The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. Accordingly, apart from the fact that the Commissioner, Workmen's Compensation, had confused the concept of functional disablement with permanent disablement in arriving at the figure of 85% loss of earning capacity, we also have to take into consideration the fact that the injury suffered by the appellant did not disable him permanently from earning his living other than as a driver. We, therefore, are of the view that the percentage of functional disablement has to be modified, since the appellant is permanently disabled as far as earning a livelihood as a driver is concerned.” Taking the cue from Palraj (supra), this Court is of the considered opinion that, having regard to the limited scope of appeal under Section 30 of the Act and the further fact that concededly, the argument of „no loss of earning capacity‟ was not even raised before the learned Commissioner, the contention raised merits rejection. This Court even on reappreciation of merits is in agreement with the findings returned by the learned Commissioner. Insofar as the second contention, namely that no intimation of the accident was given to the appellant, is concerned, it is noted from the record of the Commissioner that the respondent had filed a communication dated 21.05.2013, whereby intimation of the accident suffered by three employees, including the present claimant, was duly furnished. The said communicat…
13. In view of the above, this Court finds no ground to interfere with the award. Accordingly, the present appeal is dismissed along with the pending applications. The amount lying deposited with the learned Commissioner shall be released to the workman forthwith. There shall be no order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: 26.02.2026
+
FAO 200/2023, CM APPL. 40661/2023 and CM APPL. 2013/2026
NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED .... Appellant
Through:
Mr. Shubham Sharma, Mr. Sumit
Prasad, M. Shagun Shahi and Mr.
Deepansh Sharma,
Advocates
versus
BIRENDER KUMAR TIWARI & ANR.
Through:
.... Respondents
Mr. Nitesh Kumar and Mr. Mayank
Goswami, Advocates for respondent
No.1
Mr. Shwetank Sharma, Advocate for
respondent No.2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1.
The present appeal has been filed under Section 30 of the Employees‟
Compensation Act, 1923 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act”), against the
order dated 31.05.2023 passed by the learned Commissioner, Labour
Department, Government of NCT of Delhi.
2.
Vide the impugned order, the learned Commissioner allowed the
claim application for injury compensation and, after issuance of notice under
Section 4A, directed the insurance company to pay compensation of
Rs.3,67,819/- along with interest @ 12% per annum w.e.f. 17.06.2013 till
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
13:22:46
FAO 200/2023
Pg. 1 of 7
realization. The insurance company was further held liable to pay penalty
and interest under Section 4A of the Act.
3.
Briefly, the claimant filed the subject application stating that he had
been employed with the management since the year 2007 as a mechanic and
that his last drawn salary was Rs.14,000/- per month. It was further stated
that the management, being engaged in the business of construction, had
deployed him at its ongoing construction site. On 18.05.2013, while
deployed at the Sarojini Nagar Metro construction site, the claimant
allegedly suffered injuries on account of an accident involving the breaking
of the Kelly due to excessive loading, as a result of which a heavy object fell
upon him. The claimant sustained injuries to his legs as well as his spinal
cord, and FIR No. 137/13 under Sections 287/338 of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 came to be registered. Subsequently, the claimant was re-employed
with the management, and his services were eventually terminated on
23.07.2018. Along with the claim application, a disability certificate issued
by the Medical Board, Aruna Asaf Ali Government Hospital, was placed on
record, wherein his disability was assessed at 41%.
4.
The management appeared and admitted the employer-employee
relationship. It, however, denied its liability to pay any compensation. The
management further submitted that it had taken insurance policy cover under
the Workmen Compensation Employees Compensation Insurance Policy
vide Policy No. 360300/41/12/8600000055. Under the said policy, a total
sum of Rs.29,40,000/- was insured for about 100 workers across different
wage brackets. An insurance premium of Rs.20,089/- was also paid. The
insurance policy was valid from 30.03.2013 to midnight of 29.06.2023. The
management further stated that all medical expenses for the treatment of the
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
13:22:46
FAO 200/2023
Pg. 2 of 7
workman were borne by it and that, in total, a sum of Rs.3.50 lakh was spent
towards medical expenditure.
5.
The insurance company also appeared and contested the claim. It
denied that any accident had taken place and, consequently, denied liability
to pay compensation. It was further stated that intimation of the accident had
not been conveyed to the insurance company.
6.
On the basis of respective stands taken by the parties, the learned
Commissioner framed four following issues: “1. Whether the claimant is entitled for compensation on
account of accident occurred on 18/05/2013, in the course out
of his employment with respondent no 1 and if so?
2. To what amount of injury compensation is he entitled?
3. Whether the claim is time barred?
4. Whether respondent are liable to pay penalty and upto what
extent and what amount?
5. Any other relief?”
7.
While answering the aforesaid issues in favour of the claimant, the
learned Commissioner awarded compensation of Rs.3,67,819/-, taking into
account the age of the claimant as 39 years and applying the factor of 186.90
as per Schedule IV of the Act. The last drawn wages were calculated at
60%. The relevant extract of the impugned order is reproduced as under:
“15. As made discussion above for relief I am taking age of claimant as 39 y
ears (as per disability certificate No . UP5910619730039693 issued by
Medical Authority, Deoria, Uttar Pradesh) and relevant factor 186.90 and
60% of last drawn wages restricted to 8,000/- and 41 % disability ( as' per
disabiTity certificate issued by Medical Board - Aruna Asaf Ali Government
Hospital), as such calculation is made as under:
The applicant/claimant is also entitled to interest as per Section 4A of the
'Act' @ 12% per annum from 30 days after the accident.”
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
13:22:46
FAO 200/2023
Pg. 3 of 7
8. The insurance company was also saddled with a penalty of 50% of the
principal amount awarded.
9.
The scope of appeal under Section 30 of the Act is limited. Being a
welfare legislation, Parliament thought it is fit to restrict the appeal only to
substantial questions of law. A useful reference in this regard can be made to
Golla Rajanna & Ors. Vs. Divisional Manager & Anr.1.
10.
Learned counsel for the appellant/insurance company has raised
twofold contentions. Firstly, it is contended that the learned Commissioner
erred in granting compensation as he failed to take into account that there
was no loss of earning capacity, inasmuch as the workman came to be reemployed with the same management after a period of 11 months.
Moreover, during the said period of 11 months of hospitalization/treatment,
the management continued to pay wages. Further, upon being re-employed,
the workman was promoted from the post of Mechanic to Supervisor and his
wages were enhanced from Rs.14,000/- to Rs.16,000/-. It is thus contended
that, there being no loss of earning capacity, no compensation ought to have
been awarded. Secondly, it is contended that the Tribunal erred in imposing
penalty and interest upon the appellant, as no information of the accident
was ever furnished to it by the workman/management.
11.
The said contentions are opposed by learned counsel for the workman
as well as the management. Learned counsel for the respondents further
submits that the services of workman were subsequently terminated and the
said issue though raised before the Tribunal in separate proceedings, stands
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
13:22:46
(2017) 1 SCC 45
FAO 200/2023
Pg. 4 of 7
settled between the parties.
12.
Coming to the first contention, namely whether brief re-employment
would necessarily result in denial of compensation for loss of earning
capacity, the Court refers to the decision in Palraj v. North East Karnataka
Road Transport Corpn.2, while considering a claim for injury compensation
under the Workmen‟s Compensation Act, the Supreme Court was in seisin
of a fact situation where the workman, employed as a driver, suffered injury
but was provided alternate employment as a peon on the same salary. The
Supreme Court, while upholding the decision of the High Court, granted
compensation by enhancing the functional disability from 20% to 35%. The
workman had suffered physical disability to the extent of 65%, while the
functional disability had been assessed at 20%. In the present case, though
functional disability has been assessed, it is an admitted position that the
workman, who was employed as a mechanic, has suffered disability to the
extent of 41%.
The relevant extracts of Palraj (supra) are produced hereinunder: “14. In the appellant's case, by virtue of the injuries suffered by him, his
disablement as far as driving a vehicle is concerned is 100%, but that is not
the measure of loss of his earning capacity. The Commissioner, Workmen's
Compensation seems to have confused the issue by combining both
functional disability and permanent disability in arriving at the figure of
85% by way of loss of earning capacity and has, therefore, arrived at a sum
of Rs. 1,75,970 towards compensation. The High Court, on the other hand,
realising the mistake committed by the Commissioner, assessed the loss of
earning capacity as 20% instead of 85% and reduced the compensation
payable from Rs. 1,75,970 to Rs. 41,404.80p. and awarded interest on the
compensation amount only after 30 days of passing of the award.
xxx
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
13:22:46
(2010) 10 SCC 347
FAO 200/2023
Pg. 5 of 7
16. The aforesaid provision would indicate that where a workman suffers
injury which is not specified in Schedule I to the Act, compensation is to be
assessed on such percentage of the compensation payable in the case of
permanent total disablement as is proportionate to the loss of earning
capacity, permanently caused by the injury as assessed by a qualified
medical practitioner. Since in the instant case, the nature of injury suffered
by the appellant is not specified in Schedule I, the compensation has
necessarily to be assessed on the basis of the loss of earning capacity
caused by the injury which could amount to 100% disablement in a given
case. In the instant case, however, although the appellant has lost the use of
his legs for the purpose of driving a vehicle, which could be said to be total
disablement so far as driving of a vehicle is concerned, he is in a position to
earn a living other than by functioning as a driver, which, in fact, he is
currently doing, having been posted as a peon by the respondent.
17. Accordingly, apart from the fact that the Commissioner, Workmen's
Compensation, had confused the concept of functional disablement with
permanent disablement in arriving at the figure of 85% loss of earning
capacity, we also have to take into consideration the fact that the injury
suffered by the appellant did not disable him permanently from earning his
living other than as a driver. We, therefore, are of the view that the
percentage of functional disablement has to be modified, since the appellant
is permanently disabled as far as earning a livelihood as a driver is
concerned.”
Taking the cue from Palraj (supra), this Court is of the considered opinion
that, having regard to the limited scope of appeal under Section 30 of the
Act and the further fact that concededly, the argument of „no loss of earning
capacity‟ was not even raised before the learned Commissioner, the
contention raised merits rejection. This Court even on reappreciation of
merits is in agreement with the findings returned by the learned
Commissioner. Insofar as the second contention, namely that no intimation
of the accident was given to the appellant, is concerned, it is noted from the
record of the Commissioner that the respondent had filed a communication
dated 21.05.2013, whereby intimation of the accident suffered by three
employees, including the present claimant, was duly furnished. The said
communication also bears the stamp and acknowledgment of the
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
13:22:46
FAO 200/2023
Pg. 6 of 7
appellant/insurance company. The contention, being misplaced, also merits
rejection.
13.
In view of the above, this Court finds no ground to interfere with the
award. Accordingly, the present appeal is dismissed along with the pending
applications. The amount lying deposited with the learned Commissioner
shall be released to the workman forthwith. There shall be no order as to
costs.
14.
Let a copy of this order be communicated to the learned
Commissioner for information and necessary compliance.
DASTI.
MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
(JUDGE)
FEBRUARY 26, 2026
na
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
13:22:46
FAO 200/2023
Pg. 7 of 7
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review