Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:464
SL.
No.
Dat e
Of f i ce N o t e s ,
r ep or t s, or d er s
o r p r o ce e d i n g s
o r d i r e ct i o n s
a n d Re g i s t r a r ’ s
or der w it h
Si g n a t u r e s
COURT’ S OR JUD GE’ S ORD ERS
A.O. No.378 of 2025
H o n ’ b l e A l o k M a h r a , J.
Mr. Deepak Rawat , Advocat e for t he
appellant .
Mr. Sanj ay Bhat t , Advocat e for
respondent nos.1 t o 3.
This Appeal from Order has been
2.
preferred by t he appellant –I nsurance
Com pany assailing t he j udgm ent and
award dat ed 02.08.2025, passed by t he
learned Mot or Accident Claim s Tribunal/
2 nd Addit ional Dist rict Judge, Udham
Singh Nagar, in M.A.C.P. No.237 of
2023, whereby t he learned Tribunal has
awarded com pensat ion in favour of t he
claim ant s on account of t he deat h of Shri
Raj esh Kum ar in a m ot or vehicle
accident .
3.
The fact s, as borne out from t he
record, indicat e t hat on 19.08.2023,
Raj esh Kum ar was ret urning t o Rudrapur
from his nat ive village Fazalpur on
m ot orcycle no. UK- 06- Z- 0432 along wit h
his son Vikas Kum ar; t he deceased was
t ravelling as a pillion rider, while Vikas
Kum ar was driving t he said m ot orcycle.
At about 10: 30 p.m ., near Rudra Bilas
Sugar Mill, t he offending m ot orcycle
bearing regist rat ion no. UP- 22- AZ- 9772,
being driven at a high speed and in a
rash and negligent m anner, st ruck t he
m ot orcycle on which Raj esh Kum ar was
t ravelling, as a result whereof, he fell
down and sust ained grievous inj uries,
while Vikas Kum ar suffered m inor
inj uries. The inj ured Raj esh Kum ar was
init ially t aken t o Narayan Hospit al,
2026:UHC:464
Bharat pur and t hereaft er referred t o Shri
Ram Murt i Mem orial Hospit al, Bhoj ipura,
Bareilly for bet t er t reat m ent , where he
succum bed t o t he inj uries during t he
course of t reat m ent .
4.
Learned counsel for t he appellant –
I nsurance Com pany has assailed t he
im pugned
award
on
a
t hree- fold
subm ission. First ly, it is argued t hat t he
learned Tribunal has erred in assessing
t he incom e of t he deceased and in
applying 30% addit ion t owards fut ure
prospect s, despit e t he deceased not
being in perm anent salaried em ploym ent
and his incom e having been det erm ined
on a not ional basis; it is cont ended t hat
in such circum st ances, t he addit ion
ought not t o have exceeded 25% .
Secondly,
placing
reliance on
t he
t est im ony of P.W.3, t he t reat ing doct or,
learned counsel subm it s t hat , at t he t im e
of adm ission, t he deceased him self
allegedly st at ed t hat
t he accident
occurred because a st reet dog suddenly
crossed t he road and, in an at t em pt t o
save t he dog, t he accident t ook place; on
t his basis, it is cont ended t hat t he
involvem ent of t he offending m ot orcycle
UP- 22- AZ- 9772 is doubt ful and t hat , at
best , t he case would indicat e t hat t he
accident was t he result of t he deceased’s
own act , am ount ing t o a fort uit ous
m ishap rat her t han act ionable negligence
of a t hird part y. Thirdly, it is argued t hat
t he
appellant –I nsurance
Com pany
discharged it s burden of disput ing t he
involvem ent of t he said m ot orcycle by
producing t he report of it s I nvest igat or
before t he learned Tribunal, but t he
sam e was erroneously brushed aside
wit hout any cogent reasoning, t hereby
vit iat ing t he findings on negligence and
on t he involvem ent of t he insured
2026:UHC:464
vehicle.
On t hese grounds, it
is
subm it t ed t hat t he award is excessive,
cont rary
to
evidence
and
set t led
principles of law and, t herefore, liable t o
be m odified or set aside.
5.
Per
cont ra,
learned
counsel
appearing for respondent nos.1 t o 3, t he
claim ant s, has support ed t he im pugned
j udgm ent and award and subm it t ed t hat
t he finding regarding t he occurrence of
t he
accident ,
t he
involvem ent
of
m ot orcycle no. UP- 22- AZ- 9772, and rash
and negligent driving on t he part of it s
driver is fully borne out from t he oral and
docum ent ary evidence on record. I t is
point ed out t hat t he accident was
wit nessed by Vikas Kum ar, t he son of t he
deceased, who was him self driving
m ot orcycle no. UK- 06- Z- 0432, and his
t est im ony has rem ained unshaken in
cross- exam inat ion; t he fact um of t he
accident has furt her been corroborat ed
by prom pt lodging of t he F.I .R., in which
t he
offending
vehicle
has
been
specifically m ent ioned, and upon due
invest igat ion, t he police have subm it t ed
charge sheet against t he driver of
m ot orcycle no. UP- 22- AZ- 9772. Learned
counsel subm it s t hat t he Tribunal has, in
paragraph 22 of t he im pugned j udgm ent ,
specifically not iced t hat an F.I .R. was
regist ered in respect of t he accident and,
aft er invest igat ion, charge sheet was
filed against t he said driver, and in t he
absence of any credible m at erial t o t he
cont rary, such police papers furnish
adequat e proof of involvem ent and
negligence in m ot or accident claim
proceedings. Learned counsel for t he
respondent s subm it s t hat t he Tribunal
has assessed t he incom e on a reasonable
not ional basis and has ext ended fut ure
prospect s st rict ly in line wit h t he law
2026:UHC:464
declared by t he Const it ut ion Bench in
Nat ional I nsurance Co. Lt d. Vs. Pranay
Set hi, and t he subsequent j udgm ent s
which affirm t hat even in cases of selfem ployed or fixed- salary persons, fut ure
prospect s cannot be denied; hence, no
int erference is warrant ed on t hat score.
A Const it ut ion Bench of Hon’ble
6.
Suprem e Court in t he case of “ Nat ional
I nsurance Com pany Lim it ed Vs. Pranay
Set hi & ot hers, report ed in ( 2017) 16
SCC 680, has laid down clear guidelines
for det erm ining com pensat ion in m ot or
accident claim s. This Court finds t hat t he
com pensat ion awarded t o t he claim ant s
is j ust , reasonable, and in consonance
wit h t he set t led param et ers laid down by
t he Hon’ble Suprem e Court . The award
passed by t he learned Tribunal neit her
suffers from any perversit y nor warrant s
int erference in appellat e j urisdict ion.
Accordingly, t he Appeal from Order
7.
fails and is dism issed.
The st at ut ory am ount , if deposit ed
8.
by t he appellant at t he t im e of filing t he
appeal, shall be rem it t ed t o t he Tribunal
concerned for adj ust m ent t owards t he
award am ount . The balance am ount , if
any, shall be released in favour of t he
claim ant s as per t he direct ions of t he
Tribunal.
( A l o k M a h r a , J.)
10.01.2026
Arpan
ARPAN
JAISWAL
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT
OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=eabb68a3895e41937c266c23964c0485365445e3a20dd
db7393398f9fe45ba3e, postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=060FC17022BEAE3DE215D68D9D454C5109CB987
446351E4DF04AADAA2C2CEA66, cn=ARPAN JAISWAL
Date: 2026.01.10 15:07:41 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review