Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
M. A. No. 381 of 2017
1. Batiya Orain, W/o Late Jitu Lakra
2. Radha Lakra, minor son of late Jitu Lakra
All R/o Village Chairma, P.O. Ita Childiri P.S. Bero, Distt. Ranchi.
(Appellant no 1 is mother and 2 is sister of the deceased)
...
Claimants/Appellants
Versus
1. The Divisional Manager, National Insurance Company Ltd. (Legal
Cell) S.N. Ganguli Road, Main Road, Ranchi P.O. G.P.O, P.S.
Kotwali, District- Ranchi.
At present office at Sahid Chowk, Kutchery Road Near Gangaur
Sweets. P.O. GPO P.S. Kotwali Distt-Ranchi
2. Jamanat Ansari, S/o Akthar Ansari R/o Village- Larango, P.O. &
P.S. Sisai, Distt- Gumla (Jharkhand)…Opposite Parties/Respondents
With
M. A. No. 377 of 2017
1. Sumari Orain, W/o Late Somara Tirky
2. Bishnu Tirky, minor son of late Somara Tirky
3. Pritam Tirky, Minor D/o Late Somara Tirky
4. Bishnu Tirky, S/o Late Dheya Oraon
5. Somari Oraon, W/o Bishnu Oraon
All R/o Village Charima, P.O. Ita Childiri P.S. Bero, Distt. Ranchi.
(Appellant No.2 & 3 are minors and being represented through their
mother i.e. Appellant No.1)
…
… Claimants/Appellants
Versus
1. The Divisional Manager, National Insurance Company Ltd. (Legal
Cell) S.N. Ganguli Road, Main Road, Ranchi P.O. GPO, P.S.
Kotwali, Distt- Ranchi.
At present office at Sahid Chowk, Kutchery road Near Gangaur
Sweets. P.O. GPO P.S. Kotwali Distt-Ranchi
2. Jamanat Ansari, S/o Akthar Ansari R/o Village- Larango, P.O. &
P.S. Sisai, Distt- Gumla (Jharkhand)
... Opposite Parties/Respondents
With
M. A. No. 433 of 2017
National Insurance Co. Ltd. (Legal Cell), S.N. Ganguli Road, Main
Road, P.S. Kotwali, At P.O. & District – Ranchi – Issuing Branch
Office at Palkot Road, P.O. & P.S. District- Gumla.
...
Opposite Party No.2/Appellant
Versus
1. Batiya Orain W/o Late Jitu Lakra
2. Radha Lakra, daughter of Late Jitu Lakra,
All residents of Village Chairma, P.O. Ita Childiri P.S. Bero,
District-Ranchi. (Claimant Nos.1 & 2 respectively)
3. Jamanat Ansari, Son of Akhtar Ansari resident of village & P.O.
Larango, P.S. Sisai District – Gumla (Owner of Truck)
…. Respondents
With
M. A. No. 434 of 2017
The Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. (Legal Cell), S.N.
Ganguli Road, Main Road, P.S. Kotwali, At P.O. & District – Ranchi –
Issuing Branch Office at Palkot Road, P.O. & P.S. District- Gumla
...
Opposite Party No.2/Appellant
Versus
1. Sumari Orain, W/o Late Somara Tirky
2. Bishnu Tirky, minor son of late Somara Tirky
3. Pritam Tirky, Minor D/o Late Somara Tirky
4. Bishnu Tirky, S/o Late Dheya Oraon
5. Somari Oraon, W/o Bishnu Oraon
All resident of Village Charima, P.O. Ita Childiri P.S. Bero, District
– Ranchi (Respondent Nos.2 & 3 are minors and are being
represented through their mother being their natural guardian
respondent No.1 as their next friend)
...
(Claimant Nos.1 to 5 respectively)
6. Jamanat Ansari, Son of Aklhtar Ansari, resident of village & P.O.
Larango, P.S. Sisai, District – Gumla (Owner of Truck) (Opp. Party
No.1)
…
Respondents
--------CORAM: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
--------For the Appellants/Claimants:
Mr Nikhil Ranjan, Advocate
For the Respondents/Ins. Company: Mr Alok Lal, Advocate
Mr Santosh Kumar, Advocate
--------Reserved on: 25.08.2026
Pronounced on: 29/08/2026
1.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
I.A. No. 611 of 2020 in M.A. No. 381 of 2017, I.A. No. 612 of
2020 in M.A. No. 377 of 2017, I.A. No. 6329 of 2017 in M.A. No.
433 of 2017 and I.A. No. 6330 of 2017 in M.A. No. 434 of 2017
have been filed seeking condonation of delay in filing the
respective appeals. Since sufficient cause has been shown in all of
them, the delay is condoned. The applications are accordingly
allowed.
3.
These four appeals arise out of the same accident which occurred
on 11.03.2008 resulting in the death of Somra Tirky, the driver of
the jeep, and Bishu Lakra, its khalasi.
4.
M.A. Nos. 377 of 2017 and 381 of 2017 have been preferred by
the original claimants (legal representatives of the deceased)
seeking enhancement of compensation. M.A. Nos. 433 of 2017 and
434 of 2017 have been preferred by the National Insurance
Company Ltd. seeking complete exoneration from liability of
paying compensation to the claimants.
5.
By the common Judgment and Award dated 29.03.2017, passed by
the Claims Tribunal, Ranchi, in M.A.C. Case Nos. 164 of 2011 and
165 of 2011, the Tribunal awarded Rs. 7,60,000/- to the
dependants of Somra Tirky and Rs. 4,17,000/- to the dependants of
Bishu Lakra, after adjustment of interim compensation of Rs.
50,000/- in each case. Interest was directed to be paid at 9% per
annum from 23.09.2014. The Tribunal further granted liberty to
the insurer to recover the amount from the owner.
6.
Ld. advocate for the insurance company contends that the owner
violated the terms and conditions of the policy because the driver
of the truck did not possess a valid and effective licence to drive a
heavy motor vehicle on the date of the accident. It is further
contended that the truck was being plied without a route permit
and fitness certificate. On these grounds, it is submitted that the
insurer is not liable to indemnify the owner or satisfy the award.
7.
The claimants, while not agreeing with the above contentions,
submit that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is not just
and reasonable and warrants enhancement.
8.
Based on the rival submissions and the material available on
record, the following points arise for determination:
I.
Whether, on the finding of violation of the terms of the
policy, the insurer is entitled to complete exoneration
from its liability towards the original claimants?
II.
Whether the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is
just and reasonable and requires enhancement?
9.
Insofar as the first point of determination is concerned, the factum
of insurance of truck bearing registration No. BR-14G-9205 with
the appellant-insurer under Policy No. 170204/31/07/67/00002230,
valid from 20.09.2007 to 19.09.2008, is not in dispute. The
insurance company also does not dispute that the accident occurred
on 11.03.2008, during the subsistence of the policy.
10. The Tribunal, upon consideration of the evidence of O.P.W.1 and
Exts. A to D, found that the driving licence of Israil Ansari had
originally been issued by the office of the D.T.O., Ranchi,
authorising him to drive a light motor vehicle.
11. Furthermore, the evidence on record establishes that the
endorsement authorising the driver to drive a heavy motor vehicle
and a public service vehicle was granted by the D.T.O., Gumla,
only with effect from 19.06.2008. Thus, on the date of the
accident, the driver did not possess a valid and effective licence to
drive the heavy goods vehicle in question. The route permit and
fitness certificate were also not produced before the learned
Tribunal. The Tribunal's finding regarding the violation of the
policy conditions is therefore not liable to be disturbed.
12. The question, however, is whether such violation entitles the
insurer to complete exoneration from its liability towards the thirdparty claimants. The answer must be in the negative for reasons
discussed hereafter.
13. In the case of National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh,
(2004) 3 SCC 297, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that even
where a breach of the policy condition is established, the insurer is
not automatically discharged of its obligation towards third-party
claimants. The insurer may be directed to satisfy the award in the
first instance and thereafter recover the amount from the owner.
Accordingly, complete exoneration is, therefore, not the ordinary
consequence of a proved breach of the policy conditions.
14. This is especially true where the insurer fails to establish a
significant nexus between the accident and the alleged breach of a
term of the insurance policy. Victims of road accidents cannot be
forced to suffer because of terms in the insurance contract over
which they have no control. The beneficial scheme for obtaining
some compensation with relative ease and promptitude cannot be
frustrated by such strenuous interpretation.
15. In these circumstances, the Tribunal was justified in directing the
insurer to satisfy the award in the first instance, with liberty to
recover the amount from the owner. The plea of the insurer
seeking complete exoneration from liability cannot, therefore, be
accepted.
16. Point No. (i) is accordingly answered against the appellant-insurer.
17. On the question of whether the compensation awarded by the
Tribunal is just and reasonable, it is pertinent to note that the
Tribunal assessed the ages of Somra Tirky and Bishu Lakra at
about 27 and 20 years, respectively. These findings are duly
supported by oral and documentary evidence on record and have
not even been challenged before this Court. Accordingly, the
multipliers of 17 and 18, respectively, applied by the Tribunal are
maintained.
18. In Somra Tirky (M.A.C. Case No. 164 of 2011), the Tribunal
assessed the deceased's monthly income at Rs. 5,000/-,
corresponding to an annual income of Rs. 60,000/-, on the basis of
the uncontroverted oral evidence of his widow. The deceased was
27 years old and self-employed as a driver. No material was shown
to warrant any interference with this finding.
19. But having regard to the deceased’s age and avocation, an addition
of 40% to future prospects is warranted in terms of National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, reported in (2017) 16 SCC
680. The annual income for the purpose of computation thus
amounts to Rs. 84,000/-.
20. There being five dependants, a deduction of one-fourth towards
personal and living expenses is appropriate in terms of the
principles laid down in Sarla Verma v. DTC, reported in (2009)
6 SCC 121. The loss of dependency is accordingly calculated as
follows:
Rs. 84,000/- − 1/4th = Rs. 63,000/Rs. 63,000/- × 17 = Rs. 10,71,000/21. The claimant -dependants are, therefore, entitled to Rs. 10,71,000/towards loss of dependency.
22. In addition to the aforesaid amount, compensation under the
conventional heads is required to be awarded in accordance with
the principles laid down in Pranay Sethi (supra) and Magma
General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram @ Chuhru Ram,
reported in (2018) 18 SCC 130. Accordingly, a sum of Rs.
40,000/- each towards loss of consortium to the five claimants,
amounting to Rs. 2,00,000/-, Rs. 15,000/- towards funeral
expenses and Rs. 15,000/- towards loss of estate are awarded.
23. The total compensation payable in M.A.C. Case No. 164 of 2011
thus comes to Rs. 13,01,000/-. The interim compensation of Rs.
50,000/- already paid shall stand adjusted against the amount so
determined.
24. In the case of Bishu Lakra (M.A.C. Case No. 165 of 2011), the
assessment of the monthly income at Rs. 4,000/- is supported by
the oral evidence on record and calls for no interference. The
deceased was 20 years of age and was self-employed as a
labourer/khalasi.
25. Having regard to his age and avocation, an addition of 40%
towards future prospects is warranted. The annual income for the
purpose of computation thus comes to Rs. 67,200/-.
26. The deceased was a bachelor. A deduction of one-half towards
personal and living expenses is, therefore, appropriate. The loss of
dependency is calculated as follows:
Rs. 67,200/- − 1/2 = Rs. 33,600/Rs. 33,600/- × 18 = Rs. 6,04,800/27. Accordingly, the claimants are entitled to Rs. 6,04,800/- towards
loss of dependency.
28. The claimants are further entitled to compensation under the
conventional heads. A sum of Rs. 40,000/- each towards loss of
consortium to the two claimants, amounting to Rs. 80,000/-, Rs.
15,000/- towards funeral expenses and Rs. 15,000/- towards loss of
estate are accordingly awarded.
29. The total compensation payable in M.A.C. Case No. 165 of 2011
thus comes to Rs. 7,14,800/-. The same is rounded off to Rs.
7,15,000/-. The interim compensation of Rs. 50,000/- already paid
shall stand adjusted against the amount so determined.
30. Point No. (ii) is accordingly answered by holding that the
compensation awarded by the Tribunal is not just and reasonable
and requires enhancement.
31. M.A. Nos. 433 of 2017 and 434 of 2017, preferred by the insurer,
are dismissed. M.A. Nos. 377 of 2017 and 381 of 2017, preferred
by the claimants, are allowed.
32. The compensation in M.A.C. Case No. 164 of 2011 is enhanced to
Rs. 13,01,000/-. Whereas the compensation in M.A.C. Case No.
165 of 2011 is enhanced to Rs. 7,15,000/-. The interim
compensation of Rs. 50,000/- already paid in each case and the
statutory deposit amount shall stand adjusted.
33. However, no interference is warranted with respect to the rate of
interest awarded by the Tribunal. Having regard to the socioeconomic background of the deceased and the claimants, the rate
of interest at 7.5% per annum is considered just and reasonable and
is accordingly maintained from the date of filing of the respective
claim petitions till actual realisation.
34. The appellant-Insurance Company shall satisfy the enhanced
awards at the first instance and shall be entitled to recover the
amount from the owner of the truck in accordance with the liberty
already granted by the Tribunal and affirmed by this Court.
35. The direction of the learned Tribunal for deposit of a sum of Rs.
2,00,000/- each in the names of the two minor children of late
Somra Tirky (M.A.C. Case No. 164 of 2011) in a Nationalised
bank under a fixed deposit scheme, until they attain majority, is
hereby affirmed.
36. The appellant-Insurance Company is directed to deposit the
enhanced amounts before the learned Tribunal within eight weeks
from today, after due intimation to the learned counsel for the
original claimants. Upon such deposit, the learned Tribunal shall
permit the claimants to withdraw the amounts in accordance with
law.
37. The learned counsel for the claimants shall furnish the necessary
identity and bank particulars before the learned Tribunal for
facilitating disbursement of the amount.
38. There shall be no order as to costs. Pending interlocutory
applications, if any, stand disposed of.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
August 29, 2026
N.A.F.R.
Manoj/Cp.2
Uploaded on 29.08.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review