counsel for the petitioner fairly submits that in view of the
admitted facts that there was no commercial production of the
product, the issue of royalty is not being agitated.
4.1
It is argued that the arbitrator erred in rejecting the claim for
damages on the ground of limitation. The submission is that albeit, the
project was completed in the year 2007 but the agreement was for
twelve years i.e. up to 05.03.2014 and thereafter before issuing notice
under Section 21 of the Act in the year 2019 the petitioner waited for
royalty for five years. It is canvassed that in violation of clause 11(e)
of the agreement, the respondent while replying to the notice for first
time in year 2019 offered to transfer the technology.
O.M.P. (COMM) 488/2023
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:44:38
5.
Per contra the view taken by the arbitrator is a plausible one.
Considering the obligation casted upon the respondent by clause 11(e)
the claim for damages is time barred. The argument is that the scope
of interference under Section 34 of the Act is limited.
6.
Heard learned counsel for the parties at length and perused the
relevant record with their able assistance. Apart from the contentions
noted above no other issue was pressed.
7.
Before proceeding further, it would be relevant to quote clause
4(i)(f), clause 8, clause 11 and clause 16 of the agreement:“ 4(i)(f)
8.
To pay to NRDC. who will receive the same
on behalf of DSIR, annual lumpsum\royalty of
Rs 24 lakhs per year for a total period of 5
years from the “Start of Commercial Sale‟ of
the Product(s)” at the end of each financial
year.
COMPLETION OF PROJECT
The Project shall be deemed to have been
successfully completed when MAK have
designed, developed, produced, tried and
tested "Product(s)" as per specifications given
in Annexure I to this Agreement; to the
satisfaction of DSIR and users.
11.
UTILIZATION OF TECHNOLOGY
a.
MAK will enter into an agreement with
NRDC within 120 days from the date of first
sanction letter under the "Project" to enable
NRDC to collect lumpsum. royalty payments
as mentioned in clause 4.1 (f) above, and will
pay to, NRDC lumpsum royalty' payments as
per clauses 4.1(f) of this Agreement.
b.
MAK will have the right to utilize the
technology developed or other IPRs generated
O.M.P. (COMM) 488/2023
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:44:38
through the "Project" for production and
commercial sale of product(s)‟. For such
commercial utilization of technology by
MAK, MAK will pay to NRDC, who will
receive on behalf of DSIR, lumpsum royalty
payments as envisaged in clause 4.1(f) above.
c.
After commercialisation of technology by
MAK as stated in clause 11(b) above, MAK
may do third party licensing, if MAK and
DSIR perceive that such a need arises. This
third party licensing and related terms and
conditions would be finalised by MAK with
the approval of DSIR. The revenue so
generated by such third party licensing will be
collected by MAK on behalf of MAK and
DSIR and shall be shared between MAK and
NRDC (on behalf of DSIR) in the ratio of
their (MAK & DSIR) actual financial
contributions towards the project as assessed
at, the end of the project.
d.
MAK may, if they do desire, utilise the
services of NRDC for third party licensing as
per mutually agreed terms and in consultation
with DSIR. The revenue so collected by
NRDC on behalf of DSIR and MAK by way
of third party licensing shall be shared
between MAK and NRDC (on behalf of
DSIR) in ratio of their (MAK & DSIR) actual
financial contributions towards the project as
assessed at the end of the project.
e.
MAK will assign the technology proposed to
be developed under this project alongwith
license to use the intellectual property owned
by them and transfer the know-how document
to NRDC within 60 days from the occurrence
of any of the following:(i)
If MAK refuses to exercise its right,
O.M.P. (COMM) 488/2023
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:44:38
(ii)
(iii)
f.
within one year of completion of the
"Project", its option to commercialise
technology,
If MAK fails to cornmercialise
technology within four years of
completion of the project.
If MAK fails to execute agreement
referred to in Clause 11 (a) above,
NRDC will have an exclusive right to license
the technology developed through the
"Project" to third parties in case of occurrence
of either of the events referred in clause 11(e)
above. MAK will provide to NRDC full
details of any improvement(s) made on the
"Product" and the process of manufacture and
any additional information, which NRDC may
require to license this technology to third
parties, in the event of third party licensing
under the circumstances given in clause 11 (e)
above. In such cases, MAK will also provide
training to third party licensees on request
from NRDC on mutually agreed terms.
Revenues earned by NRDC through third
party licensing under this clause will be
shared between MAK and NRDC (on behalf
of DSIR) in the ratio of actual financial
contributions by DSIR and MAK towards the
project as assessed at the end of the project.”
16.
DURATION OF THE AGREEMENT
The duration of this Agreement will be for a
period of 12 years from the date of its
signing.”
8.
Clause 4 deals with the responsibilities of the parties. Under
clause 4.1(f) the respondent at the end of each financial year was
obligated to pay for five years from start of commercial sale of the
O.M.P. (COMM) 488/2023
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:44:38
product, a lump-sum royalty of Rs.24 Lakhs per annum.
8.1
The completion of the project as per clause 8 is the successful
completion of designing, developing, producing, trying and testing of
the product as per the specifications in the annexures to the agreement
and being to the satisfaction of the petitioners and users.
8.2
Under clause 11(e), the respondent within sixty days had to
assign the developed technology to the petitioners along with license
to use the intellectual property and know-how documents (hereinafter
collectively referred to as „the licensed technology‟):- (i) in case of
refusal by the respondent to commercialize the technology within one
year of the completion of the project; or (ii) failure of the respondent
to commercialize the technology within four years of the completion
of the project; and lastly (iii) on failure of the respondent to execute
the agreement as referred to in clause 11(a).
8.3
The duration of the agreement is for twelve years as stated in
clause 16 of the agreement.
9.
The undisputed facts are that the project was completed in the
year 2007 and the liability of the respondent to pay the royalty was
directly connected with the start of commercial sale, which never
happened.
10.
From the conjoint reading of the clauses it emerges that the
respondent could not have indefinitely prolonged commercial sale of
the product. Respondent on failure to commercialize the product
within four years of the completion of the project had to transfer the
licensed technology to the petitioners within sixty days thereafter.
11.
The project was completed in 2007, the outer time limit with the
O.M.P. (COMM) 488/2023
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:44:38
respondent for commercialization was up to 2011 and on failure of the
respondent to transfer the licensed technology after sixty days
thereafter the cause of action arose to the petitioners. The reliance on
clause 16 by the learned counsel for the petitioner to contend that the
agreement was for twelve years does not come to the rescue of the
petitioner. Twelve years is the total period of the agreement and is not
related to transfer of the licensed technology or payment of royalty.
The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner that cause of
action arose after expiry of twelve years from 2002 and the period for
which the royalty was to be paid i.e. five years, if taken to a logical
end would render clause 11(e) to be otiose.
11.1. The duration of the agreement was for twelve years cannot be
considered in isolation. For payment of royalty and transfer of the
licensed technology the relevant point was the completion of the
project i.e. in the year 2007. After completion of the project on failure
to commercialize the project within four years, the licensed
technology was to be transferred. The payment of royalty would have
started from the start of commercial sale which never happened and
hence, there was no occasion to wait for five years that to after 2014.
In other words the project was completed in the year 2007 and was not
commercialized till 2011, the transfer of the licensed technology was
to take place within sixty days thereafter and it had no relation with
the duration of the agreement.
12.
The law is well settled that the interpretation of the clauses of
the contract falls within the domain of the Arbitrator and unless the
interpretation is perverse no interference is to be made under Section
O.M.P. (COMM) 488/2023
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:44:38
34 on the ground that another view is possible. Reference in this
regard be made to the following decisions:In Punjab State Civil Supplies Corporation Limited & Anr.
v. M/S Sanman Rice Mills & Ors. 2024 INSC 742 it was held as
under:
“13. In paragraph 11 of Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. v.
L.K.Ahuja, 4 it has been observed as under:
“11. There are limitations upon the scope of
interference in awards passed by an arbitrator. When
the arbitrator has applied his mind to the pleadings, the
evidence adduced before him and the terms of the
contract, there is no scope for the court to reappraise
the matter as if this were an appeal and even if two
views are possible, the view taken by the arbitrator
would prevail. So long as an award made by an
arbitrator can be said to be one by a reasonable person
no interference is called for. However, in cases where
an arbitrator exceeds the terms of the agreement or
passes an award in the absence of any evidence, which
is apparent on the face of the award, the same could be
set aside.””
In Prakash Atlanta (JV) v. National Highways Authority of
India 2026 INSC 76 it was held as under:“59. (vi) If an arbitral tribunal‟s view is found to be a
possible and plausible one, it cannot be substituted
merely because an alternate view is possible.
Construction and interpretation of a contract and its
terms is a matter for the arbitral tribunal to determine.
Unless the same is found to be one that no fairminded or reasonable person would arrive at, it
cannot be interfered with. If there are two plausible
interpretations of the terms of a contract, then no fault
can be found if the arbitrator accepts one such
interpretation as against the other. To be in conflict
O.M.P. (COMM) 488/2023
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:44:38
with the public policy of India, the award must
contravene the fundamental policy of Indian law,
which makes it narrower in its application.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
13.
The arbitrator rightly held that the claim for damages is time
barred as the cause of action arose in the year 2011 when clause 11(e)
was violated. The respondent after having failed to commercialize the
technology within four years of the completion of the project had to
transfer the licensed technology within sixty days.
14.
The award is not vitiated by patent illegality, perversity or is in
conflict with public policy, the petition is dismissed.
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J
FEBRUARY 11, 2026
Ch
Reportable:- Yes
O.M.P. (COMM) 488/2023
Signed By:CHANCHAL
10:44:38
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review